House of Commons (26) - Commons Chamber (12) / Westminster Hall (6) / Written Statements (5) / Written Corrections (3)
House of Lords (13) - Lords Chamber (13)
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords ChamberTo ask His Majesty’s Government what they expect the Land Use Framework to deliver in relation to reducing planning costs and accelerating planning decisions for permanent land use change.
My Lords, I declare my interests as a landowner involved in forestry, in residential, renewable and commercial development, and I beg leave to ask the Question standing in my name on the Order Paper.
My Lords, the land use framework will help to deliver development in the right places faster and at lower cost. It provides clearer priorities for land use in England, practical principles for decision-making and better spatial data, helping to identify suitable locations for development and manage pressures on land. This will support more co-ordinated decisions on permanent land use change, helping to reduce uncertainty and delay while at the same time safeguarding important natural assets and productive farmland.
My Lords, the land use framework envisages large-scale land use change, including up to 2% going to renewable energy and up to 2% to housing and urban extension. This will inevitably put pressure on our best and most versatile land, potentially undermining our food security. What assurances can the Minister give the House that sprawling solar panel developments will be treated as a permanent land use change and our best and most versatile land will be fully protected for our food security?
Only 2% of England’s agricultural land is likely to undergo land use change away from agriculture and towards renewable energy infrastructure by 2050. Some of that can of course continue to be used for food production—solar is an example of that. The National Planning Policy Framework is clear that plans should steer development to avoid the use of higher-quality agricultural land, using the agricultural land classification system. We are undertaking a review of that to ensure that it is as it should be. We need the best available data to guide that. We are also working closely with DESNZ to ensure that analysis and principles from the land use framework support the development of plans for energy—for example, the strategic spatial energy plan, which will help to locate solar farms in the appropriate places—because we need to make sure that energy infrastructure needs are balanced with our national priorities, of which food production is of course one.
My Lords, does the Minister agree that, with 9% of farmland earmarked for climate and nature use, with minimal food production, farmers and tenants need certainty that that change will be fairly funded? When will the Law Commission’s review, which is meant to ensure that tenants are not locked out of land use change opportunities, begin? I understand it is currently on hold. What will stop tenants being displaced in the meantime?
On Monday, I answered another question on tenancies and explained that we are working with, for example, the Duchy of Cornwall, and others, to ensure longer-term tenancies. That is a priority for the Government. That is the first point. Planning case law is also clear that personal circumstances and the hardship of people affected by development can be a material consideration in planning decisions. On that basis, the Government recognise that tenants should receive fair compensation if they lose land to non-agricultural development. The forthcoming Law Commission work is an important part of that to ensure that tenants are properly supported and able to be represented. It will explore statutory compensation provisions as well. We hope to see it as soon as we can.
My Lords, the land use framework was envisaged as a device to optimise our use of land, on this very small, overcrowded island, to ensure that we secure the best outcomes for all of us in terms of food, energy, forestry, health, habitats and, indeed, housing. Can the Minister tell me when the Government might consider publishing a report on what is actually happening on the ground versus the ideal of what a sensibly resilient nation might insist on or at least aspire to? If no such report is on the horizon, perhaps she could explain to us all how we are going to best use the land use framework to optimise our use of land.
The purpose of the land use framework is to optimise our use of land. There are so many different pressures—energy, food production, housing, recreation—that it is important that we have a proper overview and cross-departmental oversight. That is what the land use framework is designed to do. Regarding a report, as the noble Lord says, any policy that is coming into place needs to be properly observed and monitored as it moves forward to ensure that it is doing what it is designed to do. Nice words do not end in the results that we want to see. I suggest that the appropriate time to look at doing such a report would be once the land use framework has had time to bed in and start making changes.
My Lords, given that 10% of productive farmland is going to be taken out of production under the land use framework, will the Minister explain the thinking behind the department giving a grant of almost £2 million for the acquisition of the Rothbury estate for rewilding—so not for food production at all?
Part of the design of the land use framework is to ensure that we spend our money wisely and work with other departments to make sure that development happens in the best place. Alongside that are other policies, including the implementation of many of the recommendations in the report by the noble Baroness, Lady Batters, on food productivity. If we can increase productivity, that is what helps our food security. We can have an enormous amount of land that is unproductive or not as productive as it should be. It is about being most productive and using our land to its best ability.
My Lords, it is important for us all to have a vibrant and beautiful countryside. Does the Minister agree that we must concentrate on brownfield developments and that there are many buildings where solar panels would be much better suited than on agricultural land or beautiful landscapes? This is one of the areas where, across parties, we need to think that, if we are not careful, we will lose beautiful stretches of countryside because we have not organised ourselves effectively and efficiently. I hope that Defra, in championing the countryside, will think about that very strongly.
Clearly, brownfield sites need to be a priority; I agree with the noble Lord on that. On solar, we need to encourage more solar on buildings. We are starting to see that more, particularly with industrial buildings. Clearly, we also have to look at the energy crisis in this country, and the price of energy; we need to move more to renewable energies. It is important that now, as opposed to in previous years, Defra is working much more actively and constructively with MHCLG regarding our planning.
My Lords, the Coming Home report argued that land should be treated as more than an economic resource or development opportunity and should be used to create genuinely affordable homes and sustainable communities. The Church of England is trying to put this into practice through its own landholdings, but there are considerable challenges. Can the Minister say how the Government’s land use framework will encourage public bodies, churches and other charitable landowners to make land available for genuinely affordable housing in thriving communities and ensure that planning processes, legalities and viability requirements do not stand in the way of delivering wider social benefits?
It is important to point out that the land use framework is not a material consideration in planning. Having said that, the principles, data and evidence that the framework provides will help to drive faster, clearer and more co-ordinated land use decisions. In August, we published the revised National Planning Policy Framework, which sets out those clear policies. That is an area in which Defra and other departments, particularly MHCLG, work together to try to deliver exactly what the right reverend Prelate is talking about.
My Lords, while we are on the subject of farming, have we made any progress whatever with farmers wasting water and then complaining that there is a shortage?
We all need to consider our water use. When we consider the long-term climate situations and the issues that we have had around drought, we all need to consider that. As a department, we are looking at how we can best work with high-use water businesses—golf courses are the example that comes to mind—so that, when there is a drought, we can work more efficiently.
My Lords, farmers produce 60% of our food. The agriculture sector is therefore a vital part of our national security. To fulfil that role, it needs to be able to plan, adapt and invest. For that, it needs an efficient and responsive planning system. The current planning system is fraught with delay and indecision but, worse, its future, structure, functions and accountability are entirely uncertain because of the Government’s local government reforms. Will the Minister—she will know that I am normally on her side in these things—undertake to explain this to her colleagues in the relevant departments?
I can assure the noble Baroness that I talk regularly to my colleagues in the relevant departments. She mentions a critical point: much of what we want to do moving forward within the agriculture sector relies on the right planning applications and responses. For example, if we want to have fewer chickens in a shed—if we want to have less stocking density—we need bigger sheds, so we need planning applications that look to the reasons behind that. There is much that we need to do in Defra to continue working with MHCLG. We have been doing that constructively, and we will continue to do so.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords Chamber
Lord Cameron of Lochiel
To ask His Majesty’s Government what progress they have made towards the deportation of Shabir Ahmed; and whether they have considered the use of visa penalties and withdrawal of foreign aid.
My Lords, the Immigration and Asylum Bill has been amended to ensure that the vilest foreign criminals such as Ahmed can be handed deportation orders. We are pursuing every option to deport Shabir Ahmed. We talk to a range of countries about returns and deportations, but it would be inappropriate for us to give a running commentary on discussions.
Lord Cameron of Lochiel (Con)
My Lords, the Government are attempting to change the law to allow the deportation of Shabir Ahmed, which is welcome, but removing the legal barrier to his deportation is pointless if the Pakistani Government refuse to accept him. The UK Government have said that they are willing to use all measures necessary to deport foreign criminals, so why are they not threatening Pakistan with comprehensive visa sanctions and the withdrawal of foreign aid?
We are pursuing every available option to deport Shabir Ahmed, and, as I say, it would be inappropriate to give a running commentary on those discussions. Since coming to power, this Government have returned nearly 12,000 foreign national offenders between 1 July 2024 and 31 July 2026. That figure includes both enforced and voluntary returns. Compared with the final two years of the previous Government, foreign national offender returns have increased by 41%.
Lord Mohammed of Tinsley (LD)
My Lords, I deplore the behaviour of Shabir Ahmed and I wish he was not among us in this country. However, I want to press on the Minister a word of caution. It is easy as a soundbite to say that we want to withdraw international aid, but many of the people who benefit from our international aid in Pakistan or anywhere else are women and girls who gain access to education or healthcare. If the Government are minded to withdraw international aid, will they at least publish what the impact will be? Having seen Shabir Ahmed destroy the lives of women and girls in this country, I do not want him to now go on to destroy the lives of tens of millions of girls in Pakistan.
The noble Lord is right. Uppermost in our minds should be the victims of the criminals who commit these vile crimes. On returns of foreign national offenders, we are speaking to and working with a number of countries. That is the way we will achieve success, and the figures prove that. We need dialogue to ensure a proper returns process.
My Lords, following on from what the noble Lord said a moment ago, surely there is a crucial urgency here. A one-clause Bill to amend the Immigration Act 1971 is needed, and that would go through the House in a day if need be. Why are the Government not showing urgency here?
I think we are showing urgency compared to the previous Government. We have put a clause in the Bill. That Bill is going to be under consideration. It has already been through the Commons, where it had its Third Reading yesterday. I reassure the noble Lord that, with his support and that of his colleagues, we can deal with this matter speedily.
My Lords, if the problem is the intransigence of the Pakistani Government, maybe we should remind them of their obligations to their own citizens—because this individual is not a British citizen but continues to be a Pakistani citizen—and of our right to remove people who are not conducive to the public good. We should certainly review funding and, more specifically, as I am sure the noble Lord would agree, look at the liberal visa regime which pertains at the current time.
Again, I look forward to the noble Lord’s support for the Immigration and Asylum Bill when it comes to this place. This Government have acted. We are determined to act so that we have a system that is fair, fast and just for everyone. That is how we build confidence among the people of this country, because they have very strong values around protecting people, and we must not forget that.
My Lords, the Minister has already given us some figures about the number of people who have been deported by this Government. Can he compare that with some of the figures over the preceding period, because the failure of previous Administrations to carry out their responsibilities to deport people who should have been deported is quite stark?
I agree with my noble friend, but I am keen to ensure that this House works on a collective, cross-party basis to address these issues. It is important that we act speedily, and the sooner we get the Bill through when it comes to this place, the better.
My Lords, on 15 October, in your Lordships’ House, my noble friend Lady Monckton asked the Minister:
“How many of this cohort”
of foreign national offenders
“who are liable to deportation remain in the United Kingdom due to Article 8 claims and human rights claims?”.—[Official Report, 15/10/26; col. 337.]
The Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Lemos, answered that that information was available but not yet in a form to be published. I wonder if the noble Lord could update the House on that.
I repeat that this Government have acted speedily, with nearly 12,000 foreign national offenders returned or deported between 1 July 2024 and 31 July 2026. As I said, an increase of 41% has been seen in the years since 1 July 2024. There were 5,928 foreign national offender returns in the year ending July 2026, an increase of 11% compared with the previous year, while 31,552 foreign national offenders were removed between January 2019 and 2026. We are acting and we are delivering, and I expect support from the Opposition Benches when we get the Bill in this place.
My Lords, the sons of the former Prime Minister of Pakistan, Imran Khan, have been denied a visitor visa to visit their father in prison. What are the Government doing to encourage the Pakistani Government to issue those visas? If the noble Lord does not know the answer, as it is not in his pack, can he please write to me?
What I do know is that it is not for us to dictate to a Government what visas they permit. I would not accept that from another Government to us. However, I understand the nature of the conditions, and we make representations for fair judicial process, but it is not up to us to dictate to another Government.
Lord Bailey of Paddington (Con)
My Lords, given that the noble Lord has just said that it is not for our Government to dictate to another how they conduct themselves, what message does he think it sends to the most vulnerable people in our country that he will not say something to the Pakistani Government about taking back this individual?
I am not sure I understand what the noble Lord is trying to get at. We have deprived Ahmed of his United Kingdom citizenship, a very rare act to take. We are determined to ensure that he is deported, which is why we have put a clause in the Bill that will come to this House. I do not know what more the noble Lord thinks we can do, but we are absolutely determined. As I say, we are in constant discussion with a whole range of countries about returns, and we have succeeded—I have given the figures to the House—in increasing the number of returns in the two years we have been in power, compared to the two years that his Government were in power.
My Lords, how many of those removed were removed to Pakistan, presumably with the agreement of the Pakistani Government, and what distinguishes this particular case in their view?
I am not going to give a commentary on this specific case. I do not have the figures for direct returns to Pakistan, but we have had discussions with Pakistan and other countries about ensuring proper returns. Of the Rochdale offenders, we have had two returns—two have gone back. I do not know the total number as the noble Lord asked, so I will write to him.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords ChamberTo ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the effectiveness of prison education and employment programmes in reducing reoffending.
Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Hyde of Bemerton) (Lab)
Education and employment are vital to rehabilitation, each reducing reoffending by up to nine percentage points. Prison education, together with other work-focused activities, builds skills for life including reading, numeracy and work-focused training. Employment partnerships and employer-led skills training programmes develop the skills needed for sustainable work on release. The Government are undertaking a full evaluation of a new prisoner education service and continue to monitor delivery outcomes across education, skills and employment provision to inform future development.
I think the whole House will agree with the tenor of what the noble Baroness has just told us. Will she reassure us that she will do everything she can to reduce friction in accessing education in our overcrowded prisons? One specific example is removing the need for teachers to do a key training programme for each individual establishment rather than one for everywhere.
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
I am unsure whether the noble and learned Baroness refers to keys that lock and unlock, or key as in core.
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
I thank her for that clarification. I will take the query about the core training provision back to the team, because we are absolutely committed and focused on the need to be able to access consistent education. This Government seek to smooth the way so that teachers can be in classrooms teaching prisoners who are able to get the skills they need before they leave prison.
My Lords, I am delighted that the Prime Minister is providing leadership and funding on rough sleeping. Prisoners have a far higher rate of reoffending when they leave prison and find themselves homeless. What action are the Government taking to deal with homelessness among prison leavers?
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
I thank the noble Baroness for that question. As noble Lords may be aware, some time ago, prior to coming to this place, I sat in many homeless persons units—with prisoners on the day of release in different local authorities across London —trying to enable people to access accommodation. It is a personal passion of mine. Stable accommodation, as the noble Baroness says, is fundamental to successful rehabilitation and reducing reoffending, because those who are homeless on release have reoffending rates around double those released into settled accommodation. Through the national plan to end homelessness, the Government have committed to halving the proportion of prison leavers released homeless and increasing the proportion in settled accommodation three months after release by the end of this Parliament. As the noble Baroness rightly says, the Prime Minister’s rough sleeping programme is backed by £874 million, which builds on that national plan, taking the total homelessness investment to over £4 billion over the next three years.
My Lords, Highpoint prison in Newmarket does amazing work equipping prisoners with CSCS and CPCS cards so that they can go straight on to building sites. On a recent visit, the prison told me and other noble Lords that changes in funding were making it increasingly difficult to provide that specific form of training. Will the Government look at this explicitly in monitoring what is happening? If possible, can the Minister inform the House or me whether anything is being done to address these problems?
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
I am unaware of the specific details around the case mentioned in HMP Highpoint, but I take the point that CSCS cards are an incredibly important progression route for many people who are currently incarcerated. As I am sure the noble Baroness is aware, governors have localised commissioning powers so that they can commission specialist provision in terms of local education assessed against labour market needs. The Government are expanding provision to vocational training, prison industries and work-based learning so that people can secure employment on release. One example is through the future skills programme, which aligns training with employer demand and includes a guaranteed interview before release. I will happily write to the noble Baroness about that specific prison.
My Lords, reoffending costs £22.7 billion a year. Reducing reoffending means increasing the level of education and training in our prisons, not cutting it as is currently happening. Is the Minister aware that the Chancellor has announced plans for a preventive departmental expenditure limit, which is ring-fenced funding to fix problems and bring down costs in the future? Is her department at least looking at that as a mechanism to dig itself out of the hole that it has created?
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
The noble Lord will be unsurprised to hear that, given our dedication to this agenda, we are absolutely looking at pulling every single lever to ensure that people leave prisons with a high level of education and skills that will enable them to get into work or further training when they leave prison.
Lord Keen of Elie (Con)
My Lords, prisoners are being released so quickly by this Government that it is difficult to believe that many of them have time for either education or employment—and, of course, many of them quickly return. The quarterly recall figures for April to June 2026 show a 12% increase from the same quarter a year earlier. It is acknowledged that this is in part due to what has been termed by the Prime Minister “the early release scheme”. Will the Minister ensure that, when the reoffending data for the same period is released, it is broken down to identify the number of prisoners who had been released early?
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
We recognise the issue of recall. It serves nobody if people are going into prison on very short sentences and then coming out. That is why we progressed the Sentencing Act through the other House and this House; it has gone on to statute and become law. There may be some learning-curve amendments from that, but fundamentally we are having to address the overcrowding crisis through the provisions of the Sentencing Act and using this progressive route to enable people to resettle into crime-free lives, of which education and employment—as we have already alluded to—are a key part.
Lord Stace (Lab)
My Lords, as chair of the Prison Reform Trust, I can say that there is strong evidence of education and training in prison being an investment in life chances and a safer society. Although the ink is barely dry on Alan Milburn’s report, will my noble friend the Minister look at extending the proposed opportunity support guarantee—a route into education, training or work—to young people in prison?
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
I thank the noble Lord for all his excellent work in this arena and with the Prison Reform Trust. I know he is aware that, at present, prisons work hard to ensure that young people can access a broad range of educational opportunities including functional skills, vocational training, distance learning and work experience. Every prisoner receives an education assessment and careers guidance, which informs digital work, and a learning plan that supports progression throughout their time in custody. I welcome Alan Milburn’s ambition to increase apprenticeship opportunities for young people. HMPPS is already working with employers to expand apprenticeship provision in custody, including in sectors such as construction and hospitality, helping prisoners develop the skills they need for successful employment on release.
My Lords, many prisoners go into prison addicted, and many prisoners get addicted while in prison. The previous holder of the Minister’s post assured me that, by the end of this year, every prison in England would have AA and Narcotics Anonymous. Tomorrow is our annual fundraiser for the Rehabilitation for Addicted Prisoners Trust. Can I please tell the fundraiser that this pledge is being fulfilled?
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
The noble Baroness will be unsurprised that I will need to confirm that and write to her as I do not have it in my pack. I take the opportunity to thank NA and AA for their work. Having worked in prisons for over a decade, I recognise their essential work. This Government have invested over £300 million in trying to keep prisons safe and secure. A core part of that—£75 million—has been invested in improving physical security so that we can tackle drugs and other contraband coming in, as well as increasing access to mutual aid across the estate. We are working closely with the fellowship organisations that the noble Baroness mentioned.
My Lords, does the Minister agree that the prison library system is central to education in prisons, and that the library system is not always as accessible as it should be because there is a shortage of trained librarians? I declare an interest in that my wife is a trustee of a prison reading group charity.
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
I agree with the noble Lord that libraries are essential. In my time working in prisons, I remember being shocked the first time I heard the statistic that the average reading age for a prisoner is 11 years old. I pay tribute to the work of organisations such as the Shannon Trust, which are vital in ensuring that, beyond the higher education opportunities, basic numeracy and literacy are widely accessible within all our prisons.
My Lords, it is estimated that 25% to 40% of care leavers end up in prison, and it is higher—about 50%—for children in custody. Most of those have underachieved in education. What programmes are there specifically to address this?
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
The noble Baroness is right to raise the overrepresentation of care leavers, particularly in the women’s estate and the youth estate. We are committed to tackling that problem. We recognise the importance of early intervention and prevention across a range of things, particularly so that it is not inevitable that a child leaving care will end up in the criminal justice system. We are committed to ending that pipeline.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords Chamber
Baroness Hazarika
To ask His Majesty’s Government what consideration they have given to staggering the age of consent.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Justice (Lord Lemos) (Lab)
My Lords, a range of offences already exist to protect children, and it is for the police and prosecutors to determine whether a crime has occurred. We will always look at what more can be done to protect young people from abuse and exploitation, and we are focused on tackling exploitation and supporting young people to understand healthy relationships and consent.
Baroness Hazarika (Lab)
My Lords, I think we will all have been sickened by the behaviour of Russell Brand and allegations involving other people. Some of the victims are calling for legislation, with the idea of staggered consent, but we should have a much wider conversation about consent. Can my noble friend the Minister say whether we should have a broader conversation about culture? It is not okay for predominantly, although not always, older men to prey on younger people—lots of women, lots of men and sometimes teenagers—for sex. It is not okay if you are a musician or an actor, and it is not okay if you are an ordinary person—we have just been discussing the grooming gangs, and that was a feature of that kind of abuse. Can my noble friend say that we need to have a bigger conversation about this? Can we all agree that the shame and the stigma should be not on the younger person, who is often coerced into sex, but on the creepy older man?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
My Lords, I agree with my noble friend Lady Hazarika that we need to have a wider conversation. The question of the staggered age of consent has come to the forefront of public discourse. It is a complicated question, but we can certainly look at it—it has far-reaching consequences. However, as she indicates, there are plenty of things that we could take action on now. The issue at stake is the sexual exploitation and coercion of vulnerable young people by powerful and manipulative older people. There is much that can be done by broadcasters, by online companies and in education.
My Lords, I agree with what the Minister just said about the topical interest, but this Topical Question raises very difficult issues on which there are widely divergent views and evidence. The Law Commission has an upcoming project on consent in criminal law, on which it has not yet embarked. Have the Government considered whether they might ask the Law Commission to broaden the ambit of that project to include considering the age of consent?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I can confirm that the Law Commission is, as part of its 14th programme of work, reviewing the concept of consent in the criminal law, including in sexual offences, so it will look at the issue that the noble Lord raised. It has confirmed that the review will include a wide range of issues and will provide greater predictability to modernise particularly the criminal law in England and Wales. Of course, the Government will consider its findings carefully.
