House of Commons (29) - Commons Chamber (9) / Westminster Hall (6) / Written Corrections (5) / Written Statements (4) / Public Bill Committees (4) / General Committees (1)
House of Lords (14) - Lords Chamber (7) / Grand Committee (7)
(1 day, 23 hours ago)
General CommitteesI beg to move,
That the Committee has considered the draft Tobacco and Vapes Act 2026 (Age Verification Defence to Underage Sales) (England and Wales) Regulations 2026.
The Chair
With this it will be convenient to consider the draft Tobacco and Vapes Act 2026 (Display of Tobacco Products) (Consequential Amendments) Regulations 2026.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner, as my next-door constituency neighbour in the great city of Hull. Earlier this year, the Tobacco and Vapes Act 2026 became law. This landmark piece of legislation will deliver on the Government’s commitment to create a smoke-free generation and tackle youth vaping. As we all know, tobacco is a uniquely harmful product, and smoking still claims about 75,000 lives a year in the United Kingdom. From 1 January 2027, it will be an offence to sell tobacco products, herbal smoking products or cigarette papers to anyone born on or after 1 January 2009, helping to create the UK’s first smoke-free generation.
While vapes can be an effective aid for adult smokers to quit smoking, children and non-smokers should never vape or use nicotine products. The Act therefore closes loopholes in previous age-of-sale legislation by making it an offence to sell vaping or nicotine products to anyone under the age of 18. The two draft statutory instruments that we are considering will support the effective implementation of the new age-of-sale measures in the Act.
I turn first to the draft age verification regulations. The Act provides powers to set out in regulation steps that retailers may take to verify that a customer meets the relevant age requirement, as a defence to age-of-sale offences. The regulations set out steps that would satisfy that defence in England and Wales. They aim to give retailers confidence about how they can verify the age of customers attempting to buy such products.
The regulations provide for two alternative methods of age verification, both of which will satisfy the defence. First, a person charged with an age-of-sale offence may rely on the defence when they can prove that they were shown a physical identity document bearing the customer’s photograph and date of birth, and a holographic mark or ultraviolet feature. Those criteria capture common forms of ID such as passports, driving licences and PASS—proof of age standards scheme—cards.
Alternatively, a retailer may rely on a digital proof of age, verified and delivered through a digital verification service known as DVS. That service must have been independently assessed against the UK DVS trust framework and be listed on the statutory DVS register. The provisions on digital proof of age follow the passage of the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, which placed the trust framework and the DVS register on a statutory footing. They also follow the Licensing Act 2003 (Mandatory Licensing Conditions) (Amendment) Order 2026 coming into force, which enables the use of such services as part of alcohol sales. I reassure the Committee that there is no requirement for individuals to use digital proof of age, nor are businesses required to accept it. It simply provides an additional, voluntary option alongside physical documents.
In developing the draft regulations, we sought to mirror the criteria for physical and digital proofs of age that can be used for alcohol sales. That aims to ensure that the many retailers who sell alcohol as well as tobacco, vaping and nicotine products will need to remember only one set of criteria. In developing the criteria, we also ensured that a range of commonly used forms of ID can be accepted. Finally, we have sought to future-proof the regulations by ensuring that digital proof of age can be used alongside traditional physical documents. It is important to note that neither the 2026 Act nor the regulations create a requirement for retailers to ask every customer for proof of age before every sale.
The steps in the draft regulations are also not the only way a retailer can establish a defence. The 2026 Act provides an alternative defence where a retailer can prove they took “all reasonable steps” to avoid committing the offence. That is a re-enactment of the defence in previous tobacco and vapes legislation of having taken all reasonable precautions and exercised all due diligence. The regulations set out an additional, more prescriptive route to establishing a defence. A retailer who follows the steps in the regulations can have confidence that they would be able to demonstrate a statutory defence if they were charged with an age of sale offence.
The second set of regulations relates to the display of tobacco products in retail premises. Under the current legislation on tobacco display, retailers in England, Wales and Northern Ireland are prohibited from displaying tobacco products in most shops. The Tobacco Advertising and Promotion Act 2002 includes an exemption that allows retailers to display tobacco products to a customer aged 18 or over, on their request. There is also a linked defence that applies when a retailer mistakenly displays products to a customer they reasonably considered to be 18 or over, as I discussed in relation to the previous statutory instrument.
This SI updates the exemption and defence to align with the new age of sale that comes into force on 1 January. This will mean that tobacco products can be displayed, on request, only to people born before 1 January 2009. Without those changes, under the current display legislation, individuals aged 18 and over could still be shown tobacco products, even if the products could not legally be sold to them. That would create an inconsistent and confusing position for retailers, and it could increase the risk of accidental under-age sales.
