(2 days, 1 hour ago)
Public Bill CommitteesThe Bill rightly puts a legal duty on responsible entities to remediate, yet it establishes no fixed timescale for that. Instead, the Bill relies on the basis that the work must be completed “as soon as reasonably practicable” with the detail left to future regulations. That is despite the fact that the failure to meet deadlines and properly remediate can mean up to two years in prison or a financial penalty of £500,000. That is a serious weight on the mind of responsible people left waiting for further details.
With such heavy penalties, we believe that those responsible for remediation must be afforded clarity on what the law expects of them. If the work cannot be done, because there is no assessor or contractors or materials to be found, thanks to the recognised shortage, it would be wrong to treat an owner who has done everything they can to solve the issues the same as someone who has dithered and delayed.
That is why we have tabled amendment 26, which seeks to make it clear that “as soon as reasonably practicable” must be seen in the context of whether it was possible to obtain the necessary assessors, contractors and materials. We must have assurances from the Minister about how the constrained supply of trained officials will be treated in guidance and how owners will be expected to show they did all they reasonably could. I hope the Minister and other hon. Members will support amendment 26.
Turning to amendment 27—
I have just moved on, I am afraid. My apologies.
On amendment 27, as we have already discussed, materials, contractors and assessors are finite and supply is short. While every potentially dangerous building, no matter its scale or complexity, needs remediation to be considered urgent, we must ensure that can happen as efficiently as possible. The amendment would allow responsible entities to tackle remediation works in batches if that were more efficient and still satisfy the duty. A responsible entity that can procure once, plan across several sites and sequence works sensibly will deliver remediation at a swifter pace and a lower cost than an entity forced to treat every case in isolation. Moreover, those savings are directly beneficial to taxpayers and to leaseholders.
The phased approach allows for a targeted approach: in allowing a responsible entity to group and phase the works, the most vulnerable residents in the most affected buildings can benefit first rather than finding themselves further down the paperwork pile. None of this serves to dilute the responsibility to remediate, only to make it more efficient, more effective and more accelerated.
On amendment 34, one of the core issues with the cladding crisis is fairness. How can it be right that someone who works hard to afford their mortgage or rent their home is left to find out, once they have purchased it, invested in it or paid, that it is in fact an unsafe dwelling rather than a place to call their sanctuary? It is egregiously unfair and that is why we must ensure remediation work is completed at a much greater pace—I know that is what the Government are seeking to achieve. For that to work, we must also ensure that the process for responsible entities is fair. That means ensuring that such entities are not subject to punishment for the tardiness of others.
Amendment 34 would clarify that where an individual is named in a remediation compliance plan, that does not in itself make them liable for delays outside their control. We need to work with those responsible for accelerating remediation to make it as swift as possible, not punish entities genuinely trying to make right what is wrong when the Government or another organisation is hindering them with uncontrollable delays.
I turn to amendment 41. The provisions in clause 33 have vast legal repercussions. At present, the guidance that courts, responsible entities and residents may rely on in a court of law is set to be decided without democratic approval or parliamentary scrutiny. We believe that this is wrong.
Such high-stakes guidance, with severe legal, financial and reputational consequences attached to it, needs to be judged in Parliament before it can be judged in a courtroom. Amendment 41 would require Parliament to approve the guidance relating to the duties to mitigate, remediate and prepare a remediation plan before such guidance can be relied on in proceedings.
The amendment upholds one simple and unarguable principle: that any guidance that carries the weight in a courtroom is acting as law, and law should be decided in this place. Moreover, the amendment would also ensure that property owners, responsible entities, leaseholders, residents and contractors have clear and well-judged rules in front of them before millions of pounds are committed to remediation works.
By putting the rules to Parliament, we also create a consistent set of rules rather than guidance that the Secretary of State can amend unilaterally. We believe that this is a common-sense amendment. We hope that the Minister and hon. Members will support it.
(2 days, 1 hour ago)
Public Bill CommitteesI rise to speak to my new clause 4. In any sound legal practice, it is not the job of the investigator or the prosecution to decide on the sentence for the offence that they have been investigating. As currently drafted, however, the Bill fails to uphold that principle. It is wrong for an individual to face an arm of the state, with its legal teams, insurance, army of civil servants and statutory immunity. That is especially true when the individual has to contend with the joint weight of being up against an opponent that is a regulator, prosecutor and judge—all in one.
By contrast, a tribunal offers a fairer but equally robust alternative. It is independent, led by a judge who is independent and experienced in the field. It acts as a proper court should, hearing evidence from both sides, and makes judgment after hearing evidence, rather than waiting for evidence at a later appeal. New clause 4 would make enforcement fairer, clearer and sounder. It would do nothing to weaken it, and everything to make it better. When the time comes, I hope that the Minister and hon. Members will agree.
Noah Law (St Austell and Newquay) (Lab)
The severity of the penalties aside, I wonder whether new clause 4 would introduce additional delays to the process of ensuring that the penalties are imposed and that justice is served.
That is not the intention of the new clause at all. It is very much about the last part of what the hon. Member just said, which is ensuring that justice is served. Our central contention is that having the same person act as judge, jury and prosecutor will not secure justice. It will speed the situation up, but democracy needs to be done properly, and we think that a first-tier tribunal would be the appropriate place to do it.
I congratulate the Minister on a marathon performance. We will not oppose clause 34 or the vast majority of schedule 1. However, I will speak to amendment 45, which was tabled in my name.
At present, “connected person” is too broad a term for us to leave such entities without remedy to misplaced or excessive liability. The costs notices we are discussing in schedule 1 can impose millions of pounds in remediation liability, so it is only fair that such financial penalties can be met with judicial checks and balances. That is why I have tabled the amendment, which would allow connected persons a full right of appeal on costs notices.
That is a matter of fair and consistent legal discipline. Decisions must be able to withstand scrutiny on an error of law, irrationality and disproportionality. Otherwise, the decision lacks the effective scrutiny it deserves. Such scrutiny also encourages best legal practice on the part of authorities pursuing notices in the first place, creating a smoother system and encouraging best practice. I therefore hope that the Minister will—
The hon. Member has done it for a third time. Of course I will give way.
We do not believe so, which is why we tabled the amendment. However, I thank the hon. Member, because this is the third time he has intervened when I had literally one word left in my script—it is becoming a regular thing. With that, I commend the amendment.