(2 days, 1 hour ago)
Public Bill CommitteesMr Dowd, you will be delighted to hear that we are now on part 7 of the Bill.
Was that a cheer in the background?
Part 7 is about existing toll road legislation rather than the new licensed highway regime, which we have been debating at length over previous days. It is about toll legislation made prior to 1999 that assumed that tolls would be collected at toll booths with barriers to prevent non-payment. Of course, as we all know, since the start of the century, remote payment methods, including paying online, by phone, by post or in person at nominated locations, have been successfully used on road user charging schemes around the country. These methods, which I shall refer to as free-flow tolling, have helped to provide smoother and quicker journeys for drivers.
The part aims to provide a route for the operators of tolled roads, bridges and tunnels established using historical legislation to modernise their operations and replace booths and barriers with free-flow tolling should they wish to do so. Most of the clauses in this part replicate provisions in the Transport Act 2000 and regulations made under the Act relating to the collection and enforcement of payments by road user charging schemes. They are also similar to clauses we have already debated in part 3 of the Bill that make these provisions for licensed highway authorities. In doing so, our intention is to ensure that, for the driver, the experience of paying to use a road is the same whatever legislation has been used to implement that toll or charge initially.
Clause 87 gives the Secretary of State the power to make collection and enforcement regulations as the mechanism for setting out how free-flow tolling would work at existing tolled undertakings, and the powers and duties of the toll operator in relation to collecting and enforcing tolls. In particular, the clause provides that such regulations may specify the deadline by which tolls must be paid; provide for how they are to be paid; require documents to be displayed and any equipment to be carried in or fitted to a vehicle for making payment; and provide for the maintenance of any equipment or structures that may need to be done for operating the free-flow tolling system.
Subsections (3) to (5) clarify that collection and enforcement regulations may be made only in relation to statutory tolled undertakings and that that excludes both licensed highway authorities created under the rest of the Bill and road user charging schemes made under the Greater London Authority Act 1999 or the Transport Act 2000. That clarification ensures that there is no opportunity for duplicate or conflicting regulations to be made in relation to the same payment system. I commend the clause to the Committee.
Amendment 20 is fundamentally procedural. It connects with an amendment we will discuss later. Together, the amendments reassign the regulation-making power for notification and enforcement of penalty charges from the Secretary of State to the Lord Chancellor. That is in line with standard practice and represents the appropriate designation of authority.
I now turn to Government amendment 89. Clause 88 provides that collection and enforcement regulations may impose penalty charges for any person who fails to pay a toll, as required when free-flow tolling is introduced at a tolled undertaking. That is essential to ensure that tolls can be properly enforced after the removal of toll booths and barriers. However, there may also be existing offences relating to the non-payment of tolls in the original primary legislation under which the relevant tolling powers are exercised.
It is our intention to ensure that a person should not be subject to sanctions under multiple pieces of legislation for the same infringement. The amendment enables collection and enforcement regulations to set out how penalties imposed under the provisions of the Bill interact with liabilities arising under any other legislation. That could mean that either the imposition of a penalty charge, or the payment of it, switches off liability for the other offence. In short, collection and enforcement regulations could provide that, if a person receives or pays a penalty charge, they cannot be pursued under another legislative regime for the same infringement.
Clause 88 covers the imposition of penalty charges where tolls have not been paid in accordance with the regulations or a range of other actions where people have acted contrary to the requirements of the regulations, which are the subject of succeeding clauses. The clause requires that regulations must specify whether these penalty charges are payable in addition to the toll or instead of it, so there is clarity for drivers about what is owed. In addition, regulations may make provision about the setting of penalty charges, including any discounts, surcharges or administrative fees. The clause also makes clear that it is the registered keeper of the vehicle who is liable to pay for penalty charges unless the regulations specify otherwise. In locations where toll booths and barriers have been removed, those powers are essential to ensure that people who do not pay by the deadline can be pursued to recover the debt. That protects the interests of the majority of people who pay on time.
(3 weeks ago)
Public Bill CommitteesWith its wheels.
Ben Garratt: With its wheels, indeed—in terms of using a toll road to improve reliability in that space. The risk of rolling this out to other roads was highlighted earlier. We would have concerns about that. That is why I mentioned that this is a particularly important route for UK trade. We would not want to see the powers in the Bill used to push out tolling much more generally without new capacity. There is language in the Bill about associating it with new capacity, and again, we would seek further ministerial reassurances that the Bill is focused on that and not widespread tolling.
Declan Pang: I would just add, in relation to the role of the ORR, the stakeholder group needs to be strengthened much more in terms of how it is described at the moment. There is no statutory requirement for a representative of freight and logistics to be in the group. Really, it is quite vague as to who would be sitting in it. In theory, you could have representatives from toll companies or from the DFT, for example, and exclude any industry or road users. Clearing that up and making the governance of that much clearer is vital. I agree with the previous witness who talked about having a more independent role for a stakeholder group, which would make it much more impartial.
Ben Garratt: We would concur with all of that.
Jacob Collier (Burton and Uttoxeter) (Lab)
Q
Ben Garratt: It may be that there is a market dynamic around the M6 that means it is working reasonably well, in that there is a good alternative route that is not always congested. I assume that Michael would feel that they are playing in a competitive environment. Logistics businesses, as we said, are often choosing to use it. It is a slightly different situation in other parts of the network when the current crossing is full a lot of the time, so it could be more of a distress purchase, let us say, to use the alternative route. Therefore it is important that it is regulated and that there is a role for the regulator in ensuring fairness, which the broader market might not necessarily apply in all parts of the network.
Declan Pang: The role of the regulator is certainly very important. As part of the process we need an independent element to that and to strengthen the role of the stakeholder group as an independent group.
On the specific aspects of the Bill that relate to toll amounts, clause 25 talks about classes of road vehicle in respect of which tolls are payable. We have some concerns about how that might impact different types of haulage operation and HGVs, which may disadvantage certain types of businesses. That is an example of something that we think needs to be a bit more consistent, given what we have with the M6 toll at the moment.