2 Lord Lemos debates involving the Scotland Office

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Lord Lemos Excerpts
Monday 16th November 2026

(1 day, 9 hours ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Ashcombe Portrait Lord Ashcombe (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, we have heard concerns from noble Lords about the impact these reforms are going to have on magistrates’ courts, especially if they are not prepared for them. Amendment 37, in the name of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, in the previous group also sought confirmation regarding the training provided to magistrates. These amendments, brought to us by the noble Baroness, Lady Hamwee, seek also to question the allowances that will be available to magistrates. These amendments raise a legitimate concern about the extent to which magistrates are adequately prepared and supported for these reforms. I look forward to the Minister’s response.

Lord Lemos Portrait The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Justice (Lord Lemos) (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Hamwee, for tabling these amendments. Due to the mysteries of grouping, we also discussed magistrates capacity towards the end of the last day of Committee proceedings, but it was very late in the evening and we were all in a rush—although I am sure that, even at 10pm, noble Lords hung on my every deathless word. This will be an opportunity to emphasise the point in prime time, as it were.

On the question of the review, my noble friend Lord Katz will deal with the amendments from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Bellamy, in a later group.

Before I go into my remarks, I think that the question the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, asked me was whether any magistrates supported these reforms, to which my reply was that the Magistrates’ Association supported them—we can check the record on this. I do not regard that as “cavalier”. I certainly did not suggest that the Magistrates’ Association had not expressed concerns; I have met with the Magistrates’ Association, and I have heard its concerns. The noble Baroness, Lady Fox, might rather withdraw the “cavalier” assertion in relation to what she said.

These amendments seek to ensure that magistrates’ training and allowances are in place before the measures in Clauses 1, 2, 5 and 6 commence. The Government are confident that the magistrates’ courts can deliver the reform set out in the Bill, and we are already taking action to ensure that the magistrates’ courts are set up to succeed. I want to set this out carefully for the record and for the benefit of noble Lords today. The capacity of the magistrates’ courts has been raised a number of times and in different ways, and it is at the heart of the success of the Bill. The Government are very much aware of that.

As noble Lords will no doubt be aware, the magistrates’ courts have a higher volume and higher turnover due to jurisdiction. The magistrates’ courts handle more than 90% of all criminal cases each year. In 2025, they handled almost 1.5 million cases, and 73% of those cases were completed at the first listing. Triable “either way” offences progress substantially quicker in the magistrates’ courts than in the Crown Court.

As I said at Second Reading and on the first day in Committee, the question is not just the size of the backlog but waiting times and the speed with which cases can be processed. The magistrates’ courts typically handle triable “either way” cases four times faster than the Crown Court. From the perspective of victims, witnesses and, indeed, the defendants, that is a considerable benefit. The average at-court time for a not guilty “either way” trial case in the magistrates’ court is about five months, compared to 18 months in the Crown Court where the defendant is on bail. I am sure noble Lords would agree that that is a substantial benefit, not just to the system but, as I said, to victims, witnesses and defendants.

The Bill’s economic impact assessment, published on the Bill’s introduction to the other place in February 2026 and supplemented by an appendix published on introduction to your Lordships’ House, set out that the structural reforms would increase demand in the magistrates’ court by around 8,500 sitting days per year in steady state following implementation—we want to be completely transparent about that. The Government are already expanding the capacity of magistrates’ courts to meet this demand, increasing funded sitting days from 114,000 last year to 125,800 in 2026-27, with a target of 131,000 sitting days by 2028-29. We are confident we will meet that.

--- Later in debate ---
Finally, let me take just 30 seconds to say a word about the other amendments in the group on judicial training. Judicial training is obviously critical; it is required in various areas and provided at a very high standard. Obviously, I will listen carefully to what the Minister says in response, but the general approach of the Government, certainly when I was on that side of the Chamber, was that, although the funding of training is ultimately a matter for the Government, its content is always left to the judges. Amendment 53H appears to mandate particular training in fairly broad terms, which might overstep and contravene that distinction, which is actually quite important constitutionally.
Lord Lemos Portrait Lord Lemos (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, this has been an extremely important, powerful and timely debate, with strong views expressed in different directions. I thank my noble friend Lady Levitt, both for her amendment and for giving the Committee the opportunity to have this rich and important debate.

It is clear from this debate that there is much on which we all agree. First, we all agree that rape myths have absolutely no place in our courts or, indeed, in wider society. The noble Lord, Lord Marks, referenced my response to the Private Notice Question. I think that the media—online and traditional—as well as employers and civil society all have important roles to play in challenging rape myths. The law also has a significant part to play.

