(1 week ago)
Public Bill CommitteesWe have a bit of a mega grouping here, so I will try to take the Committee through it slowly and carefully.
I will briefly talk about the provisions generally before I get into the detail. The provisions relate to the enforcement and non-payment of tolls. Government amendments 6 to 10 and clause 27 clarify the framework for unpaid tolls and penalty charges, including responsibility for notification and enforcement. Government amendments 11 to 13 and clause 28 strengthen the offences of deliberate evasion and unauthorised removal of penalty notices while protecting users from unauthorised toll collection. New clause 1 extends the framework to additional tolling-related penalty charges, with safeguards for notification and offences for fraudulent evasion.
Amendments 10, 8, 7 and 6 are fundamentally procedural. They reassign the regulation-making power for notification and enforcement from the Secretary of State to the Lord Chancellor. That is in line with standard practice and represents the appropriate designation of authority. Amendment 9 requires that regulations relating to the imposition of a penalty charge for non-payment of a toll must specify whether the penalty charge is intended to displace the toll due or is in addition to it. That will add clarity to the regime and avoid uncertainty for users.
Clause 27, as it will be amended, allows the Secretary of State to make regulations about penalty charges where a toll is not paid and for the Lord Chancellor to make regulations about the notification and enforcement of that penalty charge. Those regulations may allow the licence holder to issue penalty charges and set out how the penalty system will operate. That may include who must pay the penalty, how they will be notified, when and how payment must be made, and how unpaid penalties may be enforced.
The regulations may set the penalty rates directly or allow the ORR to set them within the framework established by the regulations. Different penalty rates may be set for different circumstances. The arrangements may also include reduced amounts for prompt payment, increased amounts for late payment and administration fees. If the Secretary of State proposes to set the penalty rates in the regulations, they must consult the ORR first.
Dr Peter Prinsley (Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket) (Lab)
Last night, we heard from the chief executive of Royal Mail about the terrible problems of huge delays in mail being delivered. It is sometimes the case that people are unable to pay a fine without incurring the additional fine for late payment because of the failure of Royal Mail to deliver the penalty charge in an appropriate time. What provision could be made to cope with that particular problem, which seems to be widespread in the country?
We will come to that issue later in the Bill, so if my hon. Friend bears with me, I will address it then. In summary, clause 27 provides a clear framework for dealing with unpaid tolls, while ensuring that the detailed rules and penalty rates are set through regulations or by the ORR within that regulatory framework.
Amendments 11 and 12 extend the scope of the offences under clause 28(3) to cases where a person seeks to avoid payment of a penalty charge for non-payment of a toll, as well as to those seeking to avoid payment of the toll itself. It is plain to me that those offences, principally for fraudulently seeking to avoid payment, should apply equally in relation to a penalty charge as to a toll.
Amendment 13 creates a new offence within clause 28 for the unlawful removal of a penalty charge. This is standard in relation to the issuance of penalty charges and is principally there to discourage anyone other than the person for whom the charge is intended from removing the notice from the vehicle. That ensures that the intended recipient gets proper notice.
Clause 28, as it will be amended, deals with deliberate attempts to avoid paying tolls, as well as the unauthorised charging of tolls. It makes it an offence to deliberately interfere with tolling equipment or obscure a vehicle registration plate to avoid paying a toll or being identified for non-payment. It is also an offence to deliberately use false information or documents to seek to avoid payment of a toll or a penalty charge. Those offences can result in an unlimited fine, imprisonment or both.
The clause also sets out that it is an offence for anyone not authorised to do so to remove a notification of a penalty charge from a vehicle. That can attract a fine of up to £500. The clause also protects road users by making it an offence to charge or collect tolls without complying with the Bill’s requirements, or without being authorised to do so. That can attract a fine of up to £1,000. A person carrying out tolling functions on behalf of the licence holder under clause 31 is not caught by that restriction. Clause 28 therefore provides sanctions against deliberate toll and penalty charge evasion, while also protecting road users from unauthorised toll collection.
Government new clause 1 gives regulation-making powers to the Secretary of State and the Lord Chancellor to make regulations about the imposition and enforcement of penalty charges related to a specified list of additional matters related to tolling. The list includes matters such as the release of a vehicle from an immobilisation device and, where certain equipment or documentation is required as part of a tolling scheme, a failure to carry them. Those are charges that the holder of a licence could conceivably need to levy, but they would be conferred only as needed. As is the case for penalty charges related to non-payment of tolls, the clause would allow for the rates to be set either by the Secretary of State or by the Office of Rail and Road as the independent regulator.
As with the other penalty charges in the Bill, the new clause includes two offences. First, it is an offence to make false representations, including by using a false document, with intent to avoid paying a penalty charge or being identified as having failed to pay one. On summary conviction, that carries imprisonment up to the maximum term for summary offences, a fine or both. Mere non-payment is not itself the offence; an unpaid charge is recoverable as a civil debt.
Secondly, it is an offence to remove a penalty charge notice fixed to a vehicle unless the person is its registered keeper, is using it with the keeper’s authority, or acts with the authority of either such person or the licence holder. That protects proper notification while allowing authorised removal. On summary conviction, the offence carries a fine not exceeding level 2 on the standard scale. I commend these provisions to the Committee, and will respond to the shadow Minister’s amendments in closing.
(1 month ago)
Commons ChamberThe bottom line is that the previous Government committed to far more schemes than there was funding for, so we had to evaluate which were the least value for money and the least advanced. It is nothing more than that. The right hon. Member may be frustrated, but perhaps the previous Government should not have made promises that could not be delivered.
