(2 days, 22 hours ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, I do not want to appear to be ignoring Amendment 50, but I am not going to say anything about it. I want to refer to the two amendments in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Neate, who talked about domestic abuse and issues around that. I declare that I was chair of the charity Refuge for a long time. It was quite a long time ago, but I have a feeling that things have not changed dramatically.
The noble Baroness refers in Amendment 53H to
“the impact of trauma on memory, communication, behaviour and engagement with court proceedings, and best practices for reducing retraumatisation within courts and tribunals”,
which all seems immensely important.
When the noble Baroness said that you can start working in this field thinking that you understand, and then you realise that actually, you do not, that struck quite a chord with me. I am mentioning this because it seems to me that the term “trauma” has been devalued. People say, “I had a bad cold: I was traumatised”. Sometimes it is not as absurd as that, but we have lost the real meaning and the real impact of “trauma”. I hate hearing government departments, among others, saying, “Oh, everything we do is trauma-informed”. If they say that, it says to me that probably it is not.
My Lords, I will make one tiny point. I listened to everything the noble Lord, Lord Pannick, said, and I agreed, obviously, with much of it. But I wonder why directions are not given, therefore, in all cases that come before us. I would evidence to him that the Law Commission and the Victims’ Commissioner say that this is an issue. I fail to understand why we do not wish to give rape victims—women who are in court desperately trying to tell their story—the best opportunity they have of putting those points across without being denigrated and having spurious nonsense about what a victim should behave like put before the jury.