Victims should never feel like they are the ones on trial, and we are already taking steps to change the culture in our courts. On the point from the noble Lord, Lord Russell, I pay tribute to the victims in the Brand case and in so many others for showing the courage to ensure that justice is done.

In this Bill, we are changing the law to stop irrelevant evidence that relies on rape myths being weaponised against victims. The Lord Chancellor is standing up a rape justice taskforce to tackle not only inefficiency in rape cases but this precise challenge.

The independence of the judiciary, as well as judicial discretion, are both cornerstones of the rule of law and of ensuring a fair trial. It is also right that steps are taken to ensure that directions are given consistently. My noble friend Lady Levitt placed some emphasis on that, which is one of the points of issue on this amendment; the noble Lord, Lord Russell, also mentioned it. So the Government agree that it is right that steps are taken to ensure that directions are given consistently and in line with the agreed standards set by the judiciary.

In response specifically to the questions asked and the very powerful case made by my noble friend Lady Levitt, I will say today that the Judicial College has committed to updating the Crown Court Compendium to state that directions should be given in all sexual offence trials—this goes straight to my noble friend’s point—at the outset of the trial and when summing up, subject to judicial discretion. This new requirement would set a clear expectation. In the light of that, the college also intends to update sexual offences training for judges.

The noble Lord, Lord Russell, raised the question of training for barristers. The job of regulating, setting standards for and training barristers is a matter for the Bar Standards Board, and it is for it to take this forward. It is already developing specialist standards for barristers acting in rape and serious sexual offences cases. As has been reported, the Lord Chancellor wrote to the Bar Standards Board this weekend to ask for a meeting to discuss progress on its planned standards. He made it clear that harmful rape myths should not be perpetuated.

I am confident that the measures I have set out will ensure that directions are given consistently, as my noble friend Lady Levitt challenged us on. However, I understand that we have heard concerns expressed by my noble friend and others from all sides of the argument, and Minister Sackman and I are happy to meet with her and other such interested Peers, ahead of Report, to discuss the concerns that underlie this amendment and the measures that I have set out. We are happy to consider anything more that the Government can do, within the well-established parameters of judicial independence and discretion. I hope I have reassured my noble friend Lady Levitt and, on that basis, shall invite her to withdraw her amendment in a moment.

I turn to Amendments 53E and 53G from the noble Baronesses, Lady Brinton and Lady Neate. These amendments are very similar in their intent. Amendment 53E seeks to place a duty on the Lord Chancellor to ensure sufficient resourcing for judicial training on areas related to vulnerable witnesses, domestic abuse, sexual violence and trauma. Amendment 53G focuses specifically on the funding for this judicial training and the duty on the Lord Chancellor concerned with child arrangement proceedings.

The Government recognise the importance of specialist training being delivered to our judiciary, and the Lord Chancellor already has a statutory duty to ensure appropriate resourcing of the courts, which includes judicial training. Statutory responsibility for judicial training is rightly held by the Lady Chief Justice. A comprehensive programme of induction and continuation training is in place, which is designed to embed the necessary experiences and skills to deal with these cases. The Judicial College keeps judges up to date with a wide range of resources, as I just set out in relation to rape and serious sexual offences. The Crown Court judicial induction has a dedicated session on vulnerability, which sets out automatic eligibility for complainants in cases in these areas, including special measures.

Domestic abuse training is not a stand-alone course or single intervention, and is instead embedded throughout the training programme, focusing on domestic abuse dynamics, coercion and the impact on children. The Judicial College draws on experienced practitioners and external experts, including survivors of domestic abuse and psychologists. In May, the college published a summary of judicial education in domestic abuse, and the college keeps judges up to date with a wide range of resources. The Government are therefore content that there is sufficient provision for this training provided by the Judicial College.

Finally, on Amendment 53H, also tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Neate, I agree that it is essential that domestic abuse training is provided to all court staff. I hope I can reassure the noble Baroness that HMCTS court staff must complete domestic abuse awareness training within three months of joining HMCTS. Existing staff are expected to complete the training every two years.

In addition to the domestic abuse awareness training, in August, we introduced trauma-informed training for court staff. This aims to help staff to better understand how traumatic experiences, particularly domestic and sexual abuse, can affect the way that people communicate, behave and engage in court and throughout court processes. It has been developed to support the Government’s commitment to improve how courts support victims and witnesses. To preserve judicial independence, as I have said, statutory responsibility for the training of the judiciary rests with the Lady Chief Justice and is fulfilled by the Judicial College.