Demand will only go in one direction. Road vehicle mileage is set to rise on the strategic road network by 12% over the nine years to 2035. Climate change continues to bare its teeth across our transport infrastructure, and our strategic roads are no exception. All those challenges bear down on a network that holds up our economy every day. That is why I am proud that the Government published the third road investment strategy earlier this year. It committed not only £27 billion to future-proofing our roads, and to resurfacing a quarter of our entire network, but to three major enhancement schemes in the north of England, on which it will work even closer with local leaders. It proved to MPs like me that road investment can address regional inequalities, and is compatible with our promise of greater devolution. When we talk about growth and power in every postcode, that is exactly what we mean.
That is the context in which I present the Bill. I have mentioned what we have already delivered, but in truth, much more needs to be done. Delivering the roads this country needs to connect our ports, our major cities and our communities requires substantial investment over many years, and across several Parliaments. Public investment will, of course, continue to play a vital role, but we can go further when private investment is harnessed to meet public goals. When Government and the private sector come together in partnership, and when we balance certainty for private investors with safeguards for the public interest, we give ourselves more tools to build the modern infrastructure that Britain needs. The Bill creates such a tool, and does so in two ways.
Dr Peter Prinsley (Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket) (Lab)
I welcome the measures in the Bill to invest in our road system, but will the Minister comment on the technological advances to vehicles over the next decades? Most vehicles will eventually become self-driving. That will mean much less congestion, and vehicles will communicate with each other, so there will be much simpler junctions and fewer accidents. What account are the Government taking of the technical changes to vehicles?
We are working on projections and what we know about the road network now, and overcapacity at Dartford in particular needs to be addressed. On whether automated vehicles reduce congestion, we need to see what happens in practice.
The regulated asset base model will be applied to trunk roads in England. That model is not new—it was used to fund the Thames tideway tunnel and Sizewell C—but this is the first time it will be used on a road network. For our roads, it starts by granting a licence for a specific highway project to a private investor. The framework for that licence is set in this Parliament. The framework starts with construction and goes through to operation and maintenance. Any infrastructure project under this model will therefore start as it should, with a sound legal and regulatory foundation.
The Office of Rail and Road will then act as the independent economic regulator. It will have a wide range of powers in the public interest, including monitoring performance, obtaining information, issuing penalties and, if necessary, taking enforcement action and revoking a licence. These public interest safeguards are vital and will never be compromised. There can also be no disparity between the operation of a privately funded highway and one managed by National Highways, so I can assure the House that the Bill means that roads operated under the new licensing regime can be held to the same standards as the rest of the strategic road network. Even when difficulties arise, the framework ensures that road users are protected and there is continuity of service on the network.
Finally, the Bill allows a private operator to make a regulated return on their investment. Any charges or tolls will be levied under strict conditions set out by the Office of Rail and Road, which will be required to consider the interests of road users. Let me be crystal clear: the Bill is not and will never be national road pricing by the back door, and it is not and will never be a way to charge motorists across the wider network. The provisions in the Bill apply only to roads brought in under the financial and legal framework that we are debating today.
Let me be clear: that framework is not open ended. Licences may only be issued for new road projects, capacity enhancing improvements or the continued operation of a previously licensed road, and any road specified in a licence must be a trunk road in England. This is about strategically important routes, not minor improvements to the road network. Government policy is that tolling will normally be used only for costly river and estuarial crossings, and nothing in the Bill is set to change that.
I will now turn to the second major feature of the Bill. Some of the legislation governing toll collection dates back to the 18th century. It is high time that was updated, so that we can unleash the benefits of modern technology on our roads. Many of us have at some point experienced long queues at toll booths. It adds unnecessary delay to journeys, and drivers will rightly wonder when regulations will catch up with technology. Free-flowing tolling systems do not require vehicles to stop at traditional booths, and by allowing payment after use, they ease congestion and shorten journey times. The Bill does not mandate a certain approach to toll collection, but simply allows new technologies to be adopted and creates a modern statutory framework for enforcement practices. I have little doubt that drivers will welcome measures that can remove friction from their journeys.
It is no secret that our desire to push forward with this legislation stems from the lower Thames crossing. That crossing will almost double road capacity across the Thames to the east of London. It will improve journey times and it will tackle chronic congestion at Dartford, which is bursting at the seams. Its 2.6-mile dual tunnels under the Thames will be the longest road tunnels in the country, and the largest in Europe by diameter, and it will set the standard for carbon-neutral construction. In short, it is exactly the sort of ambitious and world-leading infrastructure project that Britain should be building.
We have been clear that the regulated asset base model is our preferred financial approach for the lower Thames crossing, but the Bill is not about the lower Thames crossing’s design, nor does it grant development consent. That work has already been done. It simply creates the financial framework that can deliver the lower Thames crossing, as well as appropriate future road projects.
I finish by reminding colleagues what lies at the heart of the Bill: recognition that too many people, in too many places, remain held back by poor connectivity, and a recognition that each congested road and every delayed journey stifle productivity. The Bill does not ask the House to choose between public and private finance as a matter of ideology, but it puts another tool at our disposal for delivering the infrastructure that Britain needs. This financial model will not be used in every case, but it does set out one practical approach, guided by a financial framework set by Government. There will be a compliance regime enforced by an independent regulator. Private capital is provided by investors, and public safeguards are protected at every stage. That is the balanced model that this Bill will deliver, and I commend it to the House.