Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Manzoor
Main Page: Baroness Manzoor (Conservative - Life peer)Department Debates - View all Baroness Manzoor's debates with the Department of Health and Social Care
(3 weeks ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, I thank the Minister very much. I am absolutely delighted that the Government have listened with regards to Healthwatch and HSSIB, which are two very important legs of the NHS in terms of independence, patient safety and patient voice. I welcome that and thank the Minister; I know that she is also passionate about those areas.
I thank my noble friend Lord Howe and others who have spoken on his amendment. Irrespective of what one feels about NHS England—I will certainly share my views—it is right that there is an operational plan and a transitional plan. No business would move to such a major reorganisation without having such plans and risk assessments, with key performance indicators and clarity around outcomes in relation to budgets and finance.
My key question is that if savings are to be made, when will they made and how will they be reinvested into direct patient care? With all these changes, what does it mean for the patient? How do they benefit, so that we are not just talking round and round to ourselves about reorganisations?
I have been involved with the NHS for nearly over 40 years—the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, and I have been around a long time. I chaired a health authority when I was in my 20s, and I chaired one of the eight regional offices of the NHS. My region was northern and Yorkshire, and we had a budget of £3.5 billion. I have some experience of transformation and of the difficulties, challenges and risks that will be involved. If we do not have these plans or clarity, things will go wrong. That will adversely affect patient care, when trying to improve patient care is what the Bill is really about.
I do not like to see lots of duplication in services. I like direct and simplified governance structures in the NHS. We had them when we had the regional offices. I recollect—it was a Labour Government at that time—that the eight regional chairs rocked up to the Department of Health, I think quarterly although the memory has faded a bit, and sat down with the Secretary of State, the Permanent Secretaries and the chief executive of the NHS Executive. We went round to find out what the finances were within our regions, which hospitals were performing well and which were not, and where there were real issues about waiting lists. It really concentrated the mind. Then we went back and fed it to all the 60 or 80 chairmen within our regions and their respective chief executives. I am not too worried and concerned that there will be a lot of haters, but we must have very clear plans to enable this to happen.
Last but not least, I want to talk about the governance structures; I mentioned them in my speech previously. If we do not have clarity around governance structures and accountability, we really will not deliver. If there is one plea that I can make, can it be that? I totally support the amendment tabled by my noble friend Lord Howe.
Baroness Gerada (CB)
My Lords, one of the people who I have most admired over the years is the American paediatrician, Professor Don Berwick—some of your Lordships may know him—who is an international expert on healthcare and a great advocate of the NHS. In fact, he led the Mid Staffs review in 2013. In the States, he led Medicare and Medicaid under President Obama. It always struck me that Don Berwick wrote us a birthday card on the NHS’s 60th birthday. It was a long card and I urge your Lordships to read it one day. He offered a simple prescription for the NHS: “Stop restructuring”. He warned that successive reorganisations drained the workforce’s “energy and confidence” and argued that stability makes improvement easier. Does the Minister agree that his advice would be well taken?
My Lords, the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, and the noble Lord, Lord Patel, made some important points about cross-government working. I was thinking back to what the noble Lord, Lord Patel, said, basically that what started under Tony Blair was continued under Gordon Brown. It was backed up by, first, a specific Cabinet committee, which underpinned the inequalities work, and, secondly, by what were called PSA targets, which tied different departments in. I think that was a good mechanism. In defence of the Government, though, the important work that is being undertaken in relation to health inequality by Alan Milburn, working with different government departments, is going to be pivotal because it embraces the terrible outcomes for so many people who come under the NEET category. It is also looking at the dreadful mental health support for children and adolescents, which goes to the heart of many of these issues. If we can pull this off, we can start to achieve some of the equality issues that we have been talking about.
Like the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, I am here to say a few words about coastal health because the noble Lord, Lord Patel of Bradford, told us we must. Five years ago, the Chief Medical Officer devoted his 2021 annual report to health in coastal communities. He identified high levels of poor physical and mental health, an ageing population with increasingly complex needs and serious challenges in recruiting and retaining the healthcare workforce. The noble Lord, Lord Patel, basically has three asks, on which I want to reinforce what the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, said. Five years after the CMO’s report, we have no strategy. First, will the Government publish a substantive account of progress against his recommendations? Secondly, how will the Government ensure that coastal populations are separately identified? Unless we do that, we do not have the data on which to plan and strategise and see whether improvements can be made. Thirdly, will the department work across government to develop and test commissioning prevention workforce models suited to the distinctive geography and needs of coastal communities? I would be very grateful if my noble friend would agree to meet the noble Lord, Lord Patel of Bradford, to discuss this further, because it is an important consideration.
My Amendment 11 relates to the terrible distribution of GPs in England currently and asks for a much more equitable distribution. I am grateful to the noble Baronesses, Lady Gerada, Lady Hodgson and Lady Manzoor, for their support. Last week I was very fortunate to have a meeting with Minister Dame Diana Johnson and her officials, which I found extremely helpful, and I was grateful to her officials for the way they have been prepared to communicate on this.
