Highways (Financing) Bill (Eighth sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Tuesday 17th November 2026

(2 days, 1 hour ago)

Public Bill Committees
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful to the shadow Minister for raising this issue once again. He is clearly very exercised by the issue, but I refer the Committee to the actual evidence we heard from the chief executive of the project on the lower Thames crossing. There were various references to this not having any impact on the overall cost.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I apologise if I am about to ask a question that the Minister was on the verge of answering, but my understanding from the evidence session was that we heard the lower Thames crossing had not considered any other fuel. I therefore do not think that is completely accurate.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am about to address the hon. Lady’s point. Let me explain exactly what happened. The construction carbon limit for the lower Thames crossing and the carbon-neutral requirement were included in the development consent order, which I think the shadow Minister is now saying is “pure madness”. He is again traducing his own party’s reputation in government. That is fine—he is entitled to do that, and it saves us a job.

The order did not specify any particular type of fuel. The evidence we heard from Matt Palmer, the chief executive of the lower Thames crossing, is that about two thirds of contractors were coming forward with HVO as their proposal, rather than saying, “We’re mandated to procure a particular type of fuel.” That is what the market was delivering, and those requirements are there to ensure that the lower Thames crossing is consistent with national carbon budgeting during the construction period.

Across the project’s three delivery partners, carbon formed part of the tender evaluation criteria, and tenders were required to meet or exceed a carbon reduction target. The successful delivery partners met or exceeded that requirement without increasing overall construction costs. The tenderers that submitted the lowest-cost bids also had the lowest carbon from construction. As I say, National Highways did not prescribe individual technologies or fuels that delivery partners should use, which is effectively what the new clause would do.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Seventh sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I never doubted the shadow Minister for a minute, but he is obviously future-proofing himself by seeking to amend the legislation. The shadow Minister spoke as if what we are proposing—that liability should sit with the vehicle keeper—is an entirely novel concept. Of course, that is already the existing provision for tolls, and it is important because the keeper record is the official information about who is responsible for a vehicle. That does not prevent other people from paying a toll or a penalty charge remotely, which is important, but it is even more important that liability remains with the person legally responsible for the vehicle, unless there are very clear reasons to take a different approach.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I think we are in danger of violently agreeing with each other. The point that my hon. Friend the Member for Mid Buckinghamshire is trying to make is purely about making sure that the wording in the Bill reflects the intent.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

The intent is clear that the liability would remain with the vehicle owner. I take the point that a number of hire and lease companies will technically be the owner, but they already have provisions in their agreements with hirers and lessees to recover penalty charges with appropriate administration fees. I also take the shadow Minister’s point that we do not want those fees to be disproportionate or exploitative, and there is plenty of regulation already in place to protect consumers in those situations.

The amendment would create unreasonable risks by forcibly transferring liability to people whom toll operators could not identify without the co-operation of hire and lease companies. It is unnecessary, because the systems in place can already accommodate the handling of tolls and penalty charges under these circumstances. In my view, the flexibility and balance we have at the moment is right. I therefore invite the shadow Minister not to press the amendment.

Question put and agreed to.

Clause 87 accordingly ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 88

Penalty charges

Amendments made: 20, in clause 88, page 60, line 21, leave out from “fees)” to end of line 23.

See the explanatory statement for amendment 21.

Amendment 89: in clause 88, page 60, line 29, at end insert—

“(4) Collection and enforcement regulations may make provision as to the effect the imposition or payment of a penalty charge has in relation to any liability to conviction for an offence of refusing or failing to pay, or attempting to evade payment of, the toll.”—(Justin Madders.)

This amendment would allow collection and enforcement regulations to provide for imposition or payment of a fixed penalty to replace or discharge liability for criminal offences of non-payment, such as that in section 15(1) of the New Roads and Street Works Act 1991.

Clause 88, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 89

Offences relating to tolls and penalty charges

Question proposed, That the clause stand part of the Bill.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I hear what the shadow Minister is saying. If his party, while in government, had used the word “must” instead of “may” in the countless pieces of legislation that they passed in those 14 years, his argument might have more strength. If they had removed the word “may” from the Transport Act 2000, which is effectively the equivalent and the template that we are using, and replaced it with “must”, I might have accepted that he had an argument. Of course, there is a clear intention for us to create regulation; I can give that commitment today. Having the standard wording that we have used in previous legislation, which the previous Government did not change, indicates that this argument is not a serious one.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Will the Minister give way on that point?

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

Sorry; I have finished.

Question put and agreed to.

Clause 95 accordingly ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 96

Disputes, appeals and evidence

Amendment made: 21, in clause 96, page 64, line 19, at end insert—

“(A1) The Lord Chancellor may by regulations make provision for and in connection with the notification and enforcement of penalty charges.”—(Justin Madders.)

This amendment, together with amendment 20, means that the power to make regulations in connection with notification and enforcement of penalty charges provided for by collection and enforcement regulations under clause 87 is exercisable by the Lord Chancellor.

Clause 96, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 97 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

New Clause 1

Other penalty charges

“(1) The Secretary of State may by regulations make provision—

(a) conferring powers on the holder of a licence for or in connection with the imposition of penalty charges in relation to a matter specified in subsection (2);

(b) for or in connection with the rates of penalty charges imposed in accordance with provision within paragraph (a);

(c) about the timing and method of payment of such a penalty charge;

(d) about the person by whom such a penalty charge must be paid;

(e) about the collection or provision of information and evidence in connection with the imposition of such a penalty charge.

