All 1 Debates between Lord Pack and Baroness Coffey

Wed 4th Nov 2026
Baroness Coffey Portrait Baroness Coffey (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I too support these amendments, and I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Frost for making sure that people of Irish citizenship can definitely continue to register. I have heard other people ask: why displace the Commonwealth and not the Irish? We have a very different relationship with Ireland and the people of Ireland, and that is why I hope we see these amendments come back on Report.

Lord Pack Portrait Lord Pack (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

It is worth starting by paying tribute to the many Commonwealth citizens who, in both peace and wartime, have made very many significant contributions to our country. But it is also right, as several noble Peers have mentioned, that the Commonwealth is the creation of an unusual set of historical circumstances. If we were starting completely from scratch, maybe with a new written constitution for the country, we might take a slightly different approach to some aspects of it.

In the spirit of the noble Lord, Lord Frost, saying that these are probing amendments, there are two points worth highlighting. One is that some restrictions exist on which Commonwealth citizens are able to register to vote. The combination of the requirements under the RPA 1983 and the linked requirements under the Immigration Act 1971 does not provide the fully open door that was perhaps touched on in some of the speeches earlier. Also, this is only one part of a wider question, because one could similarly reasonably ask why, when it comes to the local government franchise, somebody who is living in this country for decades, legally here and diligently paying their taxes every year, and who has no criminal record, is not allowed to vote for their local council.

I use that as an example of how there are many related issues. It would be wrong to single out Commonwealth citizens as the only part of that complex picture, as if they are the only group about whose right to vote we should in some way feel concerned. If the Government decide to look further at this issue, I hope it will be in the spirit of seeing it as part of a wider, more complex issue, rather than there being a specific problem that means we should single out Commonwealth citizens above and beyond all those other aspects of the issue for consideration.