This morning, the RCGP published the State of General Practice 2026 report. Chapter 4, about fair and sustainable general practice care—equitable care—makes clear that action is needed. One area where I believe we need action is what the noble Lord, Lord Darzi, described as
“huge and unwarranted variations in the number of patients per GP”.
Data from the NHS general practice workforce team shows that the national average list size of fully qualified full-time equivalent GPs hovers at around 2,200 patients. John Gooderham, a retired civil servant who once worked for me, undertook a number-crunching exercise showing that the differences in average list sizes are almost unbelievable. His evidence, which was published by the Institute of Health and Social Care Management, showed at least 20 areas with an average list size ranging from 8,300 to 4,400 patients, almost four times as many as the national average. All of them are clearly severely underdoctored. At the other end of the scale, there are 20 areas with an average list size ranging from 1,000 to 1,444 patients.
The trouble is that there seems to be no approach or system to rectify this. We used to have the Medical Practices Committee, which was set up by Nye Bevan in the 1946 Act and lasted until 2001. I have to confess that I took through the legislation abolishing the MPC. Mea culpa—it was a mistake. At the time, the line that I took—I looked it up—was that area health authorities would sort it all out. Where are area health authorities? They did not, and none of their successors has. I think we need to go back to a system that identifies areas that are overdoctored or underdoctored to consider how we can justify this situation. It cannot be allowed to continue. I know that officials feel that the kind of MPC system we had is not fit for today’s more modern circumstances, but one way or another, either through financial incentives or through some restrictions, we have to do something about this. I hope the Government will be sympathetic.
Noble Lords will know that I am passionate about improving the health of all. The National Health Service is the National Health Service, not the ill service. So many disadvantaged, marginalised groups are not receiving the care or the health that they need. I will not go back into the disparities and the health inequalities. I have put my name to the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Patel, who spoke very clearly. It is a simple amendment but would be a pivotal, key amendment to the Bill.
I also support the amendment in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, because without having the first line of defence of GPs, marginalised groups do not have the access to doctors that they desperately need. Everybody knows the effects of inequalities on the economy, the NHS and individuals. The Government have a great opportunity to enhance the Secretary of State’s power and strengthen it, rather than transfer the current power.
As I indicated earlier, in my region we had a duty to bring down inequalities in a deprived area. I worked closely with Alan Milburn and other Ministers, including the then Prime Minister, Tony Blair. It worked when that key emphasis, monitoring, duty and strategy were put in place. We need a health strategy, as the noble Lord, Lord Patel, indicated. I leave the question on the table for the Government. This is a fantastic opportunity. It is not about all the structural change that we have been talking about; this is about making a real difference to people’s lives and to the health of our nation.
Baroness Manzoor
Main Page: Baroness Manzoor (Conservative - Life peer)Department Debates - View all Baroness Manzoor's debates with the Department of Health and Social Care
(2 weeks, 1 day ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, I support the amendments in the group, particularly Amendments 22 and 24, in the names of my noble friends Lord Kamall and Lord Howe. I say to the Minister that patient choice needs to be significantly strengthened, particularly in three important areas.
Currently, there is choice, but we need to make choice much more meaningful, rather than simply theoretical, by giving patients greater control over access to services and their care pathways and ensuring that choice is available across the whole of the NHS and the health ecosystem, not just elective hospital treatment, as was clearly outlined by my noble friend Lord Howe. Patients are not always aware that they can choose which hospital or provider they attend. In practice, patients may simply accept the hospital suggested by their GP or referral system, without being told about alternatives.
How do we improve this? I passionately believe that GPs should have a duty to routinely explain patients’ rights to choose, and patients should be offered a meaningful range of clinically appropriate providers. They should be provided information about waiting times, quality, outcomes and location, as Amendment 22 suggests. Patients should be supported to make informed decisions, rather than being directed towards a single provider. The NHS England guidance recommends currently that referrers should shortlist an average of five provider choices where it is practical, clinically appropriate and preferred by the patient.
Choice is particularly relevant in relation to NHS 111 and A&E attendance. Patients contacting NHS 111 are often given a recommended pathway, but their ability to access alternative services may be limited. For example, a patient might be advised to contact their GP, attend an urgent treatment centre, access a community pharmacy, receive a telephone or face-to-face clinical assessment, or attend A&E if clinically necessary. The problem is that a recommendation is not necessarily a genuine choice if the alternative service is unavailable.
Improvement is needed. There needs to be better access to same-day GP appointments, wider choice in the NHS and wider health ecosystem, more accessible urgent treatment centres, greater availability of evening and weekend services, better integration between NHS 111 and local urgent care providers, and much greater transparency about where patients can receive treatment. The key principle should be that patients are given practical alternatives, not simply redirected from one service to another—audiology has already been mentioned. Amendments 22, 23 and 24 would enable this. I know that this can happen, because, back when we had regions, we had the ability to refer patients to other providers where waiting times could be reduced, and it worked very well. Of course, we must not allow cherry-picking, which is a danger, and we must clearly define what outcomes are to be expected.
My Lords, I agree with the amendments. The original duty included by the Government feels a bit lightweight and almost declaratory, rather than anything of substance. That it is why it is proving a useful debate, through the variety of amendments, to look at putting more substance to this.