(2) The matters referred to in subsection (1)(a) are—

(a) a failure to display a document, or carry or fit equipment, in accordance with a requirement imposed under section 24(3);

(b) the release of a road vehicle from an immobilisation device fitted in accordance with regulations under section 30(1);

(c) the removal and storage of a road vehicle in accordance with regulations under section 30(1);

(d) the release of a road vehicle from storage in accordance with regulations under section 30(1);

(e) the destruction of a road vehicle in accordance with regulations under section 30(1).

(3) Section 27(4) to (6) (provision about rates of penalty charge) applies to provision within subsection (1)(b) as it applies to regulations within section 27(2)(b).

(4) Regulations under subsection (1) which make provision for the imposition of a penalty charge must specify whether the charge is payable in addition to the toll in respect of which the charge is payable or instead of it.

(5) The Lord Chancellor may make regulations about the notification and enforcement of penalty charges imposed in accordance with provision within subsection (1)(a).

(6) If a person does not pay the whole or any part of a penalty charge imposed on the person in accordance with provision within subsection (1)(a) by the time specified for payment, the penalty charge or unpaid part is recoverable by the holder of the licence as a civil debt due to it.

(7) A person commits an offence if the person makes false representations (whether by using a false document or otherwise) with intent—

(a) to avoid payment of a penalty charge imposed in accordance with provision within subsection (1)(a), or

(b) to avoid being identified as having failed to pay such a penalty charge.

(8) A person who commits an offence under subsection (7) is liable on summary conviction to either or both of the following—

(a) imprisonment for a term not exceeding the maximum term for summary offences;

(b) a fine.

(9) A person commits an offence if the person removes a notice of a penalty charge which has been fixed to a road vehicle in accordance with regulations under subsection (5) unless—

(a) the person is the registered keeper of the vehicle or a person using the vehicle with the registered keeper’s authority, or

(b) the person does so under the authority of the registered keeper or such a person or of the holder of a licence.

(10) A person who commits an offence under subsection (9) is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 2 on the standard scale.”—(Justin Madders.)

This new clause, which would be inserted after clause 30, provides for the imposition of penalty charges in respect of matters other than non-payment of tolls. It also provides for offences in relation to non-payment of such penalty charges.

Brought up, read the First and Second time, and added to the Bill.

New Clause 3

Airport operators and surface access obligations

“(1) Where the ORR designates a licence holder under this Act who controls access to an airport, the licence holder may not use road user charging under the licence as part of the airport’s strategy to meet its surface access obligations.

(2) For the purposes of this section, ‘surface access obligations’ means any requirement or target to reduce journeys to or from an airport by private car, taxi, or private hire vehicle, or increase the use of alternative transport.”—(Greg Smith.)

This new clause would prevent road user charging by licence holders to enable airports to meet their surface access obligations.

Brought up, and read the First time.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Fifth sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful to the shadow Minister for reminding us all of Denis Norden and “It’ll be Alright on the Night”. I am not sure I can give him that level of wisdom today, but I will attempt to answer his questions.

The shadow Minister has of course correctly predicted that we will not be accepting the amendment. I hope he is going to give us the lottery numbers for Saturday night as well—his powers of prediction are very strong; he may even anticipate what I am going to say. The amendment would force the ORR to publish a tolling code in the abstract before the Act has commenced and therefore before the licensing authority could actually consult on the licence, which is required under clause 4 of the Bill. That could slow down or delay the delivery of the lower Thames crossing.

The tolling code will set out the principles and constraints that the licence holder must follow when proposing, setting and implementing tolls.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths (Bognor Regis and Littlehampton) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Minister is describing the process he wishes to take place. My hon. Friend the Member for Mid Buckinghamshire made an important point about principles. Surely the Minister and the Government know the principles they wish to deploy in the collection of tolls. That should be something he can explain here today.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

If the hon. Lady shows a little patience, I shall hopefully do that for her. The important thing in terms of the Government principles is the guidance from the Secretary of State. That guidance will specify to the ORR the various parameters, and the ORR must have due regard to that guidance. It is clear, from what I have said, that we intend to include something on local discounts in the guidance. Ultimately, we would want that to be reflected in the tolling code published by the ORR. Of course, the ORR is independent and therefore the exact content of the code will be up to it.

As I was saying, the tolling code will set out the principles. It will include requirements around how the tolling regime is structured. It will also cover how final charges are published and communicated to users, alongside governance arrangements, including consultation. As I have said, in making its code, the ORR will have due regard to guidance set by the Department and the Secretary of State. The details of the code are ultimately up to the ORR, and it is necessarily dependent on any guidance provided by the Government and the specific arrangements set out in the licence.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Fourth sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful for the intervention, but I am not suggesting that at all. I am suggesting that it is important that we keep the Bill technology-neutral because we do not know what might happen further down the line.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I think it is quite interesting that, in an age of acute cyber-security risks, the Minister considers this a technology-neutral position. We have an analogue system that works very effectively and systems that could be controlled by the Government rather than the licensee, which would ensure appropriate cyber-security. The position that the Minister is suggesting is technology-neutral is actually the reverse: it exposes us to acute cyber-risk over which we will have very little control.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful to the hon. Lady, but I would say that she is making my case for me: we need to keep up with important changes and risk in the cyber-security world. That is why keeping the Bill as technology-neutral as possible is important, because we simply do not know what will be coming next. Giving operators the flexibility to be able to determine what technology is used is an important part of cyber-security moving forward.

