"My Lords, very briefly, I have for a long time shared the concerns expressed by the noble Lord. Those concerns appear to me to be met by Amendment 50. Has he considered that?..." Lord Campbell of Alloway - View Speech
"I have a very short question. Will my noble and learned friend deal with the argument of the noble Lord, Lord Grocott, which appeared to me to be totally acceptable? Can he say what is wrong with the constitution? If there is nothing wrong with it, what are we doing …..." Lord Campbell of Alloway - View Speech
"I have not taken much active interest in this debate but I have read all the official reports. I cannot understand why one has to go into this rather complex, devious regime and not leave this matter of tremendous importance—non-political importance—to the Boundary Commission. I may have missed it, but …..." Lord Campbell of Alloway - View Speech
"I am grateful to the noble and learned Lord for his helpful clarification, but how can judicial review, which is of general application, have any specific relationship with this particular question? Acceptance of judicial review is a matter always for the discretion of the court. You have no right to …..." Lord Campbell of Alloway - View Speech
"My Lords, could the noble Lord explain what on earth a public inquiry subject to judicial review means in practice in the courts?..." Lord Campbell of Alloway - View Speech
"Very briefly, my Lords, I got involved in this affair with a lot of other members of the Bar and I have to say where I stand. I totally support the legal analysis of the noble Lord, Lord Pannick, who is totally correct. Of course, it puts me in a …..." Lord Campbell of Alloway - View Speech