By aligning the age at which customers can be shown tobacco products with the new age of sale, we are aiming to help businesses comply with the law and support effective enforcement. This alignment also aims to maintain the effectiveness of tobacco display restrictions. Long-term evidence has shown that reducing the visibility and accessibility of tobacco products reduces their appeal and supports smokers trying to quit by reducing everyday exposure to tobacco.
Taken together, these regulations mark an important milestone in the implementation of the Tobacco and Vapes Act, helping to protect the health of today’s children and generations to come. I commend them to the Committee.
Gregory Stafford (Farnham and Bordon) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I will speak to both statutory instruments together, and I reassure the hon. Member for Winchester—I believe he is the only other person in this Committee who was also on the Tobacco and Vapes Bill Committee—that I will not speak for the hours and hours that I did on that Committee.
Let me start with where the Opposition were throughout the passage of that Act. We share the objective of cutting smoking and stopping children from taking up nicotine. Those on the Government Benches know that the Bill began life under the previous Conservative Government, so we will not oppose either instrument this afternoon. We have questions, however, about how well the Government are delivering this, because the success of the legislation depends on delivery.
Turning first to the age verification defence regulations, the Tobacco and Vapes Act makes it an offence to sell tobacco to anyone born on or after 1 January 2009, and to sell vapes and nicotine products to anyone under 18. It gives retailers a defence if they took the steps specified in regulations, and these regulations specify those steps. A retailer can inspect a physical identity document or use a certified digital identity checked through a registered provider. The alternative defence of taking all reasonable steps remains.
I welcome several things. The principle of giving retailers a clear route to a defence is right, and many of them asked for that. The regulations are permissive, not mandatory. The approach also aligns with that for alcohol, which is sensible for the many shops that sell both. I also put on record that the regulations are before us under the affirmative procedure. The Government accepted that late change during the passage of the Act, following recommendations from Conservative peers, and that was the right call.
I do have some concerns, however, and I will set out four. First, on the timing, the vape and nicotine offence started on 29 October, but this defence does not start until 1 January. The Government’s explanatory memorandum accepts that gap. For two months, retailers are left with the reasonable steps defence alone, which a court judges after the event.
My second concern is about whether the safe harbour works for those who make most sales. The explanatory memorandum acknowledges that a company may not be able to show that it took the steps itself, because the defence is framed around what the person charged did. Most sales are made by incorporated retailers. For them, the clarity that they were promised is partial at best.
Thirdly, on the drafting, paragraph 5.8 of the explanatory memorandum says that it
“must appear to a reasonable person”
that the document has a
“photograph…a date of birth and…a holographic mark or ultraviolet feature”.
The regulations say something different. The reasonable person test applies only to the document being unaltered and showing the age, and the features are a hard requirement in the definition. A seller who in good faith accepts a convincing card that lacks a feature may find that they have no defence. The Government should tell us whether that is correct in the regulations or in the explanatory memorandum. The regulations also do not tell the seller to check that the photograph matches the customer, that the card is in date, or who issued it.
Fourthly, the digital route rests on a number of assumptions. The Government estimate around £179 million of cost over 10 years on the basis of 15p a check, and they admit that they have no evidence of what providers will charge. Small businesses that cannot adopt digital checks are, in the explanatory memorandum’s words, at risk of “losing customers over time”, and there is no review clause. The Government rely on a review of the whole Act in four to seven years, which is a rather long time in a fast-moving field.
The regulations on the display of tobacco products are short and technical. The display of tobacco is prohibited, but section 7B of the Tobacco Advertising and Promotion Act 2002 does allow a requested display to a customer who is 18 or over. The new age of sale is a date of birth, not an age of 18, so the instrument replaces the age references in section 7B with references to being born before, on or after 1 January 2009. We agree that that is necessary and we will not oppose it. A long attack on the text would probably be disproportionate, but three points are worth raising.
First, why is this a separate instrument at all? The Act carried schedules of consequential amendments. If section 7B was missed, the Government should perhaps ask what else might have been.
Secondly, on the practical effect, section 7B has a defence whereby nobody could reasonably have suspected from appearance that the customer was under age. As I read the amended text, the test becomes whether anyone could reasonably have suspected that the customer was born on or after 1 January 2009. As that cohort grows older, the test drifts towards a Challenge 25-style standard without Parliament having debated it. The Minister should say whether that is the Government’s intention and what further guidance might be issued on that.
Thirdly, on the wider picture, the substantive display regulations are still to come. The Government’s consultation closed on 2 October, and retailers are being asked to absorb new notices, age checks, display rules and, in due course, licensing, all in a matter of weeks.
