All 3 Debates between Justin Madders and Jim Dickson

Highways (Financing) Bill (Fifth sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Jim Dickson
Jim Dickson Portrait Jim Dickson (Dartford) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Wishart. I will speak to both amendments.

Currently, Dartford residents who use the Dartford crossing are able to do so at a considerable discount. The definition covers residents within the Dartford borough council area, who either pay £25 a year to use the crossing as many times as they like or pay £12.50 a year for 50 crossings. That represents good value for Dartford residents and gives them some compensation for having to live next to a crossing that takes all the burden of traffic crossing the Thames outside London and that therefore causes huge congestion and significant problems with air quality.

I imagine that when the lower Thames crossing is opened, residents of Gravesham or in the area around and north of the crossing will also want a resident discount, to compensate them for living near a busy crossing. The Dartford crossing and the lower Thames crossing will both still be busy, albeit that traffic will be much better distributed between the two, which will certainly be a blessing for Dartford residents.

I totally understand why the Minister does not want this set out in the Bill; I am sure he will say that such things should be dealt with by the regulator and the licence holder. However, I hope he will give Dartford residents some assurance that that conversation will be had at the right moment, as we expect, so they can have confidence that they will continue to benefit from the current concessions and maybe even see them extended to both crossings, as might be the case for Gravesham residents using the Dartford crossing in future.

Justin Madders Portrait The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport (Justin Madders)
- Hansard - -

It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair this morning, Mr Wishart, and to welcome you back to the Committee. I am glad to see that most of us have made it back after the excitement of last week; I hope we will continue to have some very thought-provoking debates.

I turn to the interesting amendments tabled by the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage. Amendment 41 would make it a statutory requirement for any licensed highway to include a discount for blue badge holders. We all recognise the importance of ensuring affordability and the need for specific groups to be taken into account. I can confirm that the existing scheme for exempting vehicles used by or for people with disabilities that is already in place in Dartford will continue to apply for the first control period, which is nine years from the date of the transaction. That would also be extended to the lower Thames crossing. I am happy to make that commitment on the record today.

Beyond the first control period, the hon. Member and I are aligned in the view that the needs of individual groups must be considered in the setting of tolls, and that suitable discounts or exemptions should continue to apply. However, my view is that that is already captured by the regime set out in the Bill. A fundamental tenet of the duty on the Office of Rail and Road is that it must act at all times in the manner

“best calculated to further the interests of users”,

which of course means all users.

There is an established precedent that toll operators offer toll concessions for disabled users. Our issue with the amendment is that generally those schemes are tied to eligibility for exemptions from vehicle excise duty, as is the case with the current Dart charge. That exemption recognises the additional mobility needs and costs faced by people whose disability significantly affects their ability to move around.

As a public sector body, the ORR is already bound in legislation to advance equality of opportunity for people with protected characteristics, through the public sector equality duty. That will be supplemented by a duty to further the interests of users. Both duties will apply in the setting of tolling conditions and the ORR’s tolling code. Additionally, the Government will be able to issue guidance to the ORR on the exercise of its tolling functions.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

The hon. Gentleman is a generous man.

There are discounts available for early payment in most of these schemes anyway, which I think would speak to the impassioned plea he made about people who innocently contravene the regulations. It is important that such a change is made in regulations and not primary legislation for reasons I will go on to explain.

I do not believe fixing a cap in primary legislation would be the right approach. Penalty charges vary across the country depending on local conditions. For example, the Tyne tunnel has an initial penalty charge of £30 plus the toll, while for the Blackwall and Silvertown tunnels the full charge is £180. The levels of PCNs and the structure of payments need to be appropriate and proportionate to the specific scheme. The Bill already allows penalty charges to be set through regulations, and that responsibility is to be delegated to the Office of Rail and Road acting in accordance with its statutory duties, which we have covered several times already. That of course gives it the flexibility to keep charges under review.

