Highways (Financing) Bill (Eighth sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Olly Glover
Tuesday 17th November 2026

(2 days, 1 hour ago)

Public Bill Committees
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover (Didcot and Wantage) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship on this Committee for the final time, Mr Wishart.

New clause 5 is a remarkably sensible amendment from the shadow Minister—I have not always felt able to say similar during these proceedings. The hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire raises a very good point: the Government are taking a totally inconsistent approach to the role of the Office of Rail and Road. This Bill is strengthening its role to ensure that things work sensibly and appropriately in relation to private toll roads, but for the railway the Government have significantly denuded the ORR’s powers, presumably because Great British Railways will eventually do more than display a livery of rather dubious, garish colours. I hope the Minister can explain the logic for why the ORR is being treated so differently in those two sectors.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

It is wonderful to hear the shadow Minister being such a champion for regulation. That is not something that we have been treated to previously, but we are delighted to hear that he has come onboard, if the Committee will pardon the pun.

In October last year, the Government announced that we were commissioning Dr Richard Judge to undertake an independent review of the Office of Rail and Road, in relation to the significant changes being made in the rail sector, to which both Opposition spokespeople—the hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire and the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage—referred. The Government felt it would be helpful to get ahead of that change with an independent review to help to ensure that the regulator is well placed to deliver the transformation, and to oversee organisational change in the rail sector while continuing to deliver its other roles and functions effectively, particularly those that relate to roads. The review was also intended to allow the development of key learning and insights to support performance improvements for other regulators. Dr Judge spent nearly a year doing the review and published his findings very recently, in September, with 12 recommendations. The review considered the role of the ORR in both rail and road and the Government are, of course, considering those recommendations. We will publish our response in due course.

As the Committee would expect me to say, asking for another report on the duties of the ORR in a slightly different format would not be the best use of taxpayers’ money. The shadow Minister says that his central question—why we are treating rail and road differently—is not complicated, and it does not have a complicated answer. Rail and road are, of course, different modes of transport and therefore require different types of regulatory oversight.

One reason for the change in the ORR’s role in rail is that, of course, many passenger services are moving into the public sector whereas, under this Bill, road will move into the private sector for the first time. Rail also runs differently to road, and has different risks and opportunities. Rail is a closed system, by which I mean people cannot turn up in their own locomotive and get on the tracks, whereas anyone can get in a vehicle and use a road. The rail operator is therefore responsible for every passenger on the train, but a member of the public can drive on the road whenever they wish and the road operator is not responsible in the same way.

Those are fundamental and obvious differences, which is why the answer to why we are treating them differently is not complicated. They are entering into new regimes: one is clearly far more involved in the public sector, as it is far more related to passenger services, and the other is not. In simple terms, that is why they are being treated differently.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Fifth sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Olly Glover
Justin Madders Portrait The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport (Justin Madders)
- Hansard - -

It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair this morning, Mr Wishart, and to welcome you back to the Committee. I am glad to see that most of us have made it back after the excitement of last week; I hope we will continue to have some very thought-provoking debates.

I turn to the interesting amendments tabled by the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage. Amendment 41 would make it a statutory requirement for any licensed highway to include a discount for blue badge holders. We all recognise the importance of ensuring affordability and the need for specific groups to be taken into account. I can confirm that the existing scheme for exempting vehicles used by or for people with disabilities that is already in place in Dartford will continue to apply for the first control period, which is nine years from the date of the transaction. That would also be extended to the lower Thames crossing. I am happy to make that commitment on the record today.

Beyond the first control period, the hon. Member and I are aligned in the view that the needs of individual groups must be considered in the setting of tolls, and that suitable discounts or exemptions should continue to apply. However, my view is that that is already captured by the regime set out in the Bill. A fundamental tenet of the duty on the Office of Rail and Road is that it must act at all times in the manner

“best calculated to further the interests of users”,

which of course means all users.

There is an established precedent that toll operators offer toll concessions for disabled users. Our issue with the amendment is that generally those schemes are tied to eligibility for exemptions from vehicle excise duty, as is the case with the current Dart charge. That exemption recognises the additional mobility needs and costs faced by people whose disability significantly affects their ability to move around.

