(5 days, 11 hours ago)
General Committees
The Minister for the Future of Work (Kate Dearden)
I beg to move,
That the Committee has considered the draft Employment Rights Act 2025 (Unfair Dismissal) (Removal of Limit on Compensation) (Consequential Amendments) Regulations 2026.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Alec. The draft regulations, which were laid before the House on 12 October, will make necessary consequential amendments arising from the Employment Rights Act 2025. Commencement regulations have been signed to confirm that, from 1 January 2027, the statutory cap on compensation awards for unfair dismissal will be removed. A number of other employment law provisions do not contain their own stand-alone compensation limits; instead, they cross-refer to the unfair dismissal cap. Once it is removed, those references would no longer operate as intended. The draft regulations therefore replace or remove them where necessary.
At present, compensatory awards for unfair dismissal are capped at the lower of £123,543 or 52 weeks’ gross pay. The 2025 Act removes the statutory cap by repealing section 124 of the Employment Rights Act 1996. Removing the compensatory award cap forms part of a wider package of reforms to strengthen unfair dismissal protections, which will reduce the qualifying period from two years to six months. Together, the changes will give more than 6 million employees greater security at work while ensuring that employers retain the flexibility to assess and, where appropriate, dismiss new recruits during the first months of employment.
Will the consequence of these provisions be felt more keenly in the public sector than the private sector, given the interaction of the regulations with final salary schemes, which are more generous in the public sector?
Kate Dearden
We do not think there will necessarily be a significant impact on employers. We are removing the cap—I will come on to the engagement we have had, and am happy to update the right hon. Gentleman on it—but a process will still be in place for unfair dismissal claims to be handled in an established, known way by judges.
Let me continue with the provisions affected by this statutory instrument. It will replace references to section 124 of the 1996 Act with references to section 123 of that Act. That means that tribunals will continue to determine compensatory awards based on what is
“just and equitable in all the circumstances”.
Compensation will remain based on evidence of actual and projected losses sustained by the claimant. In practice, most awards are expected to remain modest, reflecting the continued application of these well-established legal principles, as I have said. That is important, because most of these provisions concern claims for detriment brought by workers when that detriment consists of their contract being terminated.
The Minister just said that she thinks the implication of the provisions will be modest, but is it not the case that higher-paid potential claimants have been deterred by the cap, that removing the cap will open the door to many more higher-paid claimants, and that therefore their claims will not be modest, particularly, as per my previous intervention, when they relate to final salary pension schemes, such as those in the NHS?
Kate Dearden
As I have said, this change does not reset how tribunals calculate awards. Tribunals have well-established ways to calculate compensation that might be awarded for particular losses, and they will continue to base those awards on evidenced actual and projected financial losses. We are committed to ensuring that all employees receive fair compensation when they have been unfairly dismissed. We are talking about unfair dismissal here.
As I have said, the provisions concern claims for detriment brought by workers. Our long-standing approach is that such workers should receive neither more nor less compensation than they would have received as employees for bringing an unfair dismissal claim. These amendments preserve that alignment after the statutory cap is removed.
The regulations also amend section 140 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992. That provision concerns compensation where a person is refused employment or the services of an employment agency for reasons related to trade union membership. The amendment ensures that compensation in those cases continues to be aligned with the unfair dismissal compensation.
We are taking a different approach to sections 67 and 176 of the 1992 Act. Those provisions cover compensation payable by trade unions when members or former members have been unjustifiably disciplined, excluded or expelled. Parliament removed the compensation cap for unfair dismissal, but it did not intend to increase compensation limits for trade union discipline and expulsion cases. The regulations therefore preserve the existing limits in those provisions.
The regulations preserve the existing position by replacing the reference to section 124 with the fixed amount of £123,543, which is the current cap on unfair dismissal compensation. That amount will continue to be uprated annually in line with inflation using the retail prices index, and the additional limit based on 30 weeks’ pay will remain. That ensures that removing the unfair dismissal cap does not change the existing compensation limits that apply in these cases.
Finally, the regulations amend the ACAS Arbitration Scheme (Great Britain) Order 2004. They remove references to section 124 so that, following the removal of the unfair dismissal compensation cap, an arbitrator’s powers to award compensation continue to align with those of an employment tribunal.
