Artificial Intelligence: Impact on Human Relationships and Society Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateBaroness Fall
Main Page: Baroness Fall (Conservative - Life peer)Department Debates - View all Baroness Fall's debates with the Cabinet Office
(1 week, 3 days ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, I join the chorus in thanking the most reverend Primate for an excellent and timely debate and a brilliant speech. It is also always a pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Ahmad.
We are already in the midst of a technical revolution. AI is only the latest iteration to radically change the way we live, work, think and even love. We have learned the hard way, from our battles with social media, that unless we seize the moment and try to mould technology to our value system, we will be left navigating the Wild West. AI is much larger and more consequential. Debate seems to swing between two extremes: the optimists who believe that AI will solve all our problems, and the pessimists who believe that robots have already taken charge. As usual, the truth lies somewhere in between.
This is no futuristic debate—AI is already here—which is why this is such a commendably timely intervention. We can already feel AI in the workplace. We hear business leaders speaking about the opportunities for improving productivity, although they do not really know exactly how, or whether AI will give way to new and unknown jobs. The transition is likely to be a difficult one. However uncomfortable it may be, attempting to put the genie back in the bottle is not a strategy. We in Britian cannot afford to stand back and miss the AI boat, for our own future prosperity and security.
As we grapple unsuccessfully with low growth and low productivity, there are so many areas where AI could be a rocket-booster. We are a country with world-class universities, a strong financial sector, leading scientific research and a thriving creative industry—all areas where AI can drive enormous growth, if we get the policy and investment right. But—here is the crux—the debate over last weekend between former Prime Minister Blair and Burnham and Streeting seems to be a classic misunderstanding. There should be no trade-off between growth and inequality. Growth is vital to the health and welfare of our nation, as is ensuring that those benefits are felt by all communities. These aims must go hand in hand.
It would be extremely dangerous to turn our backs on AI because of concerns around driving further inequality, just as it would be foolish to ignore the possibility that it could. We should not be blind to the danger that the latest tech revolution continues the trend we have already seen in globalisation in delivering for some but not others. When people begin to feel that the economy is no longer working for them, and that they have no stake in its success, the politics of that frustration follows quickly behind.
No group is more exposed to AI than the young, especially those about to leave school wondering what best to study next and whether there will be a job for them when they leave higher education. Alan Milburn spoke devastatingly of the silence of the unheard voice of young people applying for jobs. His recent report has shaken the nation. One million and growing young people who are NEET is not just a national tragedy but an economic one in slow motion. We must ensure that the Government do not make policies that make this worse. It is a moral and economic imperative that these issues are tackled, especially at this time of AI.
The dignity of work is a very human condition. We heard Pope Leo and the most reverend Primate the Archbishop of Canterbury speak so eloquently about what it is to be human. I was struck too by the call to arms. Setting boundaries for AI is a matter for all humanity—no one is without responsibility to shape the future of AI, including and especially those who dedicate themselves to the AI race. In the pride and ambition to win, we must never lose sight of what we are trying to achieve. As the co-founder of Anthropic said this week, morality is not a side business.
We must focus on what we want from technology, before it imposes what it wants on us. There are no easy answers. We are grappling with a revolution in real time. We are trying to make it bow to our values. While the opportunities are clear, it is the responsibility of each and every one of us to push back against the excesses of AI and to grapple with the moral issues it raises, for AI will shape the future, and we must shape it in turn.