Amendment 53 would insert specific consultation requirements into the Bill before a toll can be set. I agree that local communities and those who use the tolls should have a voice. The question is not whether they should have a voice, but how best to secure that engagement within the Bill’s framework of independent regulation. As it stands, the framework places responsibility with the regulator to set tolling requirements through its code and licence conditions, and to enforce compliance. Consultation requirements should sit within those arrangements, rather than be prescriptive in the Bill.

In exercising its functions, the ORR must have regard to the principles of transparency, accountability, proportionality and consistency, and keep the interests of users at the heart of its decision making. That is an important safeguard in the Bill, and I hope that it addresses some of the shadow Minister’s concerns. He will know that the Bill establishes a stakeholder group that will directly advise the ORR. Again, I hope that will address the point about the voices of users being heard in this process. I do not believe that the amendment would improve engagement. Instead, it would constrain the regulator’s discretion to determine how best to take forward individual users’ voices, so I ask the Member not to press it.

Highways (Financing) Bill (Third sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Tuesday 3rd November 2026

(2 weeks, 2 days ago)

Public Bill Committees
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful for the shadow Minister’s question. The Bill’s purpose is to give the ORR the powers and ultimately the responsibility to regulate this model. It will be able to levy the licence holder to finance that particular work. A great deal of preparatory work is already going on to ensure that the ORR is capable of delivering the important functions set out under the Bill.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Minister just made the point that the ORR is not yet capable of delivering this. What is the plan from the Secretary of State and the Minister to deliver an ORR that has that capability? We also heard in evidence last week that the ORR does not believe that it is ready for it either.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful for the hon. Lady’s question. There is a plan in place, but it would be a bit ridiculous for us to have everyone ready now when the legislation has not been passed. I assure her that a number of considerations are already taking place about having the right skills. We heard evidence last week that there is confidence that the right skillsets and people will be in place to provide the important functions that the ORR will have to deliver under the legislation.

Clause 2 sets out the overarching duty that will guide the Secretary of State when exercising functions under the Bill. It mirrors the duty placed on the ORR in clause 1 and ensures that both key decision makers operate within a consistent statutory framework. As the Bill gives important functions to the Secretary of State and the ORR, it is therefore important that decisions made by each are guided by the same overarching objectives and principles.

The clause requires the Secretary of State, like the ORR, to act in a way that furthers the interests of road users. In doing so, the Secretary of State must balance a range of important considerations, including efficiency, safety, sustainability and the impact of decisions on the wider strategic road network. These duties are underpinned by established principles of good regulation, helping to ensure that decisions are transparent, accountable, proportionate and targeted only when action is needed. I therefore commend the clause to the Committee.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

That would be where clauses 1 and 2 come in, which should give the hon. Member sufficient reassurance. It is important to say—I will use scouse terminology, if you do not mind, Mr Dowd—that I think the arguments coming forward are a bit jarg. I do not know if that is a phrase the Committee is familiar with, but it is a bit of a scaring-the-horses moment—a bit of a ride on the ghost train. Unfortunately, that is what we have come to expect from the Opposition. They are trying to create a scare story where none exists. I have to be clear, as I was on Second Reading and in the evidence sessions, that improving an existing road does not mean that the road will automatically be brought into the regime or be subject to tolls.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Will the Minister give way?

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I will just finish.

Establishing and structuring a RAB arrangement comes with significant costs, so for small-scale improvements such as the setting up of a speed camera, it is just not going to be financially viable for anyone to consider it. In practice, it simply would not be justified, or work, in any way. We are clear from the evidence that we heard last week that the model will make sense only for projects of sufficient scale, where the benefits of bringing in long-term private investment justify those costs.

Members should be clear that I know that what I say on the record is relevant to the intention of the Bill, and that that will be something that any future court will take into account.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I will now give way to the hon. Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I will pass to my hon. Friend the shadow Minister.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

We are very clear that the clause is about the specified highway. It is about the trunk road. It is about the protections in clauses 1 and 2. I will simply push back that, if there was some secret plan to expand road tolls, there is already legislation in place that would allow us to do that. The New Roads and Street Works Act 1991, which was passed by the hon. Member’s party in Government, created the powers to introduce road tolling. If there was a secret plan to do that, we would not need to bring forward legislation. This is about setting up a new regulatory model to bring in investment for particular projects.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I refer back to the intervention that I was going to make earlier, which was about clarity. The Minister said several times that he was being very clear, but I would gently suggest that the legislation is not very clear. That is the point that several of us are making: we are in danger of passing legislation that may not deliver what is perhaps intended by the Minister at this stage. It is at a point where a future Government, perhaps not as benign as others, might abuse the wording of the legislation. We are really just looking to ask the Minister to be clear in the Bill, not just in his words.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful for the hon. Lady’s question and her description of “benign”, which I will frame and put on my wall at home.

The Bill is clear. There are reasons why we have to look at the existing network, particularly when we consider what is happening in the lower Thames crossing. The simple economics of this would not be attractive to investors if we were going to broadly open up road charging across the country—as I say, there is already legislation that would enable us to do that. The clause is about setting up a specific financial model, which will have strong regulation and will enable capacity-enhancing improvements to be made to the road network. As I say, it is very clear that there are sufficient protections already within the legislation to avoid the situation that Opposition Members are concerned about.

Turning to amendment 44, I thank the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage for raising the question of capacity-enhancing improvements. We will be clear that this framework is intended for major road infrastructure, not for minor changes to the road network. There are practical constraints on the use of this model. Again, as I have referred to, clauses 1 and 2 require the ORR to act in the “interests of users” of the highway specified in licences or proposed to be specified. Clause 2 requires the Secretary of State to act in the

“interests of users of trunk roads in England.”

