Financial Services Reform

Lord Tunnicliffe Excerpts

Wednesday 23rd July 2025 Lords Chamber

[Lord Livermore (Lab)]

I have already made it clear in previous answers that I disagree with that analysis. It is not at all how we see the financial services sector.

How are people going to benefit? I think the 1.2 million people employed in the financial services sector right across the UK will benefit from that. That is a pretty substantial benefit. The noble Baroness will know that we need to get more investment into our economy, and we are not going to get that investment unless we have a growing and thriving financial services sector. So I am very clear that I disagree with the noble Baroness’s analysis.

[Lord Tunnicliffe (Lab)]

My Lords, any system of regulation consists of rules and administration. If you have good rules and bad administration, you will get bad regulation. Is my noble friend satisfied that the quality of administration is sufficient? If not, what is he doing about it?

[Lord Livermore (Lab)]

My noble friend sums up quite nicely the balance between rules and administration. We are maintaining many of the rules that were put in place, as I have tried to make clear this evening. We are maintaining the architecture that was put in place after the global financial crisis, but the way in which those rules were administered was overly burdensome and probably disproportionate, placed too much of a burden on the sector and stifled the growth there that we want to see. As I have said, the pendulum swung too far in the opposite direction, and the balance of regulation has gone too far towards regulating for risk and not enough for also regulating for growth. As I have said before, no other globally competitive financial services hub imposes such bureaucracy on its businesses, so neither should we.

My noble friend asks what we are doing about it. What we are doing about it underpins the entirety of these reforms. We are seeking to recalibrate and rebalance the approach to risk so that it is more proportionate and that, in the right places, consumers and industry can take informed risks so that we create the space for the innovation and growth in the sector that I think we all want to see.