In the real world of the NHS, in my experience as a patient and previously as an advocate, what is convenient for the NHS is more important. We will come to this in a broader sense later in the Bill, but it is vital that we try to help patients, as with the earlier duty in the clause that is not being changed, to have more involvement in their healthcare. As my noble friend Lady Manzoor just said, patients are often not aware of the availability of other services. It would be useful to get an understanding of how the Secretary of State intends, through this clause, to make patients more aware.
At the same time, as my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe points out, in effect, probably due to budget constraints, rationing has started by not allowing patients to take advantage of provision in the interests of trying to manage budgets. I am not saying that the NHS is a bottomless pit—it is not—but we have to come back to what the NHS is there for. The constitution is quite clear that patient choice is a key element. That is reasonable in order to try to make sure that we have a healthier society. As my noble friend pointed to, quite a lot of illnesses are stopping people working, or working to their full potential. That is no good. A lot of illnesses mean children are not allowed to reach their full potential and are spending time out of school.
We need to consider such factors when carefully considering the amendments tabled by my Front Bench and that of the Liberal Democrats to beef up what it means to ensure that other provision can be readily accessed to have a healthier society. I hope that my noble friends will bring this back on Report if we do not have any satisfaction today.
My Lords, I support the thrust of the amendments in this group, particularly Amendment 28 in the name of my noble friend Lady Shawcross-Wolfson. She has put her case forcefully and clearly, so I will not detain the Committee for long.
Poor long-term workforce planning creates significant challenges for NHS staff and patient care. Inadequate forecasting, insufficient investment in training and recruitment and poor staff retention contribute to persistent vacancies and skills shortages. This increases workforce loads, stress, burnout and sickness absence, resulting in low morale and higher staff turnover. The NHS becomes increasingly reliant on expensive agency workers and international recruitment, placing additional pressure on budgets. Consequently, services experience longer waiting times, reduced productivity, compromised continuity of care and potential risks to patient safety.
NHS England estimates an existing workforce shortfall of approximately 150,000 full-time equivalent staff, potentially rising to 260,000 to 360,000 by 2036-37 if there is no intervention. Effective long-term planning is therefore essential to develop a sustainable workforce, improve staff well-being, strengthen retention and ensure safe, high-quality patient care. I strongly urge the Minister to support this amendment. Ministers should be held accountable for the delivery of this workforce plan.
My Lords, I strongly support the amendment in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Shawcross-Wolfson, and I have added my name to it. She spoke so eloquently and made her case so strongly that I have put aside what I have written down because it would have been a repetition of what she had already said. I am going to take a slightly different tack but make the same point.
The noble Baroness quite rightly linked education, training and workforce planning. You have to know what workforce you might require for the health service you plan to have. I guess one can say that the Government’s 10-year health plan and the 10-year cancer care plan outline the kind of health service that the Government wish to see develop over the next 10 years. If that is the case, we need to address what kind of training and education and what kind of people we will need to deliver that plan.
I am guessing now that the reason why the 10-year workforce plan is delayed is because the premise on which it was to be formulated was that technology such as AI and digital technology would free a lot of clinical time, and hence the headcount need not be so high. That is a false assumption. It is false because we need to train people to use AI and digital technologies. The assessment is that, if you use these technologies, you might free about 40 minutes a day for front-line clinicians. With the pressure that the NHS now faces and the needs of the workforce it now faces, that time will be used to deliver better care to patients, particularly as the 10-year health plan identifies that technologies such as genomics and personalised medicine will be the way healthcare will go. There is an ambition by 2040 to have 50% of patients with some idea of their genomics, and the treatment is therefore based on that.
If you add all these together, and the Secretary of State now has responsibility for education, training and workforce planning, you ask the question: why is the workforce plan delayed? It is delayed because maybe the penny has dropped that, if you do not count the numbers and do not present a case about how technologies will reduce front-line clinical time, then you cannot plan the workforce.
Furthermore, I wonder whether the Bailie review of productivity in the NHS is based on the premise that greater productivity will be delivered in the NHS because of using technologies such as AI and digital technologies. We do not know that that will happen, but we have to wait until the Bailie review comes out. I wonder whether that is another reason—the Minister might comment on that—why the workforce plan is delayed.
It might be political pressures, it might be fiscal pressures or it might be the pressures from not knowing how to get the workforce numbers that we would require to deliver the 10-year plan and the cancer care plan that are holding up workforce planning. However, as the noble Baroness, Lady Shawcross-Wolfson, pointed out, if we do not have a plan, things will get worse. We will introduce technology, which will not be across the board, and we will then look for workforce that is not trained to deliver it. I hope the Minister will give us some answers about where we are going.
Baroness Manzoor
Main Page: Baroness Manzoor (Conservative - Life peer)Department Debates - View all Baroness Manzoor's debates with the Department of Health and Social Care
(2 weeks, 1 day ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, following the review by the noble Lord, Lord Mann, I certainly hope that the regulators toughen up their act, and in accepting its recommendations the Government certainly expect them to. I agree with the thrust of where the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, is coming from. Whether all discretion should be taken away from the regulators, I very much doubt, but it will be interesting to hear what my noble friend has to say on that.