Lord Keen of Elie (Con)
My Lords, the author Graham Greene described fame as a “powerful aphrodisiac”. As recent events have illustrated, it can also be a catalyst for vile exploitation. What steps will the Government take to address such conduct, widely regarded as morally repugnant, and render it liable to the criminal law?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
Sorry, I missed the very first sentence—could the noble and learned Lord just repeat it?
Lord Keen of Elie (Con)
The first sentence was a reference to the author Graham Greene, whom the noble Lord may have heard of. He described fame as a “powerful aphrodisiac”. As I pointed out, it can also be a catalyst for vile exploitation. What steps will the Government take to address such conduct and render it liable to the criminal law?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I have read a bit of Graham Greene; I am happy to confirm that. I did English literature at university—I dare say that the noble and learned Lord did law. Indeed, if he did, I would say that the law curriculum should be updated to include a little bit more Graham Greene.
On the serious point that the noble and learned Lord makes, of course the Government will look at ways in which we can address the criminal behaviours here. We have done things in the online safety space; we have created new offences there. However, I think it is fair to say that no one feels that we are in a comfortable place, and the Brand case illustrates some aspects of sexual exploitation and abuse that we need to think about more carefully—and we will. If necessary, we will legislate. It is an appalling case, as my right honourable friend the Prime Minister said, and we will do all that we can.
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Hazarika, for the Question and agree with everything she said in asking it. I thank the Minister for his Answer, which I found very encouraging. I agree that the Law Commission can play a big role in this. I feel confident that we can have a genuinely cross-party discussion in this House, especially with the expertise that we have, with many noble Baronesses on both sides of the House having fought for protecting women against male sexual violence and many on both sides of the House who have experience in the judicial and legal system.
Fundamentally, do we think that it is okay for a 60 year-old man to be having sex with a 16 year-old woman? We do not—we recognise that there is a great power imbalance by virtue of age. Do we think that the criminal law could step in and provide some protection against this imbalance founded in age? I hope that we can. I agree that there should be a staggered age of consent, and I think that we should discuss it. Does the Minister agree that that is an important discussion to be had?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
Yes, I agree with my noble and learned friend that it is an important discussion for us to have. I think the scenario that she describes is deeply troubling to all of us, and we should absolutely discuss it—and if necessary, we will legislate. She referenced the Law Commission’s work. We have accepted all the recommendations of the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, and we have legislated in the Crime and Policing Act to create new offences covering rape and other penetrative sexual activity with a child under 16 by an adult. I agree with my noble and learned friend that there is no doubt more that we can do, and we must come back and look at that. What she describes should concern us all.
Lord Young of Acton (Con)
The Minister has just confirmed that the Government are taking seriously suggestions of staggering the age of consent. Can he confirm that the Government are reconsidering lowering the voting age to 16?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I sort of expected that question—I did not quite know who from, but I guess I might have guessed. But no, we will not reconsider voting at the age of 16. It was a manifesto commitment, we are legislating on it, and we hope that it will be law very soon.
My Lords, I declare my interest as a former safeguarding and child protection officer. I thank my noble friend Lady Hazarika and my noble and learned friend Lady Harman for suggesting that we need collective action to address these massive issues. My noble friend talked about wider society and the difficulties of consent, but what procedures and support are in place for vulnerable young people who come into this House for volunteering or work placement regarding whistleblowing? What processes do we have in place to ensure that their safeguarding is as paramount for us here in this House as it is outside?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
I agree with the noble Baroness that we in this House must have the highest standards. That is really a question for the House authorities. I think it is true to say that we have all done training and been introduced to the code on this—I certainly have, and it was excellent—but I am sure the House authorities will write to the noble Baroness and set out our approach.
Lord Pannick (CB)
My Lords, none of us supports sexual exploitation, but is it really for the criminal law to tell 16 year-old men and women who they can have sex with?
Lord Lemos (Lab)
The noble Lord is right. One issue that we are concerned with, and which the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, was concerned we should be clear about, is that we should not inadvertently criminalise consensual relationships between young people—I am not quite sure if that is exactly what the noble Lord had in mind. As I have said, we will look again at the wider question of consent of 16 year-olds for sexual relations with older people. If there is a need to do something, we will, but the age of consent has been set at 16 for a very long time—although only much more recently for young gay men—and it would be a big and far-reaching change. Still, we will do what we can on sexual exploitation.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords Chamber
Lord Lemos
That the draft Orders laid before the House on 12 October be approved.
Relevant document: 15th Report from the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee. Considered in Grand Committee on 17 November.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords ChamberThat the draft Regulations laid before the House on 14 October be approved.
Considered in Grand Committee on 17 November.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords Chamber
Baroness Antrobus
That the draft Orders laid before the House on 20 October be approved.
Considered in Grand Committee on 17 November.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords ChamberThat the House do agree with the Commons in their Amendment 1.
My Lords, with the leave of your Lordships’ House I will also speak to Amendments 2 to 60. I am delighted to be opening the debate on the Sporting Events Bill. I am particularly pleased because when the Bill was last before us, a week before the reshuffle, noble Lords—not looking at any noble Lord in particular—raised concerns that I may not still be a DCMS Minister by the time the Bill headed to the Commons.
Earlier this year, as the Bill passed through your Lordships’ House, a strong and thoughtful case was made that a small number of our world-class recurrent events could in future face the same delivery, commercial protection and hosting challenges as itinerant events. I am hugely grateful to noble Lords and our outstanding recurrent events sector in the UK for the constructive engagement we have had on this issue. I particularly thank the noble Baroness, Lady Evans of Bowes Park, and the noble Lords, Lord Markham and Lord Addington, for their continued engagement on this point, as well as many other noble Lords. Our recurrent sporting events make an important contribution to the sporting life of this country and bring significant economic and social value to the United Kingdom. Having carefully considered this matter over the summer, as I committed to doing, this Government ultimately agreed with the principal points of consensus reached between noble Lords, albeit with a small number of important and proportionate amendments.
The Bill as amended by your Lordships’ House risked being overly broad in scope. That is why Amendment 8 requires events to have “international”, as opposed to just “national”, interest. In our view, without safeguards to ensure the framework is applied in a proportionate way, we risk an extremely large pool of events being unintentionally eligible for protections, therefore having a disproportionately wide effect on local businesses and communities. We believe that the outlined approach is the most appropriate and right one.
Amendments 3, 5 and 10 introduce a third condition that must be met in the case of recurrent events. Under this third condition, the organiser of a recurrent sporting event must apply to the Secretary of State, or the devolved Government, requesting and setting out evidence as to why it is appropriate to apply one or more parts of the framework to the event. The Secretary of State, or devolved Government, may then consider such events on a case-by-case basis, notably considering such matters as the prominence of the event within its field of sport and the frequency of such events. This is a right and proportionate approach for a cohort of events which are numerous, well established and not routinely dependent on government operational support. It builds on the concept of application introduced in your Lordships’ House.
Government Amendment 11 introduces a sunset provision so that a recurrent event would need to reapply after a maximum of five years to keep the protections applied to it. Events would then be expected to apply again, setting out why it remained appropriate for one or more parts of the framework to be applied to it. That is an important safeguard. It ensures that provisions and their wider impact do not continue indefinitely by default, while providing the chance for events that continue to meet the framework conditions to receive proper scrutiny and continue to benefit from them.
Amendment 21 introduces a mechanism for cost recovery in relation to the advertising and trading provisions where those provisions are applied to a domestic sporting event. Where additional burdens arise from the delivery of events run wholly independently of government, it is right in our view that these costs should not fall on the taxpayer. That is why this amendment enables local authorities to recover additional costs incurred when implementing the advertising and street trading provisions, but no more than that. That is, in the Government’s view, a fair and proportionate approach.
This Government are committed to ensuring that the Bill provides appropriate protections for major sporting events to take place, but at the same time are committed to ensuring businesses are supported. For recurrent events, Amendment 46 now provides a blanket exception to the trading offence for traders in a restricted zone who already hold a licence granted by the local authority. This means that, for example, a long-standing independent food seller will be able to continue to trade as usual. We have also made further amendments to the advertising and unauthorised association provisions to strengthen safeguards for small and microbusinesses through Amendments 18 and 43. Amendment 12 will also mean that traders licensed by local authorities, who are prevented from trading, can now expect reasonable steps to be taken to mitigate that. This includes having alternative trading locations identified.
My Lords, although it is a pro bono position, I declare my interest as a board member of the London Marathon Foundation.
First, I thank the Minister and her officials for their continued engagement as the Bill progressed through the other place. I am particularly grateful that the Government listened to the concerns raised in this House and by the major sporting events sector about the overly narrow scope of the Bill in its original form and, in response, have brought forward a number of amendments which are before us today and which make provision in relation to the application of the sporting events framework to domestic sporting events.
Although the expanded scope of the Bill’s framework is extremely welcome, it has come with a sting in the tail in the form of the new enforcement provisions the noble Baroness mentioned, set out in Commons Amendment 21, which introduces a new mechanism for enforcement authorities to recover from domestic sporting events organisers the additional costs they incur in connection with enforcing the advertising and trading offences. With these powers, the Bill creates a two-tier system, as these cost recovery provisions, as the Minister set out, will apply only to domestic sporting events, not the one-off international events covered by the framework. I would be grateful if the Minister could explain in a bit more detail the thinking behind this inequality of treatment, and particularly why our iconic recurrent events will be expected to pay these costs, but one-off international events will not.
In introducing the new clause, the Minister in the other place said that guidance will be published, emphasising that these new provisions will apply
“only to additional unfunded burdens”
and do not
“replace existing regulatory and enforcement arrangements”.—[Official Report, Commons, Sporting Events Bill Committee, 20/10/26; col. 23.]
However, there is concern among the major sporting bodies potentially affected that, in reality, it will be quite difficult to neatly differentiate between the work that local authorities or other enforcement agencies already do to enforce the existing law from what they would now do under the new provision and that, as a result, there is the chance they could face significant additional costs. Can I ask the Minister for reassurance on this issue?
I would also welcome further clarity around how, in practice, the Government expect local authorities and enforcement agencies to make these judgments. Can the Minister commit to working closely with the major sporting events bodies to ensure that any guidance that is provided addresses their concerns and ensures they are not unfairly penalised? Finally, can the Minister confirm that enforcement agencies cannot use this provision for a recurrent domestic sporting event, as a wronged party, to be asked to cover prosecution costs? I very much look forward to the Minister’s response and once again thank her for all her engagement and for bringing the Bill back in a better form than it left us.
Lord Fuller (Con)
My Lords, this Bill was sold to us as a special provision for a handful of those once-in-a-lifetime global sporting events that we would need to fight off other nations with a dirty stick for the right to host. All manner of regular sporting events in this country are fighting to jump on the bandwagon under the provisions of government Amendments 5 and 23. You cannot blame them for trying to get in but they should not be admitted.
Government Amendments 4, 11 and 17 recognise that the annual events already have special transport provisions in place, so I welcome the exclusion of those. Government Amendments 52 to 60 accept that the unauthorised association provisions would not apply, which is also welcome. However, we see that these annual events, as important as they are to our sporting life, are now included in what my noble friend has called a “two-tier muddle”, a half-in, half-out purgatory, in a Bill that was never meant to include them in the first place. It is important because, once included on the list, it gives the organisers of these events state-backed monopoly powers to enrich themselves at the expense of the fans and the casual follower.
At Second Reading, in Committee and on Report, I warned your Lordships and the Minister that FIFA was not the “good chap” the Government said it was. I warned against granting monopoly ticketing powers to FIFA and said that those powers would be abused. They were. The Government have already enabled FIFA’s ability to charge both the buyer and the seller of an excess ticket 15% each way. That is a 30% bid-offer spread. Now the Government want to extend those harms to the Open, Wimbledon and the Grand Prix. No wonder the sporting bodies welcome it. They would, would they not? So do my noble friend Lady Evans and all her sporting friends, but who is sticking up for the fans?
The legitimate secondary ticketing market operators, such as Ticketmaster and StubHub, with all the security and authentication processes in place, let those with a spare ticket match with somebody else. It enables choice and competition, but it is to be banned. The Government say they are on the side of fans but I cannot see how this is in anybody’s interests at all. The Government decried FIFA’s predatory pricing but are now enabling these monopoly powers, not just for FIFA but for the others.
Even if they press this matter, as I am sure they will, the Minister has missed out on an opportunity to strike a proper deal in the public interest. Events that come on to the list should be asked to forfeit broadcasting rights to make them free to air. Then we would see how much they want their monopoly powers. It is not too much to ask, but Labour does not understand the concept of leverage in negotiation.
It gets worse. In Amendment 37, the dead hand of the state will ensure that a ticket-touting offence would cover the giving of an event prize in a lottery for charity. The well-meaning fan offers his ticket to the local hospital charity, and the chair of trustees gets carted off to clink. Is this really where we have come to? Rather than rewarding these organisations, perhaps we should be calling in the CMA to have a proper look at these proposals, especially the extension of bans to regulated secondary ticketing, because they will otherwise harm fans and distort the market.
There is a ticket touts Bill coming. Let us have these debates then. In the meantime, let us not accidentally sleepwalk into giving the men in blazers another payday while the Government feed their habit at the expense of the jilted boyfriend who has a spare ticket because his girlfriend dumped him and he has not found a replacement yet.
My Lords, it was nice to hear the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, and his rather romantic view of the things that go wrong in sporting events. Along with the noble Baroness, Lady Evans, I congratulate the Government on having listened—the whole of government listened. We had to make more noise than we should have done, but they have listened. That is definitely a step in the right direction.
If we go forward with this, there is one other question on which I should like the Minister to go a little further. We have said that it is a five-year thing. How does a domestic sporting event arrive at this status? How does it get up there? Can we make that a little clearer? Also, how does a sporting event decline? Some advice on that would help, because we would know what the progress is. Just because something has happened, it does not mean that it should continue to do so.
The agenda could get quite crowded here if all sporting events come in: which ones will be up there and which ones will actually take part? The Grand Prix, Wimbledon and the marathon would probably qualify, but all events can be downgraded, especially in professional sport, in terms of the structures behind them. I hope that does not happen, but it is possible. Could we have just a little more information about how you can slip from this status or climb to it? That would help us. It is a genuine concern.
The main thrust of this is good. We all agreed that we need a package of measures and that we need to take them up and do something with them for the big international sporting events. We acknowledged that some are of international significance. Let us try to make sure that we maintain that status. Let us see how we can do that. The whole House should be in favour of that; the noble Baroness, Lady Evans, raised one or two caveats, which I am interested to hear the answer to, but the basic principle behind this is sound. With one or two questions, I wish the Bill well.
We from these Benches welcome the Bill and, as mentioned by other noble Lords, the approach that the Minister has taken throughout. We are delighted that she is still here post reshuffle. We welcome the inclusion of the other major events; I very much thank my noble friend Lady Evans for raising those and look forward to the reply to her questions on that, so that we can understand exactly how it is all going to work.
Organisations have approached me with concerns, which were brought up in the other place, about the control of pop-up parking facilities. Farmers having car parks can cause chaos with major event organisations’ transportation. I welcome the Minister’s views on that.
Very quickly and separately, I raise a concern about the impact on our ability to host these major events following the change to the CQC requirements, which will require every medical person at an event to have an £1,000 registration. There will be a lot of admin behind that. I have just received a letter, as many other noble Lords have, from the US Olympic & Paralympic Committee, saying that the cost and burdens that this will add will be not only a real deterrent for sporting bodies to hold training camps here but a reason why it would be reluctant to support major events, such as the Olympics, being held here. It is a burden that no other country in the world places. I know that the Minister is very aware of this and very supportive of what we are trying to do. This will come up in the Health Bill, to which I have tabled an amendment. I would appreciate the Minister’s support in this particular course and thank her and all noble Lords for this very encouraging Bill.
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have taken part in this concise, considered and constructive debate on the amendments made in the other place. The only thing I will say on the speech made by the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, is that it is always nice to hear an alternative perspective when everybody else is in agreement across your Lordships’ House.
Throughout the Bill’s passage, your Lordships’ House has brought a breadth of knowledge and expertise from a number of noble Lords’ remarkable sporting careers or oversight and involvement in delivering some of the most high-profile events. The scrutiny that this has provided will ensure that the Bill leaves this House in a definitely stronger form than when it arrived. I am grateful to all noble Lords, in particular the noble Baronesses, Lady Bonham-Carter of Yarnbury, Lady Grey-Thompson and Lady Evans of Bowes Park, and the noble Lords, Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay, Lord Markham, Lord Foulkes of Cumnock and Lord Addington—last but by no means least.
I also thank our outstanding recurrent events sector for its engagement over a number of months, which has been invaluable in shaping and refining the Government’s thinking. The Government have listened carefully to the points that have been raised. This package of amendments addresses concerns that have been highlighted. We believe that it strikes the right balance between supporting major events and ensuring that the framework is fair and proportionate in its operation.
I turn to the points made by the noble Baroness, Lady Evans of Bowes Park, on the differing approaches taken for itinerant and recurrent events. For itinerant bid-for events, government and host cities are often required to make commitments to event owners which include covering the costs of enforcing advertising and trading restrictions. Recurrent domestic events, even those with international standing, are delivered independently of the Government and in co-operation with local authorities.
The concept of recurrent event organisers paying local authorities for discretionary services to support event delivery is not novel. What would be novel, and not reasonable, would be to expect local or national taxpayers to bear the additional costs arising from the application of these provisions to an event, given that it is generally the event organiser that is expected to gain economically from their application. For such events, access to these provisions is by application only. Therefore, it is for the event organisers to weigh up the associated benefits and potential costs.
That the House do agree with the Commons in their Amendments 2 to 60.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, I have to say, speaking on behalf of the Conservative Benches, that our party does not approve of this Bill. We are the party of private enterprise and prosperity, and the competition that creates that prosperity. We are proud of what the privatised railways have achieved in fantastically increased numbers of passengers and wonderful new rolling stock, which the Treasury would never have paid for if the railways had not been taken out of that system and put into a privatised structure.
None the less, we recognise the need for reform. Those who go back to my speech on the Bill two years ago, which began the process of terminating the TOCs franchises, will recall that I said then that the system that had been adopted had shown cracks, and that these were well exposed when we came to Covid. Reform is needed, and we set in hand the Williams review to point the way. It created the single controlling mind that the Government and the Minister wish to see brought into the railways, but it continued to involve the private sector in the running of passenger rail services.
The problem the Government have made for themselves in deciding to be both the single controlling mind—effectively, the regulator of the system—and a provider of passenger rail services is that they have created a load of internal tensions, because they are in competition with other private parties. For example, they are in competition for access to the track and in relation to retail sales, and online retail sales in particular, where they are going to be both the competitor and the decision-maker. It could be said that there is an appeals system to the ORR, but that appeals system is extremely exiguous and rests only on judicial review grounds. The Government have created these problems for themselves, and they are going to arise again on Report.
We should bear in mind that, after this Bill has been brought into effect and the system has been completed—which will take some years, I admit—only 75% of the movements on the rails will be GBR movements. The other 25% will be non-GBR movements, principally freight, existing open access services, the large number of services provided by mayors—in particular London Overground, London Underground, Merseyrail and so forth—and a certain amount of heritage rail traffic. These are now going to be in competition for access to the track, but their main competitor will be deciding who gets that access.
To understand the mentality of those who are proposing this structure from the Government’s point of view, I quote from the consultation document, published last week, for the new licence that GBR will be given. In it, the Government say:
“It is vital that GBR can operate with authority, independence, and clear strategic direction, without the day-to-day influence of government or disproportionate regulatory burden”.
I can think of many private companies and businesses in this country that would like to be able to say that they operate without day-to-day government interference or a disproportionate regulatory burden. They do not get that pass, but GBR wants it. It is not keen to be accountable to Parliament; it wants that independence and does not want a strong regulatory system in control of it. That is dangerous and, as I said, something that various amendments continue to address.
This amendment addresses a most egregious clause—Clause 1(3)—which states that, once GBR has been designated, a process that the Secretary of State is required to go through,
“no Minister of the Crown, and no person who is a member of the body”—
GBR—
“may take any steps that will result in the body ceasing to be wholly owned by the Crown”.
The Government will say that all this does is to require primary legislation for the privatisation of GBR in the future. I say that it goes way beyond that, as “any steps” would include an incoming Minister for a new Government instructing civil servants to prepare such legislation. The clause is drafted far too widely and it should go.
I pulled it out as a small illustration of the—what shall I call it?—arrogance or hubris on the part of those who wish to see a railway system that is almost completely free of governmental control, parliamentary accountability and regulatory conformity. The clause ought to go and the Minister should be willing to say so. With that, I beg to move.
My Lords, I am happy to agree with my noble friend on the Front Bench. The Bill confers extraordinarily wide-ranging powers on what is said to be an independent railway but which is, of course, to be a nationalised railway, directly under the control and direction of the Secretary of State, so there is an inherent contradiction. The public will regard a nationalised railway as a plaything of the Secretary of State and hold him or her responsible for its performance and for the general policy.
My noble friend pointed to one of many examples in the current drafting where the Bill goes far too far and is wide-ranging in granting undue powers to this nationalised, allegedly independent body. This is a body that will be funded by the taxpayer, with representations by politicians to the management. Of course, the politicians will have the power to call the management to account for performance and their expenditure of public money. They will be asking the management about bad performance and, heaven forbid, accidents and safety problems that might occur, because, naturally, these will be part of public and national debate and interest. Like my noble friend, I urge the Minister to think again.
As my noble friend rightly says, a quarter of the railway will still be operated by other interests, not the nationalised company itself. It is terribly important that there are fair terms when judging how to use the limited track space and train routes available, and when considering where to place the new investments. Quite often, services improve because of open access or the threat of open access, and I do not think we will succeed with the shared aim that the Government and people such as me have of greatly expanding rail freight, which will be in the private sector, unless there is a fair way of assessing the relative claims on the track space and the new investment available. I urge the Government to think again, and I back my noble friend.
My Lords, I disagree with the two noble Lords who have spoken. I point out to the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, that the Green Party is the party of prosperity and human survival. I will try to include some of that in my amendments in the next group. In fact, I think the Bill does not go far enough in putting the railway into public ownership. In spite of all the Minister’s kindnesses in explaining it to me, I still think that GBR should be wholly publicly owned.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, I will start this group from a very different place from the other Front Bench. First, I put on record my sincere thanks to the Minister and his excellent team of officials, who have spent so much time answering our queries and discussing issues with us that were raised in Committee. We on these Benches are very grateful.