One of the problems with setting a fixed price cap in legislation is that it will erode in real terms with inflation. Hopefully, we will not see rising inflation over the coming years, but of course it is inevitable that, as time goes on, the value of the cap will decrease. For a good example of why fixing these caps in legislation is a bad idea, I refer the shadow Minister to the saga of the Swinford toll bridge, which I am sure he is familiar with: the 10p fee was set in 1760—I believe that is a little time before the hon. Member was actively engaged in politics—and because it was fixed in primary legislation, it has unfortunately not moved on because of the difficulty in changing it. That is a good example of why setting these figures in primary legislation is inappropriate.

Jim Dickson Portrait Jim Dickson
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

While we are dealing with the administration of tolling and charges that result from non-payment, I want to mention that the operator that administers the Dart charge in Dartford changed in 2023, and during the transition there were numerous problems: people being charged for cars that were said to have used the crossing when they had not; people whose resident discounts disappeared from their accounts and who were then charged the full amount; and other problems with the way in which the administration was done. Could the Minister give some reassurance that such administrative errors around both charging and penalties, if they occur in the future, either on the lower Thames crossing or with the Dart charge, will be subject to the regulator’s intervention to ensure that the licence holder performed their responsibilities properly?

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

My hon. Friend is absolutely correct. The situation under the Bill gives the regulator the power to deal with those kinds of instances. If licence conditions are not being complied with, which is the sort of situation to which he has referred, the Bill gives the regulator the power to intervene. That strengthens the position for people in those instances, although hopefully we will not have too many such instances.

Amendment 59 concerns the use of regulations. It is the case that using the negative procedure for this type of regulation follows an established precedent set in the Transport Act 2000. The Road User Charging Schemes (Penalty Charges, Adjudication and Enforcement) (England) Regulations 2013 were made under the procedure, and they are comparable with the regulations that we would expect to make under the Bill. They implement the detailed machinery needed to enable the charging authorities to impose and enforce civil penalties, including adjudication and, subject to safeguards, vehicle examination or search, immobilisation and removal.

The negative procedure provides an appropriate balance between parliamentary scrutiny and the flexibility required to ensure that the penalty charge regime remains effective, proportionate and capable of adapting to future operational requirements, without the need for further primary legislation. As explained in the delegated powers memorandum, published alongside the Bill, those regulations will set out the detailed enforcement framework to confer powers. As with many things that concern operational matters, this needs to remain flexible, hence why regulations were chosen as the mechanism for setting out the detail. I invite the hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire not to press amendment 59 to a vote.

Amendment 71 would prevent the Bill from coming into force until after the publication of a report on the policy regarding penalty charges. Unfortunately, this would also slow and frustrate the progress that we want to make on the lower Thames crossing. Clause 27 allows the Secretary of State to make regulations about the very thing that this amendment asks for: a report before commencement.

It is already the case that Parliament will need to see details of the enforcement regime by way of the regulations made under clause 27 before any enforcement regime would come into effect. Blocking commencement of the rest of the Bill until a report had been issued would mean Parliament being asked to look at the same thing twice—once in a Government publication, and again when it scrutinises regulations. That is the kind of bureaucracy and slowing of progress that we want to avoid. Again, I ask the hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire not to press amendment 71 to a vote.

Amendment 6 agreed to.

Amendments made: 7, in clause 27, page 19, line 22, leave out paragraph (a).

This amendment is consequential on amendment 10.

Amendment 8, in clause 27, page 19, line 28, leave out paragraph (e).

This amendment is consequential on amendment 10.

Amendment 9, in clause 27, page 19, line 38, at end insert—

“(6A) Regulations under subsection (1) which make provision for the imposition of a penalty charge must specify whether the charge is payable in addition to the toll in respect of which the charge is payable or instead of it.”

This amendment ensures that a requirement to pay a toll may remain in force (and therefore be recoverable as a civil debt under clause 24) even where a penalty charge is imposed in respect of the toll.

Amendment 10, in clause 27, page 19, line 38, at end insert—

“(6B) The Lord Chancellor may make regulations about the notification and enforcement of penalty charges.”—(Justin Madders.)

This amendment provides that regulations about the notification and enforcement of a penalty charge in respect of a toll are to be made by the Lord Chancellor (instead of by the Secretary of State).

