To match an exact phrase, use quotation marks around the search term. eg. "Parliamentary Estate". Use "OR" or "AND" as link words to form more complex queries.


Keep yourself up-to-date with the latest developments by exploring our subscription options to receive notifications direct to your inbox

Written Question
NHS: Negligence
Monday 16th November 2015

Asked by: Karl Turner (Labour - Kingston upon Hull East)

Question to the Department of Health and Social Care:

To ask the Secretary of State for Health, what assessment he has made of the effect of claims management companies on the number of unmeritorious claims brought forward in clinical negligence cases.

Answered by Ben Gummer

The Department is working closely with stakeholders to develop the proposal to introduce fixed recoverable costs. We have undertaken a pre-consultation exercise with a number of key stakeholders, including representatives of claimant lawyers, and are planning an open public consultation shortly. We welcome views on the proposal from all sectors.

The consultation documentation, including the Impact Assessment, will be published in early 2016 subject to relevant Committee clearances. We are working upon the assumption that there is nothing about Fixed Recoverable Costs regime which will alter the percentage of unmeritorious claims.

Any scheme proposed will include consideration of the right incentives to support a fairer and quicker process that provides the improvements to the system whilst maintaining access to justice.


The NHS Litigation Authority reported in their annual report for 2014/15 that it resolves over 4,000 clinical negligence cases annually for no payment of damages and in 2014/15 it saved over £1.2 billion for the National Health Service in rejecting claims which had no merit.





Written Question
NHS: Negligence
Monday 16th November 2015

Asked by: Karl Turner (Labour - Kingston upon Hull East)

Question to the Department of Health and Social Care:

To ask the Secretary of State for Health, what assessment he has made of the effect of introducing a fixed recoverable cost regime in clinical negligence cases on the number of claims brought by claims management companies and litigants in person.

Answered by Ben Gummer

The Department is working closely with stakeholders to develop the proposal to introduce fixed recoverable costs. We have undertaken a pre-consultation exercise with a number of key stakeholders, including representatives of claimant lawyers, and are planning an open public consultation shortly. We welcome views on the proposal from all sectors.

The consultation documentation, including the Impact Assessment, will be published in early 2016 subject to relevant Committee clearances. We are working upon the assumption that there is nothing about Fixed Recoverable Costs regime which will alter the percentage of unmeritorious claims.

Any scheme proposed will include consideration of the right incentives to support a fairer and quicker process that provides the improvements to the system whilst maintaining access to justice.


The NHS Litigation Authority reported in their annual report for 2014/15 that it resolves over 4,000 clinical negligence cases annually for no payment of damages and in 2014/15 it saved over £1.2 billion for the National Health Service in rejecting claims which had no merit.





Written Question
NHS: Negligence
Monday 16th November 2015

Asked by: Karl Turner (Labour - Kingston upon Hull East)

Question to the Department of Health and Social Care:

To ask the Secretary of State for Health, what estimate he has made of the costs to his Department associated with unmeritorious claims resulting from changes to a fixed cost recoverable scheme for clinical negligence.

Answered by Ben Gummer

The Department is working closely with stakeholders to develop the proposal to introduce fixed recoverable costs. We have undertaken a pre-consultation exercise with a number of key stakeholders, including representatives of claimant lawyers, and are planning an open public consultation shortly. We welcome views on the proposal from all sectors.

The consultation documentation, including the Impact Assessment, will be published in early 2016 subject to relevant Committee clearances. We are working upon the assumption that there is nothing about Fixed Recoverable Costs regime which will alter the percentage of unmeritorious claims.

Any scheme proposed will include consideration of the right incentives to support a fairer and quicker process that provides the improvements to the system whilst maintaining access to justice.


The NHS Litigation Authority reported in their annual report for 2014/15 that it resolves over 4,000 clinical negligence cases annually for no payment of damages and in 2014/15 it saved over £1.2 billion for the National Health Service in rejecting claims which had no merit.





Written Question
NHS: Negligence
Monday 16th November 2015

Asked by: Karl Turner (Labour - Kingston upon Hull East)

Question to the Department of Health and Social Care:

To ask the Secretary of State for Health, what assessment he has made of the propriety of his Department overseeing the consultation on a fixed recoverable cost regime in clinical negligence cases when it is the defendant in most such cases.

Answered by Ben Gummer

The Department is working closely with stakeholders to develop the proposal to introduce fixed recoverable costs. We have undertaken a pre-consultation exercise with a number of key stakeholders, including representatives of claimant lawyers, and are planning an open public consultation shortly. We welcome views on the proposal from all sectors.

The consultation documentation, including the Impact Assessment, will be published in early 2016 subject to relevant Committee clearances. We are working upon the assumption that there is nothing about Fixed Recoverable Costs regime which will alter the percentage of unmeritorious claims.

Any scheme proposed will include consideration of the right incentives to support a fairer and quicker process that provides the improvements to the system whilst maintaining access to justice.


The NHS Litigation Authority reported in their annual report for 2014/15 that it resolves over 4,000 clinical negligence cases annually for no payment of damages and in 2014/15 it saved over £1.2 billion for the National Health Service in rejecting claims which had no merit.





Speech in Commons Chamber - Tue 24 Feb 2015
Oral Answers to Questions

"T2. A recent Ashcroft poll shows that only 15% of the public think that this Government have the best approach to running the NHS. Will the Secretary of State stand up at the Dispatch Box and apologise for his top-down reorganisation of the NHS and his Tory privatising Health and …..."
Karl Turner - View Speech

View all Karl Turner (Lab - Kingston upon Hull East) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions

Speech in Commons Chamber - Mon 01 Dec 2014
NHS (Five Year Forward View)

"Up until her retirement, my mother was a very proud and committed nurse in the NHS. The Secretary of State wears a lapel badge pretending his love for the NHS. Today, my mother asked why, if the Secretary of State had £700 million in his Department, could he not have …..."
Karl Turner - View Speech

View all Karl Turner (Lab - Kingston upon Hull East) contributions to the debate on: NHS (Five Year Forward View)

Speech in Commons Chamber - Tue 21 Oct 2014
Oral Answers to Questions

"8. How many patients waited longer than four hours in A and E departments in 2013-14...."
Karl Turner - View Speech

View all Karl Turner (Lab - Kingston upon Hull East) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions

Speech in Commons Chamber - Tue 21 Oct 2014
Oral Answers to Questions

"Data published last Friday show that A and Es have missed their waiting targets for 64 weeks on the bounce. They are in a worse state now than they were last winter. What is going on?..."
Karl Turner - View Speech

View all Karl Turner (Lab - Kingston upon Hull East) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions

Speech in Commons Chamber - Tue 26 Nov 2013
Oral Answers to Questions

"15. How many NHS walk-in centres have (a) closed and (b) restricted their opening hours since May 2010...."
Karl Turner - View Speech

View all Karl Turner (Lab - Kingston upon Hull East) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions

Speech in Commons Chamber - Tue 26 Nov 2013
Oral Answers to Questions

"Official NHS figures show that attendances at accident and emergency departments have increased more than three times faster under the Tory-led Government than under the Labour Government. Does the Minister regret allowing so many walk-in centres to close?..."
Karl Turner - View Speech

View all Karl Turner (Lab - Kingston upon Hull East) contributions to the debate on: Oral Answers to Questions