Amendment of the Law

Debate between Ed Balls and Albert Owen

Thursday 24th March 2011 Commons Chamber

[Ed Balls]

Let me turn to the detail of the Budget for a second more, but I look forward to hearing from the hon. Gentleman. I only read out five of his Labour campaigns, but maybe he will enlighten us on a sixth in a moment.

[Albert Owen (Ynys Môn) (Lab)]

The shadow Chancellor was right to remind the Liberal Democrats that they once thought that a VAT increase would be a bombshell, but does he also remember the Prime Minister, when he was Leader of the Opposition, saying that VAT was a regressive tax that would hit the poor the hardest, and that he had no intention of increasing it?

[Ed Balls]

I also remember the Chancellor saying that the Budget was progressive, and it turned out to be regressive, but my hon. Friend is being unfair to Liberal Democrat colleagues. They were not against a VAT rise; they were against a Tory VAT rise. Nick Clegg’s general election leaflets said, “Stop the Tory VAT bombshell,” and he never said, “Stop the Tory-Liberal Democrat VAT bombshell,” so my hon. Friend is being a little harsh on colleagues.