I will be brief in setting out why we on these Benches cannot support Amendment 1 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan. Clause 1(3) is a short provision, but it does a great deal of work. It provides that once a body has been designated as Great British Railways, it must remain wholly owned by the Crown. As the noble Lord’s explanatory statement makes clear, removing it would open the way for Great British Railways to become privately owned.
We should take a step back and be clear where this Bill comes from. Setting up Great British Railways as a publicly owned body to run a railway in public ownership was a clear commitment in the Government’s manifesto. The Government were elected on that commitment, with a large majority in the other place. It may not be the model—
Just very briefly, the question at issue—I hope the noble Baroness will agree—is whether a new Government might be elected on a mandate to privatise Great British Railways and whether they then should have this obstacle placed in their path.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
If the noble Lord will let me finish, I will come on to that. It may not be the model that we on these Benches would have chosen, but it is the Government’s choice. A publicly owned Great British Railways is not simply a detail of the Bill; it is the point of it. It is not for this House to undo by amendment on Report the central purpose of a Bill that the electorate has endorsed.
I also gently remind the noble Lord that his party’s manifesto at the last election promised a Great British Railways that would be a state-owned public body, although I accept that running the different lines would probably have been through a concession model. Keeping Clause 1(3) does not bind any future Government. A future Government with their own mandate would remain free to bring forward legislation to change it as they saw fit. The clause ensures that any such change is made openly through Parliament on the strength of that mandate.
Beyond that, the amendment would also put at risk the stability that the Bill is designed to provide. Without Clause 1(3), the ownership of Great British Railways would be left exposed to every passing political headwind, and the body would never be able to operate with the security it needs. Great British Railways will plan across five-year funding periods and beyond. It will work in long-term partnership with the devolved Governments and local and strategic authorities, and it will commission rolling stock that will be in service for decades. None of that is possible if the ownership of the institution and so its purpose is always open to question. This amendment is designed simply to destabilise Great British Railways and to undermine the Bill. We on these Benches will not support it should the noble Lord choose to press the issue.
My Lords, I am disappointed to see Amendment 1, which is of course a wrecking amendment, from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, tabled for today. I thought the noble Lord and I had exhausted the topic of public ownership, given how thoroughly it had been discussed during the passage of both the public ownership Act and of this Bill so far.
While the Benches opposite may not agree with public ownership, it is entirely in keeping with the commitment made to the British public in the manifesto on which this Government were elected. I think the British public, three-quarters of whom support public ownership, would be confused to see a departure from a very clear manifesto commitment, as the noble Lord’s amendment proposes. The amendment would, in effect, remove the provision whereby an Act of Parliament is required to change the ownership structure of our railways. Given that transparency has been a repeated theme across our debates, I am at a loss as to why noble Lords on the Opposition Benches are now trying to allow one of the most significant possible changes of all—privatising Great British Railways—to be done behind closed doors and with no parliamentary scrutiny.
The noble Lord makes the point that the provision would prevent a future Government privatising the railways. That is not the case. The provision prevents Ministers or those in GBR taking steps that will result in GBR ceasing to be wholly owned by the Crown—for example, by selling shares in GBR. It does not stop a Minister considering, taking advice on or legislating on privatising the railways, as these are activities that may result in GBR ceasing to be wholly owned, depending on the will of Parliament, of course.
The noble Lord also said that this was unprecedented, but it is not. The Great British Energy Act 2025 also includes a provision, in Clause 1, that equally requires an Act of Parliament before privatising a body receiving significant sums of taxpayers’ money. The Bill does not prevent a future Government making the case that private operation of the railways is preferable. It simply means that that proposition will continue to require an Act of Parliament and appropriate democratic scrutiny, just as it has in this instance to bring the railways back into public hands. That prohibition against nationalisation, interestingly, was also still in place under the previous Government’s draft rail reform Bill, so I really do not see the noble Lord’s point here.
Finally, I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, for her appreciation of the work of my officials, and for her engagement and that of her officials. I encourage the noble Lord to withdraw his amendment.
My Lords, perhaps as a result of the meeting the Minister and I had this morning, for which I am very grateful, he has understood the import of the amendment in a way that, perhaps, the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, has not. It is not, of course, about allowing privatisation of the railway through the back door; it is about the binding of a future elected Government from putting their own manifesto into effect.
The Minister has addressed that, in the sense that he says that the word “will” is not the word “may”. In the Government’s view—he has said this at the Dispatch Box—this does not prevent an incoming Government preparing, proposing and, if possible, passing legislation to privatise Great British Railways. All those steps, although they are steps, and the Secretary of State is prevented from taking steps, only “may” result in privatisation. The word “will” does not apply, and it is only “will” that appears in the Bill. That is a very important exegetical point. It is very valuable that the Minister has said that at the Dispatch Box. It has legal weight and in the light of that, I am content to withdraw my amendment.
My Lords, I realise that, by the end of this group, noble Lords will absolutely loathe me as I have 18 amendments in it and I intend to speak on all of them. I apologise in advance for keeping noble Lords here. However, this Bill is important, and it is important to me as a Green Party person who cares about getting people off the roads.
One of the things that worries me about the Bill is the fact that the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024 will effectively be repealed in its entirety. This dismantles the protections for public ownership, including that a public sector company must always be wholly owned by the Secretary of State. The Minister has been generous with his time to explain this to me, but it is still a cause of concern for me. However, I do not intend to push any of my amendments to a vote.
On Report in the Commons, the Government quietly made amendments to define Great British Railways companies as “subsidiaries” under Section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006. This means that almost any railway function could end up part-owned by the private sector through a range of private shareholding arrangements, including private investors owning just under 50% of a company, provided that GBR retains a controlling stake. This definition was chosen instead of “wholly owned subsidiaries”, also available under Section 1159 of the Companies Act 2006. This much more obvious choice would have aligned with the 2024 Act, which required that public sector companies always be wholly owned by the public. This definition would still allow a broad range of partnerships with the private sector, as can be seen in the example of Platform4, a wholly owned subsidiary of Network Rail. Platform4 has a variety of joint ventures in property development, even as a minority partner at 33%. There is no need for a subsidiary status to enable this. One justification given so far is that a subsidiary status is necessary for property development, but we can see that this is not necessary due to the wide range of joint ventures that are already under way with Platform4.
From discussion with the Minister earlier today, the Government’s position appears to be that majority public control is sufficient and that private investment should be permitted where it brings additional money into the railway. I understand the argument for attracting investment, but I do not accept that attracting private investment requires private ownership of companies exercising public railway functions. There is a difference between allowing a wholly publicly owned company to enter into commercial partnerships and allowing private shareholders to earn a substantial stake in the company itself. As far as I understand it, this means that any GBR statutory function in Clause 3(1) could end up part-privatised, so there is no protection even for infrastructure management. Why is the latter necessary? What prevents private shareholders extracting profits from companies whose functions and assets are ultimately part of our publicly owned railway?
I also oppose the Government’s Amendment 3. I see this as a complex and worrying two-part amendment that needs a proper clear explanation, not as something that can be brought in and waved through at the last minute. We know from Clause 3(5) that GBR can exercise any of its statutory functions through one or more GBR companies. Proposed new Clause 3(5A) says that such companies should not be regarded as agents for GBR when exercising these core functions. But if that is the case, what other legal relationship is in place and how does that relationship ensure legal accountability? On this point, the GBR licence consultation that has just been published, much too late for consideration of this Bill, tells us that GBR’s subsidiaries will not require their own separate licences and will instead be covered by the parent company’s licence. This also means they will not be accountable to the ORR for licence enforcement. This relationship between GBR and a GBR subsidiary is key, yet here we learn nothing about what it will be—only that it will not be an agency relationship. Why is it thought necessary to exclude agency arrangements in the first place? What relationship will exist instead for functions exercised under Clause 3(5), and how will this provide accountability to GBR subsidiaries?
Proposed new Clause 3(5B) says that a GBR company or any other person can exercise core functions of GBR as an agent if it is done outside the arrangements of Clause 3(5). I find this extremely worrying. It seems to be saying that any statutory function of GBR can be contracted out to any person and that all the core functions are eligible to be contracted out to the private sector. This is the first time we are learning that such functions could be carried out outside GBR altogether. What protections are there here for public sector control? Is it the case that literally any statutory function, even infrastructure management, could in theory be carried out by private sector companies under the Bill?
Amendment 48 concerns another area where the protections of the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act 2024 are being dismantled. The 2024 Act ensured that mainline passenger rail services would always be awarded to a public sector company, but now we have loopholes in Chapter 1 of Part 2 of the Bill on the designation and exemption of services. It was a strong theme in our Committee—and it is fair to say that it was agreed by Peers across most parties—that there is no clear definition of “designation” and “exemption”, and that there are serious drafting issues in this section.
Clauses 25 and 31 require that the Secretary of State
“must designate railway passenger services, or a description of railway passenger services”,
but only that she “may” secure the provision of those services. Only when the Secretary of State personally secures designated services is there a requirement to do so
“by making a direct award of a public service contract … to one or more of Great British Railways or a GBR company”.
However, there is no actual requirement for the Secretary of State to secure the services she designates, nor any provision to say how services would otherwise be secured. This omission seems to create space for any type of contract to be awarded by and to any party. This is such a problematic loophole in the Bill that it seems it cannot stand, on the basis of drafting quality alone.
You have all have been very kind in not pointing that out to me. I will say only that my other amendments are incredibly important as well.
My Lords, I spent the morning throwing out of my office a huge amount of paper—reports dating back to when I first came here in 1999. I urge all noble Lords who are thinking of leaving, or maybe dying, to get rid of some of their stuff, because you get some irrelevant rubbish lying around.
First, I would like to talk about when I first came here. A very junior clerk in the other place was one of the staff on the Transport Committee, then chaired by the late Robert Adley. It is very pleasing to see that junior clerk now holding a very senior position in this House. It is very nice to see the progression of people as they make their way.
Perhaps I may say how much I have appreciated all the help from all quarters of the House, whether in coalition or government. That help came from all staff and Members of the House, some of whom I have disagreed with and others I have agreed with. It does good to reflect on the part you have played in a bit of history.
The thing I really want to address is the fact the railways are a long-term industry. The assets that they use last at least 30 years, and some last as long as 100 years or more. The settlement provided under the Railways Act 1993 suited the then Government, who were anxious to get rid of the rolling stock for virtually nothing and, at the beginning, were anxious that the track be separated into what became Railtrack. That was an abject failure in attempting to cater for the long-term needs of the industry, because the people who ran those businesses were interested only in profit and in piling up the debt, which eventually fell on to the public sector.
We then come to what we should do about it. This is very important. I want the Minister to commit that the Government will treat the industry as a long-term investment and will revise the money spent on a 10-year or longer basis—not periodically but as a rolling programme—and that they will ensure that the various bureaucrats in the department, in the Treasury and in government as a whole do not make arbitrary decisions to cut investment, as they have in the past. I remind myself that no really responsible railwayman has been involved in HS2 or the intercity express programme—two things that have failed absolutely because there was no proper professional input.
My Lords, I will spend a few minutes following the speech by the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, by saying a few words about him, because I believe that this is his last appearance here. I can quite see that he does not want to stay here until midnight to move his Amendment 13, but he has spoken a lot of common sense about what is in the amendment.
I had the honour of introducing the noble Lord. I was here a couple of years before he was, and we marched up and nodded to everybody you have to nod to. He entered the Lords in July 1999, after a really successful career as general manager of the great western region of the railway—we still miss him there—as well as in buses: Ulsterbus and Citybus Ltd in Belfast. Of course, he was also a special adviser to the Commons Transport Committee and a fellow of Wolfson College. I have not always agreed with what we have done on railways together, but I have enormous respect for what he has done here since 1999. I know noble Lords will join me in wishing him a long and happy retirement. I hope he will come back occasionally and make such excellent interventions as the one he has just made. I wish him all the best.
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley. With his great experience and knowledge of the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, he said all that needs to be said about his valedictory speech. I do not think I am able to add much.
I want to speak briefly about Amendments 23 and 25 in the name of my noble friend Lord Lansley, who is unable to be here today. He wanted me to draw them to the Minister’s attention and, we hope, secure a helpful commitment that means we will not need to pursue them.
The amendments would require the rail strategy to be laid before Parliament. Then, if the House chose to pass a Motion on that rail strategy, the Secretary of State would have to respond to that Motion. We had a debate on this in Committee and the Minister indicated at that stage that he did not feel he was able to support the amendments as drafted. I hope that he will be able to at least give a commitment from the Dispatch Box that, when the Government publish the rail strategy, they will lay it at least as a Written Statement before the House. I hope, although I know this is not entirely within the Minister’s power, that he will make best endeavours to have an Oral Statement so that we are able to question him on it. I look forward to listening to him being able to give a commitment, or something like it, when he responds to this group.
My Lords, I wonder whether I might pay my own tribute to the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw. He and I joined this House in exactly the same month in 1999, but I had known him for a long time before that, when he was a very senior manager at British Railways. If it does not embarrass him, I hope he will allow me to say that he was the epitome of a dedicated public servant, working for a nationalised industry in the public interest. There are very few people it has been my privilege to know in the way that I know the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, of whom that can be said. He is, I think, the last serving railwayman in this House, following the sad death of the noble Lord, Lord Snape.
I too wish the noble Lord a very long and happy retirement. His political career has been very distinguished. The fact that all his parliamentary colleagues were there to hear his valedictory speech spoke volumes. He was a distinguished county councillor in Oxfordshire. He has contributed a huge amount to the railway, to local government and, above all, to this House. I am very grateful to him for that and I wish him well.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, it is a genuine pleasure to have listened to my noble friend Lord Bradshaw’s valedictory speech and his wise words on this Bill. I wholeheartedly support his amendment, pushing once again for a long-term funding settlement for the railways beyond the five-year control periods that we see today, and for a rolling programme. Major infrastructure, as we know, takes decades to design and build, and funding is certainly crucial. You have only to look at the headlines today about Vauxhall Bridge needing massive investment, otherwise it will soon be closed to buses and then all vehicles, to show the constant need to maintain and invest in transport infrastructure.
My noble friend Lord Bradshaw became a life Peer in July 1999 as Baron Bradshaw, of Wallingford in the County of Oxfordshire. He has given more than 27 years of service to the House. As we have heard, one of Bill’s supporters on that day was the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, from the Labour Benches. We have seen Bill work tirelessly cross-party to secure the transport system that we need. Bill is known as a railwayman through and through, which is not surprising given that, as we have heard, he was a British Rail management trainee and rose up through many roles to become a general manager in the early 1980s before a distinguished career running a bus company in Belfast. Bill is even featured at the National Railway Museum, having provided an oral history some years ago.
Politically, as we have heard, Bill was an Oxfordshire county councillor for 15 years and a member of the Thames Valley Police Authority. He has brought expertise and wisdom to this House in the railway, public services and his work in transport. Bill acted as our transport spokesperson for many years. He has been an incredible mentor to me personally and a great support over many years, long before I came to this House. We salute Bill for all his work and wish him a happy retirement from this House, though we still look forward to his emails with his thoughts on current issues.
I will move briefly to some of the other amendments in this group, many of which we discussed in great detail in Committee. Amendment 23, from the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, would require the rail strategy to be laid before Parliament and debated. I absolutely agree that this long-term strategy should be debated in Parliament, but I do not think that this needs to be in primary legislation, as we have heard. I hope the Government will provide a means to debate this important document.
Amendment 33, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, about disabled passengers is important, but we have a substantive group on accessibility on day 2, when my noble friend Lady Brinton and the noble Baroness, Lady Grey-Thompson, have a detailed range of amendments for consideration, bringing their in-depth knowledge on the subject.
In Amendment 36, also from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, she has retabled my noble friend Lord Russell’s amendment from Committee. It raises important points. The Government set out their commitment and work in this area in Committee, and we strongly believe that getting more people on to the railway is key, hence our amendments at a later stage, which I hope the noble Baroness will be able to support.
Government Amendment 22 is a welcome measure to ensure that Great British Railways is properly captured by relevant consumer rights legislation. I look forward to the Minister’s response to this group, and I thank again my noble friend Lord Bradshaw for championing the railway and public transport over the decades.
My Lords, I endorse what my noble friend Lord Harper has said about the amendments tabled by my noble friend Lord Lansley, who sadly cannot be in his place today.
I have considerable sympathy with the amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw; indeed, in Committee I put my name to an amendment that he had tabled which was very similar in character. It does not seek to constrain the Government in how they spend their money but says that, if the Government were to change a long-term settlement, they must publish, in effect, an impact assessment and explain what its consequences would be. I would have thought that that was something that, when he rises to speak, the Minister might be willing to endorse, because it seems to me good practice.
The noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, has had a long and distinguished career in the railway industry and has considerably contributed to your Lordships’ House over the years, having spent 25 years with British Rail and subsequently serving as professor of transport management at the University of Salford. He has brought a wealth of practical experience and knowledge to our debates. Since joining this House in 1999, he has consistently drawn on that experience in scrutinising transport policy and legislation, and indeed other matters. While we may not always agree on every aspect of railway policy, his expertise and commitment to improving our railways are greatly valued across your Lordships’ House. I wish him well in his retirement, which I hope will be happy and long.
I turn to Amendments 6, 8A and 47, in my name. Amendment 6 would extend the Secretary of State’s power to issue directions to GBR beyond its statutory functions to its wider commercial activities. I am still left completely baffled as to why the Secretary of State, who is given a power to direct Great British Railways in its railway activities, is forbidden to issue directions in relation to other activities. The parallel with which I am accustomed—as the Minister is accustomed, from past experience—is with the Mayor of London, who also has a power of direction over Transport for London but can direct it in all aspects of its activities if he chooses to do so. As it happens, that is a rarely used power; it has been used only a handful of times during the course of the mayoralty, and then largely for technical reasons in order to facilitate something that Transport for London wanted, rather than to impose on its board something that it did not want. None the less, the arbitrary distinction seems to me quite wrong.
After all, let us bear in mind that Great British Railways, in its commercial activities, will benefit from an implicit government guarantee. It will therefore not be an ordinary commercial company in competition with other commercial companies in the same sector. Those activities will certainly include the development of property—that is already envisaged—but may extend to the provision of consultancy services, the development of technology that it wishes to sell and the provision of services to railway undertakings in other countries. These are all possibilities, and, in my view, many of them would be welcome possibilities as commercial activities for Great British Railways, but why should they not be subject to a power of direction? It is an illusion to think that Great British Railways will be operating as an ordinary independent commercial company. In a competitive sphere, it will have a built-in advantage, and it needs to be accountable.
What if, in the course of those commercial activities—and I hope this will not happen—Great British Railways loses a load of money? It is the taxpayer, of course, who will have to ante up whatever deficiency exists, and the Secretary of State will be able to say that she was not in any way accountable as she had no power of direction. I know the Minister will say that she can always sack the chairman of the company, but that is a nuclear option, and not something which leads to open debate as to its consequences. Any such action is normally accompanied by confidential documents relating to human resources matters and term and payments, which the Secretary of State would not feel able to discuss in the other place, whereas a straightforward direction, written in black and white on a piece of paper, is something on which she could be questioned and held accountable, as she should be. Such unaccountable commercial activity of Great British Railways is something I warn against. The power of direction is needed if we are going to keep it accountable.
My Lords, before going into the other amendments in this group, I would like to address Amendment 13, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw. He will not be surprised to know that I cannot support it, as I was unable to in Committee. However, before getting into the details of this amendment, I hope the House will permit me some warm words.
It is typical of the noble Lord that his valedictory speech is to support an amendment that seeks to put railway funding on a long-term stable trajectory. He, above anyone else in your Lordships’ House, knows why such a trajectory is a good thing. Bill, if the House will forgive me for being familiar, started his career on the railway as a porter at Slough, when I was still at primary school. He became a graduate trainee for British Railways in 1959. He made his way up the ladder of operational management, becoming general manager of the British Railways Western Region in the 1980s. After that, as we have heard, he made serious contributions to transport in Northern Ireland, to the bus industry and to wider transport policy. He is the embodiment of the dedication and commitment, matched with real operational experience, of senior railway managers.
Subsequent generations, including mine, look up to him as a fount of wisdom and knowledge, and he has been both an ally and, occasionally and rightly, a critic of mine as the Bill has progressed. I am delighted that he has been here to see the conclusive progress of the Bill, to reunite our railway network into coherent national control. I know I will continue to hear from him, just as the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, will. His emails, like his speech, are pithy and direct. The Government, my industry and I pay tribute to him, as this House does, and we all wish him well in his retirement.
To the amendment at hand, the noble Lord is quite right to prompt debate on this. It is true that the railway is a long-term business, with the life of some infrastructure assets, as the noble Lord, Lord Bradshaw, said, extending for 100 or 130 years. I think the oldest artefact is now 202 years old. I therefore absolutely agree that railway funding must be safeguarded as far as possible. There are clear roles for both GBR and the Office of Rail and Road set out in the Bill. Ministers will always be ultimately accountable for the funding choices of government, but the best outcomes for the railway can be achieved only by listening to the experts put in place to run it.
The Bill as drafted requires that the ORR be notified of material changes to funding, as the noble Lord says, before they are enacted. In practice, regular ORR engagement will be a core pillar of GBR’s accountability framework and DfT sponsorship. This means that the ORR will already play an important part in the routine assessments and will have the powers to seek additional information as needed. It is therefore already possible—in fact likely—that, in practice, the ORR will publish assessments of the impact of funding reductions, exactly as the noble Lord hopes. I hope this helps to reassure him and that he might not press his amendment.
I will now speak to the amendments tabled in my name. Amendment 3 is designed to correct the drafting of Clause 3 to ensure that it is clear. It would clarify that the current provision which allows GBR to delegate its functions to its subsidiaries does not automatically create an agency arrangement between GBR and the subsidiary. As noble Lords can imagine, contractual partners will want clarity over whether they are partnering with a GBR subsidiary or with GBR itself. If this ambiguity remained in the Bill, it could make GBR a less attractive commercial partner. New Clause 3(5A) inserted by my amendment therefore clarifies that the delegation provision does not by default create an agency arrangement, while new Clause 3(5B) expressly preserves GBR’s freedom to transparently establish such an arrangement if that were to be desirable. This is in line with usual company arrangements and was always the intention of the Bill.