As a public sector body, the ORR is already bound in legislation to advance equality of opportunity for people with protected characteristics, through the public sector equality duty. That will be supplemented by a duty to further the interests of users. Both duties will apply in the setting of tolling conditions and the ORR’s tolling code. Additionally, the Government will be able to issue guidance to the ORR on the exercise of its tolling functions.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I understand the Minister’s point, but does he agree that a problem with taking what he says on trust is that at the moment, as far as I am aware, there is no plan to develop or publish the ORR’s code on the charging of tolls before the Bill is passed? We would need to see that code to be assured that it is sufficiently robust to do what the Minister says.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

In our previous sittings, the Committee has debated at length why that detail will not be possible at this stage—it is simply because the level of information on financial transactions is not there—but I have stated on the record what our intention is and what safeguards and measures are in the Bill to ensure that these groups are protected. Unfortunately, the phrasing of amendment 41 does not address the protections that are currently offered.

I absolutely understand the hon. Gentleman’s good intentions, but “blue badges” is a colloquial term. The scheme varies from local authority to local authority. It is primarily not about travel between places, but about ensuring that people can park accessibly at a particular location. It does not relate to a person’s need for a vehicle in the first place; it relates solely to their needs when they have arrived at their destination.

I therefore do not think that amendment 41 is the right one to address the concerns that the hon. Gentleman has raised. I absolutely understand those concerns, but I am confident that the existing framework represents the right approach. It is a robust protection of disabled users, but it also has flexibility, meaning that as our understanding of people’s needs changes, or as scheme criteria change, the ORR can continue to act dynamically to protect the interests of all users. I hope that I have given him some assurance that we intend to deal with the matter in the way that his amendment indicates.

Amendment 42 is about local discounts. On the lower Thames crossing and on Dartford, I am happy to give the hon. Gentleman the same commitment that I made on amendment 41: that for the first control period, which is for nine years from the date of transaction, the local resident discount scheme will remain in place. Beyond that, I believe that the framework strikes the right balance in ensuring that the ORR is representing the specific needs of all users, supported by guidance issued by the Department.

The shadow Minister, the hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire, says that he is looking for recognition in the Bill that local needs will be taken into account. I believe that the Bill does provide that recognition. It is right that this is a framework Bill to secure outcomes based on clear duties and expectations.

In practice, requiring a local resident discount in the way the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage proposes would not give the protection that I think he wants. An operator could fulfil an obligation to carry out a local discount simply by taking 1p off tolls for local residents or offering £1 off an annual pass. That would meet the letter of the law under the amendment, but would clearly ignore the spirit of what we are trying to achieve. In those situations, the ORR would not be able to intervene in the way we have set up in the Bill, because the licence holder could simply say, “We have provided a local residents discount scheme,” albeit that their scheme was not in the spirit that we intend.

In the Bill, we hope to deliver a practical, flexible solution that allows the Government to outline our clear expectations, that empowers the ORR to set a fixed requirement and that requires the ORR to act in a manner that is fair and transparent. It is through that framework that we will deliver a fair outcome for all users and recognise the interests of specific user groups.

As my hon. Friend the Member for Dartford has set out, the level of detail that currently applies to local discounts is not something that we would want to make explicit in the Bill, as it would not have the flexibility that the ORR needs in order to deal with future discounts. It is not a fixed concept; it is based on flexibility and response to local need, as my hon. Friend so eloquently set out. The Government therefore cannot support amendment 42.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I absolutely understand the shadow Minister’s point. The whole point of this work is to make life easier for local residents. There will of course be some disruption during construction but, in the case of the lower Thames crossing, the local road network is quite a long way from the majority of the works. The powers of the regulator, the opportunity for guidance to be given to stakeholder groups and the overriding duties of the ORR are sufficient to give us confidence that the intentions that I have espoused today will be delivered.

My amendment 5 is intended to put beyond doubt that the penalty charge referred to in clause 25 relates to a failure to pay the toll. I hope hon. Members will agree that it is a straightforward amendment made for the purposes of clarity.

