Lord Balfe debates involving HM Treasury during the 2024 Parliament

Wed 15th Jan 2025
Financial Assistance to Ukraine Bill
Lords Chamber

2nd reading & Committee negatived & 3rd reading

Autumn Budget 2026

Lord Balfe Excerpts
Thursday 12th November 2026

(5 days, 6 hours ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Balfe Portrait Lord Balfe (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I congratulate the three maiden speakers we have heard and look forward to the fourth.

It is always good to start with a bit of good news. I am the halfway point. After my speech, noble Lords will be heading towards the end of the debate. I am sure that will please a few people.

This is a very odd debate because we know the Chancellor has ruled out cutting benefits in this Parliament. Two reports are being produced, one by Stephen Timms and another by Alan Milburn, on the future of various benefits. I have been to meetings with both and have had a private meeting with Stephen Timms. They are not postponing the decisions; they will produce reports that will start another large series of rows, as our House will say that we should implement the reports and a bit more, while the House of Commons, I suspect, will say that it does not want any cuts at all because their grannies will starve.

We have hit a major problem, because, although we have put off the decisions, the fact is that the review does not foresee any reduction at all. My noble friend Lord Hammond, whom we do not see here very often these days, once said to me that his time in the Treasury was spent interviewing MPs from the Conservative Party, who said that they believed in savings but that they had to be made from Labour’s benefits, and people from the Labour Party, who said that they wanted him to invest to save. Investing involved spending government money, and he told me he had never seen any savings coming into the Treasury from doing so. I have a certain amount of sympathy with the Chancellor in trying to get his way round this conundrum.

What has happened is that the Governments of both parties have failed to control public spending. It has been edged up for many years by a very compliant Civil Service. I was amazed when I learned that the Department for Work and Pensions was incentivising civil servants to clear people off the applications for certain benefits. They were being decided over the phone, and the key was that you were a good civil servant if you approved a lot of benefits, because if you did not approve them then you got letters from MPs and Ministers and life was made very difficult. So the first thing I say to the Government is let us look for cross-party agreement to get the benefits bill down, because it has to come down.

My final point—we do not have that long—is that the freeze on middle-class aspiration has to stop. As some noble Lords know, I have been president of two TUC trade unions: those of the dietitians and the pilots. Both of them, especially the pilots, are high-earning, but they are also hard-working. Pilots are often on the other side of the world when their child has a birthday or is in the school play. Their wives—the pilots are mainly men—are, in effect, one-parent families. They have had this £100,000 threshold for several years now, and it appears that it will never be lifted. It is a new way of raising money, but it is also a new way of disincentivising people. It says to people: leave the country and move abroad, and do less work.

We need a Government who put more incentive back into the achievers and strivers in society, to encourage them to work harder, to increase the wealth of the country, and, in doing so, to make the country and their families more prosperous, not to feel that the Government are the eternal enemy, as many of them feel at the moment.

Supermarkets: Voluntary Price Caps

Lord Balfe Excerpts
Wednesday 20th May 2026

(5 months, 4 weeks ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I absolutely understand the importance of the regulations that the noble Baroness is talking about. As her noble friend said, this is about what we as a Government can do, such as easing existing regulations on supermarkets, which would then enable them to keep costs down for consumers.

Lord Balfe Portrait Lord Balfe (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, 50 years ago I was working in the retail sector when the right honourable Baroness Williams, who was a Member of this House some time later, was the Minister for food prices. At the end of her term of office, she admitted that it was a hopeless task to try to curtail food prices or to ration them. Can I suggest that the Government dig out the files from 50 years ago, read them and then maybe reconsider whether this rather extreme idea from Scotland is worth pursuing any further?

Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

The noble Lord asks me to reconsider an extreme idea that we are not considering, so I think we should be okay on that point. The times he talked about were very different. I do not think anyone would advocate for that now, and we certainly are not.

Mansion House Accord

Lord Balfe Excerpts
Wednesday 14th May 2025

(1 year, 6 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Balfe Portrait Lord Balfe (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, having spent much of my life as a pension fund trustee, I am aware that this is not a new proposal. Can the Minister give us an undertaking that voluntary will not precede compulsory? What pension fund trustees are concerned about is being ordered what to do with their members’ money, which they are trustees of, not for.

Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I think I may have covered that several times already. I do not agree with the noble Lord when he says that this is not new. For the first time, we have 17 providers signing an accord, giving a commitment from industry to bring more assets into scope, doubling the target from 5% to 10% and including a specific commitment to investing half of that in the UK. That commitment has not been given before. As I have said, the pension schemes Bill will include more details about how these developments will be monitored to make sure that that change is delivered.

Financial Assistance to Ukraine Bill

Lord Balfe Excerpts
Lord Balfe Portrait Lord Balfe (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I add my congratulations to the noble Baroness, Lady Batters, on her maiden speech. I came across the NFU many years ago through my very good friend Lord Plumb, who introduced me to this Chamber. He taught me quite a bit about the NFU and mentioned the noble Baroness to me as one of the up and coming stars of the institution. I am surprised that she had difficulty with public speaking, but clearly she has overcome it extremely well. We all look forward to many contributions in this House, given her special knowledge of agriculture, Ukraine, Africa and other subjects.