My Amendments 22 and 122 were previously tabled for discussion in Committee. They are about providing the ORR with direct consumer law enforcement powers. They would put the ORR on the same footing as the Competition and Markets Authority, which already has these powers, promoting a consistent approach to consumer protection across regulators. For example, this would ensure that consumers receive refunds promptly, rather than waiting for the conclusion of lengthy court proceedings. The amendments will not create new investigatory powers or criminal offences, or interact with criminal law in any way. As I promised the noble Lord, Lord Grayling, should the ORR exercise its powers to enter premises for the purposes of consumer law enforcement, we would expect it to report transparently on its use of those powers. I therefore commend these amendments to the House.
I shall now respond to the other amendments in this group, starting with Amendments 47 and 48. The Bill as drafted allows local leaders to make decisions about their rail services if they have been devolved. This is not in opposition to public ownership of national rail services. The key requirement of this Bill is that decisions about passenger services and infrastructure must be brought together within a coherent, accountable system. The best way in which to do this is for the Secretary of State’s passenger services to be provided by the same publicly owned company that is managing the infrastructure. We have seen the risk of misaligned incentives and divided responsibility that national private operation of rail brings, and these reforms will fix those. Equally, it is right to give local leaders the choice about how to deliver those services, once they have been fully devolved. Those two things can coexist, as they do now.
On public ownership, I turn to Amendments 2, 126, 128, 130 and 134 from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones. These amendments would not allow for circumstances where it is desirable for a majority-owned but not wholly owned GBR subsidiary to take on activities that would fall within the functions. For example, the amendment would restrict a joint venture from undertaking property development and related infrastructure work, such as constructing a station building, even where that would be the most sensible and efficient way of managing the work. The right approach here is one of flexibility, to allow GBR to harness private sector investment effectively and ensure that future collaborations between the public sector and private sector can be pursued, while GBR also maintains public control and ownership of its core functions.
Turning to Amendment 6 from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, I recognise his intention to ensure that GBR remains appropriately accountable for the full range of activities it undertakes, including those arising from its status as a company. As we have discussed before, GBR will be established as a company under the Companies Act 2006 and, like any company, will have the general capacity to undertake activities beyond those set out in the Bill, such as property development. That flexibility is deliberate. However, even though the directions power will apply only to GBR’s railway functions, appropriate oversight of other activities, such as property development, will instead be provided through established shareholder governance arrangements, as set out in the framework document between the Secretary of State and GBR, alongside performance monitoring and funding controls.
I believe it will. I am sure the current framework document between Network Rail and the Secretary of State is a public document, and I am happy to commit that the framework document I am referring to will be published, too.
On Amendments 23 and 25, I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, and the points made on his behalf by the noble Lord, Lord Harper, that it is right that Parliament can see and scrutinise the strategy when it is published. That is why, as I promised the noble Lord, I commit today that, when the long-term rail strategy is published, I will not only draw it to the attention of the House and place it in the Library but bid for an Oral Statement to ensure that it can be debated. Although such bids are dependent on the scheduling and progress of business, I hope this demonstrates my commitment to seeking to ensure appropriate scrutiny for the strategy and allows the noble Lord not to move Amendments 23 and 25.
Amendments 33, 65 and 72 would largely duplicate existing requirements. We are retaining the Rail Passengers’ Rights and Obligations Regulations 2010, with the rights under these regulations protected as minimum consumer standards in GBR’s licence, set and monitored by the passenger watchdog and enforced by the ORR. The rights of disabled passengers are also protected under existing legislation and consumer law. For example, the public sector equality duty will apply in full to GBR, its railway subsidiaries, Ministers and the ORR, ensuring that the rights provided under the Equality Act 2010 cannot be ignored. Legal rights establish important minimum standards for passengers and are already protected through the wider legislative and regulatory framework. However, the purpose of these duties is broader: to ensure that GBR, the Secretary of State, the watchdogs and the ORR actively pursue what is in passengers’ interests, including improvements that go well beyond the minimum legal requirements. As I said in Committee on trains with a catering provision, it would be in the interests of passengers, and disabled passengers in particular, for staff to offer at-seat catering. There is no legal right to have at-seat catering, but considering providing such a service is precisely the sort of operational decision I want GBR to take with passengers in mind.
On Amendments 34 and 36, I can assure the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, that the existing duty to promote the interests of passengers and potential passengers in Clause 18 would absolutely include considering the affordability of fares. However, it is important that this is achieved in balance with the other competing priorities that GBR will need to manage, so the Bill’s current drafting is, frankly, better.
Similarly, the Bill already covers an environmental duty, including environmental considerations explicitly in the public interest duty in Clause 18. In addition, as the discussion document published during Committee sets out, sustainability—including promoting modal shift, delivering net zero, protecting biodiversity, addressing air pollution and investing in climate adaptation—will feature in the long-term rail strategy as part of GBR’s strategic objectives. GBR must have regard to the strategy, so there are two separate duties with environmental components that GBR will be considering at every step of the process. Our interests are clearly aligned, and I hope the noble Baroness will not press the amendment.
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have taken part in this fascinating debate. I will withdraw my amendment but, as I did not finish my explanation for all my amendments, I will send my notes to the Minister. He can then see whether there is anything that he agrees with. I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
My Lords, I declare an interest as the chair of the White Rose Rail Board in Yorkshire. I pay tribute to my noble friend the Minister. It is true of all political parties, and it was true when I was in government, that sometimes Ministers do not listen and do not respond. That may be because of their take on how politics should work, because they are under orders, because they have been captured by the Civil Service or just because they are indifferent. However, this Minister does and I thank him for it. As a consequence of that, I can be incredibly brief.
These amendments seek to ensure that the future of Great British Railways is linked to the Government’s commitment to devolution and to a bottom-up as well as top-down approach to delivering public service. It was raised early in Committee that it would be important that strategic authorities, particularly those with wider transport requirements, should be included in a way that ensured that Great British Railways could not cut them out of consultation and involvement in the development of programmes and schemes at regional and local level; in other words, there should be a collaborative approach. I tabled an amendment as a consequence.
I understand that the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, pointed out in Committee that this would have incorporated only mayoral strategic authorities or combined authorities and that there were areas where local government collaboration coming together at this moment in time would be important as well. This amendment incorporates that and therefore encompasses the desire to ensure that, in a reasonable way, GBR would have to publish very clear criteria on why it had not consulted or was not willing to enter into collaboration with those devolved entities.
On that basis, I am grateful to my noble friend and hope that the House will agree this amendment.
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, and to agree with him on the spirit and tone in which the Minister has conducted himself. He has indeed listened.
Picking up the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, about my noble friend Lord Lansley, I thank the Minister. My noble friend wanted me to draw to the attention of the House that we are very grateful that he listened to the point that my noble friend made about the Bill as originally drafted not encompassing those strategic authorities that have chosen not to have mayors at the moment. I felt that this is important because, in my own county of Gloucestershire, we do not have one. The Minister said in Committee that he was listening on this issue. I am very pleased that he has affixed his name to a range of amendments that will make sure that GBR will work with all strategic local authorities, including those that do not have a mayor. That is very helpful, and I am pleased that the Minister listened.
I hope to advance the merits of Amendment 46 by christening it the “Burnham clause”. It does what the Prime Minister requested when he was Mayor of Greater Manchester. If the mayor of an established mayoral strategic authority asked for a particular service not to be designated as a passenger service under that part of the Bill then, rather than the Government just being able to abide by that request, this clause would insist upon it.
That was the request that Andy Burnham made when he was Mayor of Greater Manchester, and I think I am repeating it pretty accurately. I see that the Minister is smiling wryly. Now that Andy Burnham is Prime Minister and leads the Government, I hope the Minister will be able to look favourably on my amendment and accept it, thereby delivering the Prime Minister’s request that he made when he was Mayor of Greater Manchester. I therefore commend the amendment both to the House and to the Minister.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, I am delighted to speak in this important group on devolution and to support the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, a version of which I moved on his behalf in Committee. I also welcome, as other noble Lords have, the range of government amendments that have picked up the issue raised by noble Lords of the changes to local and regional government and ensuring that no area is left out due to its type of local government structure. Strategic authorities are key partners in the railway. The noble Lord, Lord Lansley, has tabled similar amendments on the Health Bill, so I feel we will be having discussions on that too.
With more metro mayors and other devolved strategic authorities, it is really important that local and regional governments are able to work with Great British Railways, and indeed propose to take over metro or other local lines where appropriate, as we have seen with the successful London Overground, overseen by the Minister when he was Commissioner of Transport for London. Great British Railways has to have an inclusive partnership approach, rather than a “we know best” approach, if the railway is to truly deliver for all our regions. I look forward to the Minister’s response.
My Lords, I will briefly join in this debate and say how much I regret not being able to participate in the earlier stages of the Bill, for various reasons. I congratulate my noble friend Lord Harper on bringing forward the “Burnham clause”. I worked with the Prime Minister when he was chairman of Rail North and I was chairman of Transport for the North.
There is an important point here. Railway lines and railway services do not end at county or even strategic mayoral boundaries. It is about getting a feed-across so that all the particular areas are involved and feel they have a say in how the services are run. If one looks at Manchester, one sees that those services run across Lancashire and Sheffield. They are important to the whole strategic area. The issue is how the consultation will be carried out by GBR when it has this wide-ranging power, so that people in other areas who do not feel they have a say do get a say, and how that is done through strategic bodies.
My worry is that it will be easy to dismiss those views because of the way in which capacity will come under such great pressure if we see an increase in the railways. As was said earlier by a number of people, whatever one feels about privatisation, the fact is that it has revolutionised the way in which rail capacity is being utilised in this country. The history of the growth of railway and passenger numbers is something I do not want to see us diminish by bringing in a new system that will come under the cost constraints of sometimes cutting services because they necessarily do not give the kind of returns that other services in urban areas may.
I congratulate my noble friend Lord Harper on his amendment, but I also agree with what the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, said about the way in which this issue is addressed. I am very pleased that it seems the Minister is in a listening mode—and not only a listening mode but an acting mode. That does not surprise me.
I welcome the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett. Again, it is a matter of transparency, with which one generally has some sympathy. I also congratulate my noble friend Lord Lansley, who is not in his place but who, through persistent argument in Committee, persuaded the Minister to put forward certain amendments in this group that help define “strategic authority” correctly so as to meet the Government’s intentions, which the original drafting of the Bill did not.
I support my noble friend Lord Harper’s Amendment 46, in which he seeks to give to mayors in the country at large exactly those powers that the former Mayor of Manchester so ardently desired when occupying that position and that I am sure, now that he is Prime Minister, he would wish to see available not only to his successor in Manchester but to other mayors. I hope that my noble friend will choose to divide the House on this amendment, because it is important that the Prime Minister should be able to see how many of his noble friends on the Government Benches actually support the policy he articulated so well and so fully when he was Mayor of Manchester.
My Lords, the railway works best when it reflects the needs and priorities of the community it serves. That is why the Bill establishes a statutory role for devolved Governments and strategic authorities within the future railway. I am pleased to announce that the Bill has already received legislative consent from the Scottish Parliament and that Welsh Ministers laid their recommendation to support the Bill on 6 November.
The Bill places devolved leaders at the heart of railway decision-making. GBR will be required to have regard to their transport plans and strategies, consult them before taking decisions that significantly affect their areas, and work with them through formal co-operation arrangements. These measures will help ensure that local priorities are taken into account in decisions about rail services, stations and wider transport integration, while providing a flexible framework that can adapt to different local circumstances and support stronger partnerships over time. The government amendments, and Amendment 4 in the name of my noble friend Lord Blunkett, build on that framework in three areas: strengthening our partnership with the devolved Governments, reinforcing the importance of local partnerships and extending key provisions to foundation strategic authorities.
Before turning to the amendments, I want to address the point raised by my noble friend Lord Boateng in Committee about the role of the railway in supporting regional economic growth. He was right to highlight its importance then and during our recent meeting with my honourable friend the Member for Hastings and Rye. The public interest duty in the Bill explicitly enables GBR to consider social and economic benefits, recognising that these important factors are linked. Economic growth and the genuine needs of communities must be considered together, and considered locally, regionally and nationally. This priority will also be reflected in the long-term rail strategy. In fact, the discussion document published last month specifically outlines the role of our railways in harnessing regional economic growth and highlights the areas that GBR will consider in order to deliver this. This an important topic and I look forward to discussing it further during the passage of the regulating for growth Bill.
On government Amendment 14, in securing Welsh Ministers’ support for the Bill, I committed to include a dedicated chapter on Wales and the borders within the statement of objectives issued as part of each funding settlement. Amendment 14 places that commitment on a statutory footing. I am pleased that we have been able to reach agreement on this issue, and I thank Mark Hooper MS, the Deputy Minister for Transport in Wales, and his officials for their constructive engagement throughout. The close collaboration between our Governments has helped to ensure that these reforms work for passengers and communities in Wales and the borders.
The statement of objectives will help guide the future partnership between Transport for Wales and Great British Railways. It demonstrates both our commitment to working with the Welsh Government and the importance that we attach to the memorandum of understanding that underpins that relationship.
On strategic authorities and Amendment 4, I thank my noble friend Lord Blunkett for tabling this amendment and for his constructive engagement on this issue since Committee. I also thank him and the noble Lord, Lord Harper, for their kind words. I totally agree with my friend, the noble Lord, that the partnership provisions in the Bill must operate in practice as well as in principle. GBR should engage seriously with proposals from local leaders, and the bar for GBR to reject a partnership must be exceptionally high.
Mayors, in particular, have a vital role to play in the future railway. They understand the needs of their communities, have responsibility for wider transport networks and economic growth and are best placed to bring rail together with local transport priorities. A nationally integrated railway must therefore work in close partnership with local leaders if it is to succeed. The Bill gives strategic authorities a strong statutory role within the railway. GBR will be required to have regard to their transport plans and strategies, consult them on decisions that significantly affect their areas and work with them through formal co-operation arrangements. These provisions are designed to ensure that mayors are more than simply engaged stakeholders and will play a meaningful role in shaping the railway in their areas.
We are already putting that approach into practice. Each mayoral strategic authority now has a nominated railway leader from the industry. This provides mayors with a single point of accountability for rail matters in their area. We are working with the rail industry to establish mayoral-led local partnership boards across the established mayoral strategic authorities. Memoranda of understanding have been agreed in West Yorkshire and the north-east, allowing mayors to set out their priorities clearly ahead of the creation of GBR.
Across Yorkshire, we are working with the mayors to build on the white rose agreement and the work led by my noble friend Lord Blunkett on improving rail connectivity across Yorkshire. Through that collaboration, government, local leaders and the rail industry are working together to deliver a railway that better supports Yorkshire’s communities and economy. We are seeing the same commitment to strong local partnership in Greater Manchester. Local and rail industry partners are already working together to integrate rail into the Bee Network, with pay-as-you-go rail schemes in the region being introduced as part of the phased Bee Network integration from this December. We are also working with Transport for Greater Manchester to develop the scope for a future local commissioning partnership. This could see the mayor funding and commissioning outcomes from GBR, further supporting the role of rail alongside the Bee Network.
That is the kind of relationship we want to see between GBR and local leaders. Where a partnership proposal is not taken forward, there should be transparency about why. This amendment will therefore require GBR to publish a reasoned explanation where it decides not to enter into proposed arrangements or arrangements that are substantially similar. That will provide transparency and accountability while preserving the flexibility needed to reach the right outcome in each case. Thus, I am pleased to support Amendment 4 and commend it to the House.
On Amendment 46 from the noble Lord, Lord Harper, the Government’s commitment to working closely with mayors does not mean that every request for further devolution should automatically be granted. The Government are committed to rewiring the state, with greater local control of rail services for mayors being a core part of the agenda. We support further rail devolution where it is in the interests of passengers and the wider network. The Bill already provides a route to achieve that. It preserves the existing power to exempt services from designation, while Section 53 of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act 2026 provides a formal route through which established mayoral strategic authorities can seek additional rail powers. Such proposals will be considered by the Secretary of State in accordance with the department’s rail devolution guidance.
This approach is entirely consistent with the principle of devolving by default, set out in the Cabinet statement, Rewiring the State. That principle does not mean that powers must automatically be devolved whenever requested. Rather, it means that decisions should start from a presumption in favour of devolution and consider whether powers can be best exercised locally rather than nationally. As the accompanying policy paper makes clear,
“where policies or services are being designated or altered, Secretaries of State will need to justify holding them at the level of central government”.
In fact, speaking of Greater Manchester, at the time when the now Prime Minister was Mayor of Greater Manchester, commitments in the 2023 devolution deal with Greater Manchester under the previous Government focused on activity better to integrate rail into the local Bee Network—for example, in relation to pay-as-you-go and passenger experience. This activity is continuing, but there has never been a formal request to de-designate services from Greater Manchester.
The right outcome may not always be further devolution. In some cases, it may be a partnership arrangement with GBR or another solution that better achieves local objectives. It is important that the Secretary of State consider each proposal on its merits. This amendment would remove that discretion by requiring services to be exempted whenever a request is made under Section 53, which I do not believe would be the right approach. As the noble Lord, Lord McLoughlin, reflected, the railway is a network of local, regional and long-distance services, and the railway network crosses political boundaries. Whether devolution is appropriate will depend on the operational, safety and financial context of each case. This amendment risks fragmentation of an interconnected national network if the consequences have not been fully considered.
Much of today’s debate has focused on mayoral strategic authorities, but it is equally important that places with no mayor have a meaningful place in the future railway. This is the theme of government Amendments 5, 15, 26, 70, 113, 114, 118, 119, 121 to 125, 135 and 136. These amendments are the result of careful consideration of the points raised in Grand Committee on GBR’s partnership. I am grateful to noble Lords and, in particular, to the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, who is sadly not in his place today, for their thoughtful and detailed representations on this topic since Committee.
The amendments will consider how non-mayoral strategic authorities in England, known as foundation strategic authorities, can benefit from the same core mechanisms in the Bill as their mayoral counterparts. This includes entering into co-operation arrangements with GBR. Meanwhile, GBR will be required to take their transport plans into account and to consult them before taking decisions that could significantly affect their areas. These amendments are particularly relevant to Cornwall Council, following the recent announcement of its designation as a foundation strategic authority. Cornwall already works closely with the railway industry, and these amendments will ensure that that relationship can continue to develop within the framework established by the Bill.
The amendments give foundation strategic authorities a role in other important parts of the Bill, including advising GBR and the Secretary of State on local railway matters, referring issues to the passenger watchdog and contributing to the preparation of statements of objectives. Together, these changes ensure that foundation strategic authorities can help shape rail services in their areas and work with GBR on behalf of their communities. I commend to the House Amendment 4 in the name of my noble friend Lord Blunkett, and I urge the noble Lord, Lord Harper, not to press his amendment.
My Lords, before we move quickly through the amendments, I was remiss in not putting on record my appreciation to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, for the facilitation of my original amendment in Committee. I was very grateful.
My Lords, one of the areas of operating a railway that has received perhaps least attention and often escapes the attention of those considering railways is fares and ticketing. Fares and ticketing is, in some ways, one of the most exciting and interesting things about a railway—please do not get too excited—because it is where a great deal of innovation has been possible over the years and where opportunities for generating higher customer demand can be found. If I was saying this in relation to an airline, noble Lords would not think that was strange at all, but it is just as true of the railways.
With much credit to the Minister, one thinks of the introduction of Oyster cards and of zonal fares in London, even before Oyster cards were introduced. When I first worked in London, I had a season ticket on the Underground that took me from Putney Bridge up to my job in Westminster. That is how it worked, like the national railway. The move to zonal fares was in itself dramatic and revolutionary. Then, of course, there was the Oyster card and the use of contactless technology, all of which we have seen rolled out on the railways. When I say this is exciting, it is modestly exciting, but still important as far as the railways are concerned.
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, was so excited by tickets that I got overexcited myself. I was getting slightly worried about the noble Lord, because his natural, usual cheerfulness seemed to be lessening as we went through the Bill, but we are back on ticketing and back to excitement. I added my name to this amendment. I think it is self-explanatory: we need carrots and we need sticks, and everybody needs to pay.
My Lords, it has been a very interesting short debate on fares. Reading the amendments in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, made me ask a question. It is quite simple to see how it would work in places such as London, where Transport for London runs the trains and sets the fares, but what about an open access line to London, to Edinburgh, or anywhere else, where there are two competing services, or more than two? One of them would be run possibly by GBR and the others by what are, in effect, private sector operators. Does the scope for dealing with fares extend beyond GBR-operated trains to open access ones? If so, how will GBR—presumably GBR—control fares on open access trains if that is part of the deal? I would be grateful to hear my noble friend’s response, or even that of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, if he has a view.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, this is an important group, as fares are one of the most important areas for passengers when deciding whether to travel by train. It is also one of the big challenges that the Government face, because there is a need to simplify the fare structure to ensure that passengers have confidence every time they travel that they have purchased the best ticket. That is a real priority.
As we have heard, the use of contactless since the pandemic has revolutionised payments, including ticketing, in places such as London. Passengers do not trust the current rail fares system; therefore, this will be a significant piece of work for the new Great British Railways.
The government amendment in this group introducing a scheme for members of the Armed Forces and veterans is welcome. I thank the Minister for his work in securing this amendment, which we on these Benches support. We will debate my amendment about a loyalty scheme on day 2 of Report.
Tackling fare evasion has been raised. It is of course really important and part of the confidence that passengers will have in using the railway—that everyone is paying to use it. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response to these issues.
My Lords, I thank noble Lords for this debate and for their representations in Committee on GBR’s discount fare schemes.
I am delighted to announce that the Government have tabled a series of amendments to ensure that discounts for veterans and service personnel are protected in law. Those are Amendments 53 to 55 and 57 to 63. It is vital to recognise the service and sacrifice of those who give so much for our country. These amendments give reassurance to the Armed Forces community and their families that the provision of these discounts will continue. They also underline our commitment to place passengers firmly back at the heart of our railways through the establishment of Great British Railways. By placing these discounts on a statutory footing, we will ensure that future generations of veterans and service personnel can continue to access these benefits with confidence and certainty. This also builds on our expansion of free railway travel this year for a bereaved military family member attending remembrance events, ensuring that travel costs are not a barrier to paying tribute to loved ones who made the ultimate sacrifice. Taken together, these measures demonstrate our determination to recognise the contribution of the Armed Forces community through meaningful action.
