Budget Resolutions and Economic Situation

Debate between Edward Miliband and Rachel Reeves

Thursday 24th June 2010 Commons Chamber

[Edward Miliband]

I have enormous respect for the hon. Gentleman, but he will have to do better than that.

[Rachel Reeves]

Can my right hon. Friend confirm that, in addition to what I said earlier about this Budget affecting the top decile by just 0.7% and the bottom decile by 2.6%, Labour’s March Budget had an impact on the top decile of 7% and absolutely no impact at all on the income of the poorest decile? There is a different way of doing a Budget, and that was a progressive Budget.

[Edward Miliband]

My hon. Friend is right, of course. That is the difference between a Labour Budget and a Conservative Budget—

Energy and Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Debate between Edward Miliband and Rachel Reeves

Thursday 27th May 2010 Commons Chamber

[Edward Miliband]

So there we have it—the Greek defence. A person may vote Liberal Democrat, but along sails the Greek defence, which means that one does not need to keep one’s promises. Promises do not mean anything from the Liberal Democrats if something happens in Greece. The Secretary of State will have to do a lot better than that.

[Rachel Reeves]

Will my right hon. Friend confirm that Greece’s debt is 110% of its gross domestic product? That is twice as high a ratio of debt to GDP as that in the UK. That, and not the budget deficit, is the important point with regard to sustainability. The budget deficits of Greece and the UK are comparable, but in terms of sustainability, the issue is the level of debt. As the UK’s debt is half the level of Greece’s, those comparisons are scaremongering excuses for policies that the Conservatives always wanted to pursue.

[Edward Miliband]

My hon. Friend gives the House and the Secretary of State an economics lecture.