UK-EU Customs Union

Lord Razzall Excerpts

Thursday 29th January 2026 Lords Chamber

[Lord Razzall (LD)]

My Lords, having listened to the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, in the past, I am sure noble Lords will accept that I do not agree with much of what he said. The context in which we are discussing this is, to me, the obvious failure of the Brexit project. I take the comments made by the noble Lord, Lord Lamont, about the 4% of GDP spread over a period, but I would prefer to look at the recent figures from the National Bureau of Economic Research, a well-respected American organisation, that says the cost to us of Brexit has been between 6% and 8%, which, aggregated, is something like £95 billion of our GDP.

I think the other thing that is worth commenting on, which nobody has—unfortunately the noble Lord, Lord Gove, has left the Chamber—is that one of the things that the Brexit debate entrenched in our culture is that political lying is all right. Where is the money we were promised on the side of the bus for the NHS? Where are all the Turkish immigrants we were promised in the emails that were sent to people in the last two weeks of the campaign? This, to me, has been the absolute zenith of lies and nadir of results. I take the point that has been made about some trade deals having been entered into, but most of the trade deals that were entered into by the new regime were simply Snopaking out “EU” and substituting “UK” in those trade deals. The noble Lord, Lord Lilley, referred to the CPTPP, but the estimate of the impact of that on our trade deals is infinitely less than the cost of losing the opportunities that we had with the European Union.

I do not know whether our friends in the Labour Party, who were referred to by the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, include the Prime Minister, who in May 2025 clearly indicated that he wanted to reset our arrangements with the European Union. This has not been terribly successful so far. Obviously, the progress on Erasmus has been good, but we have pulled out of the attempts to participate in the €150 billion European Defence Fund, we have not been able to deal with the internal electricity market, which we thought we would be able to do, and the phytosanitary agreement, which somebody over there mentioned earlier, that we hoped that we would get has not yet happened.

We have been asked to say what we mean by a customs union. Now Al Pinkerton, the MP, ironically, for Surrey Heath—he replaced the noble Lord, Lord Gove—argued for a bespoke customs union deal with the EU, not including agriculture, with consultation on all trade deals. It should be a bespoke deal. He proposed that in a Bill in the House of Commons and it went through, with some Labour people supporting him. It will not get into legislation, but it did pass. Turkey has had that arrangement since 1995. Why can we not have it?