On Amendments 7 and 8, it is not the Government’s intention to use directions to set out the Secretary of State’s objectives for fares. We recently published a factsheet on fares, which outlines that the mechanisms to set out fares objectives and controls for GBR will be in the business plan and in the planned public service contract between GBR and the Secretary of State. Directions are a tool for use only in exceptional circumstances and are not expected to be used routinely. In practice, if the Secretary of State decides to place constraints on how GBR sets fares, those constraints will be reflected in GBR’s contractual arrangements. I understand the intention of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, to provide greater transparency in the use of directions in relation to fares, but we do not believe it is necessary or proportionate to place a statutory publication requirement on the Secretary of State. In answer to my noble friend Lord Berkeley, GBR will have no role in setting fares for open-access operators, as is the case currently.
On Amendment 52 on the subject of fare evasion, I agree with noble Lords that reducing fare evasion is important for GBR, passengers and taxpayers alike. Tackling it effectively will depend on strong operational co-operation between Great British Railways and the British Transport Police. The long-term rail strategy will make it clear that GBR must take appropriate steps to reduce costs to the taxpayer, but a long-term strategy is not the appropriate mechanism for determining the operational measures through which fare evasion should be tackled. Those decisions are best taken by GBR, working with British Transport Police and other relevant partners, including mayoral strategic authorities, who are all well placed to determine the most effective response. There are other more appropriate places where GBR could set out its approach to fare evasion, such as in its business plan.
As a passenger operator, revenue protection will be an important part of GBR’s day-to-day operation, making its business plan a more appropriate way to lay out how fare evasion will be tackled. What is made public will need to be balanced against the continued effectiveness of any revenue protection strategies, but the Government should give GBR, the British Transport Police and relevant partners the flexibility to make those operational decisions at the right level and to adapt their approach as circumstances evolve. It would not be appropriate for Ministers to prescribe particular operational solutions through a 30-year strategy, especially when the challenges themselves are fast-moving. However, I hope that noble Lords are reassured that addressing fare evasion will be a core part of GBR’s five-year business plan and that they will be able to scrutinise its plans to tackle fare evasion through that mechanism. I hope that the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, feels able to withdraw his amendment.
My Lords, I understand what the Minister says about fare evasion. I am glad to hear that there will be something significant in the business plan about it, even if not a full exposure of the details of the strategy and how it is to be enforced, but I will come back on the question of fares. At the moment the Secretary of State effectively sets not all but many fares by announcing that they are going to increase by a certain percentage every year. This is a highly political decision. The public are not much engaged with it, but they would like to be engaged with it. They certainly have views on it. What is contemplated here and what everyone expects is that GBR will not only be doing that in the future; it will be doing something much more significant. For example, as the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, said, it will be approaching the question of simplification of fares, but it also needs to have a revenue strategy. What are its fares for? Are they for maximising revenue and reducing subsidy or are they for meeting green objectives and trying to get more people on to the trains? Those do not always cohere. These things should be set out in a way the public can understand, for a debate, before anything is implemented, and not simply done piecemeal.
Although the Minister says I have missed my mark in trying to amend this so as to attach it to a direction, which he says would not be appropriate as it is going to be done through the contractual arrangements between the Secretary of State and GBR, I would still like to feel that that debate will take place as major changes to fares structures proceed and that we—the public and Parliament—will have a chance to have our say. Since I have drafted it badly and I have missed my mark, I will at this stage withdraw my Amendment 7, but I hope the Minister will feel that he is under some sort of obligation at the end of this debate to do what I say.
I thank noble Lords for the lively and productive discussions we have had to date on the topic of ticket retailing. I will use this opening speech to introduce the government amendments in this group and will respond to the amendments tabled by other noble Lords in my closing remarks. As I have said before, this Government remain committed to a fair and open retail market under Great British Railways, recognising the value independent retailers bring to passengers. That is why I am pleased to bring government Amendments 9 and 12 before the House today. These amendments require the retail code of practice to contain provision ensuring that GBR provides non-GBR retailers with access on fair, transparent and non-discriminatory terms to the products, systems, data and services they need to sell railway tickets. Importantly, they also require the code to set out how the Office of Rail and Road will monitor GBR’s compliance with those requirements.
Before turning to the detail, I acknowledge the constructive engagement of the noble Baroness, Lady Harding of Winscombe, and the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho. The development of these amendments has been an iterative process informed by several helpful discussions with them both. The noble Baroness has consistently pressed the Government to strengthen the language around fair, transparent and non-discriminatory access and to ensure that there is a clear role for the ORR in overseeing compliance. Drawing on her considerable experience, including promoting competition and fair access in regulated markets, she has brought valuable insights to these discussions. The noble Lord, Lord Dixon, has also brought to these discussions considerable expertise and insight on data and customer-facing systems, helping to ensure that the practical effect of these protections is clear, namely that GBR should not be able to provide competing retailers with a lower standard of service than it provides to itself.
Following those discussions, I believe that these amendments successfully capture those shared objectives. With Amendments 9 and 12, we are placing beyond doubt the principle that GBR must not discriminate against other online ticket retailers or provide them with a lower standard of service than it provides to itself. The amendments respond directly to concerns raised by noble Lords that in future GBR could favour its own retail activities over other retailers’. While GBR’s retail operations will form part of its wider operational responsibilities rather than an independent retail business, I agree it is important to mitigate potential conflicts of interest. In practice this means that independent retailers will be able to access the products, systems, data and services they need on the same basis as GBR’s own retail operation. Products and services such as Delay Repay will be available to all retailers by default and any differences in access must be fully justified. That matters not only for retailers but for passengers, who benefit from competition, innovation and choice in how they purchase rail travel. I also recognise that there has been a desire for greater certainty to ensure that these principles cannot be weakened over time, which is why Amendments 9 and 12 place these requirements in primary legislation, ensuring that this commitment will endure beyond the initial code and continue to be safeguarded long into the future.
I hope noble Lords will welcome the Government’s amendments. I beg to move.
My Lords, I will speak to the amendments in my name but first, I thank the Minister and his officials for their extremely constructive engagement between Committee and Report. This is an important group, because all the amendments —the Government’s, mine and those tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Dixon—are trying to do the same thing, which is to make sure that we have an economically fair, transparent and non-discriminatory market for online ticket retailers, enabling them to compete on a level playing field with Great British Railways.
This matters because we currently have a functioning, competitive online retail market. There is a real risk that, in creating GBR, we send the wrong signals—“We don’t have the right safeguards in place”—and therefore investors will not invest, competition will gradually disappear, and with it innovation. With that, we will see ticket sales decline, which none of us wants. I think we are all united in trying to achieve the same thing with this amendment.
I tabled Amendment 10, which I thank the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, for adding his name to, to ensure that GBR will compete in the online retail services market on fair economic terms, no more favourable than those on which the independent online ticket retailers do. I very much thank the Minister for tabling his Amendments 9 and 12, which broadly replace mine, and I will not press this amendment at the end of the debate. I also really appreciate what he has just said from the Dispatch Box, making it clear that “non-discriminatory terms” means non-discriminatory between the online retailers and GBR, not among the online retailers. He has also been clear at the Dispatch Box that GBR will be under an obligation to provide products, systems, data and services that are not just needed but, in effect, the products, systems, data and services that GBR itself uses, and that there will be no difference in availability and timing. I very much appreciate that.
That takes me swiftly to my Amendments 16, 18 and 21, which aim to ensure that there is transparency on GBR’s online retail costs and revenues, and that any cross-subsidy of its online retail activities is visible to the ORR, the Secretary of State and taxpayers. This is important because it is not enough just to have a commitment to a fair and transparent market; we have to see the data to be certain that it is happening.
Amendment 16 would require the online costs and revenues to be set out in GBR’s business plan. Amendment 18 would require the ORR to advise the Secretary of State whether there is
“any cross-subsidy of Great British Railways’ online … retailing activities”
from other parts of its operations, and Amendment 21 would require that advice to be published, provided that publishing does not
“seriously and prejudicially affect anyone’s commercial interests”.
I appreciate the discussions that I have had with the Minister and his team, and I recognise his personal commitment to creating a level playing field, but without clarity on the financial performance of GBR’s online retailing, his assurance is simply a hope that economic theory and business practice suggest is unfounded.
I know that GBR intends to run its online retailing operation combined with its physical retailing. Personally, I wish that it would separate them, but the Minister has been clear that that decision is not up for debate. However, any good multichannel retailer allocates costs across its different sales channels to understand the profitability of each of those channels. Regardless of how it is operated, I would expect GBR management to know the costs and revenues of its online retailing operation versus its physical retailing operation. By the way, I would also expect the Treasury to want to know whether there is a subsidy in either of those pieces. That is really all that my amendments would do.
I know that officials have been concerned about confidentiality, but we are not asking for deep, granular detail or the disclosure of commercial contracts. We are simply asking to be really clear, publicly, whether there is a subsidy between the physical retailing operations and the online ones, which is why, should we get to that stage, I expect to divide the House on this issue.
Lord Dixon of Jericho (LD)
My Lords, I thank the Minister and officials for the careful thought and movement that they have given on these issues. On money, specifically the ability of GBR to subsidise the retail arm from taxpayer funds, I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Harding, that we are not quite there yet; at the moment, we do not have the ability to see whether that is happening in practice. This is a relatively small change that should be quite practical and would not put much obligation on an organisation that should be producing those figures internally anyway. We will support Amendment 16 if there is a Division.
On data, I remain worried that we have not learned enough from the original issues with Openreach, which the noble Baroness, Lady Harding, will again be deeply familiar with, and the rollout of open banking provisions. Both of those started broadly in the position that the Bill is currently in and then, many years and much pain later, ended up with the position set out in the amendment that I have put forward. We know that whenever a monopoly provider sets up parallel systems for itself and for other people, it tends to focus on the ones that it uses itself more than those it provides for others.
However, the Minister and officials have spent a lot of time with me over the past couple of weeks and have assured me that they take this really seriously, understand its importance and are committed to ensuring that the ORR looks at this proactively from the outset. What matters in the end is how people working within GBR do this in practice. They have an opportunity to design it in a way that makes this impossible. I look forward to the Minister pressuring GBR in that way and am content to place trust in him and officials to get that right, so we will not move the amendments in my name.
My Lords, I want to add a brief footnote to the excellent speech made by my noble friend Lady Harding. It is worth putting on the record what the Competition and Markets Authority has said on precisely this subject. It said:
“In a more closely integrated model, additional safeguards are likely to be required in order to achieve the government’s aim to ensure the sector benefits from the effects of fair and open competition between GBR and TPRs”.
The question is whether government Amendment 9 delivers that commitment. My view is that, without Amendment 16, Amendment 9 does not work, because the ORR simply will not have the information to decide whether there has been discrimination against independent retailers, so I agree with her every word.
The only point I want to make is that there seems to be a parallel between GBR and BT, in that both are companies that own infrastructure but also retail. What happened in the case of BT was that Openreach, the infrastructure company owning the cabinets, telephone wires and broadband services, was separated from BT. The other part of BT is a retailer, and that retail part competed with TalkTalk and Virgin Media. Ofcom took an interest when exactly the sort of concerns expressed by my noble friend Lady Harding were expressed by the retailers competing with BT, which asserted that Openreach was giving them preferential terms. The conclusion that Ofcom came to was that, although BT Group could own both, they had to be separate companies.
My noble friend’s amendment does not go as far as that. It would simply require the retailing operation to have separate cost and revenue accounts. This seems an entirely sensible way to avoid exactly the sorts of concerns expressed by retailers. If it does not go through, there will be less investment by them in innovation and developing new techniques. Again, it is worth putting on the record that the independent retailers have grown the market for ticketing by some £450 million. It is in the interest of GBR as a whole for the independent sector’s retailing to continue to innovate and grow the market. I hope, having listened to the debate, that the Minister will not oppose Amendment 16.
My Lords, the case has been made eloquently by my noble friends Lady Harding and Lord Young. It is incumbent on the Government to show why they find Amendment 16 unacceptable, when it says that GBR should be
“showing separately the costs of, and revenues from, its online ticket retailing activities”.
There is a fear that that money could be hidden in other departments, as opposed to what GBR is doing. If the Minister is trying to reassure us that he wants to see growth—and we have seen fantastic growth in the way that these companies employ people and offer a greater range of tickets across the spectrum—then he needs to give reassurance on this. At the moment, I fear the Bill does not give that reassurance which he seeks to give; this amendment would do it.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, this group has united many of us across the House since Second Reading back in July. I added my name to Amendments 11 and 19 in the name of my noble friend Lord Dixon of Jericho. I also support the amendments in this group in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Harding of Winscombe.
I give credit where it is due: the Government’s Amendment 9 is a welcome step. It would require the approved document to make provision requiring Great British Railways to give other ticket retailers
“access on fair, transparent and non-discriminatory terms to the products, systems, data and services”
that they need to sell tickets. This is progress from where we were some months ago. It would also require the document to set out how the ORR will monitor compliance. That is right in principle, and the Minister and the Government deserve credit for bringing it forward.
My noble friend’s amendments build on that principle by setting out what fair access means in practice. Amendment 11 would require Great British Railways to give other retailers the same interface as it uses for its own online sales,
“on the same terms, timescales and service levels”.
It would also prevent it launching new products through its own channels first, which is a real fear.
Amendment 19 would require the ORR’s advice on the business plan to test whether Great British Railways is complying with the approved document and whether the funding and cost allocation of its ticket sales distort competition. These are practical and proportionate measures, and I am grateful to my noble friend for the care he has taken over them.
My Lords, before I come to the meat of the debate, I have Amendments 43 and 44 in this group. In Committee the Minister confirmed that the Office of Rail and Road, which has a vague regulatory responsibility for GBR, would be under a competition duty when creating the retail code of practice. It will be under a competition duty when it creates that code, but it will not be under a competition duty when enforcing it. My two amendments would put it under a competition duty in relation to the enforcement code. The code could change over time and, without an ongoing statutory duty to promote competition, there is a risk that competition could gradually be sidelined, with insufficient safeguards against that happening. That is why these amendments are necessary.
I turn to the amendments on the protection of the position of private sector retailers of tickets. I go back to what I said on the first group today: the Government have chosen quite deliberately to create a Great British Railways that is both the decision-maker and the competitor. There need to be strong protections and constraints on Great British Railways to ensure that it does not abuse those powers. If my noble friend Lady Harding chooses to divide on Amendments 16, 18 and 21, I will support her.
My Lords, I welcome the support expressed by the noble Baronesses, Lady Harding of Winscombe and Lady Pidgeon, and the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, for the Government’s amendments. I believe we have reached a sensible decision on retail and fair access, and I will turn to the other issues raised during the debate.
First, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for Amendments 43 and 44. The Government fully recognise the importance of maintaining a fair and open retail market. Competition and innovation can deliver real benefits to passengers through improved products, services and ways of purchasing tickets. That is why Great British Railways will remain subject to competition law in full and why we have developed the retail code of practice. Both the ORR and the Competition and Markets Authority can exercise enforcement powers in relation to GBR through the competition law framework, while the ORR can also enforce GBR’s compliance with the code. I assure noble Lords that the ORR’s competition duty will apply to the ORR when it is writing and developing the code, ensuring that the principle of competition is embedded as fully as possible in the code itself. We have not applied a competition duty to licence enforcement simply because enforcement should be fair and based on one factor: whether the operator has complied with the code and licence. The ORR should not be taking enforcement action against operators that are entirely compliant with the rules, simply because it is driven by other legal duties that are not relevant to its work as an impartial enforcement body.
I turn to funding and transparency in Amendments 16, 18, 19 and 21. Great British Railways will remain subject to competition and subsidy control law, which prohibits distortive cross-subsidisation. As GBR retail will be integrated into its wider operational business, we also do not anticipate that GBR will be funded in the same way as an independent retailer. GBR’s passenger services activities, including retail, will instead be funded under the transport-specific framework that sets out the applicable subsidy control provisions to those activities—the Public Service Obligations in Transport Regulations, or PSOT 2023—and captured as part of GBR’s integrated business plan. That is how train operators are funded today and it ensures that funding is linked to delivery of specified activities. Funding received cannot exceed the net cost of delivering those activities, the costs of which will be agreed with the Secretary of State through GBR’s business plan. GBR cannot receive more money than is necessary to deliver the retail function set out in the business plan, and nor can money be diverted from infrastructure to support retail operations.
There will also be sufficient public transparency to allow external parties to understand the level of funding being provided to GBR retail activities, so they can be reassured that GBR is using its funding fairly in line with requirements set by the Secretary of State. GBR will be required through its business plan to set out its activities, such as its broad retailing function, the costs of these activities and how it proposes that these costs are met. That should provide sufficient transparency to allow external parties to understand the funding of GBR’s passenger services. However, facilitating identical comparisons between GBR’s costs and those of independent retail is not appropriate, as many of GBR’s costs will be shared across activities. For example, its customer service centre will support a wide range of passenger inquiries, not just ticket sales. This reflects its role as a public transport operator retailing through all channels, not an online retailer. Furthermore, just because it is funded differently, that does not mean it can use this funding in a way that damages competition in the market.
GBR will be subject to competition law in full when discharging its functions and using public funding. Should the ORR suspect that its use of retail funding represents a breach, it has all necessary powers to investigate and enforce against GBR, including powers to require any information it needs for its investigation from GBR, which will be fully transparent with the regulator.
The use of BT and Openreach in telecoms as an analogy of GBR in the retail market is tempting but ultimately represents an apples and oranges comparison. Openreach is a wholly owned subsidiary of BT Group and a dominant telecoms infrastructure manager. It is Openreach’s costs and revenues that BT Group reports on separately; it does not report separately on, for example, its commercial customer-facing part of the business that sells broadband to consumers. Regarding rail retail, it is the cross-industry retail systems previously or currently managed by the Rail Delivery Group, and in future by GBR, that are the Openreach equivalent, not the costs and revenues from GBR selling its own tickets. The costs of these cross-industry retail systems are shared fairly by those who use them and, as part of our commitment to fair, transparent and non-discriminatory access, the code explicitly requires GBR to pay a proportionate share of these costs going forward.
It is therefore the Government’s position that the existing level of transparency, combined with the protections in the code of practice and existing competition and subsidy control law, are sufficient to ensure that GBR is funded fairly and a fair and open market is secured for all retailers. I therefore ask noble Lords not to press their amendments. I beg to move.
I am afraid that we have not got any further on this issue in the debate. I do not think that we are agreed. I have not heard anything that gives me confidence that we will be able to understand the separation between online and physical retailing costs. I therefore wish to test the opinion of the House.
My Lords, after that excitement, we turn to the question of funding. My Amendment 17 would require GBR to set out in its business plan—I hope I have the right document this time—how it would reduce or minimise its costs to taxpayers. The Minister has said in Committee and elsewhere that GBR will already be under a duty to have regard to the efficient use of public funds, but one can have an efficient use of funds while expanding the demand on the taxpayer. The two are not the same thing.
GBR will have at least two obvious levers for reducing the charge on the taxpayer: one will be greater efficiency and another will be the way in which it deploys and generates its fares revenue. Having this requirement that GBR should minimise the demand on the taxpayer might be thought by some to be anti-railways and anti-public transport. It is not. I have worked with railways for the last 15 years or so, sometimes alongside the Minister. I am of the firm and honest view that a railway that consumes endless subsidy is a railway that will be cancelled. It will not grow and it will not meet passenger demand. To be successful and to continue in public service, a railway needs to demonstrate that it can reduce the burden on taxpayers. Please do not let anyone suggest that this amendment is somehow moved in a spirit of animus against the railways. It is not. It is a very pro-railways amendment.
Amendment 20, which is related, would require the ORR to assess whether GBR’s business plan will minimise costs to taxpayers before it is approved by the Secretary of State. There would be an independent check on the business plan by the ORR to allow the Secretary of State to satisfy herself on this question. Amendment 38 would give Great British Railways an additional duty to reduce reliance on public subsidy.
All these amendments clearly work together to achieve what I think is absolutely fundamental for the success of the railways: a railway that can, as far as is possible, demonstrate that it can stand on its own feet without constant reliance on the public and the taxpayer. The railway is in competition with hospitals, schools and so forth for public funds. It never comes top of that list. It has to show that it can stand on its own feet as far as it possibly can and that it is doing everything it can. This will help it, and these amendments should be incorporated in the Bill. I beg to move.
My Lords, I strongly support everything my noble friend Lord Moylan said, so I will not repeat it.
I remind the Minister that, in the last spending review, the Department for Transport and the Treasury agreed that the DfT would significantly reduce the level of subsidy from the taxpayer to run rail operations. I am somewhat sceptical about how realistic that agreement was, because I have not seen any evidence yet that the Government have a plan for driving up revenue sufficiently to close the gap between revenue and costs in order to bring that subsidy down.
My noble friend Lord Moylan is absolutely correct that the subsidy has to be covered by the department’s spending. That has to be secured in a spending review. We all know, from reading about all the pressures on the Government’s departmental expenditure at the moment, that at the next spending review the Department for Transport will struggle to sustain its existing level of funding, let alone get any more. It is absolutely in the interests of the rail system as a whole, GBR and the department to have a very good plan for reducing the subsidy required; otherwise, the Treasury simply will not agree the level of subsidy and the department will be forced to make decisions that are not sensible to reduce cost, and these will have an impact on the service that is delivered.
My noble friend is right: if you are going to reduce the subsidy to the minimum level, the way you do that is not to cut costs and reduce services but to innovate and drive up the number of customers using the railway —passengers, freight customers and open access operators —and drive up the revenues and reduce the net cost to the taxpayer. If you do that, you will have a railway that is sustainable over the long term and that will deliver not just for the taxpayer but for the fare payer and the passenger at large.
My noble friend’s amendments are very well intentioned; they flow with the agreement that the DfT made with the Treasury at the previous spending review, and I am pretty sure that they are in line with where the Department for Transport will end up negotiating with the Treasury at the next spending review, if everything we read about the pressures on public finances is true. I hope that, if the Minister cannot accept my noble friend’s amendments, he can at least accept that they have the right spirit and tell us what the department is going to do to make sure it can drive down the net cost of running the railway to the taxpayer.
My Lords, I do not know whether the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, in moving amendments in this group, has spoken to Amendment 82. If not, I shall sit down and wait for him to do so. If he has, I must have missed it.