Clause 25, as amended, will set out the information that a licence holder must include in its tolling scheme. The scheme must clearly identify the highway where tolls will apply and explain when drivers will have to pay. It must set out which vehicle types will be charged, the amount of the toll and any exemptions or reduced rates. It must explain how and when tolls must be paid and how the licence holder will record and collect payments. It must describe the information that will be used to decide whether a toll is due or has been paid. It must also explain what might happen if a toll is not paid, including the level of any penalty or other charge. Importantly, the scheme must explain how a driver can challenge a toll.

The clause will allow different tolls to apply in different circumstances. For example, charges may vary by time of day, distance travelled, type or use of vehicle or method of payment. The licence holder must publish the scheme in a way that brings it to the attention of people likely to be affected. It must also provide a copy to anyone who asks.

The clause will therefore ensure that drivers can understand when tolls apply, how much they must pay and what rights they have if they wish to challenge a charge. I hope that hon. Members can see the logic of setting that out in the Bill. I commend clause 25, as amended, to the Committee.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

On amendment 41, I will give the Minister the benefit of the doubt, although it does underline the importance of the ORR code. I note that the next group includes a Conservative amendment on that topic, which will be important to discuss. I am not persuaded by the Minister’s comments that it is not possible to produce the code before the Bill becomes law. We were told very similar things about the licence and the access and use policy in relation to the Railways Bill, and yet the Government eventually decided that they could indeed publish those things before the Bill became law. I encourage the Minister to adopt that not necessarily very common instance of good practice from his Department and apply it to this Bill.

I hear what the Minister says about amendment 42, but this is a very important issue and I wish to press it to a Division.

I beg to ask leave to withdraw amendment 41.

Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.

Amendment made: 5, in clause 25, page 18, line 22, after “charge” insert—

“in respect of a failure to pay a toll”.—(Justin Madders.)

This amendment clarifies that provision in a tolling scheme about rates of penalty charges is limited to penalty charges in respect of non-payment of tolls.

Amendment proposed: 42, in clause 25, page 18, line 26, at end insert—

“(1A) A tolling scheme must provide for lower tolls to be charged for residents living within an area in close proximity to the chargeable highway.

(1B) ‘Close proximity’ under subsection (1A) is to be determined by the Secretary of State in consultation with the highest tier local authority in the areas through which the highway passes in regulations subject to the affirmative procedure.”—(Olly Glover.)

This amendment gives local residents a right to discounted tolls on toll roads that they would expect to use regularly due to geographic proximity.

Question put, That the amendment be made.

--- Later in debate ---
Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I have concluded.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I quite enjoyed the little sideshow there. It was entertaining.

I will deal first with the shadow Minister’s questions about Government amendment 13. Of course, we do not envisage that this is going to be a regular situation. It could cover, for example, a situation where a vehicle has been abandoned on a highway, but it is also for situations where there may be a persistent offender and further action is needed to enforce against them.

I turn to the shadow Minister’s amendment 52, which would introduce a £100 cap on penalty charges for non-payment of a toll. That is actually £20 lower than the current cap for a penalty charge notice issued at Dartford and on quite a lot of other road charging schemes, so it is very generous of him to give a discount.

--- Later in debate ---
Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I will say a little about amendment 88, which the shadow Minister has started off, and then make some brief comments about the Conservatives’ amendments as a whole.

Amendment 88 would strengthen the safeguards around vehicle searches in the Bill by restricting private enforcement powers under clause 29 and requiring a judicial warrant issued by a magistrate, or a police presence, before entering or searching a vehicle. Under standard civil enforcement rules in schedule 12 to the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007, court bailiffs recovering civil debts cannot enter or search vehicles without a judicial warrant of control. In that context, clause 29 creates an extraordinary anomaly whereby private toll contractors would enjoy broader, unmonitored powers of search and entry than certificated court bailiffs. The clause, as drafted, looks to give huge, potentially unintended powers to private contractors. Users of these roads should be given more protection to prevent infringement of their civil liberties with little oversight. I therefore hope that the Minister will consider amendment 88.

Most of the Conservatives’ amendments in this group seem sensible, and we are inclined to support them, but I have a—“philosophical” is perhaps overly generous—vaguely political-philosophical question about them. A lot of their amendments tend to take two routes. The first is requiring various things to be published before the Bill comes into force. We understand that route and are inclined to support it; it is a similar argument to what we heard about the ORR code. The other route is requiring the affirmative procedure rather than the negative procedure. The challenge with amendments that would require more use of the affirmative procedure is finding the right balance between holding a Government to account and not making virtually every change subject to a House of Commons vote.

