Information between 2nd May 2023 - 26th January 2026
Note: This sample does not contain the most recent 2 weeks of information. Up to date samples can only be viewed by Subscribers.
Click here to view Subscription options.
| Live Transcript |
|---|
|
Note: Cited speaker in live transcript data may not always be accurate. Check video link to confirm. |
|
5 Dec 2025, 1:17 p.m. - House of Lords "is with the word ordinarily. In 1983, Lord Scarman in the House of Lords judgement stated that " AMDT: 10 Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (Crossbench) - View Video - View Transcript |
| Parliamentary Debates |
|---|
|
Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill
192 speeches (37,331 words) Committee stage Friday 5th December 2025 - Lords Chamber Department of Health and Social Care Mentions: 1: Lord Lansley (Con - Life peer) she referred to, R v Barnet London Borough Council, ex parte Nilish Shah—the Shah case—in which Lord Scarman - Link to Speech |
|
Extremism Review
71 speeches (5,789 words) Tuesday 28th January 2025 - Commons Chamber Home Office Mentions: 1: James Cleverly (Con - Braintree) In the early years of Margaret Thatcher’s Government, Lord Scarman was commissioned to write a report - Link to Speech |
|
Employment Rights Bill (Twelfth sitting)
49 speeches (9,964 words) Committee stage: 12th Sitting Thursday 12th December 2024 - Public Bill Committees Department for Business and Trade Mentions: 1: Laurence Turner (Lab - Birmingham Northfield) The Government of the day commissioned a public inquiry under Lord Scarman in the belief that, if the - Link to Speech |
|
Arbitration Bill [HL]
33 speeches (11,776 words) Second reading committee Tuesday 19th December 2023 - Grand Committee Ministry of Justice Mentions: 1: Lord Hacking (Lab - Excepted Hereditary) Lord Diplock took part—I am just trying to remember all those who did—as did Lord Scarman and Lord Wilberforce - Link to Speech |
|
King’s Speech
112 speeches (57,201 words) Wednesday 8th November 2023 - Lords Chamber Ministry of Justice Mentions: 1: Lord Paddick (Non-affiliated - Life peer) will focus on is the preservation of the peace.In 1981, in his report on the Brixton disorders, Lord Scarman - Link to Speech |
| Select Committee Documents |
|---|
|
Wednesday 15th May 2024
Written Evidence - Windrush Against Sewage Pollution WQI0015 - Water quality and water infrastructure: follow-up Environmental Audit Committee Found: .599H to p.600A, the speech of Lord Fraser of Tullybelton at p.607F to p.608C, the speech of Lord Scarman |
| Bill Documents |
|---|
|
Feb. 12 2025
Written evidence submitted by Dr Isra Black, UCL Faculty of Laws (TIAB190) Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill 2024-26 Written evidence Found: 7 TIA Bill, clause 1(1)(b). 8 Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech AHA [1986] AC 112, 188-189 (Lord Scarman |
|
Jan. 28 2025
Written evidence submitted by Sir Nicholas Mostyn (TIAB17) Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill 2024-26 Written evidence Found: Lord Scarman was clear that "It will be a question of fact [for the doctor] whether a child seeking |
|
Jun. 29 2023
Written evidence submitted by Amnesty International UK (VPB35) Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 Written evidence Found: [17] As Lord Scarman famously said, ‘he who is subject to English law is entitled to its protections |
| Department Publications - News and Communications |
|---|
|
Tuesday 25th February 2025
Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government Source Page: Recovered appeal: Great Sike Road, Old Malton, Malton, YO17 6SB (ref: 3342002 - 25 February 2025) Document: (PDF) Found: In accordance with the principles set out by Lord Scarman in Westminster City council v Great Portland |
| Department Publications - Statistics |
|---|
|
Thursday 26th September 2024
Home Office Source Page: The Historical Roots of the Windrush Scandal Document: (PDF) Found: Five years later, in his report into race riots in Brixton in 1981, Lord Scarman concluded that existing |
| Non-Departmental Publications - Guidance and Regulation |
|---|
|
Oct. 14 2025