With these reassurances, I hope my noble friend Lady Levitt will withdraw her amendment.

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Lord Lemos Excerpts
Monday 16th November 2026

(1 day, 9 hours ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Lemos Portrait Lord Lemos (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords for participating in this debate. It has been very powerful and, indeed, moving at times. I also thank noble Lords for meeting me beforehand.

I am not sure I will be able to answer every one of the detailed questions from the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, particularly given the lateness of the hour—I rather think she was expecting that. But as we seem to have done well with the last letter, we will try again with another one.

I want to be clear—and I am sure that this is a statement of what we all think—that we all share the same goal, which is that we want safe decisions that put children’s welfare first. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, said the child must come first, and that is what we all stand by. Our presumption review identified, as the noble Baronesses, Lady Kitching, Lady Brinton and Lady Neate, said, a pro-contact culture in the family courts. The Government are not suggesting the presumption was the main driving force behind this culture, but it was a factor. Addressing this requires changes to practice, procedure and legislation.

I will set out some of the other steps the Government are taking, as well as this clause on presumption. We are rolling out child-focused courts nationally, as the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, mentioned, bringing information-gathering and risk assessment earlier in proceedings, strengthening multi-agency working and ensuring that children’s voices are heard. This holistic approach will help our courts better understand risk.

But the legislation must also change. I noted with great respect the wise words of the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, about how this presumption fits into the wider context for these decisions. Repealing the presumption means courts will adopt from the outset an open-minded inquiry into a child’s best interests, rather than starting from any presumption about parental involvement. Where involvement is safe and, I stress, in the child’s best interests, of course courts will continue to order it.

It is together that these reforms will help courts make the safest possible decisions. It is court decisions we are talking about—decisions that are grounded in a full understanding of each child, their family, their circumstances, their wishes and feelings, and the risks they may face. I urge noble Lords to support Clause 16.

Turning now to specific amendments, I will start with Amendment 53 from the noble Lord, Lord Farmer. The Government are concerned that this proposal risks reintroducing the very problems that repeal of the presumption of parental involvement seeks to address. Singling out parental relationships risks giving those considerations undue weight, rather than allowing their significance to be assessed based on the individual child before the court, which is the issue with which we are concerned. In response to the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, the welfare checklist remains an effective and enduring piece of legislation. It requires courts to pay particular regard to a list of factors that affect a child’s welfare, while providing flexibility to assess individual circumstances. This is essential to ensure individual child-focused decisions. The welfare checklist already requires the court to have particular regard to, among other things, how capable each of a child’s parents is of meeting the child’s needs. I reassure the noble Lord that this framework already enables courts to consider the matters he raised, where they are relevant to the child’s welfare.

On Amendment 53A from the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, I agree that we must understand the outcomes for children and families as these reforms take effect. As I said, repealing the presumption is part of a package of reforms to keep children’s safety and welfare at the heart of family justice. These measures work together, so it is important to consider their combined impact rather than look at repeal in isolation. I hope I can reassure the noble Baroness that this work is already under way. We are monitoring rollout of child-focused courts, which is such an important intervention, so that we can learn and improve as implementation progresses. Independent expert scrutiny is vital. That is why, as the noble Baroness noted, we asked the Domestic Abuse Commissioner to continue her research into domestic abuse in the family courts and we committed £500,000 over two years to support the second phase of the family court review and reporting mechanism, which will identify and disseminate best practice in child arrangements cases involving domestic abuse. These measures provide a robust approach to learning from these and other reforms without the statutory evaluation proposed.

On Amendment 53B, also from the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, I agree that specialist domestic abuse support services are essential to the child-focused model and must have the resource and expertise they need. I noted her comments about training and will deal with that in writing. I hope I can reassure the noble Baroness that arrangements are already in place to support this. As part of the child-focused courts national rollout, we provide dedicated funding to local areas to commission specialist domestic abuse services. She asked me about that and I will write to her on that too. We also have clear expectations for service quality. Domestic abuse service providers receive training on the child-focused model, and our target operating model, to which the noble Baroness referred, sets out requirements to ensure consistent delivery. We work closely with local areas and commissioned services to monitor delivery and identify emerging pressures. Our national network enables services to share best practice and resolve challenges, while helping us identify lessons and work with partners to improve provision as the model expands. These existing funding, commissioning and oversight arrangements enable us to identify and address issues as they arise, without the need for additional statutory requirements.

