Draft Persistent Organic Pollutants (Amendment) Regulations 2026 Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateRobbie Moore
Main Page: Robbie Moore (Conservative - Keighley and Ilkley)Department Debates - View all Robbie Moore's debates with the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
(1 day, 7 hours ago)
General CommitteesIt is a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Sir Alec.
Persistent organic pollutants are, as the name suggests, chemicals that do not go away. They are persistent and toxic, they build up in living things, and they travel long distances in the environment. They end up in our soil, our rivers and our food chain. That matters to every farmer and every family in this country, and that is why the Opposition support the ability to control them.
The United Kingdom is a party to the Stockholm convention. In May 2023 and May 2025, the conference of the parties agreed to list five further substances for global elimination: UV-328; Dechlorane Plus; medium-chain chlorinated paraffins; long-chain perfluorocarboxylic acids; and the pesticide chlorpyrifos. The draft regulations add all five to annex 1 of the POPs regulation in Great Britain. They introduce the time-limited exemptions agreed at the convention level for four of them, in sectors such as aerospace, automotive, defence and medical technology. They set unintentional trace contaminant limits for all five, and they tighten the existing limits for PFOS and the PBDE group of flame retardants. We will not oppose the draft regulations, but we have some questions, which I hope the Minister will be able to answer today.
First, two of the bans are not new. UV-328, which is used to protect plastics and coatings from sunlight, and Dechlorane Plus, a flame retardant used in cables and wiring, were banned in Great Britain in April 2025. However, after those regulations were made, the medical technology industry told the Government that it still needed to use the substances in certain medical applications, and the Government had to revoke the ban later that year while they gathered more evidence. Now, after further consultation, they are bringing back the ban. Can the Minister tell the Committee what has changed? What evidence has the Department gathered since last year that satisfies it that the medical technology supply chain will now cope? Why was that evidence not gathered before the original ban was made? Can she reassure us that no medical device used by the NHS will be at risk of shortage as a result of these regulations?
Secondly, on the consultation itself, paragraph 9.3 of the explanatory memorandum explains:
“This legislation impacts small and micro businesses.”
Medium-chain chlorinated paraffins, for example, are used in PVC, sealants, paints and metalworking fluids—products made by firms of every size—yet the Department’s own summary of the 25 consultation responses shows that nine came from very large businesses with over 250 employees and 11 came from trade associations. Not one response came from a micro or small business, so how can the Minister be confident that the consultation captured the real impact on the smaller firms that the Government admit will be affected? What did the Government do to reach out to them? Did they engage directly with bodies such as the Federation of Small Businesses? Does the Minister accept that a consultation with no responses from small businesses is not a good basis for judging the costs they will face, and will she commit to undertaking targeted engagement with those businesses before the exemptions begin to expire?
Thirdly, the exemptions in the draft regulations are time-limited and many are expected to run out in 2031. Several respondents asked for further exemptions, particularly for medium-chain chlorinated paraffins. The Government refused any that had not been agreed at the convention level. Is the Minister therefore satisfied that every essential use is covered by the regulations? What will happen to a business whose use falls outside the list? How will the exempted uses be monitored so that they are not abused? Can she assure us that proper enforcement will be carried out?
No exemptions at all have been provided for chlorpyrifos, because it has already been phased out in the UK, but British farmers who once relied on it to protect their crops have already had to change how they work. They have done the right thing, so what are the Government doing to make sure that they are not undercut by imported produce grown using these chemicals that are no longer allowed to be used in Great Britain?
Our next concern is trace limits, which set out how much of a banned substance can lawfully be present, where it is present by accident and not intentionally. For medium-chain chlorinated paraffins, the limit is 3% in substances and mixtures, and 0.45% in finished articles. The 3% figure is due to be reviewed in 2029 and every four years after that, so the limits in these regulations may change. How much notice will the Government give businesses ahead of the changes to trace limits so that they are not caught out with stock that they can no longer use or sell?
On the issue of realignment with the EU, the explanatory memorandum is very clear that equivalence with EU regulation was a key consideration. Following the consultation, the Government changed the substance definition in the draft to make it more similar to the EU’s latest proposals, even though some respondents opposed that. Can the Minister tell us today which respondents opposed that change, and why? Why are the Government adopting a definition from an EU proposal that has not yet been finalised? Does the Minister recognise that this means that, even before any confirmed deal with the EU, the UK is adopting EU definitions and rules with no seat around the table from which to change them if necessary?
There is a significant worry about the cost of the draft regulations to businesses in this country. The Government’s own impact assessment puts the net cost to businesses at £165.8 million—that is £10.4 million every year. Those costs come from firms having to learn about the new rules, formulate new products, find substances and substitutes, and in some cases lose sales altogether. The draft instrument may well be required, but it will create a further cost for businesses in this country that are already struggling with the higher costs that this Government have imposed on them. Can the Minister tell us what support will be offered to those small firms that need to find alternatives?
The explanatory memorandum tells us that the Environment Agency’s guidance will be updated
“as and when it is necessary.”
Can the Minister give us a timeline for when that guidance will be published? Finally, the post-implementation review will not begin until 2031, which is five years from now. Will she commit to updating Parliament sooner if problems with the regulations emerge?
The Opposition will not oppose the draft regulations—controlling persistent organic pollutants protects our environment, our food chain and public health—but they must be workable, properly enforced and fair to the businesses that have to comply with them, including the small firms that were scarcely heard from in the Government’s consultation. I look forward to the Minister’s answers to my questions on the reinstated bans, the consultation, the exemptions, EU realignment and the cost to businesses.