Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question
To ask His Majesty's Government what plans they have to pursue a permission-first policy for the protection of individual artists’ work from scraping by tech companies and to ensure all artists who are included in a licensing deal will receive fair remuneration for the use of their work.
Answered by Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood - Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State (Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport)
We want creators to have greater control over how their work is used. The Report and Impact Assessment on AI and copyright, published on 18 March, sets out a programme of work to advance our objectives of creator control, access and transparency. The Government will set out its final policy position once this work concludes.
Our work includes supporting licensing through initiatives such as the Creative Content Exchange pilot, launched in January 2026 with twelve cultural institutions, which enables rights holders to license digitised works to AI developers while retaining control. We have also established a working group of independent creators and smaller creative organisations to explore whether and how the Government can support their ability to license content.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question to the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade:
To ask His Majesty's Government what assessment they have made of the Smart Fund proposal to use funds from sales of electronic devices which copy, store, and share creative content to pay creators and performers whose work is accessed, distributed, and stored on such devices.
Answered by Baroness Lloyd of Effra - Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State (Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport)
The Government is not yet persuaded of the case for the Smart Fund. Further evidence is needed to fully assess the benefits, costs and wider impacts on consumers and businesses as well as creators. The Government continues to engage with supporters of the Smart Fund and will consider any further evidence on its merits, taking account of the interests of all those affected.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question to the HM Treasury:
To ask His Majesty's Government, further to the answer by Lord Pitt-Watson on 26 October (HL Deb Col 929), whether they intend to seek reciprocal arrangements with the European Union at the EU-UK summit in November to allow fashion collections, samples, and garments for shows, shoots, and showrooms to be temporarily admitted by oral or by-conduct declaration, rather than requiring admission temporaire (ATA) or written customs declarations.
Answered by Lord Pitt-Watson - Parliamentary Secretary (HM Treasury)
The Government is aware of concerns from the fashion sector about the administrative and cost burdens associated with importing and exporting goods and we continue to engage with businesses and representative organisations to understand the practical impacts. This government remains committed to reducing barriers to trade with our closest trading partners. This is why the UK introduced digital ATA carnets on 1 June 2026, making the UK one of the first countries to do so alongside the EU, Switzerland and Norway. Digitising carnets replaces a paper-based process with a secure digital format, making them simpler for importers and exporters, including the fashion industry, to use. ATA Carnets are an optional facilitation, and it is a commercial decision for businesses and individuals whether to use them in place of individual customs declarations.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question
To ask His Majesty's Government what plans they have to protect the copyright of artists and creatives whose work has been scraped by tech companies; and what plans they have to license such content.
Answered by Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood - Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State (Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport)
We want creators to have greater control over how their work is used. The Report and Impact Assessment on AI and copyright, published on 18 March, sets out a programme of work to advance our objectives of creator control, access and transparency. The Government will set out its final policy position once this work concludes.
Our work includes supporting licensing through initiatives such as the Creative Content Exchange pilot, launched in January 2026 with twelve cultural institutions, which enables rights holders to license digitised works to AI developers while retaining control. We have also established a working group of independent creators and smaller creative organisations to explore whether and how the Government can support their ability to license content.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question to the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade:
To ask His Majesty's Government what discussions they have had with the (1) fashion, (2) hospitality, and (3) tourism sectors regarding a potential reinstatement of a UK retail export scheme.
Answered by Lord Leong - Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State (Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade)
The Government keeps the tax system under review and engages regularly with businesses and representative bodies across relevant sectors. BIST continues to engage with the apparel and hospitality sectors on their priorities, including issues affecting international competitiveness. The Government also engages with the tourism sector. Decisions on taxation, including any potential changes to the VAT Retail Export Scheme, are a matter for HM Treasury.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question
To ask His Majesty's Government, further to the Written Answer by Baroness Lloyd of Effra on 16 October (HL3770), what discussions they have had with the books trade, including the rare books trade, regarding reports of destructive scanning of physical books as part of model training.