In supporting the amendment tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, I want to reflect on two points. First, I repeat what the noble Baroness said, which was striking, arising from the report of the noble Lord, Lord Mann. Drawing on the NHS staff survey, Jewish staff are the only religious group where discrimination from managers and colleagues exceeds discrimination from patients. This is a very serious indication of the stress and pressure on Jewish staff within the NHS.
I am afraid that, so far, the response from management has been pretty poor. We have seen that in relation to what we might call uniform policy. As the noble Lord, Lord Mann, described it:
“Examples such as the brandishing of badges, the display of uniforms on political marches or the co-branding of the NHS by staff or others with third parties has made it unclear what patients can expect from the NHS”.
Patients are entitled to be treated without seeing staff display any political leanings whatever or support for campaigns. Teachers are simply not allowed to do this. One has to ask, what is with NHS employers that they have failed to put across to their staff the behaviour that is expected of them?
The noble Lord, Lord Mann, clearly called for NHS England to review what we might call its uniform policy. It is not the standardised uniform, but what people wear and how they display it. My understanding is that that work is being undertaken, subject to consultation. I hope that, when it comes out, it is not going to be wiffly-waffly, leaving too much discretion to local employers. Now that the Government are taking this over—because I doubt it will be finished before 1 April next year—they should make it abundantly clear to NHS employers what should and should not be expected.
I know that Manchester has been cited as a very good example. As the noble Lord, Lord Mann, said, some trusts do not permit the wearing of political badges, of any item of clothing with a political message or of a uniform to political rallies. We need to see something firm about this so that employers are implementing what is required of them from the centre. For employers, this would be much easier than going through the agony of developing local policies that are subject to consultation and lead to variation. Patients and staff are entitled to be in an environment where somebody else’s political views are not displayed in a way which causes huge upset and concern.
My Lords, I understand and support the aims and sentiment behind this group of amendments—particularly Amendment 29 and 258. Any form of discrimination or racism is abhorrent. How one identifies oneself should not be a problem. Antisemitism is not acceptable.
It may be helpful to remind ourselves of some figures as, sadly, racism and discrimination remain embedded challenges within the NHS, affecting both staff and patients, as acknowledged by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada. It is worth noting that 28.6% of NHS staff in 2024 were from ethnic-minority backgrounds. That was around 450,000 people, yet only 12.7% of senior managers came from those backgrounds. The 2025 NHS staff survey found that ethnic-minority staff were more likely to experience discrimination from managers and colleagues: that is 13.9% of ethnic-minority staff compared with 6.51% of white staff. Some 29.16% of ethnic-minority staff experienced harassment, bullying or abuse by patients and by the public, compared with 23.54% of white staff. It is important to further strengthen legislation as there are gaps.
The Equality Act 2010 prohibits racial discrimination, harassment and victimisation. However, significant weaknesses remain. The public sector equality duty requires organisations to “have due regard to” equality but does not guarantee measurable improvements. The NHS equality standards lack sufficient enforcement and meaningful consequences for persistent institutional discrimination. Will the Minister consider how the Government can strengthen this further, particularly as reporting, investigating and addressing racism remains inconsistent, with inadequate protections and support for whistleblowers? How will the Government address this? There is no sufficiently robust uniform accountability framework ensuring that perpetrators and senior leaders face consequences, as the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, stated. Will the Government consider developing such a framework on all forms of discrimination? This would also support the 2026 review by the noble Lord, Lord Mann, which reinforces the need for stronger investigations, transparency and organisational accountability.
My Lords, I strongly support the intentions behind these amendments. Two practical issues are leadership and accountability, and the protection of those who speak out.
Tackling antisemitism and racism must be a clear responsibility of NHS leadership. These issues should be included in the performance objectives of every chief executive in the NHS—I have done this in the past. The boards would be required to monitor them and hold the executives and themselves to account. I am sure the CQC could incorporate this into its well-led reviews and make sure it happens. It is not enough to have policies and training programmes; we need to know whether they are making a difference and who is responsible when they are not.
Secondly, we must protect those who report racism or antisemitism. Too often, staff are reluctant to speak out because they fear the consequences for their careers or their relationships with colleagues. We need clear reporting arrangements, protection against victimisation and retaliation, and independent routes to raise concerns if senior managers themselves are involved. I hope the Minister agrees that we should hold boards and NHS chief executives to account and properly protect those who call this out.
Baroness Manzoor
Main Page: Baroness Manzoor (Conservative - Life peer)Department Debates - View all Baroness Manzoor's debates with the Department of Health and Social Care
(1 week, 2 days ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, who finished where I am going to start, with the huge powers of direction that the Bill provides to the Secretary of State. His amendments are directed primarily towards parliamentary accountability; my Amendment 39 is about keeping decision-making power local.
This amendment would
“prevent the Secretary of State from using the general power of direction to determine individual local commissioning decisions, while limiting directions on specialised services to defined national purposes”.
