(4 days, 23 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
Liam Byrne (Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North) (Lab)
Thank you, Mr Efford. I am grateful to the Backbench Business Committee for making time for today’s statement on the 10th report from my Committee in this Session, examining the UK-China economic relationship. I should probably preface my remarks by confessing a degree of interest in this issue. I have worked on the UK-China relationship for almost 20 years. I was among those who helped to launch the economic and financial dialogue with Lord Darling, God rest his soul. Back at the end of the last Labour Government, I was an active player in the UK-China leadership for the future forum. I sat on the board of the Great Britain-China Centre for many years, started the UK-China young leaders roundtable in my younger days and produced my own book on the UK-China relationship just before it became fashionable. This is a subject in which I have a long-standing interest, and I was grateful that the Committee agreed that it was an essential piece of our work and of the work we do on this nation’s economic security.
The House has within it a number of colleagues who would counsel that we should minimise our dialogue with China. But I am among those who believe, and my Committee agrees, that ostrich diplomacy does not serve the UK national interest especially well. The UK-China relationship will be one of the most consequential relationships for this country in the 21st century, so it was absolutely right that the new Government sought to intensify engagement with China from the moment they were elected to office. However, they undertook their audit of UK-China relationships in secret, and despite the efforts of a number of Select Committees, we have still not seen the results. Nor have we seen any comprehensive UK-China strategy that might sit on top of that new engagement or that audit.
We have what might be fairly summarised not as a strategy but as a punchline—the mantra of compete, collaborate and confront. That is a semi-helpful string of words, but it is not a strategy and not something the business community, in particular, can operationalise to any useful effect. That is important because right now many in the business community do want a deeper relationship with China. On the one hand, they are pulling their punches, pulling investment and pulling their effort; they are not intensifying in the way we might want them to, because, out of an abundance of caution, they simply do not want to put a foot wrong. On the other hand, there is now clear evidence that we are accumulating vulnerabilities in a way that is simply dangerous.
We need only look at two or three different decisions in the past, but also in the not-too-distant future, to see why some coherence and consistency and, crucially, a shared strategy between the state and the private sector are needed. The decision on Ming Yang involved the potential investment of a very significant amount by that Chinese firm in Scotland. We still do not know why that investment was pulled or why Government sent messages that it was not something to be welcomed. Equally, we were all called to this House—the Minister did a brilliant job of helping to lead the debate—to renationalise British Steel when, all of a sudden, its Chinese owners sent the business in the wrong direction.
There is now a lively debate about the sense in allowing Chinese connected tech to proliferate through our economy. We are also having a debate with our European partners about whether we should align on anti-competitive practices by China and introduce tariffs on electric vehicles.
In example after example, sector after sector, and investment after investment, we are now running into the necessity of a clear Government strategy for helping business in particular, but also civil society more widely, to understand where the guardrails are in the relationship with China. What this report seeks to do is to set out both the prize and the peril of a deeper relationship with China, and there are five points that stood out to me, as Chair of the Committee, in the work we did and that I would like to share with the House.
First, we feel there needs to be much clearer demarcation of those economic sectors in which we should encourage trade with China and those in which we should not. In the green zones, where trade should be welcomed, we should go all in. We should do more to encourage a deepening of economic relationships, and mobilising the UK’s soft power more comprehensively than we do today. That is important, not least because it is good for trade, jobs and economic growth. It is crucial for the UK’s long-term influence in China, which will extend well beyond the governance of President Xi and into what we hope will be a more constructive phase of Chinese leadership.
However, as part of that story, there need to be clear red zones. They would be easier to demarcate if the Government listened to our Committee, the Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy and the Defence Committee and set out the sovereign capabilities where trade with China is simply unwise. At the moment, business has to guess what that looks like. When we took evidence, officials and the Minister at the time, my right hon. Friend the Member for Rhondda and Ogmore (Chris Bryant), rightly said that this is very difficult and things might change, but that has not stopped allies like Canada setting out sovereign capabilities or allies like Japan setting out critical components where trade with China is unwise. The Government saying that something is difficult also does not stop other people having to make the difficult decision; it just transfers it to someone else. That transfer of risk to the private sector has a cost. We would like a clear demarcation of those sectors in which Chinese trade should be encouraged and those in which it should not.
