To match an exact phrase, use quotation marks around the search term. eg. "Parliamentary Estate". Use "OR" or "AND" as link words to form more complex queries.

Keep yourself up-to-date with the latest developments by exploring our subscription options to receive notifications direct to your inbox

Written Question
Criminal Proceedings: Disclosure of Information
Tuesday 2nd June 2020

Asked by: Cheryl Gillan (Conservative - Chesham and Amersham)

Question to the Attorney General:

To ask the Attorney General, whether the oral contribution of the Solicitor General of 22 May 2019, Official Report, column 370 WH, on there being no corresponding legal duty on the defence to disclose information that is harmful to its case was a reference to the potential harm such disclosure might do to an application that a defendant makes for an order to stay the criminal proceeding against them.

Answered by Suella Braverman

There is no duty on the defence to disclose any material or information that may undermine their case in the criminal justice system, including in relation to any application they may make. This is consistent with the fundamental principle that it is for the prosecution to prove its case and not for a defendant to prove their innocence.

All solicitors and barristers are however bound by professional codes of conduct, which include the duty to act with integrity at all times and to uphold the proper administration of justice. The Criminal Procedure Rules and judicial case management are also in place to ensure that any application for a stay of proceedings is fair, both to the prosecution and the defence.

Speech in Commons Chamber - Wed 25 Sep 2019
Legal Advice: Prorogation

"On the subject of taxation, could my right hon. and learned Friend advise me? These legal actions, I believe, have been part-funded by crowdfunding. Will that funding be taxable, and will the tax payable on that crowdfunding have to be paid by the individuals bringing the cases?..."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Legal Advice: Prorogation
Speech in Westminster Hall - Wed 22 May 2019
Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings

"I beg to move,

That this House has considered the disclosure of information in pre-trial abuse of process hearings.

As usual, it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Robertson. I am pleased to welcome the Minister, who will respond. I am very pleased to have secured this …..."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings
Speech in Westminster Hall - Wed 22 May 2019
Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings

"In the context of the debate, the hon. Gentleman makes a very valid point.

My constituent, Mr Perry, was heavily involved in the case of Caldicott School, which was heard in Aylesbury Crown court. As a pupil there in the ’60s, he and many other boys suffered very considerable and …..."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings
Speech in Westminster Hall - Wed 22 May 2019
Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings

"I would like to make progress.

The abiding concern of those complainants, however, is that to their knowledge nothing has been done to prevent the distressing situation in which they found themselves recurring in other cases, concerning other abused children. The men involved feel rightly aggrieved about the wrongfulness of …..."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings
Speech in Westminster Hall - Wed 22 May 2019
Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings

"I am grateful to the Minister for the way in which she is responding. She mentioned that it is important to maintain trust in the regulatory bodies. In the light of the circumstances of this case, does she agreed that trust has been shaken? I will provide her with those …..."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings
Speech in Westminster Hall - Wed 22 May 2019
Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings

"I agree with the Minister that victims should have priority in our criminal justice system—that is most important. She mentioned at the beginning of her response that she is working on new guidelines that will come out shortly. Could she give us a greater indication of when we can expect …..."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Information Disclosure: Pre-trial Abuse of Process Hearings
Speech in Commons Chamber - Mon 03 Dec 2018
Withdrawal Agreement: Legal Position

"On whichever side of the House hon. Members sit, those of us who have been in government know that it is very important that there is safe space in which Law Officers and civil servants can give advice to Ministers. I fear that today we are trying to breach that …..."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Withdrawal Agreement: Legal Position
Speech in Commons Chamber - Mon 03 Dec 2018
Withdrawal Agreement: Legal Position

"Well, Mr Speaker, I was just going to ask the Attorney General to confirm that there is nothing in the written advice that he has not covered today that, if it were revealed, would be damaging to the national interest...."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Withdrawal Agreement: Legal Position
Speech in Commons Chamber - Mon 23 Feb 2015
Serious Crime Bill [Lords]

"The hon. Lady may know that I have, in the past, spoken up on behalf of Mandate Now and my constituent Mr Tom Perry. I am very keen on mandatory reporting, but having looked carefully at the proposed new clause, I have found that under subsection (2)(a), she is permitting …..."
Cheryl Gillan - View Speech

View all Cheryl Gillan (Con - Chesham and Amersham) contributions to the debate on: Serious Crime Bill [Lords]