The noble Lord, Lord Scriven, said that his amendments are probing. I am afraid that mine aims to suggest a way forward for the Government, because I suspect that we will find in many amendments in this area that the House wants to see something happen with the overweening power that the Bill currently provides. As the noble Lord said, this appears to be going in the opposite direction of what the Government say their intentions are for the devolving of power and resources down to local areas.
What we have here is a fundamental question about where decisions on the NHS should be made and who should make them. Of course there should be national standards and accountability, but that is very different from giving the Secretary of State the power to intervene in the day-to-day commissioning decisions of local health bodies. My amendment talks about things such as
“the opening, closure or relocation of a particular NHS service or facility … the location at which a … service is provided”
and who should provide services.
As the Nuffield Trust has pointed out, the English NHS is already unusually centralised, compared to other similarly sized health systems. The Bill takes us even further in that direction by giving the Secretary of State powers to intervene in integrated care boards well beyond those currently available to NHS England. The powers over NHS foundation trusts exceed the powers that the department held even before NHS England was created. The concern is that these powers might be used not simply when an ICB is failing but when it is not following the political interests, personal prejudices or even whims of the Secretary of State.
Integrated care boards exist to make commissioning decisions that reflect the needs of their local populations. Those needs vary across the country and Westminster does not necessarily—or even very often—understand such individual regional differences. The health challenges facing a rural community are not necessarily the same as those of an inner-city population, but a large inner-city population may have more political clout than a dispersed rural one. The availability of services, transport links and local demographics all matter. Decisions about where a service is provided, whether a facility should open or close or which provider should deliver care require an understanding of those local circumstances. They should not be a matter of political direction from Whitehall.
I think we can all imagine the real risk that these powers will encourage Ministers to announce some great input into an individual hospital facility or services without properly understanding the consequences for the community concerned, or indeed from political motivations. We are talking about the potential for political favouritism, with decisions influenced by that rather than the needs of patients.
The amendment would prevent the Secretary of State using the general direction power to make individual local decisions, but the separate intervention powers under Section 14Z62A remain available. It recognises that specialised services are different; they are often complex, expensive and relatively rare and there is a strong case for national consistency and collaboration between integrated care boards there. In relation to specialised services for clearly defined national purposes, the amendment therefore allows directions for
“determining which services should be commissioned as specialised services”,
ensuring compliance with national standards and commissioning policies, and requiring collaboration between ICBs. We would be allowing national co-ordination where it is needed without providing an open-ended power to micromanage local healthcare.
It is difficult to see how meaningful devolution can take place if local health bodies know that the decisions they make can be overridden by the Secretary of State. Local bodies must have the freedom to make decisions and the accountability that goes with that freedom. We should be building an NHS where local leaders are supported to make decisions based on evidence, professional expertise and the needs of their population, not a system where they are looking over their shoulders and anticipating the next political intervention from Westminster.
We know that that kind of central control can encourage defensive decision-making, discourage openness and make it much harder to have honest conversations about the challenges facing local services. This amendment seriously aims to offer a practical way forward: it would preserve the Secretary of State’s ability to intervene when an ICB is genuinely failing and ensure national co-ordination of specialised services, while protecting the integrity of local commissioning decisions.
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, has tabled the probing Amendment 40, which includes the proposed new Section 14Z61A. It is important because it seeks to improve health outcomes, rather than simply restructuring the NHS, which appears to be the central purpose of the Health Bill. As the noble Lord stated, it would require the Secretary of State to publish clear national health outcomes covering patient safety, quality of care, waiting times, health inequalities and the effective use of resources. Progress would be reported to Parliament, strengthening transparency and democratic accountability.
Crucially, proposed new Section 14Z61 would require the Secretary of State to set specific outcomes for each integrated care board, reflecting local health needs and involving consultation with local authorities and mayors. This would give ICBs clear responsibilities while preserving flexibility over how they deliver improvements, which would be key. Together, such provisions would strengthen the Bill by creating measurable accountability, protecting local decision-making and ensuring that NHS reform delivers tangible improvements in patient care, illness prevention and public health.
I strongly support this important amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, and I urge the Minister to adopt it, particularly if the Government’s 10-year health plan strategy is to succeed in the long term.
My Lords, I am interested in the amendments tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, particularly Amendment 40, but I will speak to them in a slightly different way. What I am trying to understand is how his amendment differs from the current NHS constitution—it is reviewed every 10 years on a statutory basis; it happened only fairly recently—and the targets associated with patients’ constitutional rights. How would this work with the outcomes for the health service and integrated care boards?
I am actually very supportive of the change the Government are seeking to introduce. That partly comes from experience of trying to pull a few levers: sometimes the levers work, but other times you need to get on with things. A good example of how this could be deployed is if a Prime Minister decides that, instead of how IVF treatment happens now, there will be a postcode lottery around the country. At the moment, I think you are guaranteed just one. If they decided that everybody should have three, by issuing a direction and—importantly, given the clause—putting in the money to go with it, they could straightforwardly make a transformational change across the NHS. That would be instead of the Lansley Act approach, which is to work from the bottom up and evolve over time. This brings us back full circle: understandably, the public think that politicians are generally in charge and if they stand on a manifesto commitment, they should be able to deliver it. This measure is welcome in that regard.
