UK-EU Customs Union

Lord Docherty of Milngavie Excerpts

Thursday 29th January 2026 Lords Chamber

[Lord Docherty of Milngavie (Lab) (Maiden Speech)]

My Lords, I begin by thanking Black Rod, Garter, the clerk, the doorkeepers and all the staff of this House for the kindness that they have shown me since joining. I thank noble Lords from every side who have, without exception, made me feel so welcome. I thank my supporters—my noble friends Lady Armstrong of Hill Top and Lady Elliott of Whitburn Bay—for their encouragement and support, and my noble friends Lady Smith of Basildon and Lord Kennedy of Southwark for the thoughtfulness they have both shown towards me.

I grew up in a small suburb of Glasgow that few people have heard of and even fewer can pronounce. I studied at Strathclyde University, but it was at school that my interest in politics first developed. I attended St Ninian’s High School in Kirkintilloch. While my favourite subject was art, I vividly recall a young teacher in my third-year guidance class who was at pains to emphasise the importance of democracy. Indeed, that teacher created an election just to show us how democracy worked. It was the first time I stood for election. When it was time to vote, the teacher stood at the front of the class behind an improvised ballot box and we lined up to vote. My opponent happened to be in front of me. As he cast his ballot, he turned around to tell me that because there were only two of us on the ballot, he felt the right thing to do was to vote for me. I am embarrassed to admit that I also thought the right thing to do was to vote for me. I won by one vote.

After university I began a career in banking, specialising in real estate, PFI and public/private partnerships. In 1997 I was seconded to work for the incoming Labour Government on their regional development policy. I left the city in 2002 and moved to Newcastle upon Tyne, which is my adopted home. It is where I met my husband and where our children are growing up. Since then, my work has involved almost every aspect of economic development, principally in the north-east of England. It is a challenge to persuade private capital, which has a choice, to regions that have historically lower levels of accumulated wealth, capital formation and economic growth. Accelerating growth in our regions is essential—which is not to argue for slower growth in London and the south-east, although London and the south-east should irrigate, not drain.

That brings me to this debate. I was interested to hear the noble Lord, Lord Hannan, discuss last week the symbolism of the Woolsack and the centrality of business and wealth creation to the well-being and functioning of the state. I could not agree more. If only economic growth could be delivered by certainty of view alone. If one relies not on self-belief but on evidence and fact, one can only conclude that the decision to leave the customs union has been nothing other than an unmitigated disaster—for UK business, for our economy and for the Exchequer, upon which the health of our public services depends.

Drawing together my start in the classroom where I cast my first vote and today, there is a common factor in each beyond my own involvement. The energetic young teacher in whose class I first stood for election was then called Mr McFall. He is better known to noble Lords as the noble Lord, Lord McFall of Alcluith, the Lord Speaker. It would have been beyond the comprehension of my teenage self to imagine that 43 years later I would be introduced to this House at all, never mind be welcomed by the noble Lord, Lord McFall. His lifetime of public service is an inspiration. In an infinitely more modest way, I am grateful to be given this opportunity to serve.