Both have regard to the principle that regulatory action should be proportionate and targeted only where it is needed. I am not entirely sure that the amendment would deliver the changes that the hon. Gentleman proposes. I am concerned that, while he is talking about an extra lane, he has not put any de minimis length on that, which might give a future non-benign Government encouragement to take it further than is our intention.

We have to be clear that establishing and structuring a RAB arrangement carries substantial costs. It must be sufficiently large and economically viable for that financing approach to make sense. We heard evidence that the geography of this country is such that simply adding lanes on here and there is not a viable option. I therefore suggest that the hon. Gentleman not press his amendment to a Division.

The shadow Minister spoke to amendment 81. I hope I never have a call from him when he is feeling frustrated—I am not sure how that would go for either of us—but he made an important point about ensuring that local and mayoral authorities are notified where there may be a proposed scheme. It is of course the case that the Bill already ensures that the relevant authorities are consulted. As set out in clause 4, before any licence can be granted, the licensing authority must publish the proposal, which must also be shared with the relevant bodies, expressly including the strategic highways company and any other appropriate bodies exercising highway functions. At least 28 days must be allowed for representations from those bodies.

Different projects will affect different places and different authorities. Therefore, the right consultees will depend on the project. As we have seen in recent times, the structure of local government can change, so it would not make sense to hardwire into legislation that particular types of authority should be consulted, because that could become outdated.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

Of course the answer to that is that we cannot predict the future. In 2010, the idea of a mayoral combined authority was nothing more than a glint in George Osborne’s eye. It is about future-proofing the legislation: it does not make sense for us to come back at a later stage to add in extra consultees, because the Bill already has the correct powers to ensure that the licensing authority must consult appropriate bodies. That makes the framework flexible enough to respond both to the circumstances of individual projects and to changes in local government structures over the life of the legislation, which will be significant, because of the LTC project.

Clause 3 is at the heart of a lot of the debate today. The clause establishes what a licence is, what it can authorise and the circumstances in which one can be granted. The purpose of the licensing regime is to provide the framework through which private investment can support the delivery of strategic road infrastructure. In simple terms, clause 3 allows a licensing authority to grant a person a licence giving them the right to charge tolls on a highway specified in that licence. But that right is not freestanding; it is granted in return for the licence holder securing specified works to the highway.

The works fall into three main categories. A licence may support the construction of a highway; it may support the improvement of an existing highway, where the purpose is to increase its capacity; and, where a highway has already been constructed or improved under this licensing regime, it may provide for its maintenance, operation or further improvement. If another highway is specified in the licence, the licence may also authorise the licence holder to charge tolls in respect of that highway. That is an important point about the structure of the regime. Clause 3 is not simply a general power to allow private companies to charge motorists; the authority to charge tolls is tied directly to the licence holder securing the highway works specified in the licence. In addition, clause 3 does not allow the model to be applied indiscriminately across the road network.

We have heard the concern about the measure meaning a change to existing roads. A small improvement to an existing road, such as a smart motorway camera, does not automatically mean that that road will be brought into the regime or become subject to tolls. A highway can be included in a licence only if it is, or is to be, a trunk road in England, or part of one. The licensing regime created by this part is therefore deliberately confined to that network.

Clause 3 also sets out who may grant the licences. When the regime first begins, both the Secretary of State and the ORR will be licensing authorities. This is known as the “initial period”. Put simply, it is the period for dealing with the first licence under the Bill. Once the first licence has been issued, the initial period will end and the ORR will become the licensing authority. The end of the initial period will be specified by the Secretary of State in regulations.

It is important to say that there is an additional safeguard during that initial period. The ORR cannot itself grant a licence without the Secretary of State’s consent. Where the Secretary of State gives that consent, the decision must be published in a way that the Secretary of State considers appropriate to bring it to the attention of people likely to be affected. Where the Secretary of State grants the licence directly, a copy must be provided to the ORR as soon as reasonably practicable.

Clause 3 should also be read alongside the safeguards in the rest of the licensing framework. In particular, clause 4 requires consultation before a licence can be granted. The proposal must identify both the works to be secured and the highway on which tolls would be authorised, and there must be at least 28 days for representations. A licence cannot be granted unless that consultation requirement has been met.

That is an important safeguard because bringing a road into this regime is of course a significant decision. Before a licence is granted, those likely to be affected have an opportunity to understand what is proposed and make representations. The licensing authority must go through that process before deciding whether the licence should be granted.

It is also important to be clear that, whether we are talking about a new road or a capacity enhancing improvement, the regime is confined to the trunk road network. A highway can only be included in a licence if it is, or is to become, a trunk road in England.

We will come later to clause 81, which makes the necessary changes to the existing trunking provisions in section 10 of the Highways Act 1980 so that a new highway built under this licensing regime can become a trunk road. It does not create a blanket new power to designate any road as a trunk road; rather, it enables the existing process to work for the new type of highway.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the Minister for giving way. This should be the easiest intervention to reply to—I only wish to ask him to speak more slowly so that I can understand what he is saying.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

Apologies to the hon. Member.

Taken together, these provisions mean that the Bill can support both new strategic roads and significant capacity enhancing improvements, while remaining firmly focused on the trunk road network. The licensing authorities will also exercise their functions within the overarching statutory duties we have just debated. Those duties put the interests of road users at the centre of decision making, while requiring consideration of matters including efficiency and economy, safety, the wider strategic road network, sustainable development and competition.