I do not think that this will be used to stop the closure of a particular hospital, but—dare I say it—if it is, so what? That would be acceptable so long as the Government come up with the cash to keep that hospital or maternity care unit open. Very soon, there will be only one maternity unit in the whole of the county of Norfolk, and that is a big area to cover. Perhaps that is because there are fewer births, but it is nevertheless worrying, given that it is necessary to travel for well over an hour to get to a hospital to give birth. If the Government decide that this is not appropriate, instead of going through this rather complex ICB consultation, it would be much easier if the Secretary of State could say that they are not prepared for that to happen and are prepared to achieve something else—whatever the situation is. I am just giving examples because I think we were asked what kinds of examples this could be used for.
I would like just a bit more clarification, and for anyone listening to this debate, on this real issue of patient services and how we are going to improve them. So, are there the positive directions? I understand there will be special directions by the Secretary of State, which is totally understandable—it has always been the case, certainly in the last 30-odd years that I have been involved with the NHS in one form or another. If we are going to improve our NHS, we need duties regarding the outcomes. Is there any thinking on that? Sorry to push a bit further, but that is critical if we are looking to improve the NHS for patients.
There is no need for the noble Baroness to apologise; that is what we are seeking to do. The point here is that we are, by definition, confining our discussions to when things are going wrong or there are concerns. It is important to state that all the changes we are making and all the frameworks that are in place—the whole suite of measures—are there to ensure patient safety, the right outcomes and the right service to patients. In this discussion there is inevitably a greater focus on when things go wrong, but we are trying to ensure that things do not go wrong.
My Lords, I do not want to repeat anything that has been said, and I agree with most of the comments that have been made, except, with apologies, those of the noble Baroness, for the reasons that have been articulated. We have an independent, private and state sector NHS. I was around in the 2000s, and we did an awful lot of commissioning in the independent and charitable sectors and it worked well.
To make this clause much stronger, the real emphasis should be on procurement. There is a real issue when the NHS procures—not thinking of the impact it has on other services being provided by that hospital, and it is usually hospitals. That funding, when things go wrong and that care has been provided by the private sector, reverts back into the NHS. There needs to be some mechanism and recognition of where those costs sit.
When she looks at this clause, the Minister should perhaps also look at what happens to the spare estate facility and capability of those organisations, because they still have rents, rates, electrics, et cetera. That does not get shut down because, irrespective of what we say, there are still block contracts. I know that we have clauses on block contracts, but procurement is very important and we should look at where choice is in the way that the contracts are let out. It is not cherry-picking; for the very simple operations—I think the noble Baroness, Lady Murphy, mentioned cataracts—that is very important. It is not just about the timeliness of things, which is important, but the quality and the outcome of that service that has been provided to that particular patient. I totally support the comments made by my noble friend Lady Coffey. We must put the patient at the heart of this.
My Lord, when we started this group, I did not expect the phrase “the Soviet model of healthcare” to be mentioned, but the noble Baroness, Lady Murphy, used it. It is always surprising what one hears and learns in Committee. From these Benches, our starting point is simple: the principle that defines the NHS is that care is free at the point of use and based on need, not ability, to pay. That is a line that I think most noble Lords would never wish us to cross.
Who owns the building matters less to a patient than whether they get good care in good time, and a good outcome without paying for it. As Liberals, we start from individual patients. We ask what power the patient has, who can take it away and why. I respect what the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, is trying to do. She is right to raise concerns about profit and public money, but her amendments are the wrong answer. They would take choice from patients, and those with the least would lose most.
Let us take Herefordshire. It is a large, rural county with one NHS acute hospital: the county hospital in Hereford. The next-nearest NHS acute hospitals are in other counties, or even across the border in Wales. Many villages have few buses. The county’s own draft transport plan is still working towards better links between Hereford and market towns. Nuffield Health also has a hospital in Hereford, which provides some NHS services free at the point of use to patients. Under the noble Baroness’s presumption, that option exists only if there is no reasonable public alternative within a clinically appropriate timeframe. The test asks, “how soon?”, but not “how far?”, nor how a pensioner with no car gets to an operation in another country or county, and home again. Care is free at the point of use; the journey is not. For someone on a low income, a free operation that they cannot reach is not much use, nor is it right. A patient on a long waiting list at the only public hospital in their county should be able to choose another provider nearby, free at the point of use—whether that be private or NHS provided. Someone with money can already pay to leave the queue. Taking away that free option would not abolish the two-tier system; I believe it would deepen it.
This also goes well beyond hospitals, as other noble Lords said. The new clause in the amendment after Clause 11 says a service is not publicly provided if it is contracted to a private body, and only public bodies may provide it. As noble Lords said, most GP practices are private contractors, as are many community pharmacists, high street dentists and opticians. They are the front door of the NHS. What about hospices? There are 135 independent adult hospice charities in England. The National Audit Office says the sector cared for about 251,000 people in 2023-24, with the Government funding around 29% of its income. Are those to be taken out or shut down under this amendment? As has already been pointed out, in 2023-24, over half of NHS cataract operations were done by independent providers. Bringing them back at speed into NHS public bodies would lengthen waits for older people to have their cataracts done. The term “private sector body” is not defined in the amendments, so we cannot tell which of these would fall under the presumption.