At some point, could the shadow Minister say a little bit about the Conservatives’ thought process and criteria for what should be subject to the affirmative procedure? They are asking for a lot of things to be subject to the affirmative procedure. In principle, that could mean a very large number of things coming to the Commons for a Division after consideration by a Delegated Legislation Committee, but perhaps I have misunderstood and he can clarify.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I will have a bit of banter and answer the Liberal Democrat spokesperson’s question about the Conservative approach to delegated legislation. He need only look at their 14 years in power to see that they were very fond of the negative procedure and delegated legislation.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Fourth sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Olly Glover
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I was about to sit down, but there are publication requirements in clause 78, which will deal with a number of the issues that the hon. Member referred to, so I request that the Committee reject the amendment.

Question put and agreed to.

Clause 5 accordingly ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 6 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 7

Tolling and other mandatory conditions

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I beg to move amendment 39, in clause 7, page 6, line 11, at end insert—

“(c) a condition requiring the holder of the licence to compensate affected local highway authorities for extraordinary maintenance costs, traffic management or congestion mitigation arising from any increased traffic as a result of vehicles avoiding tolls on the chargeable highway.”

This amendment ensures that local authorities are compensated for the knock-on costs of increased traffic on local roads as a result of drivers aiming to avoid the toll road.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I thank the hon. Members for Mid Buckinghamshire and for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton for their amendment.

The hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage tried to make a noble case for something that this Government are already dealing with through the record funding for highways maintenance that we have announced and are already delivering on. I understand the thrust of his argument about compensation to local highway authorities for displaced traffic. The right approach is to undertake an assessment of the whole strategic road network, to understand what improvements and likely increases to overall capacity could achieve more widely. Then, we should assess the impact if we do not proceed.

Of course, the whole thrust of the Bill is to reduce congestion, not increase it. As my hon. Friend the Member for Dartford has said on many occasions, we know that his part of the country is already at bursting point. We know what happens when things go wrong at that vital section of the strategic road network. There are already local problems as people try to find alternatives to avoid the congestion it has caused. That is clearly not because people are trying to avoid the toll, which has been in place for many years; it is actually about the lack of reliability at that vital pinch point. The answer is not to compensate people for delays caused by trying to avoid that unreliability; the answer is to make the Dartford crossing more reliable so that people actively choose that road.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Minister, as he has in a few of his speeches, is talking as if the Bill is only about the lower Thames crossing, but it is not. It is much broader than that, as he has acknowledged, although it is focused on the lower Thames crossing. If the Bill was just about the lower Thames crossing, I might well agree with his argument, as there are no alternatives in that particular case. But as drafted, it is not just about the lower Thames crossing, is it?

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

The hon. Gentleman is absolutely correct that the Bill is scheme-agnostic, but as the lower Thames crossing is the only scheme we currently have in mind, it is helpful to draw examples from that for why the amendment is not acceptable.

It is probably also worth pointing out that I am not aware of any other such toll schemes operating in this country at the moment. Is it his position that this compensation measure should be extended to the Mersey tunnels or the Mersey Gateway crossing, for example? My local transport authorities might be interested to hear that, and they might wonder where the funding would come from.

As I have said, the whole purpose of the Bill is to create the regulated asset base model that will fund the crossing. It will be a separate income stream from the general roads budget, and those who benefit directly from the new infrastructure will pay for it. It will improve the reliability of the whole network, which is the correct approach and is far more effective than trying to compensate people for an already overstretched and failing network.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Third sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Olly Glover
Tuesday 3rd November 2026

(2 weeks, 2 days ago)

Public Bill Committees
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I turn first to amendment 45. I thank the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage for raising whether alternative transport investment should be considered before a licence is granted. I have to say that I have never been entirely clear whether the Liberal Democrats support the lower Thames crossing. The hon. Gentleman’s comments push him more into the “no” territory, but as the Bill progresses we will no doubt see whether they can support it.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Given that the Minister was putting words in my mouth, let me clarify my view. We do support the lower Thames crossing, because the Dartford crossing is under pressure and there is no resilience when it closes, but that does not mean that we support only the lower Thames crossing. The problem with policy over decades—I disagree with the shadow Minister on this—is that it has been roads, roads, roads, and motorways, motorways, motorways. It should be not either/or, but both.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I appreciate the hon. Gentleman’s clarity. I understand his argument, but it is probably a bit late now. The assessment on alternative transport options belongs in the scheme appraisal and the business case process, not in this Bill, which is about whether to grant a licence in the first place.