Environment Agency Source Page: CW5 6DB, Nick Brookes: Appeal Reference APP/EPR/684 Document: (PDF) Guidance and Regulation Found: Dictum of Lord Scarman in Pioneer Aggregates (UK) Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment [1985] |
|
Oct. 14 2025
Environment Agency Source Page: CW5 6DB, Nick Brookes: Appeal Reference APP/EPR/684 Document: (PDF) Guidance and Regulation Found: 1984, in Pioneer Aggregates Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment [1985] 1 A.C. 132 , Lord Scarman |
|
Oct. 14 2025
Environment Agency Source Page: CW5 6DB, Nick Brookes: Appeal Reference APP/EPR/684 Document: (PDF) Guidance and Regulation Found: As Lord Scarman pointed out in Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment [1981 |
| Non-Departmental Publications - News and Communications |
|---|
|
Jun. 03 2025
Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber) Source Page: [2025] UKUT 00164 (TCC) Nellsar Limited v The Commissioners for His Majesty's Revenue and Customs Document: Nellsar Limited v The Commissioners for His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (PDF) News and Communications Found: Lord Scarman expressed his view on the manner in which the apportionment was to be made at page 847: |
|
Dec. 13 2023
Employment Appeal Tribunal Source Page: The Kingdom of Spain v Miss Lydia Lorenzo: [2023] EAT 153 Document: The Kingdom of Spain v Miss Lydia Lorenzo: [2023] EAT 153 (PDF) News and Communications Found: [1981] AC 251 , esp at pp 272E, 276-278 (Lord Wilberforce), 281 -282 (Lord Diplock), 290B -D (Lord Scarman |
|
Jun. 29 2023
Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber) Source Page: GE FINANCIAL INVESTMENTS v THE COMMISSIONERS FOR HER MAJESTY'S REVENUE AND CUSTOMS [2023] UKUT 00146 (TCC) Document: GEFI v HMRC (final decision) (webpage) News and Communications Found: precedent, but on broad principles of general acceptation': per Lord Diplock (at 281–282) and Lord Scarman |
| Scottish Government Publications |
|---|
|
Saturday 16th December 2023
Constitution Directorate Source Page: Correspondence in relation to offshore wind: FOI release Document: FOI - 202300344494 - Information release (PDF) Found: LORD SCARMAN, 1911 -2004 Jacob Rees -Mogg says: "The Scottish Government, by passing its controversial |
| Scottish Parliamentary Research (SPICe) |
|---|
|
Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill
Thursday 3rd September 2020 This Scottish Government bill seeks to modernise, consolidate and extend hate crime legislation in Scotland. It deals with the aggravation of more general offences by prejudice as well as specific hate crime offences. View source webpage Found: It was inserted in 1976 into the Race Relations Act 1965 following criticism by Lord Scarman in his report |
|
Informed Consent in Healthcare Settings
Thursday 10th January 2019 The law of informed consent requires permission for the clinician to treat or examine the patient. It protects patients' rights to decide what happens to their bodies. The Supreme Court decision of Montgomery v Lanarkshire HB [2015] enhanced protection of patient rights to include information about the risks involved in proposed treatment, and information on alternative treatments. View source webpage Found: 1991, s 1. xxxi[1986] AC 1 12.Informed Consent in Healthcare Settings, SB 19-01 29In Gillick, Lord Scarman |
| Welsh Government Publications |
|---|
|
Tuesday 17th June 2025
Source Page: Ordinary residence disputes decision: responsibility for an individual’s after care Document: Responsibility for an individual’s after care (PDF) Found: Council, Ex p Nilish Shah [1983] 2 AC 309 (usually referred to as “the Shah case”) in which, Lord Scarman |
|
Tuesday 17th June 2025
Source Page: Ordinary residence disputes decision: responsibility for funding of an individual's care home fees Document: Responsibility for funding of an individual's care home fees (PDF) Found: Lord Scarman expressed the meaning of "ordinarily resident" in the following terms: "Unless, therefore |
|
Friday 24th July 2015
Source Page: Implementation of the Social Services and Well-being (Wales) Act 2014 - the regulations and code of practice in relation to part 11 of the Act Document: Annex D - Code of Practice on Miscellaneous and General (PDF) Found: In this case, Lord Scarman stated that unless … it can be shown that the statutory framework or |