The review in Amendment 36 is the most useful idea in this group from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, but it is framed around returning services to public provision. It should ask a neutral question: which providers—public or independent—give quality, value and fair access, with provision free at the point of use? None of this is a blank cheque for the private sector. Independent providers delivering NHS care must meet the same standards and publish the same data. They should train staff and not pick off the simple cases while the NHS keeps the complex ones. That is part of what ICB strategic commissioning needs to pick up. Independent providers delivered only around 7.5% of NHS planned care in February this year, based on their own trade body’s figures. They are a useful supplement, but they are no substitute for NHS care that is properly and publicly funded.
This brings me to Clause 10. What is the point of it? What problem is it solving? Can the noble Baroness give the Committee an example of what a Secretary of State cannot do now that they could do with this clause? We need to be clear that this clause changes a provision in the 2006 Act which stops the Secretary of State from swinging between private and public. The new clause would allow to happen the very thing that the 2006 Act stopped, depending on how the Secretary of State felt when they got up that morning and decided whether they were in the mood for public or private healthcare. The Committee needs to understand what problem this is solving, because, I think like most noble Lords, I have no idea why this provision is in the Bill and what it is trying to solve.
The noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, rightly asks in her amendment for us to think of patients rather than the organisation. The noble Lord, Lord Kamall, goes further, and I find his approach the most persuasive in the group. It is that, basically, a change would have to be necessary to improve patient outcomes. Surely that is the test against ideology from either a public or a private direction. The Secretary of State would also publish the reasons and lay them before Parliament.
The amendments from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, raise serious concerns in terms of completely undermining what a public health service—the NHS—should be about. It should be about quality, about outcomes and about patients having choice. The Secretary of State should not dictate which type of hospital a patient should go to, as long as the basis is free at point of use, the quality of care is monitored, and outcomes are the same as in a publicly funded body. I really look forward to the Minister explaining the reason for Clause 10, because I believe that most noble Lords would like to understand exactly what problem it is trying to solve.
Baroness Manzoor
Main Page: Baroness Manzoor (Conservative - Life peer)Department Debates - View all Baroness Manzoor's debates with the Department of Health and Social Care
(1 day, 15 hours ago)
Lords ChamberThat makes sense, because clearly, the ICB itself is accountable to the Secretary of State and is generally acting under delegated powers. Clearly, the mayoral nominee is accountable to the mayor. Hopefully, because there is joint responsibility, that will work well. However, the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, will then ask why Clause 24 is abolishing the partnerships between health and local government.
There is another question about delegation and devolution. I have been surprised that the arrangements in Greater Manchester, where the combined authority has much wider responsibilities in relation to the NHS than in other parts of the country, have not been extended to other parts of the country.
The noble Lord, Lord Stevens, is not in his place, but those changes were made basically because George Osborne reached an agreement with the chief executive and mayor of Manchester City Council. It was done without consulting NHS England, which had just been announced, and it fought tooth and nail against it. That is a great pity. I am not saying that everything is rosy in Greater Manchester—as a West Midlander, I have views on that—but there is no doubt that there is strong evidence, and I have seen research by Manchester University, to show that there have been improved outcomes because of that partnership. What one is really looking for here is some assurance from the Government that they recognise that they need to go further. We need to get this partnership working. If ever one wanted a reason for it, the Milburn report refers to the role of mayors in trying to deal with the horrendous problem we have with young people at the moment. It must have a strong health element.
I am afraid this is a bit of a disparate group of amendments. It all comes back to the same thing: recognising that health and local government have to work together. I hope that the Government can respond in a way that gives us confidence that they recognise that, and that we can build on that in future.
Does the noble Lord agree that until budgets for social care and health are combined in a meaningful way, there will always be anomalies between the two sectors? We really need to target that in light of what has already been said.
Yes, but I point to Northern Ireland, where health and social services were brought together in 1974. I am afraid I do not think that provides a model because, in theory, they had a joint budget but, in practice, they did not and ran it separately. We have to wait for the outcome of the current review into social care before we can come to a conclusion in relation to that. In the meantime, although there is always going to be a cost shift between health and social care, I still think we can make these partnerships stronger.
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 97, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Scott of Needham Market, to which I added my name. I will speak also to my Amendment 99 in this group, to which the noble Baroness has put her name, for which I am grateful.
Both these amendments seek to strengthen Clause 25 and address the critical question of whether the neighbourhood health framework is sufficiently clear about people whose conditions require continuing co-ordinating support but may not always be visible in immediate access or activity measures. The answer, in short, is no, and this is the view held by a host of dedicated organisations, including Alzheimer’s Research UK, Parkinson’s UK, the Migraine Trust and the Neurological Alliance, to name a few.
