(1 day, 10 hours ago)
Lords ChamberTo ask His Majesty’s Government what they expect the Land Use Framework to deliver in relation to reducing planning costs and accelerating planning decisions for permanent land use change.
My Lords, I declare my interests as a landowner involved in forestry, in residential, renewable and commercial development, and I beg leave to ask the Question standing in my name on the Order Paper.
My Lords, the land use framework will help to deliver development in the right places faster and at lower cost. It provides clearer priorities for land use in England, practical principles for decision-making and better spatial data, helping to identify suitable locations for development and manage pressures on land. This will support more co-ordinated decisions on permanent land use change, helping to reduce uncertainty and delay while at the same time safeguarding important natural assets and productive farmland.
My Lords, the land use framework envisages large-scale land use change, including up to 2% going to renewable energy and up to 2% to housing and urban extension. This will inevitably put pressure on our best and most versatile land, potentially undermining our food security. What assurances can the Minister give the House that sprawling solar panel developments will be treated as a permanent land use change and our best and most versatile land will be fully protected for our food security?
Only 2% of England’s agricultural land is likely to undergo land use change away from agriculture and towards renewable energy infrastructure by 2050. Some of that can of course continue to be used for food production—solar is an example of that. The National Planning Policy Framework is clear that plans should steer development to avoid the use of higher-quality agricultural land, using the agricultural land classification system. We are undertaking a review of that to ensure that it is as it should be. We need the best available data to guide that. We are also working closely with DESNZ to ensure that analysis and principles from the land use framework support the development of plans for energy—for example, the strategic spatial energy plan, which will help to locate solar farms in the appropriate places—because we need to make sure that energy infrastructure needs are balanced with our national priorities, of which food production is of course one.
(2 days, 10 hours ago)
Grand CommitteeMy Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing these regulations, which we welcome from our Benches. These five chemicals share one grim quality: once they are out, they stay out, building up in wildlife and in the food chain, and, as my colleague, Dr Roz Savage MP, put it in the House of Commons, in most of our bodies.
First, there is a slight sense of déjà vu about part of this instrument. In April 2025, the Government banned UV-328 and Dechlorane Plus, then revoked those bans when medical technology firms and others warned that they still needed them. As I understand it, it was to do with the chemicals still existing within some equipment of that nature. Can the Minister reassure the Committee that the exemptions have been got right this time so we are not back here in a year?
Secondly, some of those exemptions end in 2030, but others run to 2041 or even 2044, and some simply last for the lifetime of the equipment—yet the regulations themselves contain no review clause at all. How will the Government make sure that “time-limited” really means what it says?
Thirdly, the memorandum tells us that small and microbusinesses will be affected, but the consultation drew just 25 responses, mostly from trade associations and large firms. How did the department hear from small firms? I echo the question of the noble Baroness, Lady Redfern, about how, in partnership with small firms, similar chemicals can be eliminated from the chain. There is a very small point that caught my eye: that toys, children’s seats and cots made with recycled material may contain these flame retardants at 35 times the normal limit until May next year. I just wonder why we are waiting for that when it comes to children.
In the long term, long-chain PFCAs are of course forever chemicals. In April, the Environmental Audit Committee, on which my colleague, Dr Savage, sits, found the Government’s PFAS plan long on monitoring and short on action. It asked Ministers to draw on the EU’s restriction within three months of its publication. Will the Minister commit to that or are we still waiting to see what Europe does?
Finally, my noble friend Lord Teverson chaired this House’s inquiry into REACH during the Brexit negotiations. From these Benches, we warned then about the cost of drifting apart. I genuinely welcome the Government now saying that EU rules are the starting point for UK REACH, and, as I understood it from the opening remarks of the Minister, that Northern Ireland is aligning with that and that no aspect of the Windsor agreement will overly complicate that—in which case it is good that we are aligning as well.
As far back as 2018, we were promised a chemicals strategy. I think everyone here is well aware that these chemicals have no respect whatever for any borders, whatever Brexit legacy we may or may not have. So, it is about time that our rules are aligned and keep up. By the way, just to reassure the Minister, I have fired off some questions, but I am extremely happy to be written to and not answered in her response, because I recognise that some of them are a little bit on the technical side.