Product Regulation and Metrology Bill [Lords] (Third sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank my right hon. Friend for putting a vital point on the record. New clause 5 reflects a commitment to coherent governance, to the integrity of the UK, and to a regulatory system that respects the voices of all four nations. I urge Ministers and the Government to back it.

We must consider the broader economic implications of our relationship with the EU single market. Post Brexit, UK goods exports to the EU have declined, with some studies indicating a reduction of up to 30% compared with a scenario where the UK remained within the single market and customs union. The downturn is largely attributed to non-tariff barriers such as increased paperwork and regulatory divergence, which have disproportionately affected small and medium-sized businesses. The Windsor framework, while aiming to address some of these issues, has introduced complexities of its own: notably, the creation of an Irish sea border has led to significant concerns among Unionist communities in Northern Ireland.

The leader of the Traditional Unionist Voice, the hon. and learned Member for North Antrim (Jim Allister), has been vocal in his criticism, describing the new parcel regulations as tightening the noose of the Irish sea border on local businesses. He argues that these measures further entrench a divide between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK, undermining the Union and placing additional burdens on commerce. His stance highlights the ongoing tension between regulatory alignment with the EU and the desire to maintain the UK's internal market integrity. The imposition of EU standards on Northern Ireland, without equivalent application in Great Britain, creates a disjointed regulatory environment. This disparity not only affects businesses but fuels political discontent and challenges the coherence of our Union. 

New clause 5 serves as a necessary safeguard. It ensures that any EU regulations paused in Northern Ireland due to the Stormont brake are not automatically implemented in Great Britain without due consideration. This approach promotes consistency across the UK and respects the principle that all constituent nations should have a say in the laws that govern them. By adopting new clause 5, Labour would renew their commitment to a united and sovereign United Kingdom, where all regions are treated with equal respect and consideration in the legislative process.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

As Opposition Members have articulated, the new clause would provide for a delay to the Secretary of State’s implementation of regulatory changes in Great Britain where Northern Ireland Assembly Members provide notification of triggering the Stormont brake on similar regulatory changes in Northern Ireland. That delay would persist until the Government make a determination on that notification.

I am sorry that Opposition Members feel that the Windsor framework is not up to scratch any more, but we take our responsibilities under it extremely seriously. The Bill does not alter or restrict the Windsor framework scrutiny mechanisms given to the Northern Ireland Assembly. The shadow Minister questioned the Prime Minister’s commitment to Northern Ireland, and I would remind her that he was in fact Director of Public Prosecutions in Northern Ireland for a number of years before his election to this place.

If the new clause were accepted and the Stormont brake were triggered by the Assembly on a particular EU regulation, it would delay the Government from providing certainty on the regulatory approach that we might take and it would cut across the devolution settlement, none of which is the intention of the Bill. The Stormont brake is about EU regulations, but this new clause would prevent UK Ministers from legislating on our own rules, which I am sure is not the shadow Minister’s intention.

It is also worth saying that the new clause, as drafted, is inoperable. It refers to the incorrect provisions giving effect to the Stormont brake, which are contained in schedule 6B to the Northern Ireland Act 1998.

Again, we have had an awful lot of talk about the EU. We have had a little ride on the ghost train, and nothing that Opposition Members have said bears any relation to the reality of what is in this Bill. I therefore ask that the new clause be withdrawn.

Product Regulation and Metrology Bill [Lords] (Second sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank my right hon. Friend for his wise words. I agree that it makes no sense whatsoever.

A noble Lord in the other place put it well, saying that we should be

“open to the best standards globally”—[Official Report, House of Lords, 20 November 2024; Vol. 841, c. GC56.]

accepting that goods made in high-standard, well-regulated economies like the US, Canada, Australia, Japan and the EU are safe for our markets. In fact, the UK’s own Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency already recognises approvals from such countries to get innovative products to market faster. Why not apply the same principle here, if this is truly about economic liberalism and global free trade from a pro-growth Government?

Why do the Government not support the amendments? By broadening recognition beyond the EU, we would reduce duplication and costs for British businesses that export and import worldwide. We would also bolster our sovereignty by making our own decisions about which international standards serve UK interests, rather than reflexively mirroring Brussels. The Government claim that subsection (7) is merely about “recognition”, not automatic alignment. But recognition should not be exclusive to Europe; it must extend to any standard that meets British safety and quality benchmarks, whether it originates in Brussels, Washington, Canberra or beyond.

Our amendments would ensure equal openness to global standards and end the special status of EU law in the Bill. This is a sensible alternative: a truly global Britain that maintains high standards without tethering itself to EU rules alone. I urge Government colleagues to accept these sensible amendments.

Justin Madders Portrait The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Business and Trade (Justin Madders)
- Hansard - -

It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair this afternoon, Ms Vaz. I think it is to your advantage that you have not already heard the same arguments on this issue as we heard this morning. I am sorry to say that we are still clearly at cross-purposes about what the Bill does and does not do. There was a ripple of laughter on the Government Benches when the shadow Minister accused us of being fixated with the EU. If we did a word count on how many times it has been mentioned in the debate so far, we would find that the Opposition Members are comfortably ahead.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

Okay, Ms Vaz. It was also said in that debate:

“We should bear in mind some of the history and the proximity of the UK to EU markets.”—[Official Report, Second Delegated Legislation Committee, 13 May 2024; c. 4.]

Those were not my words, but the words of the hon. Member for Thirsk and Malton (Kevin Hollinrake), who was the Minister at the time. It is clear that we are acting entirely consistently with the previous Government’s position. We recognise that there is a great deal of common history with the EU on product safety regulation, but the Bill gives us the power and the option to do as we see fit on a case-by-case basis. Conservative Members’ obsession with this issue does not reflect the reality of the Bill.