Amendment 97 seeks to build on the existing architecture of neighbourhood care by requiring neighbourhood health plans to set out how the needs of people with long-term, complex or fluctuating health conditions are to be met—in particular, the needs of those suffering from neurological conditions, which impact one out of every six people in England and span more than 600 different conditions, ranging from sudden onset issues such as stroke or traumatic brain injury to progressive diseases such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s, to intermittent conditions such as migraine and epilepsy. I should declare that I suffer from migraine and that epilepsy impacts one of my children, but is, thankfully, well controlled. With this hugely significant and diverse group in mind, Amendment 99 would require guidance issued by the Secretary of State under Clause 25(4) to cover the identification of unmet needs, clinical pathways, workforce and service capacity, and accountability arrangements for services supporting those with long-term, fluctuating health conditions.
These amendments would support earlier recognition, co-ordinated care and appropriate planning across primary care, and community and specialist services, while preserving local flexibility. Crucially, they would set measurable improvement objectives and make organisational responsibility clear. These amendments are proportionate. They would strengthen the existing NHP process, rather than creating a separate, disease-specific plan or treatment entitlement. By keeping the legal duty broad and non-exhaustive, they would avoid disease-by-disease legislation.
Crucially, these amendments would give neurological conditions a clear policy home within neighbourhood planning. Without greater clarity, under-recognised conditions risk being overlooked within broad population priorities. A prime example of this is migraine: a neurological condition that impacts 10 million of us across the UK, for which treatment is underfunded, inconsistent and, at times, misguided, and shows huge regional disparities. Migraine is generally a high-volume but low-complexity condition, meaning that, if optimal treatment pathways are followed efficiently, capacity can be freed up in other parts of the health service.
Let me illustrate this. The NHS currently spends around £150 million a year on directly treating migraine, a condition that carries an annual cost to this country of £10 billion to £12 billion, of which more than £1 billion is incurred by the health service itself. How so? We currently have more than 5 million undiagnosed migraineurs, resulting in 2.5 million to 3 million primary care appointments in England per year, 40,000 hospital admissions per year and a huge increase in visits to A&E since the pandemic. Only a third of people diagnosed with migraine are prescribed basic preventive medication within one year of diagnosis. This is hugely inefficient and frustrating, both for the patient and the NHS. The impact on the workforce and the economy is eye-watering, with lost working days and reduced productivity currently running at £8 billion to £10 billion a year.
Migraine represents an important test for whether the reforms in the Bill will improve care. As for many neurological conditions, there is currently a postcode lottery of care for migraine. The Migraine Trust tells us that only 26 of England’s 42 integrated care systems have a specialised headache clinic.
In conclusion, Amendments 95 and 97 offer critically needed safeguards during NHS restructuring and health devolution—particularly during the transition period, with the uncertainty around national clinical leadership and analytical capacity—and where the less visible conditions lack clear ownership. I hope the Minister and her department will accept these amendments as both constructive and proportionate, or at the very least set out equally robust commitments through statutory guidance.
My Lords, Clause 25 concerns neighbourhood health plans and the guidance covering their implementation. I agree that they need to be strengthened to ensure that they lead to measurable improvements in patient care rather than becoming another layer of NHS bureaucracy. I support the general thrust of all these amendments, particularly Amendments 95 and 100. Amendment 95 was so ably and comprehensively covered by the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler of Enfield, and I have no doubt that Amendment 100 will be comprehensively covered by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada.
These amendments could improve the Bill in five ways. First, they would strengthen accountability—today and on other days in Committee, we have heard a lot about accountability and transparency—by requiring local authorities and integrated care boards to publish clear objectives, responsibilities and annual progress reports. Secondly, they would guarantee meaningful public involvement by explicitly including patients, carers, voluntary organisations and seldom-heard communities in designing and reviewing plans. Thirdly, they would protect clinical leadership by requiring GPs, nurses, pharmacists and other front-line professionals to contribute to decisions. Fourthly, they would provide adequate resources by ensuring that plans are supported by identified funding, workforce capacity and realistic implementation timescales. Fifthly and finally, they would ensure that outcomes are measured. We have all been talking about outcomes, which are fundamental and run through the 10-year strategic plan. Measuring outcomes and requiring measurable targets covering prevention, waiting times, access, health inequalities and patient experience are important.
Crucially, the neighbourhood health plan should be a statutory delivery commitment, not simply a document that the organisation must have regard to. The Secretary of State should issue guidance setting minimum standards while allowing local flexibility. This would make Clause 25 more practical, transparent and genuinely accountable to local communities. I hope the Minister is able to give the thrust of these amendments and arguments further consideration before Report.
Baroness Gerada (CB)
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 100 in my name. I thank Impact on Urban Health for its support. I was struck by the speeches of the noble Lord, Lord Londesborough, and other noble Lords about neurological conditions and the need for joined-up care. I have sat though many of the debates on the Bill, and this further reinforces my view that we need a fundamental shift in how we look at the NHS and how we use our hospitals. Hospitals are not just places that people go to but part of our local community, where we do prevention. We need to look at how we use our teams of staff and move consultants and nurses out of hospitals to support integration, and how we use the resources, the money and the expertise.