You can always depend on me when we have a debate on Russia. I am the one who makes the speech no one wants to hear. Today, unfortunately, my two co-religionists, the noble Lords, Lord Skidelsky and Lord Campbell-Savours, are not present, so I am left to do this all on my own. My message has not changed over the years. My message is very simply this. We have all agreed that Russia was wrong to invade Ukraine. It does not take an O-level in geography to recognise that. But what we have not been very good at is looking at the consequences of where we are now and where we are heading to. We need to remember my good friend John Major’s advice: in a hole, stop digging.

We need to look at some perspective. The Minister in the Commons, Darren Jones, said that we were going to carry on until Russia ceases its war of aggression and we win. I will first ask a very simple question. What is “win”? I have seen no evidence of any movement in Crimea to go back into Ukraine. Nor have I seen any evidence from Luhansk or Donetsk to the same effect.

The Ukraine Government made, as I have said many times, a tragic and stupid mistake when it outlawed the Russian language in places where 100% of the people spoke Russian. That alienated the eastern provinces, and the chasing out of Viktor Yanukovych did the rest. We now have to live with the consequences and build for the future.

The extraordinary revenue acceleration is a Group of Seven agreement, but has it been implemented elsewhere? Is this particular programme on the statute book of the US Senate? Will it sustain itself in the face of a President Trump? Is it passed by the Canadian Parliament? Will it sustain itself with a Prime Minister Poilievre, whom Canada is likely to get? Is it on the statue book of the Federal German Republic? Will it survive a new Chancellor in Germany? Has it gone through the French Parliament? That Parliament appears unable to pass any legislation at all at the moment, let alone something like this.

I am unclear as to where we are, apart from the fact that we are passing the Act. What about the rest of the people on the list? What is actually happening? In the case of Italy, Italian support of Ukraine is not at a very high level at the moment. From what I know of Prime Minister Meloni, I wonder what her Government are doing? It would be good to know—not because I will vote against the Bill or try to stop it; it is a government Bill that seems to have the support of everybody in this House apart from me, so it will go through. But we need to know where we are with the Bill.

We also need to know pretty soon where we are with the new United States Administration because, let us face it, they will call the shots; we are not going to. This will be like Afghanistan—the US Administration will decide on a policy, we will be lucky to get a phone call and we certainly will not be able to carry on on our own. We need a European dimension to all this that looks at it from the interests of Europe. Those interests clearly involve the rebuilding of Ukraine but also involve coming to an arrangement with the Russian Federation that will stick. We seem to forget that we expelled Russia from the Council of Europe. “Great”, we said. We expelled 135 million Russians from the protection of the Court of Human Rights. We do not talk about that, though, do we?

We need a reset of our relations with the Russian Federation, with Ukraine and with the riparian countries of eastern Europe that rightly feel alarmed about Russia but also feel a little alarmed about the capacity and willingness of those of us further west to defend them. It is fine to say, “We have Article 5 of the NATO treaty”. I talked not so long ago to a Portuguese admiral —noble Lords will be surprised who I tend to know—who said, “Oh, yes, Article 5 says an attack on one is an attack on all”. It does not say what we have to do about it, though, does it? He said, “Do you honestly think that the people of Portugal would send troops to Ukraine? They would not”.

This is going to be difficult, but it has to be done. We need to think again about European security. We have spent too long behind an American blanket, expecting them to look after us. The fact of the matter is that 80 years after the end of the war, we have to start redesigning a Europe that works for Europe. We cannot continue to rely on the United States.

In building that new unity, we have to get closer to the European Union. I really am on my own on that—in this party, anyway. The European Union and the countries that are closer to us geographically in Europe are our future. I say to both parties that if neither of you can come to terms with Europe, you will lose the youth vote and it is not impossible that we will end up with that little Bench down at the end sitting on that Bench over there, and God knows who sitting on this Bench. Let us think our way through to a brighter future and stop repeating all the shibboleths of the past.

European Investment Bank

Lord Balfe Excerpts
Wednesday 24th July 2024

(2 years, 3 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Asked by
Lord Balfe Portrait Lord Balfe
- Hansard - -

To ask His Majesty’s Government what plans they have to seek a closer relationship with the European Investment Bank to encourage investment in the United Kingdom.

Lord Livermore Portrait The Financial Secretary to the Treasury (Lord Livermore) (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, the Government have set out plans to significantly increase investment in the UK economy, including through a new national wealth fund and far-reaching reforms to the planning system. The Government have not set out any specific plans in relation to the European Investment Bank.

Lord Balfe Portrait Lord Balfe (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

I thank the Minister for his reply. When we left the European Union, we left the agencies in a particularly violent way. We did not really deal with them at all, but there is nothing in the EIB statutes that precludes it lending to non-EU countries such as the United Kingdom. Will the Government consider opening negotiations with the EIB to get a closer relationship, one that is based not on cherry picking but on the mutual concerns on both sides to get a better spread of investment in the United Kingdom and Europe?

Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I agree with the substantive points that the noble Lord is making. We need to reset our relationship with the European Union. The Government are committed to doing this in order to strengthen ties, reinforce our commitment to security and tackle barriers to trade. We also need, as he says, to increase investment in our economy, so we have set out significant steps to unlock billions of pounds in private sector investment in the industries of the future through a national wealth fund, planning reform, a pensions review and a modern industrial strategy.

The noble Lord asked specifically about a third-party relationship with the European Investment Bank. Although it is possible to agree such an arrangement, it is unlikely that such an arrangement would provide anything like as much investment into the UK as membership of the EIB did.