The Association for Consultancy and Engineering was clear in its written evidence that schemes must be

“sufficiently developed before financing and procurement decisions are taken.”

As the hon. Gentleman knows, for the lower Thames crossing, the development consent order has already been issued, and all the issues that he talked about were considered. It has been approved, and construction is under way.

The Bill is not about which road should be built; it is about creating an additional financing and regulatory framework, which can be used where there is a need for a road scheme. It is not about putting roads ahead of rail or bus transport. That will be considered through the earlier business case process. Requiring that to be assessed again once the licence has been granted would duplicate the work and add delay. As hon. Members have said, there is an urgent need for this scheme to proceed, so I ask the hon. Gentleman to withdraw the amendment.

On Opposition amendment 78, we debated a similar point when we discussed amendment 81. The shadow Minister did not press that amendment to a vote, but given the gusto with which he advanced his argument today, he may press amendment 78. I will not repeat the point that have been made, but clause 4(1)(b)(iv) requires that consultation includes

“such other persons (including persons exercising functions in relation to highways) as the licensing authority considers appropriate.”

So the assurances that Opposition Members seek are there in black and white.

If we are too prescriptive, we may not cover every type of authority. At the moment, we know exactly what the local authority structures are but, as we have seen in recent years, that can change, so it would not be prudent to hardwire that into primary legislation. The Bill rightly allows the licensing authority to identify and consult the appropriate bodies exercising high-risk functions for the scheme. That makes the framework flexible enough to respond to the circumstances of individual projects and changes to local government structures over the lifetime of the legislation.

On amendment 87, I understand the concerns of the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage. We absolutely recognise that major road schemes can have impacts on surrounding local roads, and they need to be properly considered—indeed, the lower Thames crossing is proceeding because we want to improve the conditions on the local roads—but I do not believe that the amendment puts the consideration in the right place.

Licences granted under the Bill are about bringing qualifying trunk road projects within the new financing and regulatory framework. It is not the process through which the underlying impacts of a road scheme are first identified and addressed. Those impacts, including changes to traffic and congestion, should be considered through the development and planning of the road scheme. As the hon. Gentleman knows, for the lower Thames crossing, traffic forecasts were assessed and considered as part of the development consent order, which is the appropriate stage for such considerations. Carrying out that work again would delay the project and duplicate work that has already been completed.

Clause 4 sets out the requirements that must be met for consultation before a licence can be granted under the Bill. It ensures that the grant of a licence is subject to a clear, transparent and accessible consultation process, giving those likely to be affected a proper opportunity to make representations before the licence is granted. I therefore commend the clause to the Committee.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Second sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Olly Glover
Thursday 29th October 2026

(3 weeks ago)

Public Bill Committees
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

We hope the Bill will address those concerns.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover (Didcot and Wantage) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Q Both of your organisations and many others have highlighted how the UK is not great at delivering infrastructure quickly and efficiently. Do you believe that the Bill in its current form has the potential to accelerate the delivery of major road projects?

Ben Hopkinson: I completely agree that the UK has a long historical challenge with delivering infrastructure cheaply and quickly. HS2 is the most expensive railway ever built, and the Bakerloo line extension will be one of the most expensive underground lines ever built. Tramlines are double the cost here compared to other European countries. We have the most expensive nuclear power plant ever built. There is a real long-term failure to build infrastructure quickly and cheaply.

On the Bill, it is good that we are getting private financing in, and that will help ease some of the burden on the state, when we are already pushed up against our fiscal limits. As I have mentioned, I have a little concern about the incentive structure, especially insofar as the private constructor has incentives to escalate costs as much as they can get away with under the ORR. A concession model might work a little better.