Clause 27, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 28

Non-payment of tolls and unauthorised charging of tolls

Amendments made: 11, in clause 28, page 20, line 17, after “toll” insert

“or of a penalty charge imposed in accordance with regulations under section 27(1)”

This amendment and amendment 12 widen the offence under clause 28(3) to cases where a person seeks to avoid payment of a penalty charge for non-payment of a toll.

Amendment 12, in clause 28, page 20, line 18, after “toll” insert

“or a penalty charge mentioned in paragraph (a)”

See the explanatory statement for amendment 11.

Amendment 13, in clause 28, page 20, line 23, at end insert—

“(4A) A person commits an offence if the person removes a notice of a penalty charge imposed in accordance with regulations under section 27(1) which has been fixed to a road vehicle in accordance with regulations under section 27(6B) unless—

(a) the person is the registered keeper of the vehicle or a person using the vehicle with the registered keeper’s authority, or

(b) the person does so under the authority of the registered keeper or such a person or of the holder of a licence.

(4B) A person who commits an offence under subsection (4A) is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 2 on the standard scale.”—(Justin Madders.)

This amendment creates an offence where a person removes a notice of a penalty charge from a vehicle without lawful authority.

Clause 28, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 29

Examination, entry, search and seizure

Highways (Financing) Bill (Fourth sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Jim Dickson
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful to the hon. Lady, but I would say that she is making my case for me: we need to keep up with important changes and risk in the cyber-security world. That is why keeping the Bill as technology-neutral as possible is important, because we simply do not know what will be coming next. Giving operators the flexibility to be able to determine what technology is used is an important part of cyber-security moving forward.

Amendment 53 would insert specific consultation requirements into the Bill before a toll can be set. I agree that local communities and those who use the tolls should have a voice. The question is not whether they should have a voice, but how best to secure that engagement within the Bill’s framework of independent regulation. As it stands, the framework places responsibility with the regulator to set tolling requirements through its code and licence conditions, and to enforce compliance. Consultation requirements should sit within those arrangements, rather than be prescriptive in the Bill.

In exercising its functions, the ORR must have regard to the principles of transparency, accountability, proportionality and consistency, and keep the interests of users at the heart of its decision making. That is an important safeguard in the Bill, and I hope that it addresses some of the shadow Minister’s concerns. He will know that the Bill establishes a stakeholder group that will directly advise the ORR. Again, I hope that will address the point about the voices of users being heard in this process. I do not believe that the amendment would improve engagement. Instead, it would constrain the regulator’s discretion to determine how best to take forward individual users’ voices, so I ask the Member not to press it.

Jim Dickson Portrait Jim Dickson
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Without wishing to prolong proceedings, it is very important that the exact level and differential of tolls between the Dartford crossing and the lower Thames crossing—this legislation is being used to construct the lower Thames crossing—is properly considered. My constituents are particularly keen that there should not be a differential between the two crossings so that a financial incentive is created to use one rather than the other, somewhat negating the fact that we have the new infrastructure in place. We need to try to balance the traffic between the two crossings, and tolling will obviously be an important part of that. Would the Minister note that? Perhaps we can ensure collectively that that is in the thinking of the licence holder going forward.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Third sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Jim Dickson
Tuesday 3rd November 2026

(2 weeks, 2 days ago)

Public Bill Committees
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Jim Dickson Portrait Jim Dickson
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is clearly incredibly important to all users of this future infrastructure and the present Dartford crossing that the ORR is as capable and fully equipped as it can be to carry out its duties. Up to now, the ORR has been more equipped on rail than on road, even though it has considerable responsibilities for roads at the moment. A recent report commissioned by the Department for Business and Trade indicated that the ORR needed to increase its skills and capacity in order to do this work. Will the Minister reassure my constituents and all other future users of the infrastructure that the ORR will be fully equipped, have full capability and be able to discharge its duties under the Bill?

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I can give my hon. Friend that assurance. It is vital that the duties set out in clause 1 can be delivered to the best of the ORR’s ability. The whole purpose of the RAB model is that we have a functioning and effective regulator, so resourcing it is vital.