I have not spoken to it, but I am not sure it is in this group.
My Lords, I add a very short footnote to what my noble friend Lord Harper said about the prospects for the Department for Transport’s budget. The OBR publication published at the same time as the Budget projects that unprotected government departments, which is the Department for Transport, face real-terms day-to-day spending cuts of 2.6% per year during the final years of the forecast period. It is even worse than what my noble friend said, when he implied that it might be able to hang on to its existing budget. If the Government are to stay within their fiscal rules, there will be a real-terms spending cut of 2.6% each year.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, the amendments in this group are focused on minimising taxpayer costs of the railway, as we have heard. Clearly, there is not an open-ended chequebook—if we still have chequebooks in this day and age—but the railway will always need some sort of subsidy to operate services, because not every service and line can cover its costs. There are wider environmental and economic benefits of the railway. Our highways, in effect, need subsidy, and investment in maintenance and replacement—and we would not consider minimising the costs in that area.
Given the tight budgets that we expect in this current climate, Great British Railways will have to operate incredibly efficiently and work to get more passengers on to the railway, increase other income, whether through advertising or other commercial income, and of course increase freight and other operators using the railway. I commend again my amendment, which we will debate on the second day on Report, which would look to introduce a loyalty scheme to attract and keep greater numbers of passengers on to the railway. I look forward to the Minister’s response to this group and to his explaining how Great British Railways will be able to continue to run the quality services that we hope it will in the future.
My Lords, on Amendments 17, 20 and 38, while I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, that railways need to become more efficient with taxpayers’ money, I do not agree that these amendments would create the right incentive or generate the right behaviours in Great British Railways to achieve that. In my view, there is a tangible difference between minimising taxpayer subsidy and getting the best value for money out of the subsidy that the Government choose to put in. Minimising costs pushes the balance towards GBR cutting costs and raising fares, rather than seeking true efficiency and getting the most value out of every pound in the railway.
The balance here is so important because of the knock-on impact that the imbalance can have on the longer-term prosperity of the railways and the wider social and economic benefits that the railway can provide. I think we all agree in this Chamber that a well-functioning railway delivers more than the sum of its parts and that connectivity provides opportunity and productivity. A branch line that operates thanks to public subsidy also allows people to get to work or their place of education or to see family and friends. It is a valuable part of a wider economic picture. GBR should be incentivised to run such a line in the most efficient way possible, not to close it down because that would deliver the lowest cost to the taxpayer. As I said in Committee, it was that kind of thinking that led to the Beeching closures and those subsequent to them, and I do not think any of us wants to see a repeat of that.
In addition, sometimes to get more out of the railway in future, there needs to be investment in the present. This Bill should not risk giving GBR no incentive to try to find opportunities and present them to government, which can decide whether to fund those opportunities based on the fiscal circumstances at the time.
In summary, I do not believe that the role of GBR is to cut the cost of the railway; it is to deliver the objectives of the Government of the day in the most efficient way, whether that objective is simply to cut costs or something else. The Bill fully provides for this model and already includes consideration of value for money. The Secretary of State will be able to set out their objective in the statement of objectives. GBR will need to create a business plan in response to those objectives, considering its duty in Clause 18 to make efficient use of public funds. Finally, the ORR will provide independent, expert advice to the Secretary of State about whether this plan represents the achievement of their objectives and good value for money. Under the Bill as drafted, at every step in the process, from planning and funding to delivery, value for money is considered. That is a better and more balanced approach than one that incentivises a race to the bottom, as these amendments would do. I hope the noble Lord agrees and sees fit to withdraw his amendment.
My Lords, normally I can express with great sincerity a very high level of regard for the Minister. However, I think that speech was pretty disgraceful. There was no suggestion in my speech or in these amendments that we are heading for Beeching cuts on the railway or that we desire Beeching cuts on the railway. Any business that is dependent on, let us say, start-up funding or some other external source needs to have a plan to show how it can move away from that. Nobody here is suggesting that public subsidy should be eliminated. The question is the word “minimising”.
The Minister seemed not to hear my speech at all when I said that this was a pro-railway amendment to help to protect the railways by having a plan when the fact is that they are going to be squeezed on subsidy anyway, a fact which was supported by two very distinguished former Transport Secretaries, my noble friends Lord Harper and Lord Young of Cookham. It is pretty disgraceful that the Minister should stand there and say that what I am calling for is a race to the bottom and for Beeching cuts. That is not what is implied by these amendments at all. I am sorry he did not feel fit to address the amendments and my speech as I gave it. However, clearly there is no hope of getting blood out of a stone on this occasion, so I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Enactment | Extent |
1. Acts of Parliament | |
Consumer Rights Act 2015 | Chapter 4 of Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 of Schedule 5 |
Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 | Chapter 1 of Part 4 |
2. Secondary legislation and assimilated direct legislation | |
Regulation (EC) No 1371/2007 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 23 October 2007 on rail passengers’ rights and obligations | All articles except article 26 |
Rail Passengers’ Rights and Obligations Regulations 2010 | All regulations |
Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012 | All regulations |
Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 | All regulations |
3. Other subordinate legislation | |
Any other subordinate legislation (not otherwise listed in this Schedule) so far as made under an enactment so listed | The entirety of the legislation” |
My Lords, it is me again. I shall speak to Amendments 24 and 82 in my name—I know that Amendment 82 is of interest to the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley. Before I do so, I wish heartily to associate myself with the amendments in this group in the name of my noble friend Lord Harper; I shall not be speaking about them, but I am happy to lend my support to him in what I believe he is about to say.
Amendment 24 would require the long-term rail strategy to include a policy linking pay increases for GBR employees to measurable improvements in productivity or operational efficiency. We have seen, not solely under this Government but very much so under this Government, a succession of pay rises without corresponding commitments to productivity improvements. We all think back with embarrassment to the pay concessions made by the former Secretary of State, Louise Haigh—who I see has resurfaced in government. She had not been in office for five minutes before dishing out everything the unions wanted in exchange for no productivity improvements whatever—one of the first actions of the failed and discredited Starmer Government.
In Committee, the Minister argued that making pay increases conditional on productivity improvements through primary legislation would be restrictive. That is the whole point: this is taxpayers’ money and it should be restricted and controlled. There should be limits on how it is dished out, and one of them is that the taxpayer should get something back for the money they are paying out by way of improvements in efficiency. We are an economy that needs to improve labour efficiency—everyone agrees on that. “The need to improve productivity” is another way of putting it, but it is exactly the same thing, and we wish to see that in the railway sector and in the Bill.
Amendment 82 also relates to industrial relations. We have a beautiful new east-west railway that goes to Milton Keynes, Winslow and places like that, and the trains occasionally even run—but they have no passengers, because there has been no agreement with the unions about the operation of the trains. Fingers of blame can be pointed: “Oh, it’s the fault of Chiltern Railways”—now part of the Department for Transport’s operator—“or the fault of the last Government for not thinking about it far enough”. However, the fundamental problem is that the unions, particularly the RMT, I believe, do not want to agree to driver-only operation, and they have held up the operation of the railway for just that reason.
Driver-only operation should be required on all services—although this amendment, as I recall, would simply require it on all new services—and it should not be held hostage by the unions. Passengers living in the Winslow area, and I am afraid I hear a lot from them, are fuming that they are not getting the service they are promised. They are also fuming that the first passenger use of the railway, although I may or may not get the details of this right, is going to be for diverting services. Fundamentally, because there are going to be closures on the main line into Paddington, trains from Swindon—which I think is the Secretary of State’s constituency—are going to be diverted to Paddington around that line, so there will for a period be many passengers on the line, but the trains will not be stopping at Winslow or places like that and giving local people, who have thirsted for this railway for a long time, the chance to get on it. All that is because it is being held up by the RMT.
It is a disgrace. The Minister can say that it is someone else’s disgrace or someone else’s fault, but it falls to him to sort it out, and it falls to us in this Bill to ensure that there are measures in it to ensure that this sort of thing will not happen again, and that we get a modern and efficient railway running with modern standards that serves the people. I beg to move.
My Lords, I apologise for getting up at the wrong time and trying to speak to this amendment.
I am talking about Amendment 82 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, who has already spoken about driver-only operations on new trains, as he puts it. This is all very odd because, as he said, they are planning to put new trains on the Milton Keynes-Winslow route and others. Part of the Chiltern Railways network, which this route will join, has been using driver-only trains for many years. I say driver-only, but that does not mean that there will not be anybody else in the train. One of the arguments is about who presses the button to shut the door at stations. Is it the driver—is he allowed to do it? Or is it someone who might be called a conductor or something else? However, the fact remains that, as the noble Lord, Lord Moylan said, there are no trains running on a finished railway. That is not the only such situation: a new set of trains has been purchased for South Western services out of Waterloo, but I believe there are still several hundred of them sitting in sidings that have not driven more than a few miles because, again, the company cannot reach agreement with one of the trades unions as to how many drivers or how many conductors or what.
My Lords, I will speak to a number of these amendments. I have three tabled in my name, but I will start by referring to the lead amendment, Amendment 24 from my noble friend Lord Moylan. They are of course connected.
For most people who work in the private sector, to suggest that a company have a pay and productivity policy, in which what you pay people bears some relation to the level of productivity in the business, would strike them as fairly unexceptional and quite reasonable. If businesses that operate in competitive marketplaces do not behave like that, they do not exist for very long. Trade unions that operate in businesses that work in competitive marketplaces absolutely understand that. In my experience, they behave accordingly and often have very constructive relationships with the management of the businesses they operate in, because they understand the fundamental truth that, if the business is not profitable, there are no secure, well-paid jobs for their members. You tend therefore to have a much more constructive relationship. In my experience, it is in the public sector, where there is always the taxpayer to bail out unproductive working practices, that you get some of the most unhelpful relationships, because unions know that they can use political power to try to extract more cash rather than delivering productivity.
My noble friend Lord Moylan talked about what this Government did at the beginning of their time in office, which demonstrates why his amendment is well targeted. One of the consequences of the then Transport Secretary handing out no-strings-attached money to train drivers was that the existing negotiations under way between the RMT and the train operating companies —which were constructive and going well, and intended to reach a win-win deal through which we would deliver productivity improvements, which would help fund pay rises for all of the staff working in train operating companies, from the lowest paid to the highest paid, in a sustainable way that was fair to both farepayers and the taxpayer—were blown up. The RMT said, not unreasonably, “If you are going to hand out a load of free money to train drivers without asking for anything in return, it is not unreasonable that you do the same for our members”. That is what happened. Pay rises were given out to all the workers in the rail sector and there was nothing gained in return. Going back to the previous group, this is at a time when the taxpayer is having to put multibillion pounds-worth of subsidy into keeping those passenger services operating. My noble friend’s Amendment 24 is very reasonable. It seems to me extraordinary that the Government would not want to have that in place for their own negotiating arm.
The three amendments in my name are all connected. The first flows from what the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, noted about minimum service levels. He referred to what happened in France. The amendment does not say that unions cannot take industrial action, but it recognises that many people depend on railways for their own economic freedom—to get to work or hospital, or to do important things—and that the freight sector has to keep products we all use flowing and many essential services working. It says that, if you are going to go on strike, you have to make sure that there is at least a minimum level of service to keep those essential things operating. I accept it is not a straightforward thing to deliver. We had a go at delivering it and it is complicated. It never had to be tested, but the legislation is complicated. The amendment is well intended, and I am interested to hear why the Minister does not think it is necessary.
Amendment 50 is on industrial action ballots relating to passenger railway services. It does not try to do anything more widely, but would address the changes made in the Employment Rights Act, which got rid of the requirements whereby at least 50% of those entitled to vote had to participate in ballots and at least 40% of those entitled to vote had to vote in favour of industrial action. Those were swept away. We are not proposing in this amendment to change that more widely but, for the reasons I set out about its essential nature for many people and services in the country, it should certainly be re-established for the rail industry.
Finally, my Amendment 51 is partly about today but also partly about the future. It connects back to the conversation we had on Amendment 24. GBR has been taking back into public ownership franchises as those contracts expire. They are separate companies owned by GBR. When we debated this in Committee, the Minister made it clear that the Government have no plans at the moment to consolidate any of those operating companies into a single entity or fewer entities. This amendment does two things. It says that unions cannot argue that people working for those different companies are actually all working for the same employer, even though they are all owned by GBR. That would stop there being a national rail strike. As soon as you can have a national rail strike, you significantly strengthen the bargaining power of unions, which means they will be in a much stronger position to extract money without any strings attached from Ministers and the taxpayer. That would be unhelpful.
Finally, can the Minister confirm what will happen in the future? It is certainly the case that the rail unions want the companies all to be part of one entity once they are owned by GBR. They want one set of terms and conditions and one entity. It is my understanding that, without making any changes, at that point it would be possible for the trade unions to have a national rail strike. Is the Minister comfortable with that, or can the Government see that that is not a helpful place to be and it would be much better from their point of view if they had better bargaining power on behalf of the taxpayer? That is the reason I tabled my amendments.
My Lords, I will speak briefly to my noble friend’s Amendment 24, although I shall do so with less passion than he did. This is about workforce pay. If you go back to the 1990s and the time of British Rail, pay was negotiated nationally by the RMT and it was done under the machinery and negotiations Act. There was industry-wide collective bargaining and a single national pay deal. That all stopped in the process of privatisation when we moved over to the train operating companies.
If I can put myself momentarily in the shoes of Mr Whelan, he has said that there is a difference of £10,000 between what one train driver and another one gets because they work for separate train operating companies. He wants to harmonise, and obviously he wants to harmonise upwards. He also wants a 32-hour, four-day week, which is a perfectly legitimate ambition. The question, touched on by my noble friend Lord Harper, is this: how are the Government going to manage, when at the moment you have people on different pay rates nominally all working for the same company, namely GBR? Inevitably, there will be some harmonisation upwards. It is going to be very difficult for the Government to resist a pay demand from one of the subsidiaries that my noble friend mentioned to harmonise with another, when one is clearly on a much higher rate.
That brings me back to the question posed by my noble friend Lord Moylan. If there is upwards harmonisation, and I think it is inevitable, unless there is going to be some compensating reduction in the Department for Transport’s budget, is it not the case that there will have to be some movement on productivity? This is a question for the Minister, as much as for my noble friend. We had a debate on this in Committee. The Minister replied that
“there has never been a single rate of pay for any job”.—[Official Report, 12/10/26; col. GC 22.]
That is absolutely true, but there has certainly been a national pay increase across the board for all the jobs, and that is exactly what is going to happen. Coupled with the harmonisation that I referred to earlier, how is the Minister going to manage this sensitive process within a budget which, as we have already heard, is going to be constrained by the fiscal demands of the Treasury?
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, this group relates to industrial relations and includes measures such as the minimum service levels and disapplying the recent Employment Rights Act for thresholds.
We on these Benches do not support these amendments. While we fully understand the disruption that strikes cause to passengers, these amendments would reopen questions Parliament has only just settled in the Employment Rights Act 2025, which repealed the minimum service levels regime, and would create a separate regime for railway workers alone.
My reading of Amendment 49 is that it would allow the Secretary of State to amend the Employment Rights Act by regulations—a sweeping power to rewrite primary legislation—and would make compliance with minimum service levels a condition of holding access rights, putting freight and open access operators at risk over disputes they may have no part in. We believe that the best route to fewer strikes is better industrial relations, and Great British Railways has a real opportunity to reset relations with its workforce.
Amendment 82 would require all new Great British Railways passenger services to be operated on a driver-only basis. We have to be very careful here. There is a lot behind this amendment. I feel at times that I am stuck in a time warp and we are back at City Hall, hearing about how every Tube and train run by Transport for London should be driverless. It is a similar debate we are having here, but we are talking driver-only operations, and it is the same individuals putting the case.
My Lords, I simply say to the noble Baroness, if I may, on a personal note, that I have never advocated driverless trains. She is suggesting I did. I never have, because I do not actually believe that they are feasible. I thought it was worth making that point, because otherwise she would be misrepresenting me, and I know she would not want to do that.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
I absolutely would not want to do that, as I would not want a Member of the House to suggest that I do not understand something when I actually just disagree with the point they have made.
On some lines, trains can and do run safely with driver-only operation, but this is not the case for all lines, and this amendment would not take into account the specific demography of different routes and the need for staff on trains other than the driver. We saw the chaos that passengers had to suffer for years over the removal of guards on the Southern network under the Conservative Government. We do not want to go back to that again. I look forward to the Minister’s response.
My Lords, the amendments before us would revive policies that this House has previously rejected and which many noble Lords from across the House have raised serious concerns about. They would take us in the wrong direction for industrial relations on the railway and risk undermining the collaborative approach needed to deliver better outcomes for passengers. I hope that noble Lords will again take the view that these measures are neither justified nor proportionate, and will decline to support them.
Amendment 24 relates to workforce pay and the long-term rail strategy. As I said in Committee, I simply do not agree that the long-term rail strategy should be required to include a workforce modernisation strategy. The strategy is not intended to go into specific operational requirements of that nature. Instead, its purpose is to set out the objectives for the railway over a 30-year period, and to consider long-term challenges such as environmental and demographic changes, or technological development. I am sure that noble Lords who have run companies will agree that you do not manage your workforce successfully through long-term, vision-setting documents.
We need to allow GBR the flexibility to respond to operational needs, challenges and opportunities. It is impossible for us to precisely forecast what elements will affect pay for the workforce over a 30-year period. Of course, I would expect GBR to plan its approach to its workforce policy, and all its other policies, around achieving the objectives set out in the long-term rail strategy. It would clearly also be inappropriate to set pay policy for one public sector workforce in legislation. That is not the approach taken with other bodies and it should not be the case for GBR.
Moving on to minimum service levels and industrial action, the previous Government brought in minimum service levels legislation, similar to that proposed in Amendment 49. It was repealed by this Government under the Employment Rights Act, as it did not support a positive or productive relationship between employers, employees and their trade unions. In fact, it served only to exacerbate the national rail disputes under the last Government, which saw two years of widespread strikes and disruption to millions of passengers. Further, while many rail employers, including some controlled by the previous Government, had the opportunity to use minimum service levels regulations, none chose to, as they deemed it either unworkable or unnecessary. I therefore cannot see any argument for including it here and strongly urge the noble Lord not to press his amendment.
Amendment 50 focuses on reforming the threshold for industrial action ballots. The Employment Rights Act 2025 removes restrictions on lawful industrial action because this Government believe that collective bargaining rights are key to tackling problems of insecurity, inequality and discrimination across sectors. We want to foster co-operation between trade unions, employers and the Government, which will support employers to amicably resolve disputes with their workforce, and lead to less disruption and cost overall. This is precisely what we have seen in the rail sector. This Government have improved relationships with the unions considerably and our collaborative approach has meant that the number of rail services lost due to strikes has more than halved compared to under the previous Government.
The cost of settling the disputes that the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, referred to was far less than the cost of continued industrial action that the Conservatives faced, which according to industry estimates amounted to around £850 million in forgone revenue between June 2022 and August 2024—a huge burden that fell directly on the taxpayer. In any event, there was no productivity on the table, because the private sector employers would not table any, as the Government had not agreed what their cut of the savings was.
In any event, as I said in Committee, I reassure noble Lords that the Government and the chair of GBR will consider factors such as productivity when reviewing pay. That is why the Government have already committed that, for pay settlements in 2025 and 2026, any increase above inflation must be in return for productivity. I assure the noble Lord that pay decisions in the future will reflect the Government’s determination to have a motivated, empowered and productive workforce. Before organising industrial action, trade unions must already comply with detailed balloting, notice and procedural obligations. This helps employers plan for industrial action and reduces the impact for passengers. There is therefore no need for the higher threshold proposed by this amendment.
On Amendment 51, this Government will focus on how we work with trade unions constructively to avoid industrial action as far as possible. It is worth highlighting that secondary industrial action is already prohibited under Section 224 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992. Trade unions support the creation of GBR and the railway returning to public ownership. They understand that we need to make it a success and that it will take all of us working together to do so. I acknowledge that there are both benefits of a single employer and, as the noble Lord, Lord Harper, and others have said, concerns about the potential for GBR to be a single employer. I assure the House that the Government would not make any such decision lightly or without productivity in mind.
As I said on the fourth Committee day, I will not make commitments about the future structure of GBR at this time because it will be for GBR’s leadership to consider how best it should be structured to achieve its objectives, working with government and in consultation with its employees, trade unions and key stakeholders. Clearly, we all want the railway to work properly for passengers and the public, and there would be no point in me bringing forward any reform that would undermine that.
Finally, I address Amendment 82. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, referred to East West Rail. Of course, the previous Government could have had that railway open in 2024 if they had let a contract in 2022 when it was known that the railway was going to be finished, but it is now this Government’s job to sort it out. Those who listened to the recent hearing of the Transport Select Committee will have heard both the management and the trade unions say that they are in the course of doing so.
The Minister said a number of things in Committee that I did not entirely agree with, but we did not get into an argument about it. I do not know whether he has seen the excellent article recently in Rail magazine on this subject. Any fair reading of it demonstrates that quite a lot of the responsibility for the fact that there are no trains carrying passengers on East West Rail falls on the present Government. They were warned pretty early on when they came into office in 2024 about what they would need to do to get things going and did not move sufficiently swiftly.
There was notice that there was no contract as soon as we took over. We noted that the previous Government had not let it; various things have intervened so far but it is now under discussion, as was heard at the Transport Select Committee. I do read Rail magazine; it is by my bed, but I do not often finish it. Quite often, it has only part of the story. We will see where that might go, but the noble Lord cannot absent himself from the knowledge that many of us had in 2022. We were surprised that the contract had never been let and, when I turned up in office in 2024, virtually nothing had been done and we had to start again.
My noble friend Lord Berkeley is entirely incorrect about the trains on South Western Railway. All of them should have been in service, but they are not because the previous private sector operator had not recruited enough train drivers to actually drive them. There is no dispute on South Western Railway about driver-only operation. By the way, I am not going to emulate the industrial relations climate of the French railway system.
Railway managers take many factors into account when determining the staffing model for particular services, including technological capability, passenger accessibility and operational safety. Let us take the example of a disabled passenger disembarking at an unstaffed station on a rural part of the line, a subject we will return to in a later debate on accessibility: in these situations, it may be the onboard staff who help disabled passengers get safely on or off the train by deploying ramps, or there may be other means. It is not efficient or appropriate for primary legislation to prescribe a single staffing model for all new GBR passenger services or to determine how those and other considerations should be resolved. I therefore urge noble Lords not to press their amendments.