Amendment 20 would broaden the Bill to recognise product requirements in “relevant foreign law”, rather than only EU law. There is nothing in the Bill that prevents us from adopting other jurisdictions’ standards if we so wish, but “relevant foreign law” is very vague drafting. It could mean almost anything, and there is no definition in the Bill, so it is certainly not a provision that we can support. That approach is capable of being taken under the Bill anyway.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Minister is still not being clear with us about exactly why he objects to broadening the scope of the Bill to include the valuable jurisdictions that I mentioned. Instead, he is constraining the Bill to being about only the EU.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

The answer is that the Bill does not constrain us from doing as the amendment proposes; it is perfectly possible for us to do it anyway. However, the definition of “relevant foreign law” is not set out in the Bill, which would cause us difficulties later on.

Amendment 22 proposes that the UK recognise updated EU law only if we incorporate the updates into our domestic regulations, and that the Secretary of State must make an explanatory statement if recognising EU law under the Bill. As I have mentioned several times, there are a number of opportunities for the Government to set out exactly why we are taking any particular option. The explanation that I quoted from Hansard from last year is a good example of why we might choose to follow the EU, but there will be occasions when we will not. There will be impact assessments and opportunities for debates, and the code of conduct will guide us in that respect. The amendment is therefore unnecessary.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Minister talks about impact assessments and so on, but does not the framing of the Bill mean that the current Government and any future Government can ignore any impact assessments and carry on regardless? There is no parliamentary scrutiny and there are no meaningful safeguards.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

That is not correct. There are a number of opportunities for debate under the affirmative procedure, and we have set out in the Bill the triggers that would allow that, so there will be plenty of parliamentary scrutiny. The amendments do not reflect what the Bill actually does and seek to paint it as a project, which it simply is not in reality. I therefore ask that they be withdrawn.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I understand the point being made. We have already made it clear that there will be a number of occasions when we bring regulations under the affirmative procedure—for example, when a new power of entry is created; when regulations are disapplied in the case of an emergency; when a criminal offence is created or widened; when information sharing provisions are introduced; when cost recovery procedures are established; where changes are made to primary legislation; when the definition of an online marketplace is amended; when requirements relating to the marking of products and online marketplaces are introduced for the first time; when requirements on persons who control online marketplaces are introduced for the first time, and so on. I suggest that there will be ample opportunity for Parliament to have its say and scrutinise regulations made under the Bill.

Finally, I turn to the technical standards that will be developed or updated. Technical standards set out practical ways in which a requirement may be met, to help manufacturers in meeting their obligations. Currently, they can be used to demonstrate compliance with a particular product requirement, and are often prepared and adopted by recognised bodies such as the British Standards Institution. The reference to standards in clause 2 makes clear that regulations will maintain this practice, and that will therefore help to provide clarity to manufacturers and traders on how to comply with regulatory requirements through the use of these standards.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I ask the Minister to speak slightly slower; I am partially deaf and am really struggling to hear him. I am grateful for his forbearance.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I apologise—I had not realised. I will try to slow down.

Clause 2 is a vital part of the Bill: it will ensure that the UK has a comprehensive framework for regulating products sold on its markets and provides the flexibility to recognise global standards and maintain the highest safety and quality requirements for consumers and businesses.

--- Later in debate ---
Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I agree with my right hon. Friend that this is a very serious moment. It might appear to be just a line in a Bill, but it could have far-reaching consequences that are far greater than Government Members are considering at the moment. Parliament must debate and decide such grave matters, not rubber-stamp them after the fact.

Taken together, our amendments champion a pro-business climate. Effective regulation should not mean endless state interference. We can secure compliance in smarter, targeted ways by information sharing and using civil sanctions for minor breaches, rather than unleashing these unbridled powers. I urge Ministers to accept amendment 26 or, at least, to provide iron-clad assurances for the record.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am beginning to wonder whether Opposition Members think that “Capricorn One” was a documentary rather than a work of fiction. We are really entering some quite interesting territory about what evil plots this Government have, which of course is not the case at all.

Amendment 26 seeks to remove the ability to create or widen criminal offences, or to implement civil sanctions, through regulations. The harm caused by breaches of regulations can vary considerably depending on the product sector. Consequently, offences and penalties must be tailored to the specific requirements of a given sector and the seriousness of the breach. The consequences of failing to provide the necessary instructions for a product could be entirely different for a highly sensitive component within a nuclear energy installation than for a lower-risk product. Reducing enforcement flexibility to a series of broad, rigid offences would negatively impact relevant authorities’ ability to enforce proportionately. Attempting to draft very broad offences and penalties in the Bill, to capture requirements in a less targeted way, would actually undermine legal clarity and the principles of the rule of law.

There was talk from Opposition Members about how this would all be done through the back door. The affirmative procedure will apply where new offences are created or widened, so there will be no rubber-stamping after the event. There will be parliamentary scrutiny, as one would expect. We have considered the views of the DPRRC, but we have taken this approach in the Bill because it is not, in fact, unique to it. The shadow Minister said that she was shocked when she saw these subsections. I wonder whether she was equally shocked when criminal offences were created in regulations by the Building Safety Act 2022, the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023 or the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018. Those all included similar powers to the ones that we are talking about now, but I do not recall Opposition Members expressing shock and dismay at what was happening. Existing product regulations, such as the Cosmetic Products Enforcement Regulations 2013, also contained offences and penalties, further demonstrating that this is not a departure from existing practice.