My Lords, I also thank the Minister for bringing forward these regulations for scrutiny and for her excellent explanation of their purpose.
To be classed as persistent organic pollutants, or POPs, substances must meet four criteria: a half-life of more than two months in water or six months in soil; building up in living organisms; demonstrating an ability to travel far from where they are released; and giving evidence of toxicity. The Stockholm convention restricts their use to protect our environment and our health, and we welcome the restrictions on these five POPs in this regulation.
However, there is also the intention here to align more closely with the EU’s policies, including the substance definition itself. Can the Minister explain why we are adopting EU rules and definitions? We have no formal way to influence a future change to the definition, unless perhaps the Minister would like to provide insight into the terms of the Prime Minister’s upcoming dealings with the EU—obviously we do not expect that to happen. In addition, the eight-week consultation led to requests for new exemptions, but these have not been included. Can the Minister clarify that all exemptions are covered and give the Government’s rationale for not including those requested?
Following the comments from the noble Baroness, Lady Grender, I understand that Dechlorane Plus and UV-328 were both banned in the UK in early 2025, before a rapid reversal one month later to avoid disruption in the NHS. Can the Minister confirm that the nature of the exemptions proposed in this instrument will lead to no disruption in the NHS or the defence sector, which she referenced in her opening comments?
While we agree that provisions within this SI are required and the instrument has received favourable green ratings from the Regulatory Policy Committee, does the Minister appreciate the further cost to businesses? The impact assessment notes that there are costs such as familiarisation, compliance, reformulation, substitution and producer revenue costs. It estimates a negative business net present value, and the equivalent annual net direct cost to business is estimated to be £10.4 million. Is there any hope that the Government may be able to reduce these costs on businesses? I look forward to the Minister’s responses.
My Lords, from the comments by my noble colleagues, I assume that everyone supports the instrument in front of us. It is clear that our approach has to balance regulatory compliance, environmental responsibility and the practical realities faced by industry across the UK. The noble Lord asked about much of those practical impacts. Our actions are guided not only by the domestic priorities but by our international commitments under the Stockholm convention and the evolving expectations of our global partners.
The noble Lord, Lord Roborough, asked about the EU and the agreements that we are currently finishing negotiations on. This is an international commitment under the Stockholm convention; it is not tied to the negotiations with the EU. The legislation ensures that existing legal provisions for the prohibition and restriction of the manufacture, use and placing on the market of POPs will be extended to the newest POP substances that have been adopted for global elimination under the Stockholm convention. The reason for doing that is to continue to protect the current and future health of the population, wildlife and environment of both the United Kingdom and the rest of the world. We will also amend the legal provisions on the two existing POPs, as I mentioned, to adapt them to scientific and technical progress.
The impact assessment, which has been referenced, clearly demonstrates that the changes are going to maintain a high level of protection for human health and the environment. At the same time, to come back to the noble Lord’s question about costs to industry, it is to avoid any unnecessary costs to industry, because that is really important. That is partly why we have the exemptions and the transition periods. The chemical sector is one of the United Kingdom’s most important manufacturing industries. Its products are essential to sectors right across the economy and to many aspects of our daily lives. We fully recognise the economic and strategic importance, but at the same time we have to recognise risks to human health and the environment if chemicals are not properly understood and managed. The instrument is designed to strike the right and appropriate balance here, preserving strong environmental and health protections while at the same time providing industry with the time and certainty that it is going to need to transition over to the safer alternative substances.
I come to a few of the specific questions. My noble friend Lord Stansgate asked about new nominations and the timings for those. Clearly, if there are serious concerns about a chemical, we need to act as quickly as we possibly can. As a party to the Stockholm convention, we engage with its substance evaluation process via the POPs Review Committee and meetings of the Conference of the Parties, in addition to online correspondence. All relevant stakeholders have opportunities to put into the convention process through the calls for comments and information that we hold on the GOV.UK website. We currently have a live call for information on the three substances being considered for adoption by the committee; that is happening right now. We encourage stakeholders to submit information, as we need to be really robust. We need timely information to inform the international discussions taking place right now, so that we can move forward as quickly as we can under the circumstances.