Amendment 53C is from the noble Baroness, Lady Neate. I was grateful to the noble Baroness for the meeting we had. This Government share the concerns about unregulated experts, often using the title “psychologist”, being instructed in the family courts. We have already taken action to address the concerns she raises. Earlier this year, the family procedure rules were updated to limit the instruction of unregulated experts in most circumstances. The changes to the rules and practice directions now require any expert in relevant children proceedings, subject to limited exceptions, to be regulated by a UK statutory body with an approved regulator under the Legal Services Act 2007 or appear on a register accredited by the Professional Standards Authority. In the Government’s view, the family procedure rules are a more appropriate place to address this concern. They can be more readily updated than primary legislation, allowing us to respond more quickly to changing practice in the family courts. I hope the noble Baroness agrees with me that primary legislation is not required to resolve this issue.

Finally, on Amendment 53D, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, it is vital that judges in the family court can hear evidence from appropriately qualified experts to support their decision-making. That is why the family procedure rules, as she noted, and their associated practice directions make clear provision around the regulation and accreditation of experts in family proceedings. I particularly draw the noble Baroness’s attention to the changes made by the family procedure rule committee which came into force in July. These mean that any expert instructed in relevant children proceedings must, aside from limited exceptions, be regulated.

I know that the instruction of psychologists has been a particular concern, and I note the case to which the noble Baroness referred, Re Y, and the judgment by the former President of the Family Division. This clarifies that courts should not give permission for the instruction of an expert “psychologist” who is neither registered by a relevant statutory body nor chartered by the British Psychological Society.

I appreciate that it is late, but I hope that my responses to these amendments have done them sufficient justice to reassure noble Lords. I therefore ask the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, not to press his amendment.

Clause 16 agreed.
--- Later in debate ---
Finally, Amendments 62B, 64A and 71A are signed only by my noble and learned friend Lord Keen of Elie and not by me, but I can assure the Committee that the distinction is one of authorship and not agreement—I think my name was left off for time reasons. They seek to prevent the Bill coming into force until the Government have published the evidence on which they base their assertion that limiting the right to jury trials will reduce the backlog in the courts. Of course, we dispute that the measures are necessary, but on any analysis, we suggest that the Government should not bring in those provisions without publishing the evidence which is said to underpin them. For those reasons, I commend those amendments.
Lord Lemos Portrait Lord Lemos (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

Yes, of course it can be right that this should remain a judicial function. I am afraid the noble Lord will have to yield to me in my respect for judicial independence. It is a judicial function, and it is going to remain one.

Individual listing decisions are made under judicial responsibility, with HMCTS providing the information, processes, tools and operational support required to enable effective decision-making. The new judicial national listing framework, which came into effect on 10 October, expressly preserves judicial discretion and local leadership while providing greater national consistency in how cases are prioritised and listed, so I am afraid we will have to differ on that. Substantial work is already under way through the HMCTS listing improvement programme, which includes the deployment of AI tools. I think it is right to say that the MoJ has led the way. People are often critical of the MoJ, but it has led the way on the adoption of AI tools to achieve the objectives envisaged by this amendment.

Amendments 62B, 64A and 71A, tabled by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Keen, seek to prevent this Act coming into effect until the Government have published their evidence on the expected impact of the reforms on the court backlogs. The noble and learned Lord asked me this before, and I do not really understand why he is asking me again. The Bill’s economic impact assessment was published in February this year, alongside the Bill’s introduction, as is standard practice. It set out a detailed cost and benefit analysis for each Bill measure, as well as our modelling for the overall impacts on the criminal justice system. The impact assessment is accompanied by other material setting out our modelling in a range of scenarios, covering our overall approach to criminal court improvement, financial investment, modernisation and structural reform. As I said, I have made those points before. Following the Government’s decision in October not to proceed with the Crown Court bench division, we published further modelling.

Our modelling shows that, with these reforms, the backlog peaks in 2028 before starting to fall rapidly over 2029. I realise that the Opposition will not support these reforms, so they look relentlessly for other opportunities to divert the stream that is joining the backlog. I am afraid that the ones that the noble Lord has put up tonight are particularly unconvincing. In fact, without the operational challenge of creating a new division of the Crown Court, we can move faster with other reforms and turn that tide sooner, peaking in 2027 before starting to fall. For those excellent reasons, I urge the noble Lord to withdraw his amendment.

Lord Wolfson of Tredegar Portrait Lord Wolfson of Tredegar (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, the reasons may or may not be excellent, but they are certainly familiar, because I think I used to read out almost the same formulation when the point was put to me. For present purposes, I should say that I am certainly not persuaded that it is as simple as that formulation, even as elegant as the Minister makes it sound, but I am persuaded that these amendments ought not to be pressed.