The Bill has also placed limits on the maximum criminal penalties that may be implemented for contraventions of product regulations. Product regulations made under the Bill will not be able to exceed maximum criminal penalties that reflect the existing maxima. I believe that Opposition Members are making this a far more dramatic issue that it needs to be, and I ask that the amendment be withdrawn.

--- Later in debate ---
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am grateful to the hon. Members for West Worcestershire and for Chippenham for the measured way in which they have put forward their concerns, which take us back to where we started this morning. One of the central debates about the Bill concerns the level and balance of the powers in it, and ensuring that the right level of scrutiny is applied to regulations made under it. I believe that we have demonstrated through our actions in the other place that that balance has changed, and that we have struck the right note.

Amendments 8 and 9 would make all regulations made under the Bill subject to the affirmative procedure. As introduced, the Bill required new regulations to be subject to the affirmative procedure in a range of important areas, such as emergency powers and the creation of a criminal offence. However, having heard some of the concerns mentioned in the other place, we went further and amended the Bill so that the affirmative procedure would be applied to more areas, including when we impose product requirements on a new category of economic actor for the first time. We believe that that strikes the right balance between the need for scrutiny, appropriate use of parliamentary time, and the flexibility needed to keep our product and metrology regulations up to date. I will not remind Members of the quotes I gave from Ministers in the previous Administration who made similar points.

Amendments 10 to 13 are concerned with how the Bill may amend or repeal existing primary or secondary legislation. I understand the concerns about Henry VIII powers, but we heard the concerns and points expressed by peers and the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee and have removed almost all the Henry VIII powers from the Bill.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Does the Minister not agree, though, that amendments 10 and 11 are morally necessary to uphold the role of Parliament as the supreme legislative authority in the United Kingdom?

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I am not sure whether I would say they are morally necessary. It is quite normal for there to be some Henry VIII powers in most legislation, and I will now explain why that is not something that we need to trouble ourselves with too much in relation to the Gun Barrel Proof Act 1868, which I am sure all Members have familiarised themselves with. That is, as I have already demonstrated by reading its title, a very old and highly technical piece of legislation. It covers the parameters of the process of approving a firearm, including the archaic governance elements of the Birmingham proof house. It was passed in 1868, when there was a thriving Birmingham gun trade, which I presume no longer exists. To give Members some indication of—

Product Regulation and Metrology Bill [ Lords ] (First sitting)

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

We have had several impassioned speeches from Conservative Members. Unfortunately, they are all wrong about what the Bill does. I will attempt to explain what the position actually is.

The Bill provides powers to make and amend relevant product regulations, so that the UK can act in the best interests of our businesses and consumers, which I think we would all agree is a good thing. That includes choosing to recognise or stop recognising EU product requirements. That is the key: there is absolute ability to recognise or not recognise as we see fit. This is not back-door submission to the EU or having our tummies tickled—I am not sure what the correct legislative term for that is. This is about the Government taking back control to set their own laws, as we determined back in 2016.

Amendment 3 would remove clause 1(2), which gives us a power to update regulations that address the environmental impact of products where similar provisions exist in relevant EU law. Increasingly, product regulations take account of the environmental impact of goods and provisions. The Bill will enable us, where it is in the best interests of UK businesses and consumers, to choose whether to update our laws or not. As I have set out, the Bill is about supporting the UK’s interests. Clause 1(2) means that, where it is in the UK’s interests, product regulation can make the same or similar provision as that contained in relevant EU law, which can simplify the regulatory landscape for UK businesses.

Turning to amendment 4, again, clause 2(7) allows us to act in the best interests of UK businesses and consumers. It enables us to provide that requirements in our law can be satisfied by meeting specified EU requirements, but it does not mean that we are obliged to recognise EU provisions, and it also gives us the power to end such recognition. We have been clear that decisions will be taken on a case-by-case basis, which I think is what the shadow Minister was asking for, based on the needs of UK businesses and consumers, with appropriate parliamentary scrutiny. Amendment 4 would take away that flexibility and would freeze EU law in time at May 2024. I mention May 2024 because that is when the Product Safety and Metrology etc. (Amendment) Regulations 2024, which effectively introduced the same powers as those in the Bill, were made.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am genuinely curious. The Minister says that new clause 4 would take away powers. Can he explain why he would possibly object to the introduction of a review panel within two years? Surely there cannot be any objection.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I have not got on to new clause 4 yet. I will come to it shortly, and there are several reasons why we will resist it, but I was talking about amendment 4. All these numbers are very confusing.

I draw the Committee’s attention to what the then Minister—the hon. Member for Thirsk and Malton (Kevin Hollinrake), who is now a member of the shadow Cabinet—said in May 2024 when introducing the Product Safety and Metrology etc. (Amendment) Regulations:

“Where EU regulations change, we will consider whether to continue recognition of EU rules on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the views of industry and consumer safety.”—[Official Report, Second Delegated Legislation Committee, 13 May 2024; c. 4.]

That is exactly what we seek to do in the Bill. I know that there has been some change in the Conservative party since May 2024, but the current leader of the party was the Secretary of State for Business and Trade at the time. It is therefore curious, to say the least, that the Conservatives are now distancing themselves from their original position and seeking to take away our ability to make decisions on a case-by-case basis in the interests of UK consumers.