The noble Baroness, Lady Redfern, asked about consultation and the concerns of industry and business. A draft of the instrument was published as part of the statutory public consultation in spring this year. It sought feedback on our proposed approach to the prohibitions, on our intention to implement all the exemptions allowed for under the Stockholm convention and on equivalent amendments or proposals, including any potential impacts of divergence with the EU. It was shared widely with industry, including through other relevant departments and trade associations, so that we would hear from as many people as possible. We received 25 responses, primarily from large businesses and trade associations. Obviously, trade associations are often the bodies through which we hear from small and medium-sized businesses. We did as much as we could to engage as many businesses and industries as possible.
On the assessment of the impacts on industry, as I mentioned, the impact assessment was published alongside the instrument. The evidence that we collected indicated that most businesses will not have to make any significant additional changes to their activity to comply with the new requirements. We also do not expect the amendments to have a significant distributional impact, nor will they —this is important for the noble Baroness’s question—disproportionately burden small businesses. In fact, the time-limited specific exemptions will help to ensure that transition, so that it does not put too much pressure on smaller businesses.
On the post-implementation review that the noble Baroness referred to, a formal post-implementation review will commence by the end of 2031. This timing is intended to allow sufficient time for businesses to respond to the restrictions and for a number of the time-limited exemptions to have reached or approached their expiry date. That review will be supported by evidence provided through ongoing monitoring that will also take place. Additionally, as a party to the Stockholm convention, the UK is already required to undertake ongoing reporting and monitoring activities in line with our obligations under Articles 4 and 15 of the convention. This reporting and monitoring includes providing information on import and export and the use of specific exemptions. The information gathered through those processes will help inform the post-implementation review and could inform any future legislative changes that we might feel we want to bring in.
The noble Baroness, Lady Grender, asked about the revocation of the UV-328 and Dechlorane Plus bans— the things that we have already been doing. They were previously prohibited under the POPs regulations in April 2025, including specific-use exemptions as allowed by the Stockholm convention. However, we received information that indicated previously unknown continuing needs for the use of these substances in certain applications, including medical and defence applications. I hope that helps to clarify that for the noble Baroness.
That suggested that more time was needed to investigate impacts on supply chains and the transition to the alternatives. The Government therefore revoked the prohibitions on those two substances in May 2025 so that further evidence could be gathered. These issues were not confined to the UK, and other mitigations had to be implemented by other parties to the Stockholm convention. We committed at the time to reinstate the prohibitions as soon as possible, where sufficient evidence was gathered to provide greater certainty. To reassure the noble Baroness, we subsequently engaged with the relevant sectors and held a public consultation on the proposed draft legislation. We went through all the processes as we got the new information through. This instrument reinstates those prohibitions in line with the revised requirements of the Stockholm convention.
(4 weeks, 2 days ago)
Lords ChamberObviously, desalination is an important part of moving forward when we have concerns around the amount of water that we have, and we are very keen to work more proactively in this space. One thing I am sure my noble friend is aware of is that water companies need to demonstrate that schemes will maintain secure water supplies. That includes the eight new desalination schemes that have been proposed in the current water resourcing management plan, so it is something we are keen to move forward with.
My Lords, I declare my interest as a farmer and landowner. Water company investment in nature-based solutions to drought resilience, as well as flood prevention and water quality, is disadvantaged against grey infrastructure due to the continued scepticism of the Environment Agency and the bureaucratic approach of other arm’s-length bodies. Re-wetting, decanalising, riparian planting and peatland restoration demonstrate strong results in short timeframes while delivering significant benefits to our rural economy and to nature restoration. Can the Minister assure us that the Government will remove this bias in the forthcoming clean water Bill and allow the acceleration of nature-based solutions?
Clearly, I am not in a position to tell noble Lords what will be in the Bill, but I can assure the noble Lord that nature-based solutions are a very important part of the Government’s work in managing the situation regarding climate change and drought. Providing more integrated sustainable solutions is where we make the difference—even things such as creating better soil quality can make a huge difference. The three main aims around nature-based solutions for water that we are looking at are better groundwater resources, improving low flows in rivers, and improving our resilience to drought. We need to look at the effective schemes that we can bring forward, and that does not have to be just through the water Bill.
