High-control Religious Groups: Support for Victims Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateConnor Naismith
Main Page: Connor Naismith (Labour - Crewe and Nantwich)Department Debates - View all Connor Naismith's debates with the Ministry of Justice
(1 day, 7 hours ago)
Commons Chamber
Sam Carling
I am grateful to my hon. Friend, and I will shortly sing those volunteers praises, because it is very much right that we thank them.
People just cannot understand why victims in these groups do not leave early, or why they stayed. The themes of thought control, financial exploitation, isolation from family and friends, and threats against leaving should sound familiar, because they are exactly the things that characterise domestic abuse and coercive relationships. Indeed, the Government’s statutory guidance on what could constitute criminal coercive behaviour puts it as
“a range of acts designed to make a person subordinate and/or dependent by isolating them from sources of support, exploiting their resources and capacities for personal gain, depriving them of the means needed for independence, resistance and escape and regulating their everyday behaviour.”
That is a very good definition, but there is a catch. Under the current law, coercive control can take place only in a family or in a romantic relationship, so when religious leaders or cultic groups do exactly the same thing, it is not covered. The Family Survival Trust has been campaigning to change that. It is one of the few organisations that specifically aims to support cult survivors, and one to which I often refer cult survivors who write to me, alongside the excellent Faith to Faithless service operated by Humanists UK, which supports people leaving a range of different religions and the consequences that can bring.
May I ask the Minister and officials to look at the Family Survival Trust’s extensive report on coercive control and cultic groups in the UK, published in 2022, which sets out the scale of the problem far more than I can in the time I have available? Would she agree to meet me and the Family Survival Trust to explore options for legislative reform? That could mean a change to the existing coercive control law through the Serious Crime Act 2015 to remove the requirement for a family or romantic connection, or it could mean a new offence.
Governments around the world are waking up to the reality of what people are being subjected to. France has had legislation in place since 2001, focusing not on particular organisations but on the psychological subjection tactics they use. It strengthened that in 2024. Belgium passed an abuse-of-weakness law in 2011, and Luxembourg passed a similar law in 2013. Several proposals aimed at combating psychological manipulation, particularly in relation to high-control groups, are under consideration in the Italian Senate, and the Government of the Netherlands consulted earlier this year on a proposed Bill, too. In the Australian state of Victoria, a parliamentary committee published an extensive report in July this year, specifically on the recruitment methods and impacts of cults and organised fringe groups. It concluded that there was
“a clear case for legislative reform”
to capture
“group-based coercion as a distinct criminal offence”.
So there are a range of options available to us. I urge the Government to work with me to consider them in detail, and to bring forward measures to combat the very real phenomenon of psychological subjection in high-control groups in the UK.
Let me turn briefly to what else we can do to support victims right now. In 2023, the Bloom review was published, an independent review of how Government engage with faith. There are some things in there that I do not agree with, but on the whole, I think it is a very valuable report that made important recommendations around countering extremism and supporting victims of high-control groups. True to form, the previous Conservative Government welcomed the report, said that they would consider the recommendations carefully, and then proceeded not to lift a finger on them. I want to cite recommendation 19:
“Government should fund a programme that supports vulnerable people to leave high-demand groups, high-control movements (often referred to as cults) or religious groups. In addition, this work should help people who face isolation as so-called ‘apostates’ and those facing threats of homelessness, shunning and honour-based abuse.”
It goes on to praise Humanists UK for its work in this space. Its Faith to Faithless helpline launched in February 2024, and within its first year, over 500 people received crucial support. But the support those incredible volunteers offer cannot match demand, and it cannot provide the deep-reaching therapy that many victims need to overcome years of abuse.
I had the privilege recently of hosting a parliamentary screening of the BBC documentary, “Inside the Cult of the Jesus Army”, at which I met several survivors from that organisation. I also met Gillie Jenkinson, a psychotherapist who specialises in helping cult survivors, having spent much of her 20s in a cult herself. She has called for the NHS to offer specialist counselling for those leaving cults. That is a deeply specialist type of support that just does not exist on any major scale right now. Gillie has spoken of trying to find that support herself and finding none; that is what motivated her to train and develop her own practice. Will the Minister work with Government colleagues to examine how we can develop much-needed expertise in this space, within NHS-funded counselling? What can the Government do to provide support for people to rebuild their life?
Connor Naismith (Crewe and Nantwich) (Lab)
My hon. Friend is giving a powerful speech and deserves immense credit for bringing forward this debate. Allegations against members of the Ahmadi Religion of Peace and Light, headquartered in my constituency, are a matter of public record. Local children’s services and Cheshire police are, unfortunately, shouldering the burden of carrying out due process in that case. Does my hon. Friend agree with me that in the aftermath of such cases, we really need cross-Government co-ordination and resourcing to ensure that local communities do not pay the price?
Sam Carling
I remember seeing that case earlier this year, and I was very sorry to hear what happened, when I learned more of the details. That is exactly why we need the Government to take high-control groups seriously at policy level. We need to create the powers and offences to deal with cases like the one in my hon. Friend’s constituency before they become catastrophic and create more victims who need more immediate support, so that this harm is prevented.
I am coming towards my conclusion. Perhaps the Minister could consider picking up once again the recommendations in chapters 6 to 8 of the Bloom review and providing a substantive response to it; the Conservative Government who commissioned it failed to do so. One of the major issues, in my view, is that supporting victims who are leaving high-control groups does not fit neatly into any Government Department. There are safeguarding and crime concerns for the Home Office; implications for faith, on which the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government leads; links to healthcare, as I have just outlined; and I highlighted earlier the problems that a lack of education can create for employment. There are also implications for charity law and regulation, which comes under the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport. This is truly cross-cutting.
What steps can the Government take to create ownership of this issue? Could they set up a dedicated unit of some sort against spiritual, ritual and cultic abuse, or give a named Minister responsibility for co-ordinating across Government in this space? Until Government and Parliament take this issue seriously, people will continue to suffer, and I know that all of us want to ensure that is not the case. So let us have the courage to do what Governments have shied away from for too long: call this out and put an end to it.