The regulations are an important and necessary step in implementing the unfair dismissal reforms that Parliament has already agreed. They are necessary so that, when the unfair dismissal compensatory award cap is removed on 1 January, the wider statute book continues to work as intended. They preserve existing policy where appropriate, and ensure that related compensation provisions remain effective. I commend the regulations to the Committee.
(1 year, 2 months ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
Kate Dearden
I was just about to get to that point. I thank the shadow Minister for the reminder.
I pay tribute to my predecessor for all his work and to the officials and colleagues who worked with him. Many Members of this House and the other place engaged constructively with the team, and their insight has materially shaped the Bill. I thank them for their valuable insights. Likewise, the Bill has been shaped by extensive engagement from external stakeholders, businesses, trade unions and civil society alike. I thank them all for their engagement to date, and I reassure them that this Government remain committed to full and proper consultation on the Bill’s implementation.
I declare my interest as a proud trade union member. I look forward to working with trade unions, businesses and all stakeholders, and to continuing the positive engagement that many stakeholders have had with the Department and with this Government so far.
The Government were elected on a manifesto that committed to implementing “Labour’s Plan to Make Work Pay” in full and to putting more money in working people’s pockets. The Employment Rights Bill is the legislative backbone of that promise. We will deliver the single biggest upgrade of workers’ rights in a generation. That is good for workers and good for business, because we believe that a strong package of workers’ rights and protections go hand in hand with a strong economy. Many good employers already know that. When staff feel secure, they stay longer, are more productive and help the business to succeed. The Bill will help to make that the norm across the economy.
Our first mission as a Government is to deliver economic growth in every single part of the country. The Employment Rights Bill is a vital step. It represents a cornerstone of our mission to grow the economy, and it is designed to modernise the UK labour market, raise living standards and support long-term growth.
Securing that growth is worth doing only if working people actually feel the benefits of it in their pay, in their security and in their daily lives. Too many people face practices that undermine both their security and our economy, from fire and rehire to zero-hours contracts and last-minute shift cancellations. Those practices breed insecurity, and insecurity stifles productivity.
That is why the Bill is at the centre of the Government’s plans and is so significant. It will benefit at least 15 million workers, or half of all UK workers, protecting them from those practices and providing economic safety for the lowest paid in our labour market.
Let us consider a few of the changes that the Bill will bring. Some 9 million employees will gain protection from unfair dismissal, not after two years, but from day one. Workers in some of the most deprived parts of the country will keep hundreds of pounds a year in their pockets instead of losing them to the hidden costs of insecure work, and nearly 1 million more people each year will benefit from bereavement leave when they lose a loved one.
I thank the hon. Member for York Central (Rachael Maskell) for her comments in support of the Bill and of the Government’s work in this area, and for her work on the impact of bullying in the workplace over a number of years. I would be happy to meet her to discuss those matters further.
Economic impacts were a key part of the contribution of the hon. Member for Spelthorne. Some still argue that stronger rights are a cost, but I reject that. Stronger rights are an investment in people, in stability and in long-term growth. As set out in the Government’s published impact assessments for the Bill—I will respond in detail to his points on that—there are clear, evidence-based benefits to tackling issues holding back the UK labour market, which will have a positive impact on economic growth and will help to raise living standards across the country.
I join colleagues in welcoming the Minister to her place. She said in her reply to my hon. Friend the Member for Spelthorne (Lincoln Jopp) that there would not be an additional cost, but the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services has raised concerns about the additional costs and the funding gap, given that it will fall on local authorities and will therefore, in turn, require Government support. Could she clarify what she expects to be the extra cost of the Bill in terms of social care?
Kate Dearden
I am happy to come back to the right hon. Member on the particular social care interests and concerns that he might have.
Improving worker wellbeing, supporting productivity, reducing workplace conflict and creating a more level playing field for good employers would grant significant benefits, worth billions of pounds per year. That is why delivering the benefits of the Bill would offset the costs. That assessment is shared by organisations such as the Resolution Foundation. The £5 billion figure from our impact assessment, which the hon. Member for Spelthorne mentioned, is a top-end estimate of that cost, and will largely represent a direct transfer to the lowest paid in society, with the central estimate close to £1 billion. Even if we take that high-end estimate, the costs are therefore likely to be less than 0.4% of our national wage bill, and could even be as low as 0.1%. That is our best estimate at this stage.