(2 months, 2 weeks ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, it is obvious that we need more investment in reservoirs but the easier, cheaper and quicker improvement is to restore natural water storage through rewetting, riparian tree planting, de-canalising rivers and, as my noble friend mentioned, creating on-farm water storage. What are the Government doing through ELMS and freeing water companies to invest to incentivise these improvements in resilience? I refer the House to my registered interest as a farmer and landowner.
Within Defra we have a number of programmes to do with rewetting, tree planting and supporting farmers—we have talked about reservoirs for farmers—but also holding water better. We can look at balancing ponds, for example, which the Government have been supporting through the different river trusts. There is a lot of work going on there. The important thing is to make sure that it is co-ordinated and happening in the right place.
(2 months, 2 weeks ago)
Lords ChamberI can certainly confirm that the north-west, where I live, has been particularly damp this year, unlike the rest of the country. I think that looks to the bigger question: how are we going to look at our water infrastructure over the coming decades? There are parts of the country, like where I live, that do not have water shortages, where there is still rain, and other parts where there is nothing. It is important that we consider as a country how best to use our water resources more broadly. Where do we need to build reservoirs? How do we support farmers in holding water, for example? The water usage question is a bigger part of that, as is the question of where we build our different infrastructure.
My Lords, our uniquely high electricity prices, created by ideological energy policies, already make the UK an uncompetitive location for data centres. Developers need to navigate a tangle of many of Defra’s 34 arm’s-length bodies—of which the Minister has mentioned two—planning authorities and water companies to create cost-effective solutions to cooling without endangering our scarce water resources. What is the Minister doing to reduce this complexity, in particular through the implementation of the Cunliffe commission report? I disclose an interest as an unpaid adviser to a data centre developer.
More broadly, regarding the complexity and the number of different organisations, the Cunliffe report has made recommendations that Defra is not just looking at but working on, because we realise that we have to be more efficient and effective, as does the whole of government. As I mentioned, water-cooling systems use less electricity, so again we have this balance to make on those resources. We are looking at standards of efficiencies right across; specifically on water, there will be the opportunity to debate this more broadly when we get the water Bill in front of us.
(3 months, 4 weeks ago)
Lords ChamberAs I mentioned earlier, the report carried out by Dan Corry looked specifically at all the arm’s-length bodies in Defra—and there are a lot of them—to see whether the work they are doing was efficient and necessary and whether we could work more effectively and efficiently by reviewing the way they operate.
My Lords, the highly critical judgment against Natural England in this court case is the latest in a long list of failures: Ebbsfleet jumping spiders, fish discos, bat tunnels, pony culls and, even as we sit in this Chamber today, dangerous wildfires in upland areas following Natural England policy. Will this Government, under their new leadership, ensure that Natural England follows science, not prejudice, and focuses on delivering the best outcomes for nature and for our economy? I declare my interests as a farmer, landowner, developer and sporting rights owner.
First, we have not been culling ponies. A lot was written about that, but I am not aware of any ponies that were culled or that are going to be culled. The Dartmoor pony is an important species in that part of the country. As for the other issues, we will obviously be looking at the judgment and analysing it, and we will respond to it in due course.
(3 months, 4 weeks ago)
Lords ChamberWe are looking to start with the larger vessels because that will make the biggest difference and have the biggest impact. From that, we will look at a mandatory rollout. We will look across vessels of all sizes, because we need to make the biggest difference.
My Lords, the English Atlantic salmon is also a victim of bycatch, yet it is on the IUCN red list of endangered species. The salmon is an easy to monitor species that is a key contributor to and indicator of the health of our native ecosystems. What progress has been made on rolling out the bycatch initiative to UK vessels and EU vessels, where this Government have given another 12 years of access to our fisheries? Will EU vessels be managed under this plan? I declare my interest as the owner of fishing rights in England and Scotland.
Perhaps I should declare my interest, as I have fishing rights in England for salmon and brown trout.