Secondly, the new approach needs to be underpinned by very different rules of the game with China. That has to start with a much tougher approach to levelling the playing field. The brilliant work of the OECD makes it clear that in some sectors of the economy China is over-subsidising its industry by six times more than we are in Europe, which is simply unfair. What has become known as China shock 2.0 is costing tens of thousands of jobs across Europe. A weaker European manufacturing industry is simply not in our national interest. The Committee concludes that we should work much harder with our partners in the European Union to develop pro-competition, pro-fairness measures for levelling the playing field with China. If that means readying tariffs, that is exactly what we should do. We should align around the kinds of initiatives taken by President Macron and Chancellor Merz. I hope we see a little more progress on that at the summit with the European Union on 20 November.
The third takeaway is that although we should innovate carefully with China, which is important in fields like life science, we should be much more robust about defending technologically sensitive areas. That is particularly important in connected tech. We think that recent Lords amendments had a lot of virtue and that the Government should have supported them. We should ban Chinese connected tech from our critical national infrastructure and invest in supplying our universities with a much faster response to their inquiries about where research and development with Chinese partners is wise and where it is unwise. The recent revelations from the Security Service underline the necessity of making sure that Universities UK and our universities more widely are equipped with that knowledge.
Fourthly, we need to prepare now for the disruption to supply chains that might come. For example, if someone tries to change the status quo in the straits of Taiwan, that will be an enormous economic shock that will disrupt supply chains across our economy. We should stress-test now supply chains that will be impacted and work harder to diversify suppliers. As the Committee set out in its report on critical minerals last week, we should redouble our efforts, with a new critical minerals finance facility to bring online not just domestic supply and recycling, but a wider diversity of international supply.
Finally, we should act with speed and aggression to ban forced labour from supply chains. I was pleased to see the correspondence from the Secretary of State to my Committee at the end of last week, showing that the Government will move on that. I hope there will be Government amendments to part 5 of the Immigration and Asylum Bill to enshrine a responsibility on businesses to ensure that they are doing the right thing and banning forced labour from our country.
My final point is about the state. We are very lucky in this country to have the great Peter Wilson as our ambassador in Beijing, but in truth we have lost an immense amount of China expertise across Whitehall. It is clear that we do not have a systematic way of integrating threat assessments and benefit analysis to inform decision making in Whitehall and, crucially, regional governments. We will have to do better at building a strategic state to contend with China in the future, and I hope our report is a useful contribution to that debate.
(3 years, 9 months ago)
Commons Chamber
Liam Byrne
The hon. Lady is absolutely right. Here we are, licensing a warlord to draw down funds and move them into the NatWest bank account of a London law firm to prosecute a case that undermines the sanctions we imposed on that warlord in the first place.
Let us briefly go through the timeline of the case because it is so important and illustrative of just how broken the system has become.
I commend my right hon. Friend for the work he has done consistently over a long period on this issue. It is important to highlight the scale of the problem in London. Is it not true that there are more SLAPP cases being taken in the London courts than there are in Europe and America put together? Does that not illustrate the scale of the problem and the urgency with which we need to deal with it?
Liam Byrne
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. I said earlier that London is now the preferred strike point for oligarchs in intimidating journalists. When the Foreign Policy Centre, whose work I must commend, surveyed investigative journalists, it found that three quarters of them had suffered some kind of legal attack to silence them. The UK legal system accounted for more of those legal actions than the United States and Europe put together. That is how bad this has now become. That is how rotten our system has now become. That is why it is so outrageous that the head of the Wagner Group was given the licences. Let us be clear about this guy. This is someone who has been running mercenary operations in Sudan, Mozambique, Syria, Central African Republic, Libya and Mali—and, of course, his forces have now been redeployed to the theatres in Ukraine.
It was in August 2020 that Eliot Higgins and Bellingcat began running a series of stories that exposed the barbarities of the Wagner Group in Africa, including offences such as the murder of CNN journalists. It took the British Government and the Foreign Office until 31 December 2020 to put sanctions on Prigozhin, even though, by the way, he had been sanctioned much earlier in the Unites States for the quiet sin of running troll farms intervening in the American presidential campaign. None the less, we got around to it at the back end of 2020. In the citation for sanctions, the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office wrote that Prigozhin was providing
“a deniable military capability for the Russian state”.