My Lords, as a preliminary, noble Lords will now have realised that one technique deployed by the Minister is to respond to substantive matters by referring to the plethora of documents that he intends to produce. If you have an amendment saying that something should appear in GBR’s licence, his answer is, “Aha, no, it doesn’t belong in the licence; it belongs in the long-term rail strategy”. If you propose that it should be in the long-term rail strategy, his answer is, “No, it ought to be in the business plan”. Now we have a proposal that there should be something about industrial relations, pay and productivity in the business plan, he says that it would not belong in the business plan but somewhere else, if it belonged anywhere at all, which he does not believe it should, because he is not committed to improvements in pay and productivity in the Bill, which is exactly where they ought to be. We are heading for national rail strikes and a situation where more and more of the taxpayers’ money that is given grudgingly by the Treasury to the railways is not going into improvements or investments. It will not be available for that because it will have gone into the pockets of the rail unions without a proper return by way of productivity improvements.
Finally, it has been two and a half years now. It is possible for the Minister to carry on trying to land things on the back of the Conservative Government who were last in office two and a half years ago. But surely the time will come when Ministers have to start landing things on the failures of the Starmer Government, who were, after all, such a failure that they all united together with their fellow MPs at the other end to get rid of the Prime Minister. There cannot be a better token of a failed Government than that. I look forward to the time when Ministers, moving forward, are gradually blaming the Starmer Government for the things they did and failed to do. If they do that, I will heartily join in with them. In the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, I thank the Minister for the Statement made in the other place and Alan Milburn and his team for their work on this review. It has been excellent. There is a great deal in this review that all sides of your Lordships’ House can get behind, and I suspect many noble Lords will read parts of it and think, “I have been saying that for months, if not years”.
But publishing a review is only step one. The real test begins now. Can the Government carry their own Benches, particularly in the other place? Mr Milburn recommends savings—not enough of them, in our view, but savings all the same. Reforming welfare means hard choices, getting spending under control and setting a clear expectation to work. The question is whether the Government have the political will to see it through. If they do, there is a bigger question still: where are the jobs?
Yesterday’s figures from the Office for National Statistics tell the story. Payrolled employees fell by 34,000 in October and by 95,000 over the year. Among the smallest businesses, those with between one and nine staff, vacancies have fallen to 73,000. Outside the pandemic, that is the lowest since 2012. The ONS’s own evidence suggests why: smaller firms are holding back on hiring because of labour costs. For young people, the picture is starker. Youth unemployment is 15.6%. There is one starter vacancy for every three young people who are NEET, and graduate vacancies have fallen by 43% in a single year. A welfare system can prepare a young person for work and a programme can build their skills, but neither can give them a job. Only an employer can offer that first chance, that first wage and that first rung on the ladder.
The Government need not take my word for it; they need only read their own review. It says plainly that Britain cannot fix this by making more young people work-ready while demand for young workers keeps falling. Mr Milburn himself writes:
“There is nothing progressive about pricing young people out of work”—
my goodness, he is right. He warns that
“government cannot be indifferent to the cumulative effect of the costs and obligations it places on the decision to hire”,
yet indifference is exactly what we have had, Budget after Budget.
Employers do not feel government policy one measure at a time. As the review says, they feel it all at once, as “cost, complexity and risk”. National insurance, energy bills, business rates, wage rules and employment regulation all lead up to the same simple question: “Can I afford to take on one more person?”
Let us start with the jobs tax. The review finds that the Government’s 2025 national insurance changes added around £800 a year to the cost of a full-time worker on the living wage. Add the rise in the national living wage itself and the cost of employing that worker has gone up by £3,414 in just two years—between 2024 and 2026.
For the youngest workers, it is starker still. As the review says:
“Wage costs for young people aged 18 to 20 on the minimum wage have increased by 65 per cent over the last 5 years”.
The Government taxed jobs, knocked confidence, and then commissioned a review into why opportunities for young people were disappearing. The review has now supplied the answer. I may not be a renowned economist, and I never will be, but I know this much: if you tax something, you get less of it—fewer jobs, fewer chances and fewer first steps.
Mr Milburn’s answer is to double the threshold for 21 to 24 year-olds in retail and hospitality, but only when fiscal conditions allow, giving the Government every chance to put it on the never-never. We would act now. We would halve employer national insurance for 21 to 24 year-olds, saving a business around £1,500 a year for every young person it takes on. We would cut business rates for 250,000 high street shops, pubs and hospitality businesses, and we would create 100,000 more apprenticeships a year, paid for by the £36 billion of welfare savings we have identified. Alongside that, we would deliver “get to work” for young people on universal credit without a strong work record. Instead of sitting at home losing confidence, they would be expected to turn up every day, engaging with meaningful support in return for their benefit. That is tough love, but the alternative is a generation watching their skills fade and their hopes drain away.
Then there is the Employment Rights Act. The review put its cost to business at around £1 billion a year. More than a third of employers were planning to cut permanent hiring because of it. On guaranteed hours, Mr Milburn warns of the unintended consequences, adding:
“I believe this is likely to be the case”.
I ask the Minister three simple questions. Will the Government accept Mr Milburn’s recommendation and today commit not to increase the cost of employing young people any further? Will they cut the jobs tax on young workers now? Will they think again about guaranteed hours, where they threaten seasonal work, temporary work and the Saturday job?
The Government will not bring down the cost of hiring; their answer is to subsidise it instead. But a subsidy should be a bridge to a real job, not a permanent substitution for one. That is the circularity here: the Government raise the cost of employing young people, then spend taxpayers’ money subsidising placements with the very employers who might otherwise have created those jobs themselves. Does the Minister not see the absurdity of that? If the subsidy is the answer, it has to lead somewhere. Can the Minister tell the House what proportion of young people on the jobs guarantee the Government expect to be in unsubsidised work six to 12 months later, after the subsidy ends?
Then there are the savings. The review expects a net saving of around £200 million by 2036-37. Is that it? The OBR expects working-age welfare spending to pass £200 billion by the end of this decade. That is a saving of less than £1 in every £1,000.
Then there is the target itself. The review aims for a NEET rate of around 5% by 2036, but its own modelling gets to only 6.8%. It says that closing the gap depends on higher growth and
“new momentum in the youth labour market”.
In other words, the review’s policies do not meet the review’s own target. What is missing is a thriving labour market and employers with the confidence to hire. On both, the Government are falling short.
We need answers. Which recommendations do the Government accept in full and which do they reject? Will existing claimants be reassessed? Will benefits be withdrawn from those who persistently refuse a reasonable offer? When will we see reform for over-25s, which the review says is urgent? In the meantime, what will happen to all those who are already out of work? The restart scheme has stopped taking referrals and its last participants finish next August. Can the Minister tell the House whether the restart scheme will be extended? If not, what support will long-term unemployed people receive at its end and after the implementation of the review? Although the Statement made no mention of savings, will the Government take forward the changes to the sickness benefit that Mr Milburn proposes?
We have set five tests for this review. First, will it cut costs on business, so that it creates real jobs rather than taxpayer-subsidised jobs? Secondly, will benefits be cut for those who refuse to work or take part? Thirdly, will it reduce the number of young people dependent on the state? Fourthly, will cash benefits be kept for the seriously disabled, with support rather than cash for milder conditions? Fifthly, will it bring the working-age welfare bill down overall?
Yesterday evening, I welcomed a group of young people into Parliament to talk about the review. We sat down and they spoke passionately about their experiences. They all had one thing in common: each of them had applied for hundreds of jobs. Some had been fortunate enough to get a chance, some are still waiting to hear, and some had yet to land a single opportunity. That is why there are fewer vacancies. Will the Government listen to this report and set out clearly when they will stop adding to the cost of hiring and admit that their policies have made it harder, not easier, for young people to get their first job?
My Lords, I thank the ministerial team for bringing the Statement here for debate, and I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, for speaking at length about the Conservative’s view on this. I thank the Government for this 278-page report. We do not say anything simply—it is 278 pages. Could the Minister say where and how the trained personnel will be found to implement these reforms?
I have some more questions, and I will limit myself purely to questions. First, Alan Milburn is explicit that his reforms require an upfront investment of £500 million in 2027-28. Will the Government commit that £500 million for 2027-28, and where will these reprioritisations come from exactly?
Secondly, what assessment have the Government made of the report’s modelling that its proposed policies would reduce the youth NEET rate from 13.4% to 6.8% by 2036-37, particularly given that its NEET zero target is 5% and the lowest NEET rate on record was, sadly, 9.7% in June 2021?
Thirdly, will the Government set out a timeline for the phasing in of the reduction of NICs? On that, I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott. Will the Government commit to beginning its implementation in the next Budget? Will they consider cutting employers’ NICs beyond hospitality and retail to undo more of the damage caused by the jobs tax?
Fourthly, the youth opportunity service is tasked with delivering statutory opportunity and support guarantees across England by 2029, including mental health navigation, vocational rehabilitation, community work and health teams, and a local health and disability fund. Can the Minister say how much funding and staffing resource the Government will allocate to the youth opportunity service?
The review proposes a statutory duty to require benefit claimants not to refuse
“reasonable offers without good cause”,
backed, ultimately, by reductions in the youth allowance. What statutory criteria will define “reasonable offers” and “good cause”? It is very vague.
The Milburn review proposes three new support categories: a local health and disability fund, an additional cost allowance, and a severe and complex needs allowance. What is the Government’s assessment of how many young people will move into each category? The review also stresses that existing claimants should move to the new system following a personalised, time-limited transition. Can the Government set out the timeline for this proposed vague change?
PIP is a passport benefit for other benefits such as carer’s allowance, yet carer’s allowance does not seem to feature anywhere in the Milburn report. Perhaps I missed it—in the 278-odd pages. How will the Government ensure that carers do not lose access to their carer’s allowance off the back of these changes? How exactly will the Government decide where the line is drawn for the different types of support? The DWP has around 2 million overdue work capability assessments for universal credit health support. The Government want to merge these with the PIP assessment. How will the Government ensure that this process is workable? Will they commit to doing more assessments face to face so that claimants are better and correctly supported? What changes does the department intend to make to the implementation of the curriculum and assessment review in light of the Young people and work: interim report recommendations?
Alan Milburn explicitly warns Ministers against taking months to review his report. He calls for a legislative and funding timetable within the first 100 days. Will the Government commit to that 100-day deadline and publish a clear timetable showing which policies they accept, which they reject and when each will take effect?
One would have thought that, in light of a 278-page report, I would not have had to ask so many questions. I look forward to the answers.
The Minister of State, Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Smith of Malvern) (Lab)
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness and the noble Lord for their contributions. In the time I have available, I will do my best to respond to at least some of their questions.
Alan Milburn’s review is clear that the challenge it confronts has deep roots going back many years. Some of what the noble Baroness said made it sound as if this was a problem that has newly emerged. Let us be clear: the biggest increase in the numbers of young people not earning or learning was the 250,000 increase that occurred between the pandemic and this Government coming to power. As Alan Milburn himself says, no unfunded, unaffordable decrease in national insurance contributions will be a magic bullet that solves this problem. When it comes to the Employment Rights Act, having jobs with guaranteed hours and security is much more likely to keep young people in the workplace than the sort of uncertain work that the party opposite would want to dump them in.
The issue that Alan Milburn has done such an important piece of work on is damaging the life chances of 1 million young people who are not in education, work or training. This is a moral failure and an economic catastrophe, and we are determined to do something about it—in a way previous Governments did not. A challenge of this scale calls for a response that reaches far beyond one government department. The whole system must change. Young people need a new settlement, and Alan’s report sets out a blueprint for that. We have to move away from a system that all too easily signs off and writes off young people and build a new system that believes in and values their generation, with earlier intervention, stronger support, more devolution and clear expectations to take part.
That is why we have already started. We have started with a £2.5 billion youth guarantee. The Milburn review makes further proposals for how we put work and opportunity at the heart of the system, because it should give young people the best chance of higher living standards throughout their lives. It should start by asking what they need to build a good future. That is why we have already said that we support Alan Milburn’s recommendation for a new opportunity and support guarantee, backed by legislation, so that every young person who is not earning or learning has a credible route forward.
We have also said that we will support and implement his recommendation for a more personalised system that brings together the support and opportunities that young people need at a local level, making the most of local connections and expertise. When a young person needs help to get back on track, they should have one place to turn to, with a clear point of contact and one plan; and yes, we will ensure that the £500 million is available as a budget for the youth opportunity service next year.
In this new system, opportunity must be matched by responsibility—on which we have rightly been challenged. Where somebody can participate, with the right support, they should be expected to take up that support. Because building this system requires a joint effort across government and society, we have also committed to creating a new youth opportunities unit, reporting directly to the Prime Minister, to co-ordinate this. Today, my right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Education announced that we will guarantee a funded college place for every 16 to 18 year-old who wants one, giving those who have disengaged a fresh start. That is four significant commitments, ahead of our full response next year.
The noble Baroness suggested that there are no jobs out there for young people. I am enormously grateful for the progress we have seen in recent weeks, with the retail, hospitality and tourism sectors stepping forward with an offer of 250,000 jobs over the coming years for young people who are not currently earning or learning. We know that employers are keen to support this mission, and we will support them in helping us with that. Our work to change the system continues. As the Secretary of State has announced, we are expanding eligibility for the jobs guarantee, bringing that subsidised six-month job back to the point where a young person has been out of work for a year, rather than the current 18 months.
The Timms review of personal independence payments will report shortly. When we have that review, we will bring it together with Alan’s work to enable us to respond fully on the points about benefits that Alan makes in his report, and that noble Lords have made this evening. We will respond fully in the new year with a White Paper, followed by legislation.
On savings, let me be clear: we do want to spend less money on young people sitting out of the jobs and the learning that will create their future. However, we know from experience that the only way to do that successfully is to put the support in place first to enable those young people to get their place in work and in learning. We have learned what happens when you make abrupt cuts: it simply forces spending into the health system, into housing and into the criminal justice system. We are determined not only to make savings, but in a way that enables young people to have the chance of the future that this report is all about.
Together, this is our chance to reshape the system into one that invests in success, rather than paying the costs of failure; one that offers young people a new settlement, so that, whoever they are and wherever they are from, they can fulfil their potential—and so can our country.
My Lords, we have 20 minutes for questions. We will start with the Labour Benches and then work our way around the Chamber. The second question will come from the Conservative Benches.
Lord Stace (Lab)
My Lords, as a former chief executive of the Prince’s Trust, now the King’s Trust, I urge all of us to show young people that we understand the seriousness of this situation and that we will do whatever it takes to give them the best chance in life. Can my noble friend ensure that the centrepiece for action, the youth opportunity service, is designed with charities, employers, colleges and mayors, so that we create a system that works for the long term?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
My noble friend is absolutely right, and that is certainly our intention. Not only will that service operate at a local level, where it will make the most difference in bringing together the services that young people need, but it will do that with the sorts of partners that my noble friend identified. There is a crucial job for employers and a vital job for local authorities, but the voluntary sector, in particular the organisation that my noble friend cited, has an enormously important role to play in providing that support and future for young people, and it will be part of this project.
My Lords, I was Secretary of State when we had the lowest ever NEETs level and youth unemployment on record, whether measured in percentages, actual numbers, seasonally adjusted totals or real people. The point is that this is about real people. The Milburn review is a mixture of gold and pyrite. I wonder whether the Labour Government and the Prime Minister will understand that chapter 5, on the NHS, is the gold; the risk is that the rest is the pyrite. I desperately want to see more young people in jobs, but Alan Milburn has asked for £500 million. What is going to be cut? As one good example, next year £570 million will be spent on quite a small number of young people on Erasmus. Would it not be better to put that money into making sure that young people get going and have the youth opportunities that they deserve and merit, rather than choosing something to do with Erasmus?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
The Prime Minister is clear that we need to find the funding from across government to support the youth opportunity service. As I said to the noble Lord, we will ensure that that budget is in place for the youth opportunity service next year. The noble Baroness also made an important point about the contribution of health. That is why this is a cross-government effort and why the youth opportunity unit will play that important role in ensuring that all parts of government are contributing to the future that young people need.
Lord McCobb (LD)
My Lords, the Statement points towards giving mayors a greater role in skills and employment. In Hull and east Yorkshire, months of delays to the launch of Connect to Work prompted local MPs to write to the mayor to express concern that millions of pounds of support could have been lost in the delay. In handing mayors more responsibility for this critical area of work, how will the Government make sure that they and their authorities have the ability and the capacity to deliver it?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
The noble Lord makes an important point. We believe that the sorts of services that exist at local level, such as the youth opportunity service, can be co-ordinated at that level, commissioned by mayoral authorities but, in many cases, as I said to my noble friend, delivered by the voluntary sector, local authorities and the local health service. Those services are best organised around a young person at that level. The test will be the change that it makes for young people and the ability to deliver the opportunity and support guarantee that we have also committed to as part of our response to this report.
My Lords, I am hugely supportive of this new deal for our young. It is a vision that simply must be made to work for all our young. That is what I wish to highlight, because nowhere does this report address the specific problems of the rural young. How do they get from home to the local technology college, which is probably 12, 13 or 14 miles away—every day there and back? How do they get to their first job? It is possibly only seven or eight miles away, but even so, how do they get there and back every day without any transport? I would love to talk to the Minister and her team about the rural solutions to all the rural NEET problems. Believe me, NEET problems in rural areas are considerable, certainly where I come from in Cornwall. They really need considering in depth on their own, so I hope there is going to be serious consideration of the problems of a rural rollout of this review.
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
The noble Lord makes an important point, and of course makes the case for a locally designed youth opportunity service. What it is necessary to provide for young people in Cornwall to be able to access those opportunities may well be different from what it is necessary to provide in a city. Transport will obviously be one of those areas of support that we will need to put in place for young people to be able to access the jobs or college places that will be made available to them.
Baroness MacLeod of Camusdarach (Lab)
My Lords, the aims and aspirations of this report should be celebrated, but I have a serious question to ask my noble friend: how confident is she that these changes will be rolled out throughout the United Kingdom, particularly in Scotland?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
My noble friend makes a really important point, not least given the levels of young people not earning or learning in Scotland. While elements of this report will be delivered on the basis of powers that exist only in England, we will certainly want to work extremely closely with Governments in Scotland and Wales to ensure that the new system and the support that Alan Milburn has proposed in this report are available for everybody across the whole of the United Kingdom.
My Lords, I would like to ask a question about youth unemployment, as that is what the committee was set up for. There are 981,000 16 to 24 year-olds unemployed in our country today. That is unacceptable and a disgrace to the fifth-richest country in the world. It is because both Conservative and Labour Governments have failed to provide 18 year-olds with employable skills. That is why I set up new technical schools—university technical colleges—and Alan Milburn refers to them in his report. He says that we want to expand, but no new schools will be built for seven years in Britain because of falling school rolls. His review states:
“The UTC model should also be expanded. There are currently 44 UTCs … representing around 1% of state-funded secondary schools. A recent analysis found that UTC leavers were more likely to enter apprenticeships and more likely to be employed. Mainstream secondary schools are already beginning to build on the model by adopting the ‘UTC Sleeve’ approach”
for 14 to 16 year-olds in bog-standard comprehensives and existing secondary schools. Two opened last week, in Barrow-in-Furness and in Darwen. The review states:
“It … should become over time a mainstream part of the school landscape”.
So my question is: should the UTC model be expanded and become, in time, a mainstream part of the school system?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
From the sound of it, the noble Lord has done as good a job of lobbying Alan Milburn as he does of lobbying me on UTC sleeves. The key point, which he has been arguing for many years, is the ability of young people to have that exposure from the age of 14 to a technical education that can show them the routes into work. That is precisely why the Prime Minister has already started us down a route of developing those technical routes from 14 to 16. It is why we are already reforming qualifications post 16 in order to ensure that those routes are available. The UTC sleeve is an important way in which that can happen, and we will certainly consider that as part of our response to developing those better routes to technical education for young people.
My Lords, can the Minister give us a little guide to which department will be the ultimate lead here? We have been told that it will report to the Prime Minister. We all know what happens: it is the new, shiny project of a Minister or a Prime Minister, but the money has got to come out of a budget. Which Secretary of State will be responsible for this, or is this a new model that will depend on the enthusiasm of the Prime Minister of the day?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
In my experience in government, when you face a very big challenge such as this, it is absolutely fundamental to have not just the enthusiasm but the support and commitment of the Prime Minister. He has quite clearly demonstrated that here. It is also, of course, the case that when something needs input from across government, you need a way to co-ordinate that. That is the reasoning behind the Government’s proposal to set up the youth opportunities unit in the centre of government, reporting to the Prime Minister, with the job of co-ordinating those departments to ensure that everything necessary is there to deliver not only the service but the response that will be necessary to ensure that young people have the future they want. That machinery of government approach and the absolute commitment of the Prime Minister are what are likely to make this a success and bring government together to deliver it.
My Lords, Alan Milburn’s very welcome report emphasises:
“Poverty and inequality are at the core of the NEET crisis”.
In the long term, the hope is that his new settlement will reduce poverty. It is worth noting the big reduction in child poverty that has just been announced because of the abolition of the two-child limit. What assessment have the Government made of the impact on poverty in the shorter term? There are fears among disability groups not just that cuts to benefits for some disabled young people will cause more hardship but that that increased hardship will itself make it harder for them to take up the work or educational opportunities that are being opened up for them.
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
I do not think there is anything more likely to make somebody poor throughout their lives than, at the point at which they should be entering the workforce, being put on benefits that provide them with no question of what they are able to do and no support to enable them to do it. We are determined to turn the system around to get that support in place, not simply to leave young people on benefits without that future.
My noble friend makes an important point about the detail of benefit changes. That is why, as I have said, when the Timms review reports in the near future, we will bring together the really important work that has been led by that group, alongside Alan’s proposals, and come forward with detailed proposals about proposed benefit changes, which everybody will be able to scrutinise. She is right that an important test will be how all the changes we are making help to reduce poverty and provide young people with the chance of a fruitful life. That will certainly be a yardstick that we will use to determine our proposals.
Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Antrobus) (Lab)
We will hear from the Greens first.