A lot of these issues are tied up with the negotiations that we are doing with the EU around fishing rights and what access the EU will have, so it is difficult for me to comment on that in any detail. On the salmon bycatch, this is an important question. We have some real issues with numbers of salmon, as the noble Lord knows. Defra has been exploring the different options to improve the data collection for salmon bycatch. That includes monitoring, using REM on vessels, so that we can have a clear picture, get more data and look at how best to target the problems that this is causing to salmon stocks.
(3 months, 4 weeks ago)
Lords ChamberMy noble friend is right that it is a very small percentage. People sometimes think that solar panels are on agricultural land when in fact they are on brownfield. A very large solar development near where I live has just been given permission; it looks like it will be built on a lot of fields but, actually, it is an old mining site and brownfield.
My Lords, the land use framework identified the need for greater intensity and yields from our best farmland to compensate for the loss of production elsewhere. Market prices for agricultural commodities do not currently support an incentive to intensify this production and underpin our food security. Can the Minister clarify what support is given to farmers with this land through ELMS to meet the Government’s goals and enhance our food security? I declare my interest as a farmer.
The Government are supporting farmers through a number of different schemes. For example, we have committed at least £200 million through the farming innovation programme to support productivity improvements. We are also supporting skills development, farmer collaboration and adoption of innovative land management practices. There is a lot going on and a lot of options for farmers who are looking for support.
(4 months, 1 week ago)
Grand CommitteeMy Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for this statutory instrument following the Government’s consultation on the application for the Rolls-Royce small modular reactor. The decision obviously confirms that the small modular reactor is justified in principle, and we support that. This is an encouraging step in the right direction to enable the UK’s first small modular reactors and ensure that new nuclear reactor technologies form part of our future energy system.
Our domestic nuclear reactor industry needs a supportive Government in order to be globally competitive. There are many rivals around the world that benefit from such a situation, and we must not handicap our own. This is a strategic industry where the research and manufacturing capabilities are critical, not just to our energy security but to our national security. That support is critical also to the export success for Rolls-Royce SMRs in Sweden and the Czech Republic and its current European leadership. Rolls-Royce itself describes the need for volume to drive industrialisation and reduce unit costs.
As the Minister and the noble Baroness, Lady Grender, have pointed out, this is just a first step. The construction or operation of a reactor still has to go through all the hurdles of environmental permits, a nuclear site licence and planning consent. The Government must be consistent in their backing, and I would be grateful if the Minister could set out a timeline for the delivery of the first UK SMRs.
I have a few further questions related to the issues in this SI, which may well be outside the brief that the Minister and I usually inhabit so I will be completely happy with replies in writing. There is considerable evidence of the favourable carbon emissions intensity of SMRs, but what assessment have the Government made in coming to this decision about the cost of this electricity and how that will compare to other electricity generation sources? We appreciate the importance of this project but we would welcome the publication of more information on the impact of future electricity costs in the UK.
When making these calculations, can the Minister confirm whether they rely to a greater or lesser extent on the Government’s internal calculation of current carbon emissions, last published at a central cost of £273 per tonne? By contrast, the UK Woodland Carbon Code units trade at £30 to £40 and our own ETS price is £60 per tonne. I asked the noble Baroness’s colleague in the debate on the carbon orders two weeks ago whether this really was an appropriate cost and whether this leads to faulty decision-making about the appropriate energy investments in this country to create an affordable energy transition; I am yet to receive an answer. I should also, in that context, declare my interest as a developer of Woodland Carbon Code forests.
When we debated the creation of GB Energy in your Lordships’ House, we were assured that it would not crowd out private sector investment. Now, it has been selected as preferred bidder for the Wylfa SMRs. How can we be confident that it has not done that by using the UK’s low sovereign cost of borrowing to out-compete the private sector? How can we be confident that this government body has priced risk effectively when competing with the private sector?
Furthermore, this Government scrapped the previous Government’s plan for two SMR projects and have refused to honour the commitment for 24 gigawatts of electricity to be generated from nuclear by 2050. We are all aware of the need for energy infrastructure, as well as the economic opportunities it brings. Can the Minister give any indication of whether the incoming Prime Minister will be more ambitious and may at least match the ambitions of our previous Conservative Government? I look forward to hearing her response.