That feels quite a big sin to me, running a deniable military capability for the Russian state. That sounds like a pretty good reason for sanctions. That sounds like a pretty good reason for not offering carve-outs to sanctions to undermine them in British courts.
When Mr Prigozhin found out about the sanctions he was not very happy, so he sought to undermine them by suing Bellingcat, or Eliot Higgins in an English court. He had a choice and in fact a debate: “Do we do it in a Russian court, a Dutch court or an English court?” The conclusion was to go for Eliot Higgins in an English court. To prosecute the case, he had to fly the lawyers out to St Petersburg, so the Treasury licensed £4,788.04 to help make that happen: over £3,500 for business class flights, £320 for accommodation at the Grand Hotel Europe Belmond, £150 for subsistence—that’ll buy a pretty good dinner—£200 for PCR testing and £400 for express visas. That is what servants of the Crown, under the supervision of Ministers of the Crown, signed off.
The discussions went a bit like this. “What are the objectives here, Mr Prigozhin? Well, we think that, rather than seeking damages, what we really need is to get Mr Higgins for defamation because that is how we undermine all those irritating articles” that led to the sanctions against Mr Prigozhin. Literally, we enabled the enablers. We enabled the cash flow of a Russian warlord to prosecute an English journalist in an English court. And that is why we have to act. No one in this House today thinks that this is okay. The Minister for Security does not think that it is okay. All of us here think it has to stop, but if it is to stop, we have to take aim at the original sin: the fact that it is courts in this country that are being used by oligarchs around the world to silence journalists.
Our new clause, which has drawn cross-party support today, is very simple. It would not stop all strategic legal actions against public participants, but it would stop anybody attempting to silence journalists who are trying to reveal economic crimes. It is within scope; I am grateful to the Clerks for their work helping to refine it and make it good. I know that the Minister will say, as he said in Committee, that this is not the right Bill for it, or that it would not solve all the problems, but that is an argument for making the perfect the enemy of the good.
We have heard the Lord Chancellor talking about his ambition to change the law, but we have also heard that he seeks to do so through the Bill of Rights. The dogs in the street know that the Bill of Rights Bill is dead. It is not coming back to this House any time soon, yet today—this week, next week, next month—journalists and indeed ex-Members of this House are in court, having to pay legal bills because we allow oligarchs to abuse our courts. Let us at least make progress now.
I say to the Minister: please do not be the Minister for mañana. Please be the Minister who did not make the perfect the enemy of the good. Please be the Minister who seeks to do what he can with what we have, where we are, today. We could use this Bill to make progress. Why do we not seize that opportunity with both hands?
I am very grateful for the concerted campaign by Members across this House. I will end by saluting the courage, fortitude and determination of so many good journalists in this country. Oliver Bullough, who wrote the brilliant books “Moneyland” and “Butler to the World”, makes an excellent argument in his openDemocracy article today. He says that journalists going into the business of tackling economic crime have an uphill struggle as it is, with a lot of barriers in their way. They have a pretty difficult job, and the knowledge that the British Government are on the side of the bad guys does not make that job any easier. It is time that we put the force of the state and the force of the Crown behind the good guys for once—and that means agreeing to our new clause today.
(13 years, 7 months ago)
Commons Chamber
Mr Byrne
The Secretary of State’s level of delusion is now bettering his previous level. He knows that the policy costings—which he has clearly not read—published by his right hon. Friend the Chancellor show that the housing benefit bill is not going down over the next couple of years, but going up. The Secretary of State’s efforts have been so successful that he is bringing in a policy—the hated bedroom tax—that will cost more than it saves. We saw the proof on Wednesday—housing benefit up by more than £1 billion. That is a mark of his failure.
The Secretary of State cannot rewrite history. This Government inherited the biggest council house building programme for 20 years. One of the first things they did was scrap it. They now have the lowest building starts since the 1920s—lower even than we had, and that is saying something.
Mr Byrne
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. What we needed in the Budget was determined action to build houses, not another subsidy for Britain’s richest citizens.
Let me start to conclude by reminding the House what most families will now experience. We heard in the Secretary of State’s speech some words about the rise in the personal allowance. The truth is that, even despite the rise in the personal allowance, the cuts buried in the Budget will mean that by April 2014-15 the same family who will see the personal allowance increase to £10,000 will be worse off. They will lose £600 a year in cuts, and my fear is that worse is to come.