I have a number of questions that cover both statutory instruments. First, why does the statutory defence start more than two months after the vape and nicotine offence, and how many fixed penalty notices have been issued since 29 October? How can a company prove that it took steps that the regulations attribute to the person charged? Which is correct on the physical identity test: paragraph 5.8 of the memorandum or regulation 3 as written? Will a seller who in good faith accepts a convincing but non-compliant card have a defence? Is the seller expected to check that the photograph matches the customer, that the document is in date and who issued it? If not, why not, and if so, why is that not in the regulations?
How can an online or delivery seller obtain the defence, and at what point is the sale made? Which registered digital verification providers offer age checks that work at the till today, and at what price? What did the Information Commissioner say and how has that changed the instrument? Why are age estimation and Challenge 25-style policies excluded from the defence, given that Conversative peers in the other place pressed for an age verification policy during the Bill? Will the Minister commit to a specific early review of these regulations rather than waiting for the review of the Act?
On the display regulations, was the need to amend section 7B identified during the Bill’s passage, and has the Department audited every other provision that refers to age 18, so that we are not in this situation again or, if we are, we can correct it? Is the change to the appearance defence in section 7B intended and will guidance explain it?
When will the Government respond to the display consultation and lay the substantive regulations, and will there be a transition period running from the date that those regulations are made? The Government also point to up to £10 million a year for trading standards. Is the Minister convinced that that is enough given that the age of sale, display, vapes and licensing are all arriving together? How will enforcement be balanced between checking legitimate shops and tackling illicit sellers?
During the Bill, the Opposition proposed an annual report on illicit tobacco and vapes, which the Government rejected. How will the Government monitor the illicit market as these rules take effect? Finally, when will updated retailer guidance be published, and will it be in time for 1 January?
I look forward to the Minister’s response to as many of those questions as possible, but if she cannot give me answers now, I look forward to receiving them in writing.
I am grateful for the support from the Opposition spokesperson, the hon. Member for Farnham and Bordon. There are just six weeks to go until 1 January 2027. As we all welcome in the new year and the first young people born in 2009 turn 18, the smoke-free generation is going to become a reality. I very much welcome the scrutiny under which he has put these regulations, and I want to make a few comments in particular.
My first point is about the guidance that was issued when the 2026 Act was brought in. That guidance will be updated, and it will deal with a number of the points that the hon. Gentleman made to help retailers and shopkeepers understand what is expected. Points were made about checking the date of birth and the photograph on the physical card, and I say to him that the guidance will be coming. We have been working with retailers and the Association of Convenience Stores to make sure that we deal with any concerns that retailers and shopkeepers have.
The hon. Gentleman asked why these regulations did not come into force before the commencement of the new age of sale for vapes and nicotine products on 29 October 2026. Our priority has been to ensure that the new defence is in place in time for the commencement of the new age of sale for tobacco products, herbal smoking products and cigarette papers on 1 January 2027. The retail sector has sought additional direction on age verification specifically in relation to that change, given that an age of sale based on a date rather than an age is more of a novel concept for retailers. The Government have taken the time to consider that and the time needed to ensure that physical and digital provisions could be included in this instrument to future-proof the regulation and align with the policy for alcohol sales. I think that explains why we are where we are. Obviously, the focus has been on the January deadline that is coming up. I stress that the guidance that will be introduced will deal with a number of these points. I will write to him about some of the specific technical issues around digital sales and how that will work.
The hon. Gentleman asked whether there was any information yet on fixed penalty notices that have been issued since the end of October. I do not have that information, and I do not know whether we would be in a position to have those figures yet. It is quite early—just three weeks. We will go away and check, but I think we will probably struggle to get those figures for him at this time.
Also, I want to stress that digital checks are not mandatory. This is a choice, if shopkeepers, retailers and commercial organisations want to use digital checks, and it is not something we are requiring at all. As I said, the alignment with sales of alcohol and the checks that are already in place, and the conversations we have had with the retail sector, will ensure that we make it as easy as possible for retailers to deal with the changes coming in in January. However, I am very happy to write to the hon. Gentleman about any of the technical points that he sought clarification on.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That the Committee has considered the draft Tobacco And Vapes Act 2026 (Age Verification Defence to Underage Sales) (England and Wales) Regulations 2026.
Draft Tobacco And Vapes Act 2026 (Display Of Tobacco Products) (Consequential Amendments) Regulations 2026
Resolved,
That the Committee has considered the draft Tobacco And Vapes Act 2026 (Display Of Tobacco Products) (Consequential Amendments) Regulations 2026.—(Dame Diana Johnson.)