(4 months, 1 week ago)
Grand CommitteeMy Lords, we on these Benches also welcome this measure to extend the transition period for businesses to submit information to the Health and Safety Executive under the UK REACH regulations. I thank the Minister for bringing these regulations to the Committee.
The UK’s registration, evaluation, authorisation and restriction of chemicals replicated the EU REACH regime. To manage the transition, requirements to submit further information were phased, and the deadlines were extended twice by our previous Government, in 2020 and in 2023. This statutory instrument extends the deadlines to submit information to the HSE for registrants, downstream users and distributors that continue to import chemicals from the EU. This will allow the compliance costs of registered businesses in the chemicals sector to be spread more evenly. It is worth noting that 98% of registered businesses in the chemicals sector are small, medium or micro businesses.
In addition, the SI will provide more time for the Government to introduce a new transitional registration model to cover registrations of substances that were already on the EU market at the time of Brexit. This is expected to reduce costs for industry significantly, so can the Minister update the Committee on when this new model will be introduced?
The Minister might be pleased to hear that I do not have many additional questions, given that so many have been asked. But I highlight the Government’s response to concerns submitted to the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee about divergence from the EU in this policy area. The Government stated—the Minister was kind enough to repeat this—that
“divergence only occurs where there are compelling reasons, for example to protect the resilience of essential national infrastructure. In doing so, we will retain full control of our regulatory decisions”.
If that is the case, why will the Government not take the same approach to the SPS regulations soon to be determined by the EU, in particular on the role of precision breeding?
I will take advantage of this opportunity to ask one question on something not directly related to this SI: the chemical Asulox. Emergency authorisations for its use ended a few years ago, and we are already seeing the impact of the withdrawal of Asulox from the market, as bracken moves further and further up the hill, outcompeting grass, outcompeting degraded peat and undermining our habitats. Will the Minister commit to take that away and see whether anything can be done to reintroduce Asulox to the market? I very much look forward to her response.
My Lords, I am grateful to noble Lords for their important contributions and for the careful consideration given to the regulations. I will go through some of the questions and issues raised.
Noble Lords asked about the deadline extension. Clearly, this is now the third time. The deadlines were first altered when we were still preparing for EU exit, to allow businesses enough time to compile and submit the full required information, given the complexity and scale of the task. As I mentioned, there was a further extension in 2023 to address transitional challenges, especially the considerable cost to business of acquiring the additional information. This Government wanted to reassess their broader chemicals policy, and it then became clear that we could not implement the ATRm in time for the original deadline. We want to get a robust and effective policy framework for the future, which is why we have extended the deadlines.
My noble friend Lord Stansgate in particular asked what guarantee we can give that we will not extend it again. Clearly, we really do not want to do that. I completely agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Grender, that businesses need certainty, and continually moving the goalposts and changing dates does not help, so we have absolutely no intention of extending the deadlines further.
We published our policy conclusions on the ATRm back in March, and that set a firm path forward for government. On the questions around timetables, we are looking to consult very quickly on the legislation in order to bring the model into force next year so that businesses have ample time to prepare for the new deadlines. As I said, we do not plan to bring in any further extensions.
As I said, in March we published the timetable for implementing the alternative transitional registration model. By consulting quickly and then bringing in the new regulations next year, we want to ensure that industry has sufficient time to prepare its registrations so that it is ready to comply with the first revised submission in an orderly way, which is what we want. Now that we have said this is what we will do, we want to consult as quickly as possible.
The noble Baroness, Lady McIntosh of Pickering, asked about the Swiss style and why we could not take that approach to chemicals registration rather than developing a separate UK model. One of the core principles of UK REACH is that it is industry’s primary responsibility to understand and manage the risks of its chemicals, and registration is how it demonstrates that it is doing this. That means submitting data on hazard conclusions and classifications and how it is using chemicals in this country. We need to assure the public and consumers that chemicals are managed safely.
This “no data, no market” approach remains a central part of UK REACH, and that is not embedded in Switzerland’s system in the same way. However, we are exploring whether elements of a Swiss-style approach could help improve the speed and efficiency of UK REACH restriction decision-making, particularly where many GB businesses already comply with EU restrictions and there is no compelling reason to diverge. I hope that helps the noble Baroness, as we are still looking at the options around that.