Amendment 5 and new clause 9 would require statements to be made to Parliament in relation to aligning with or diverging from EU law. I think them unnecessary. It is very clear that we will be taking decisions on the basis of what is in the best interests of the UK, rather than taking an ideological position in either direction. There may be instances in which the UK’s product regulation interests are different from the EU’s; there may be other instances in which our interests are similar. When making regulations under the Bill, we will provide Parliament with the usual information to make sure that their purpose and effect is well understood. That will provide Parliament with a clear explanation of the Government’s intent, and Parliament will have oversight of regulations made under the Bill. The amendments would add unnecessary extra processes and would not provide Parliament with any new information.

I turn to amendment 7. I remind hon. Members again of the purpose of the Bill, which is to ensure that the UK can deliver an effective domestic regulatory regime across a range of sectors. That is why the Bill will extend only to England and Wales, to Scotland and to Northern Ireland, as clause 13 sets out. There may be instances in which it is in the UK’s best interests to recognise a provision of relevant EU law when making domestic product regulations. In this instance, the recognised EU provision that must be complied with would be stated in UK law and would be enforceable only by UK authorities. If we wanted to update our laws to reflect a decision of the European Court of Justice, we would need to make a statutory instrument. There is no automatic taking of rules from the EU, as has been suggested.

Amendment 21 proposes that the UK should only recognise updated EU law if we incorporate the relevant updates into our domestic regulations, and the Secretary of State makes an explanatory statement if only recognising EU law under the Bill. The Bill is about ensuring that our domestic regulatory framework works for businesses and consumers. The Bill will allow us to make changes to our framework and reflect global best practice when doing so. The reason that it refers explicitly to the EU is that most of our product regulation is inherited from the EU, and we continue to recognise certain EU product requirements, which is the reason why the 2024 regulations were passed last year. This gives us the ability to review decisions on recognising certain EU product requirements. Clause 2(7) will allow us to do so on a case-by-case basis.

New clause 4 proposes a review panel. The Government have published a code of conduct, which has been drafted with valuable input from parliamentarians in the other place. It sets out the various guardrails that will be in place when the powers in the Bill are exercised; they include an impact assessment that analyses the expected effects of changes on businesses, consumers and the UK internal market. All secondary legislation made under the Bill will be subject to the statutory and non-statutory assessments set out in the code of conduct, including the principles of the better regulation framework.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I assume that the code of conduct you mentioned will be voluntary. I would be interested to hear what parliamentary enforcement the code, or indeed the wider constraints referred to in new clause 4, will receive.

None Portrait The Chair
- Hansard -

Order. May I gently remind Members that they should not use the word “you”? “You”, in this context, is me, and I do not know anything about the code of conduct.

“Chapter 4A

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Tuesday 11th March 2025

(1 year, 8 months ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I refer the right hon. Member to our departmental press release, where at least half a dozen business representatives and businesses have expressed support, and of course, there are many more businesses out there. Indeed, I visited one only recently that supported the Bill.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths (Bognor Regis and Littlehampton) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Would the Minister be kind enough to name one of those businesses on the press release? [Interruption.] He had better look at the press release just to check.

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

There is the Co-op—quite a big business—Richer Sounds, Centrica and the British Chambers of Commerce. These are not bit-part players at all, are they?

New clause 38 seeks to ensure that agency workers in the adult social care sector who do not have a “worker’s contract”, within the meaning of employment legislation, would nevertheless be able to bring a claim in the employment tribunals or in civil proceedings where a fair pay agreement has been breached. It does that by deeming a contract to exist for this purpose between the worker and the party that pays them. That will allow such workers to bring an unlawful deduction of wages claim or breach of contract claim for a breach of fair pay agreement terms.

New clause 37 and associated amendments will enable the Scottish and Welsh Ministers to establish their own separate negotiating bodies and associated framework, and to enable their negotiating bodies and the resulting agreements to cover social care workers in both adult and children’s social care. Care policy, funding and commissioning is delivered together in both Wales and Scotland. In England, the two workforces, and therefore the policies and delivery, are distinct. As such, it is right for Scotland and Wales to have the powers to set up negotiating bodies that can provide for their systems and workforces as they are now. These amendments and associated consequential amendments will allow the devolved Ministers to exercise certain powers in this chapter of the Bill with the consent of the Secretary of State, ensuring that the Secretary of State retains oversight of regulations relating to the reserved matters of employment and industrial relations.

Amendment 151 to clause 41 supplements the power to make regulations in relation to record keeping. It will enable those regulations to apply to section 49 of the National Minimum Wage Act 1998 in order to prevent employers from trying to contract out of their new record keeping obligations.

Oral Answers to Questions

Debate between Justin Madders and Alison Griffiths
Thursday 31st October 2024

(2 years ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I would be delighted to meet my hon. Friend. Under the “Get Britain Working” plan, more disabled people and people with health conditions will be supported to enter and stay in work, and I am happy to discuss with her how we can achieve that aim.

Alison Griffiths Portrait Alison Griffiths (Bognor Regis and Littlehampton) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Government’s own impact assessment suggests that measures in the Employment Rights Bill could cost businesses up to £4.5 billion annually and increase the number of strikes by 54%. Does the Minister expect that legislation to enhance or undermine investor confidence?

Justin Madders Portrait Justin Madders
- Hansard - -

I gently point out to the hon. Lady that that represents a 0.4% increase on businesses’ total costs—a small price to pay for what the impact assessment says

“will strengthen working conditions for the lowest-paid and most vulnerable in the labour market, increasing fairness and equality across Britain. It will have significant positive impacts on workers who are trapped in insecure work, face discrimination, or suffer from unscrupulous employer behaviour like ‘fire and refire’ practices”.

If the hon. Lady does not support that, I am sure that she can talk to her constituents about why.