Answered by Baroness Lloyd of Effra - Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State (Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport)
The government has met on numerous occasions with stakeholders from across the creative industries, including the books trade to discuss the impact of AI.
As previously outlined, the government is aware of reports of AI companies destructively scanning physical books as part of model training. As set out in our March report on copyright and AI, we are taking steps to help rightsholders control and license their work, including reviewing technical solutions, standards and best practice on input transparency.
The government will continue to engage with a range of stakeholders, including those in the creative industries, throughout this process.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question to the Home Office:
To ask His Majesty's Government whether their new right to work checks will apply to (1) artists, (2) bands, and (3) theatre troupes, undertaking short UK tours without visas; and, if so, what plans they have to waive the checks for these groups.
Answered by Chris McDonald - Minister of State (Department of Health and Social Care)
The changes to the Right to Work Scheme from 1 October extend checks beyond traditional employment to specified non-standard working arrangements. They do not alter the Immigration Rules governing visitors.
Professional artists, entertainers and musicians, including members of bands and theatre troupes, who enter the UK without a visa and undertake activities permitted under the Standard Visitor route, including a permitted paid engagement where the relevant requirements are met will not be subject to a right to work check solely by virtue of those activities. Therefore, the Government does not consider there to be an operational conflict, and a waiver is neither necessary nor planned.
Where a working arrangement falls within scope of the Right to Work Scheme, the responsible organisation must carry out a right to work check as prescribed in legislation and published guidance.
The Government has engaged with affected sectors in developing the regulations, statutory codes of practice and guidance, and will continue to engage with businesses and representative bodies, including the live entertainment sector where relevant, to support clear and proportionate implementation and address practical concerns.
Representatives from the arts and entertainment sector, including organisations representing performers and creative professionals, responded to the public consultation on extending the Right to Work Scheme. The Home Office considered stakeholder feedback from across affected sectors when developing the final guidance and implementation approach.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question to the Home Office:
To ask His Majesty's Government whether, following the changes to Right to Work checks on 1 October, performers touring the UK on the Permitted Paid Engagement or Permit Free Festival schemes are allowed to sell merchandise if it is related to their services as a performer.
Answered by Lord Collins of Highbury - Parliamentary Under-Secretary (Home Office)
The Standard Visitor route permits creatives to undertake a wide range of activities in the UK.
However, artists, entertainers and musicians can only receive payment for their activities as a visitor under very specific circumstances, such as if they are performing at a festival on the Permit Free Festival (PFF) list or undertaking a Permitted Paid Engagement (PPE).
The Immigration Rules prohibit visitors from directly selling to the public; including the sale of merchandise related to their PFF or PPE activities.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question to the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade:
To ask His Majesty's Government what assessment they have made of reports of destructive scanning of books by or for tech companies; and whether they intend to take action to halt this practice.
Answered by Baroness Lloyd of Effra - Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State (Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport)
The government is aware of reports of AI companies destructively scanning physical books as part of model training. As set out in our March report on copyright and AI, we are taking steps to help rightsholders control and license their work, including reviewing technical solutions, standards and best practice on input transparency.
This work will help inform whether Government intervention is needed, and if so, what a proportionate approach might look like.
Asked by: Earl of Clancarty (Crossbench - Life peer)
Question to the Department for Education:
To ask His Majesty's Government how much higher education subject courses cost for each of the strategic priority grant groups A, B, C and D; and what is the cut-off point between each group in monetary terms.
Answered by Baroness Smith of Malvern - Minister of State (Department for Work and Pensions)
The subject price groups used for higher education funding derive from the former Higher Education Funding Council for England teaching funding methodology, which categorised subjects according to their relative delivery costs.
The framework was retained by the Office for Students (OfS) in 2018 and is currently used to determine the allocation of high-cost subject funding through the Strategic Priorities Grant (SPG).
The department is working together with the OfS to review and reform the SPG. The reform will ensure that high-cost subject funding is more effectively targeted towards priority provision that supports future skills needs and the Industrial Strategy, as well as ensuring that funding is targeted towards the most disadvantaged students accessing and participating in higher education.