Sam Dumitriu: One of the important things when it comes to infrastructure delivery is ensuring you have a pipeline of projects, you know what you will build next and you can plan appropriately. We have many reasons why, in the UK, those pipelines get knocked about. Sometimes you have a road that you want to build, and everyone wants it built, but someone has brought a lawsuit against the road and it is delayed by a year. That makes planning for that really challenging.

One of the other problems is that sometimes those delays mean that you get pushed into different funding windows—the Treasury can reopen conversations about value for money, especially when in every Budget someone is trying to squeeze things into the fiscal rules and moving things from one period into another period, and cost-saving measures that are really delays. Those things tend to happen, and have happened for ever.

One thing that was really impressive under the last Government was the road investment strategy approach, which essentially said “We will set out a strategic case for all the big roads we want to build, we will give a pot of money and then we will give a delivery body the freedom to execute that.” The freedom to execute was slightly constrained by the planning system and all those delays, but fundamentally that is a very good approach. The challenge comes when the money is not quite there from the public purse, in part because the fiscal situation is tighter, but also because different choices are being made. In that case, private finance can fill the gap and ensure that you have a much more stable pipeline. I am in favour of that aspect and I think that will speed up delivery.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

Do have anything to add, Mr Godfrey?

Will Godfrey: I would reiterate the point that the development consent order tightly defines the scope of what is being delivered. As Matt said, the project is already well advanced.

There are a few other points to bring up. Getting the cost forecast right, which underpins the allowed revenue for the first control period, is really important. That is the baseline against which you are holding the company to account. The instruments thereafter are what you specify in the licence, and that is really important to get right. That is not stuff you put in the Bill, but it is really important that you get it right in the licence and that you have the right incentives for the privately financed entity to deliver against that schedule. You need to make sure that the balance in the allocation of risk is right and that end users are ultimately protected from the risks of cost overruns.

As I say, this project is fairly well advanced already; it is not like we are talking about starting one from scratch.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Q Over the decades, we have often heard the wisdom that private finance is better than the Treasury, because it helps to keep things off the Treasury books and avoids constraints from public sector financing. But with some of those private finance initiatives, the whole-life costs can end up being quite a lot higher and being a burden on the taxpayer in a different way. What metrics do you feel that the Government should use to determine whether alternative finance arrangements, rather than direct Treasury funding, deliver better value for money for individual road schemes? What criteria should there be for deciding that?

Will Godfrey: I think the ORR’s role, as envisaged in the Bill, would not be to advise on those questions. That would be more of a question to address to Government. It is perhaps relevant here that it is important to take account of the risk-adjusted cost of financing. You have already made the point about whether things are on the balance sheet or not. Another point to bring in is the certainty around the funding and delivery arrangements. RAB-based price controls are a commitment to a certain cycle of, typically, five-year reviews in which you set the funding requirements, the price control limits and what is delivered in that period. You reset each time but the point is that it is not potentially subject to Government reopening the arrangements for the funding, which is sometimes encountered in other publicly funded arrangements. I think that is as much as I am able to say. That is more of a question for Government.

Highways (Financing) Bill (First sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Olly Glover
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

That is very helpful. I wonder whether the other two witnesses have anything to say from the other side of the road, so to speak.

Ben Garratt: It is a challenging calculation. Look at how much the logistics sector is currently paying to cross the Dartford crossing: it is about 40% of the road use but it is more because HGVs and larger vehicles pay more than that. We can assume they are paying over £100 million a year to cross it, as a rough calculation. The cost of congestion to drivers is about £200 million a year. We can add on to that—we do not have the numbers, but we know beyond that is the cost to wider supply chains and the cost of unreliability. We can make an assumption, thinking about the experience on the M6 toll, that the sector would rather pay up front for reliability than pay during the day for a lack of reliability, knowing that the costs for that are much bigger than the £200 million because of the impact across supply chains.

Declan Pang: The most important thing for our members is reliability. They want reliability and consistency of journey times. Congestion can be very unreliable, which drives a significant amount of cost into the supply chain, so that is, first and foremost, the most important consideration. Clearly, if we ended up in a situation in the future where we had multiple tolled routes, the cumulative impact of that situation would be deeply concerning to us, but I appreciate that the Bill is looking specifically at the lower Thames crossing.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Q Could you say a little more about what you think can be learned from the M6 toll in terms of how we might look to improve or amend the Bill? That is perhaps the largest geographical manifestation of tolling at the moment, and the most similar to the presumed application of this Bill to the lower Thames crossing.

