Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill

Baroness Gerada Excerpts

Committee stage
Friday 6th February 2026 Lords Chamber

Experts and charities say that the Bill does not contain any provision to prevent individuals with eating disorders being classified as terminally ill. They support the amendments to make the Bill safer, all of which were rejected in Committee in the other place. I ask that noble Lords think carefully about the amendments before the House and support Amendments 89, 91, 92, 101 and 103.

[Baroness Gerada (CB)]

My Lords, I am completely in favour of Amendment 87. I have permission to use the name of my patient, Melanie Spooner, who died from anorexia nervosa—she died from taking her own life. The end point of anorexia nervosa is often that the patient wants to die. As such, it is a terrible mental illness, and I think that not conflating and excluding this group is absolutely the right way forward.

One other issue has been bothering me ever since I have been coming to these Fridays: it is the conflation of the words assisted suicide with assisted death. For a decade now, I have been looking after those bereaved following the death by suicide of their loved ones, and I have about 100 people whom I care for. Suicide is often a violent act; it is often an act done alone and it is often done to punish people—I am terribly sorry if anyone here knows people who have killed themselves. It is a very prolonged bereavement, and a very complicated grief that affects up to 60 to 70 people in its wake.

Assisted death, as we have heard from the group that came from Australia, can sometimes be filled with hope and sometimes with joy, with family around for those last moments. It affects both groups: those whom I look after, who have been bereaved following suicide, and the relatives of those who have taken voluntary assisted death. It is such a small thing, but it really grates, and it is one of the most inappropriate and irresponsible ways of conflating the language.

[Baroness O'Loan (CB)]

Before the noble Baroness sits down, can I ask her whether she is aware that recent research has shown that 42% of people think that assisted death is actually the provision of palliative care, and that it is actually quite important to distinguish between the two?

[Baroness Gerada (CB)]

I was not aware of that research. The evidence shows, and we heard it from the Australian group, that where voluntary assisted death is in place, the provision of palliative care is improved. In Australia, a great deal more resource was put in to providing palliative care. My point, however, is: please can we no longer conflate the language of assisted suicide with that of voluntary assisted death.

[Lord Moore of Etchingham (Non-Afl)]

My Lords, I of course agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, that there are many different motives for killing yourself, but we are talking about making a law here. It is very important that the natural and ordinary meaning of words is established and preserved. Suicide means killing yourself, and what is proposed in the Bill is killing yourself with assistance. It is very important to keep explaining that to people, because otherwise they will be permanently misled about what is actually happening.