Higher Education Funding

Debate between Brian Binley and Baroness Primarolo

Thursday 8th January 2015 Commons Chamber

[Mr Binley]

I am sorry that my right hon. Friend did not give way. I hope that that is on the record.

[Madam Deputy Speaker (Dame Dawn Primarolo)]

Order. I am sure it will be in the record, Mr Binley, as you said it very loudly. Even I heard it. It was just a shame that your right hon. Friend did not.

Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Bill

Debate between Brian Binley and Baroness Primarolo

Wednesday 16th July 2014 Commons Chamber

[Madam Deputy Speaker (Dame Dawn Primarolo)]

Order. Sit down. We are really pressed for time and Members need to be disciplined. We did not need the introductory remarks, so you have lost the opportunity to make your point. I call Brian Binley.

[Mr Binley]

President Brian Binley. [Laughter.] I apologise, Madam Deputy Speaker.

The Bill proposes a mechanism called a parallel rent assessment. From a tenant’s point of view, such a mechanism is time consuming, and it will allow a pubco to run a tied tenant into financial collapse long before they receive an adjudication determination. It is potentially expensive for tenants, requiring them to employ professionals to represent their case, and it is complex. It is also totally unsupported: no organisation, pubco, brewer, tenant or consumer supports the parallel rent assessment mechanism. I am therefore surprised that the Government have recommended a mechanism with so little backing.

I appeal to the Minister to reconsider the proposals on pubcos, especially as they relate to the tie, and to consider the opportunity for a fair rent option without a tie. I am happy that the breweries are excluded from that particular element—the Select Committee in fact asked for that—but pubcos should be willing to face up to their responsibility in relation to encouraging tenants to take their pubs on false pretences. If hon. Members have, like me, seen a woman in their office in tears because she owes £94,000, having taken on a pub on a false premise, or seen a husband trying to comfort his wife because they know they are going bust, having sold their house to invest in a pub—there are many examples of that kind—they would recognise that reality.

--- Later in debate ---

[Mr Binley]

I had better not, or Madam Deputy Speaker will have words with me privately later.

I conclude simply by urging the Minister to reconsider the option proposed by the Business, Innovation and Skills Committee in its report. The Secretary of State initially seemed to accept it, but I fear that the Treasury oar then had an impact, smacking him—

[Madam Deputy Speaker (Dame Dawn Primarolo)]

Order.

[Mr Binley]

Pity.