Ben Garratt: There are features of the Bill about which we are not seeking amendment but seeking reassurances. For example, it must be ensured that there is a strong regulator for establishing the scheme and monitoring it going forward. That relates to the licensing conditions too. Therefore, we see value in there being a Bill setting a broad framework and including the regulator in that, rather than potentially doing things how they have been done in the past in the sense of having individual schemes. We would seek reassurances about the strength of the regulator in that space, and that it will think about freight and logistics when it thinks about economy.

We have heard from Michael about how the sector is voting with its feet—

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

With its wheels.

Ben Garratt: With its wheels, indeed—in terms of using a toll road to improve reliability in that space. The risk of rolling this out to other roads was highlighted earlier. We would have concerns about that. That is why I mentioned that this is a particularly important route for UK trade. We would not want to see the powers in the Bill used to push out tolling much more generally without new capacity. There is language in the Bill about associating it with new capacity, and again, we would seek further ministerial reassurances that the Bill is focused on that and not widespread tolling.

Declan Pang: I would just add, in relation to the role of the ORR, the stakeholder group needs to be strengthened much more in terms of how it is described at the moment. There is no statutory requirement for a representative of freight and logistics to be in the group. Really, it is quite vague as to who would be sitting in it. In theory, you could have representatives from toll companies or from the DFT, for example, and exclude any industry or road users. Clearing that up and making the governance of that much clearer is vital. I agree with the previous witness who talked about having a more independent role for a stakeholder group, which would make it much more impartial.

Ben Garratt: We would concur with all of that.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

Q I will briefly follow up on your comments. Obviously, this Bill is designed to cover the trunk roads network. It is correct, isn’t it, that mayors currently do not have any specific control over those?

Ralph Smyth: That is correct, yes. It is almost like an area that devolution has forgotten. We hear about the importance of roads; we heard about that from the previous witnesses, so it does appear a bit odd that there is not much there. One thing is that currently there is a duty, whether you are a local highway authority—county councils and so on—or the strategic highways authority, which is National Highways at the moment, to co-operate, but this Bill will create a new type of private highway authority and it will not join up. Some of the schemes that have seen funding withdrawn in road investment strategy 3 are very close to urban areas, and if they were funded via this route, that would not be an integrated approach and would be very different from what we are hearing about for the railways, where the Government have talked about the need for a single guiding mind.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Q On that theme, do you have any concerns that the financing arrangements proposed in the Bill and its general intentions could affect the balance of investment between strategic roads and local transport networks?

Ralph Smyth: Very much so. There is the issue of crowding out. If there is certainty that there is going to be a road scheme, that makes it harder for a mayor or someone else to promote an alternative, such as a tram or a rail or bus upgrade. After this meeting, I am taking part in the mass transit taskforce, where perhaps those issues will come up.

Oral Answers to Questions

Debate between Justin Madders and Olly Glover
Thursday 29th October 2026

(3 weeks ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lindsay Hoyle Portrait Mr Speaker
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.

Olly Glover Portrait Olly Glover (Didcot and Wantage) (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I join you, Mr Speaker, in paying tribute to both Sue Holt and Mr Goldsmith.

There is growing interest in the issue of illegally modified e-bikes and their use, as is shown by comments in this House and in a Westminster Hall debate last week and by our new policy passed at last month’s Liberal Democrat conference. We need to ensure that e-bikes support, rather than hinder, the growth of active travel. The Minister has talked about the cross-Government working group, but will he commit to creating an action plan based on that work to tackle the issue, with clear timescales and owners? If he did, he would have our support.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- View Speech - Hansard - -

I can assure the Liberal Democrat spokesperson that there is already an action plan. We have identified a number of issues, building on some of the work and recommendations of the all-party parliamentary group for cycling and walking, and those will be fed into the cross-departmental working group. The Government hear what the hon. Member and, indeed, all hon. Members are saying about this issue: we need to make our roads safe. We need to get this plague of illegal e-bikes sorted out once and for all, and this Government are determined to do that.