My Lords, Wales is now starting the Nature Service, delivering part of what the green new deal movement, nature charities and campaign groups have been calling for across these islands—a national nature service. It will have work outside in green spaces, in active jobs that are ideal for many. Yet “nature” appears only four times in the 278-page report and there is nothing referring to the natural world, despite its desperate need for repair for labour. Are the Government at least prepared to consider a significant investment in a national nature service? That is something that could provide good jobs and would be for the public good, rather than what is suggested here of subsidising existing employers, which will largely be giant multinational companies—subsidising their profits rather than working for the public good.
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
I think it is fair to say that Alan Milburn’s report, as others have mentioned, is pretty wide-ranging. It feels a little unfair to criticise it on the basis that it did not take up that particular point about a nature service. Where I agree with the noble Baroness is that we have to find a range of opportunities for young people, through work experience, work and training, to experience what it is like to work in a way that enthuses them and makes them want to carry on working. It may well be, for some of them, that that type of activity outside would be the way to do it, but I am afraid I am not in a position to answer her specific questions about the nature service as part of this Statement.
If the Government conclude in the next month or so, when they are considering both the Milburn report and the Tims review, that it is the right thing to do to reduce national insurance contributions for young people, will they be brave enough to make that decision and execute it now, or will they wait a year until the next Budget, when they could have a year’s worth of that lower-cost employment taking effect and giving those young people an opportunity to get into work?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
First, I started off by explaining why all the evidence about how long this problem has existed for, and at which points it increased considerably, suggests that national insurance contributions are not the determining factor here. Secondly, the noble Lord knows that decisions about taxes and national insurance contributions will be made at the point of a Budget and will be made by the Chancellor of the Exchequer.
Lord Pitkeathley of Camden Town (Lab)
My Lords, I refer the House to my registered interests representing two business communities in north London. Can my noble friend the Minister say a little more about how the businesses that provide the jobs, pay the taxes and bring life to our high streets will experience the government support implied in yesterday’s report as they help to tackle this national challenge?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
My noble friend is right: businesses, in my experience, are very keen to help us to tackle this challenge. We know that they are under pressure and we want to make it easier for them to hire young people. We are already providing substantial support to reduce the cost of employing young people. There has been a lot of talk about national insurance contributions. Of course, it is the case that if you employ somebody aged under 21, you pay no national insurance contributions. If they are an apprentice then you pay no national insurance contributions up to the age of 25, saving up to £6,790 per eligible employee.
One of the Prime Minister’s first announcements in office was to cut business rates for pubs. At the Budget, the Chancellor extended business rates cuts for thousands of retail, hospitality and leisure businesses—sectors that are particularly important in giving young people their first step back into work. Through the youth guarantee, the growth and skills levy and our apprenticeship work, we are providing incentives to employers to take on young people who are neither earning nor learning. My noble friend is right that we need to work alongside business to ensure that those jobs are there, but that is work that we have already started.
Lord Bailey of Paddington (Con)
My Lords, can the Minister tell the House what work is being done to give small firms better access to the apprenticeship levy? Does she agree that young people do not want endless training schemes? They want actual work. What measures will the Government be taking to ensure that young people end up in permanent full-time work?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
This Government, in reforming the growth and skills levy, have already increased incentives for small businesses to take on apprentices, are now fully funding the cost of an apprenticeship for small businesses and, through the funding made available for local apprenticeship services, will enable small businesses to get the advice and links to young people who want to be apprentices who I know those businesses are keen to get. In all those ways, we are ensuring that young people are getting the type of training, alongside a job, that supports not only them but the employer to bring on an enthusiastic young person for their business.
My Lords, does my noble friend the Minister agree that, as well as concern about the scarring impacts of unemployment on the young, we must also take account of the scarring impacts of insecure, low-paid work? Young people are twice as likely to be trapped in that revolving door of low-paid, insecure work as older workers. Does she agree that ensuring we have well-paid, quality employment opportunities for young people is as important as ensuring that they get off unemployment?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
My noble friend is absolutely right and, of course, the two are linked. We make no apology, therefore, as I said, for wanting young people to start their working lives in decent, secure jobs. Young people are among those who stand to benefit most from stronger employment rights, because they are, as my noble friend says, disproportionately represented in low-paid, insecure work. Giving people greater certainty over their hours and income can make work more attractive and give young people the confidence and stability they need to stay in work. Our employment rights legislation is not only morally but economically right.
My Lords, following on from the question from the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, on page 66, paragraph 307, Mr Milburn says that
“when considering the responses to the recent consultation”
on zero-hours contracts,
“the goal should be to ensure that the potential impact on youth employment should be a primary consideration, and a cautionary principle should be adopted”.
It does not sound like the Minister agrees with Mr Milburn. Am I wrong?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
Not only do I agree with him, but that is what we are doing. We want the reforms that we are putting in place to work for employers too, which is why we are working closely with businesses and unions on implementation and listening carefully to the issues raised by Alan Milburn. We do not accept a choice between creating opportunities for young people and giving them decent rights when they get to work. We need to do both.
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords ChamberMy Lords, we discussed this issue in Committee at some length, but I was not confident then that a clear message had been delivered to the railway industry that transport integration matters and is crucial to increasing the use of the rail system as opposed to other forms of transport, particularly the private car. The objective of raising the matter again on Report is to get the Minister to express as clearly as he can what I know he thinks. I do not think there is any disagreement between us about this. This is an important matter, and real progress could be made. The procedures and processes that he described in Committee, which already exist—the integrated transport strategy and things like that—do not seem to be delivering. I do not think they will deliver in their present form, and I therefore think that more attention needs to be given to it.
When you look at who is not using the train for journeys, various categories come to mind. One is people who live in a town that does not have a railway station and is not on the rail network and who therefore have to drive to some other place if they want to make use of the train. If there were a good bus connection on which they could rely, they would not need to use the car, pay a car parking fee and spend money on petrol, but rarely is that possibility available.
Then there are people who commute on a daily basis, or two or three days a week, from an often busy station into central London or other urban centres, who again use the car to get to the train or decide that, since they have to get the car out, they might as well do the whole journey in the car and not use the train. When the industry is looking for people who could be induced to use the rail system, this is a very fruitful field and much more could be done.
When it does not work, it is pretty distressing. If you arrive somewhere and there is supposed to be a bus to take you home the rest of the way, but no bus is there, you are in a hopeless position. If you arrive on a train five minutes later than the bus time and the bus has gone and has not waited for you, you are in an even more annoying position. Lots of people who have tried to use a supposedly partially integrated transport system are defeated by the inability of operators to work in conjunction.
In my amendment, I have pointed to things that are necessary: improved connections, actual timed connections between trains and buses, trains and ferries and trains and light rail; improved timetables that show that the connection exists, and the devising of a timetable that builds in the connections; and passenger information. Passengers need to be told what is available and be able to rely on that information. I do not need to say much more about it to make the Minister realise why I think it is so important.
When GBR begins its work, ceases to be a phantom body and becomes a real body, integration will be top of the agenda. However, it will not be this kind of integration. The integration that will be at the top of its agenda is to pull together the vastness of the British railway system and its many operators and participants. My fear is that that will crowd out any serious discussion of integration between different modes of transport.
I ask the Minister to make it clear that this is not an optional extra for the railway industry. It is crucial to the expansion of rail use. It is not something that might be considered in a few years’ time; it needs to be built into the system now. If we are building up a new timetable system and new links between what were previously separate railway companies, this is the time at which we need to build in new links with other transport operators. I ask the Minister to make sure that this is a priority and that the industry knows it is a priority. I beg to move.
My Lords, before I speak to my amendment in this group, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Beith, on his amendment because, on the very rare occasions when integrated transport has been mentioned, he has mentioned ferries. I live in the Isles of Scilly part of the time, and I got delayed for a whole week last week because there were no ferry services and no air services either. The co-ordination of timetables, ticketing and passenger information is important. I hope he will keep on pressing this issue, which is so simple but does not actually happen.
I will speak to Amendments 28, 29, 30 and 31 in this group, which are to do with rail freight. I was very pleased to see in Clause 17 that the Government wish to introduce a target for growth in rail freight, which is something new. I congratulate my noble friend the Minister on getting this through—a lot of people would probably say that it cannot be done. What the target should contain is obviously of interest to noble Lords. I have put in a figure of a 100% increase until 2040, which seems a long way away, but it is not that far away. Other people would say that it should be a bit less. Amendment 29 includes the need for explanations.
As to how that growth can be achieved, I tried to put in Amendment 30 some of the ideas that would need to be delivered for it to happen, including “reduced access charges” and “removal of penalty charges”, which we will come to later, as well as “improvements to rail infrastructure” to enable the trains to run faster, “improvements to junction capacity”, “reduced capacity delays” and some better electrification.
We in this House have talked to my noble friend the Minister about some of these before. Small investments in, say, the line to London Gateway at Tilbury or in the line from Felixstowe at Ely would enable all these things to happen. The way that the infrastructure manager works at the moment is that if they have the money, they will do it, but if they do not, they will not do it. Either way, freight operators would not be charged —that is what is in my Amendment 30 at proposed new subsection (3B).
Whatever percentage of growth is agreed, it is also important, as I put down in Amendment 31, that:
“The ORR must monitor the growth of rail freight against the target and publish the results annually”.
If it does not think that GBR is doing it properly, it must require further action and impose penalties. This is a very early attempt to put some flesh on the targets. I repeat that I am grateful to my noble friend the Minister for introducing them. I am sure that there will be many comments around the industry as to whether they are suitable, but I am still grateful that they are appearing at all. I hope we can take something forward on this.
My Lords, I have three amendments in this group—I will try to stick to time. Amendment 35 is about transport integration, which has been one of the biggest omissions from the Bill. It seems illogical that a Bill setting out the future of our railways says so little about how rail connects with the rest of the transport system. The existing Railways Act included duties to develop an integrated system of transport for passengers and goods, and to make it easier for passengers to complete journeys involving more than one operator. Those duties have disappeared with this Bill. This issue is important because very few people think about their journey in terms of individual transport operators; they just want to get to where they are going.
The Department for Transport’s own impact assessment recognises the problem. Its figures show that half of public transport journeys in England in 2023 involved more than one transport mode. It also identifies poor co-ordination between different modes as a barrier to integration. For me, this is quite personal, because I take at least two train journeys a week and then I take bus journeys after that, and it is really not easy to get them integrated.
But it is not just about convenience. Better integration means fewer unnecessary car journeys, better access to public transport for people who cannot drive, and a railway that serves communities rather than simply connecting major towns and cities. This amendment would restore a clear duty to support integrated transport. It would make sure that connecting journeys were considered as part of railway planning rather than left to individual operators or local authorities to sort out.
My next two amendments, Amendments 37 and 32, are about growing passenger numbers and making the whole journey work—not just the bit on the train. We need to get more people using public transport and fewer people relying on private cars. Transport is the UK’s highest-emitting sector. We cannot seriously address climate change without changing how people travel.
The railway has a major role in that, but it will not happen simply because we have a publicly owned railway. We need a clear commitment to making rail a more attractive alternative to driving. I personally think it is a much more attractive alternative—I would much rather take the train than drive—but I meet a lot of people who do not think like that. There is already recognition of this in Wales, where the Government have targets for increasing the proportion of journeys made by sustainable transport. Scotland has also maintained a policy commitment to reducing car use, although its previous target to reduce car kilometres by 20% by 2030 was abandoned after it concluded that it was not achievable.
I think there is general recognition across the UK that we need to reduce our dependence on private cars, but the railway legislation does not give GBR a clear duty to contribute to that change. We obviously need to think about the whole system, not just individual rail services. Taken together, these amendments are about giving Great British Railways the tools and responsibilities to grow passenger numbers and deliver a better transport system.
We cannot deal with any of these things in isolation. We cannot expect people to leave their cars at home if the train is too expensive, if the connecting bus does not turn up or if the journey simply is not practical. I really feel that these things should be central to the purpose of GBR.
My Lords, I do not know what my noble friend the Minister is going to say about Amendment 27, but I hope he will stress how important it is to have integration. My noble friend Lord Berkeley talked about the problems of his commuting and the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, referred to her journeys. Like other Members, I commute to this House every day, and I cannot tell noble Lords how maddening it is to take a tram to a station for a connecting journey by train only to find that, as the tram pulls into the station, it waits before opening the doors and the train—literally as far away as my noble friend is on the Front Bench now—moves off and I miss the connection. This is a small practical example, but I hope that as a result of the Bill and the new era that we are going to enter, small things such as this can be addressed. It will make an enormous difference for people to feel that the transport network we have is truly integrated.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, in Amendment 27 my noble friend Lord Beith rightly flags the importance of connectivity and integration between transport modes. Ensuring timetables work well together will ensure that passengers have confidence in using services. We have heard a number of examples from noble Lords of their own experiences. There is no point having an hourly train service arriving at a station to find only minutes later that the bus or the tram connecting passengers to the local area has left. The same applies, as we have heard, to ferries and other modes of transport. I hope the Minister will be able to assure my noble friend that he is committed to improving this connectivity. Indeed, I would like to see this in information at stations and the ability to purchase multimodal through tickets on apps, as I have seen and used in other countries. Training staff at stations will also be important to provide a more comprehensive passenger service and to show what this new Great British Railways is all about. What is the added value we are getting from this new public service? Building this in from the start is key, as my noble friend Lord Beith said.
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have participated in this debate. I will start by speaking to Amendment 84 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, which would place a duty on Great British Railways to exercise its statutory functions to increase passenger numbers. What we have heard from this Government is that they want a passenger-focused railway. We all want to see more people using our railways, but ultimately that will depend on providing passengers with good, reliable and affordable services. A competitive and efficient railway system that encourages innovation, investment and improvements in the quality of services will help achieve precisely that.
The important question is how we ensure that Great British Railways delivers a railway that passengers actually want to use. I therefore look forward to hearing from the Minister how the Government intend to improve reliability, encourage competition and attract more passengers to the railway. The Government should have the objective of increasing passenger numbers, although whether a target is necessary is debatable, as are competing priorities on the railways such as an existing freight growth target.
We welcome Amendments 28 to 31 from the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley. Amendment 28 would require rail freight to double by 2040. Amendment 29 would require explanations when the target is reviewed. Amendment 30 would require Great British Railways to set out how it intends to achieve the target, including through reduced access charges, improvements to infrastructure and increased capacity, while protecting freight operators from the associated costs. Amendment 31 would give the Office of Rail and Road powers to monitor progress annually and take enforcement action where the target is at risk of not being met.
The Government have committed to increasing rail freight by 40% by 2040, with a longer-term target of 75% by 2050. However, 2040 is still 14 years away, and it is important that the Government demonstrate what they are doing now to achieve these ambitions. Just announcing a target is not enough; the industry needs certainty and confidence that the Government have a credible plan to deliver it, particularly when operators are making long-term investment decisions. These amendments therefore raise important questions about the practical steps the Government will take, how progress will be measured and what accountability there will be if the targets are not being met. I hope the Minister can provide some reassurance to the House on these matters.
My Lords, let me begin by turning to Amendments 27 and 35, which are both about the important issue of integrating rail passenger services with other public transport modes. As highlighted in Committee, I absolutely agree that passengers want a transport system that works as a whole. This is something the Government agree with and are already working towards. That is why we published Better Connected: a Strategy for Integrated Transport in April of this year. The strategy brings together domestic transport across England into a single plan built around the principles of people, place and partnership. It includes eight priority areas focused on what people have told us they need, including simpler ticketing and reliable journeys.
As part of the strategy, the Government have set out 40 commitments to be delivered within this Parliament to improve modal connectivity. This includes, for example, providing £6 million to support a rural integrated transport demonstrator programme in the Hope Valley and exploring further integration between train and bus services. They also committed to working with transport providers to ensure they open up access to high-quality data, in line with existing legislation, enabling better real-time information for passengers to plan. In addition, as set out in a discussion document published during Committee, the long-term rail strategy will set out expectations for GBR in relation to multimodal integration, which was identified as a key factor in achieving three of the Secretary of State’s five strategic objectives, including improving connectivity, meeting the needs of future passengers and supporting sustainability.
To respond specifically to the noble Lord, Lord Beith, the noble Baronesses, Lady Jones and Lady Pidgeon, and my noble friend Lord Stansgate, GBR is mandated to have regard to both the long-term rail strategy, which I have just spoken about, and the local transport plans of strategic authorities. This sets a clear ambition that decisions should account for both national requirements and local multimodal needs.
The Bill provides further mechanisms to ensure this happens, including enabling partnership arrangements between GBR and strategic authorities, which can only lead to a better understanding of what good local connectivity looks like, and therefore improved outcomes for passengers. The Bus Services Act, which this House passed some little time ago, deliberately allows greater control for local transport authorities, which will give more stability for bus services and enable the relationship that I just mentioned. In addition, the national integrated transport strategy says:
“GBR will be responsible for the management of most stations, including developing interchange stations to support seamless connections to other forms of public transport, roads, and walking, wheeling and cycling. By working closely with local authorities and transport operators, with opportunities for devolved control, GBR will ensure stations and station precincts work well for passengers and the communities they serve”.
On Amendment 37, I know that modal shift is important to the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. As I confirmed in Committee, the long-term rail strategy will reference modal shift and connectivity between modes. Indeed, the discussion document I mentioned earlier outlines how encouraging modal shift by increasing the attractiveness of rail is key to the Government’s sustainability objective. The Bill supports this objective through the inclusion of the public interest duty at Clause 18, which explicitly includes the effect on the environment in its definition. This ensures that GBR is bound by this duty when making key decisions, and that it will respond to the LTRS ambitions specifically in its business plan, meaning that modal shift is actively considered throughout GBR’s governance and decision-making.
I turn to Amendments 32 and 84, which both look to increase passenger numbers on the railway. I agree that we must increase the number of passengers on the railway. GBR will be expected to attract passengers by providing a reliable, efficient service in which passengers can have confidence. The long-term rail strategy discussion document outlines multiple ways in which we expect GBR to deliver passenger growth, whether through improving multimodal journeys or looking at how best to make use of the network. I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, that multimodal ticketing and perhaps a passenger loyalty scheme would help as well; we will discuss that on day two of Report.
To support this, the Bill includes a passenger duty requiring GBR to promote the
“interests of users and potential users of railway passenger services”,
which requires GBR to consider how best to encourage new users on to the railways. I am happy to confirm that considering the interests of potential users will incentivise GBR to think about underutilised markets and their interests. For example, we know that older people travel less, on average, and to meet this duty I would expect GBR to be thinking about what it can do to attract these groups to use the railway.
As I explained in Committee, I do not think we should have an additional or stronger passenger growth duty; it could push the duties out of balance and undermine the incentive for GBR to promote freight, for example. As GBR’s revenue already comes from passengers, there will naturally be pressure to increase this revenue, meaning there is already an inherent risk that GBR might seek to prioritise passengers to the detriment of freight. That is precisely why we have included two freight duties to sit alongside the passenger interest duty, which is designed to address passenger growth. I hope this reassures both noble Baronesses that passenger growth is actively supported by the Bill.
I turn to Amendments 28 to 31 from my noble friend Lord Berkeley. I reassure him that we are aligned on our intentions for freight growth. This Government are committed to meaningful rail freight growth, so that the economic and environmental benefits can be fully realised. It is therefore as important to me as anyone that the target be ambitious but deliverable, in order to bring the freight sector out of its current stagnation and deliver the benefits we all agree on.
Close collaboration with the freight industry has been key to developing these targets throughout. The targets reflect the desire of industry to balance ambition with a realistic and sustainable approach to driving freight growth. We have therefore ensured that the figures of 40% and 75% are supported by significant evidence and analysis, demonstrating that they can be achieved given the right support from GBR and the sector—for example, by modelling existing pipeline commitments and assumptions of future investment. To be clear, without significant new investment in rail and infrastructure enhancements, the target could not be reached. The target also requires significant investment from industry. This is therefore the most ambitious target that is still achievable for GBR on these timescales, and the sector agrees.
Crucially, the freight sector has welcomed these targets and the ambition they demonstrate. For example, the Rail Freight Group highlighted that the target
“sends a strong message about the benefits and potential of rail freight, which will encourage investment by industry and private businesses and attract more customers to move their goods by rail”.
The support of the freight sector will be vital in ensuring that these targets can be achieved, and it reflects our expectation that GBR will work closely with the sector as part of this. I hope this explanation reassures my noble friend that this is a genuinely ambitious target that will not be achieved without significant investment, collaboration and focus, to which GBR will be held to account for delivering. I would expect any future Government to set out in similar terms their rationale for any future growth target, which I hope also satisfies my noble friend’s amendment on that front.
On Amendments 30 and 31, my noble friend will be pleased to hear that we are absolutely aligned on ensuring that GBR is required to set out how it will meet the target, and on the important role of the ORR in monitoring its progress. That is exactly the process that the Bill provides for with GBR’s business plan. As part of the business planning process, GBR will be required to transparently set out how it plans to deliver the Government’s priorities, which will of course include the freight growth target. The Secretary of State will sign off this business plan and provide funding only once she is satisfied that what is included delivers on the long-term rail strategy and the freight growth target and reflects GBR’s duties. The ORR will provide expert advice to the Secretary of State on the deliverability and robustness of the plan as part of this, and it will continue to monitor GBR’s performance against the business plan once it is agreed.
Should the ORR believe that GBR is failing to follow its agreed business plan or to meet its freight growth target, it can raise this directly with GBR and its board, publish information to name and shame GBR, or refer this to the Secretary of State for more direct enforcement. This process ensures that GBR must not only demonstrate how it plans to meet the freight growth target but actively demonstrate delivery. I hope this reassures my noble friend not only that the freight growth target we have chosen is evidenced, ambitious and deliverable but that the Bill already ensures GBR will be held to account for its delivery. I therefore ask noble Lords not to press their amendments.
My Lords, I am grateful to all who have taken part in this short debate and emphasised the need to grow rail traffic, both freight and passenger, as an environmentally friendly form of transport. I still have this nightmare that Great British Railways will struggle to integrate itself and the many elements of the railway system that have been brought together, and that integration with other forms of transport could get pushed to one side as a result. The Minister has done his best to reassure me on that point and has cited things that should already be having the effect that we desire. There is no disagreement between us. I have no desire to press the amendment to a Division, because we do not disagree. I just want him to keep at it and continue to emphasise that there is an untapped market of people who would use rail if they could access it, assisted by other forms of public transport. With that, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.