The Chancellor gave away a lot of things in the first year of the next Parliament. Although we saw a little of how he will pay for it—he is going to fast-track the flat-rate pension—this is one of the great mysteries of this Budget, and we have not heard much about it yet. When the Minister winds up, I hope he will confirm at what rate the flat-rate pension will be introduced. The original White Paper set the figure at £144, which I notice is lower than £145, which is the combined total of pension credit and the state pension set out in the Budget book on Wednesday. As we know, the advance of the flat-rate pension offers the Treasury a huge national insurance windfall of about £5.5 billion in 2016-17 and 2017-18. What is interesting—we heard nothing about this—is that half of that windfall comes from public sector employers. The Library was able to tell me earlier in the week that the national health service, schools and the police will face a bill for £1.6 billion in higher national insurance contributions. We heard nothing about precisely where that money will come from. I hope the Minister will be able to set our minds at rest and say why this will not be another cut to the NHS in the next Parliament.
The second mystery surrounds the unspecified cuts of £11.5 billion in the first years of the next Parliament. We know that things such as the strivers tax and other cuts to working tax credits will deliver up to £6 billion, but where will the other £5 billion come from? Can DWP Ministers tell us how they will resist another huge great cut to welfare in the June spending review?
We got more of the same from the Chancellor on Wednesday and more of the same from the Secretary of State today. Once upon a time he liked to say that he cared about poverty. No more. One million children on his watch will be pushed into poverty. Tens of thousands of disabled people will follow. Families get less, while millionaires get more, all because this Chancellor has flatlined the economy and because the Secretary of State has asked for nothing, got nothing and delivered nothing to bring down unemployment.
(13 years, 10 months ago)
Commons ChamberThe argument coming from the Government Benches is wholly founded on misinformation, particularly in respect of the claim that the Government have created 1 million jobs in the private sector. Is my right hon. Friend aware that, according to the Office for National Statistics, 196,000 of those jobs are due solely to the reclassification of sixth-form colleges and further education colleges?
(16 years, 4 months ago)
Commons ChamberWe have seen so many unexpected changes from the parties opposite, and my right hon. Friend is absolutely right to draw our attention to the fact that they have been silent on that issue.
I have another question about the Bill. Where does it mention the tax on the banks? When can we expect to see that measure before us? Why is it not part of the Bill? Perhaps the Liberal Democrats would like to intervene on me to tell me when we can expect to see it. We are told that it will be consulted on. If that is the case, is it going to go up or down, or is it going to stay as it is? What is the point of consulting the bankers—I assume that that is whom the Government are going to consult—on something that they would rather did not happen?
The Liberal Democrats told us that they were going to break up the casino banking system. The Secretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills wanted the banks to be broken down into smaller banks, separating casino banking from normal banking. Yet we are told that the Chancellor opposes this and has set up a commission to look into it, which will take at least a year, thereby kicking it into the long grass. [Interruption.] I hear a sedentary intervention that we are dealing with the Finance Bill. Yes we are, and this is not in the Finance Bill, but it is an integral part of the Budget. It is therefore legitimate to ask where it is, when it is going to happen and what the consultation will be about, because it impacts on what taxes we raise on the people we represent. [Interruption.] I say to the hon. Member for St Ives (Andrew George), who did not make a very good job of defending his position on the increase, that that includes VAT.
On 12 March the Deputy Prime Minister called for a 10% tax on bank profits and a £2 billion job creation scheme to rescue the victims of recession. We keep being told by the Liberal Democrats that they have had an enormous impact on this Budget, so perhaps they could explain the impact they made here. I would have supported and voted for a 10% tax on bankers’ profits, instead of for taking people’s benefits away from them or for poor families paying VAT increases. After all, where did the financial problems start?
The Deputy Prime Minister kept digging during the general election, and on 20 April accused the bankers of behaving like “Arthur Scargill in pinstripes”. He then went on to say:
“The banks have basically been given untrammelled support by Labour and Conservative governments to do exactly what they like, and take massive risks with our livelihoods and our savings. They have been holding a gun to the economy. A progressive liberal like myself is not going to be squeamish about blowing the whistle on a vested interest.”
Well, where is it? Where is the whistleblowing on those vested interests?
The Liberal Democrat website—I do not know whether Liberal Democrat Members ever look at it—still says that they are going to bring “fundamental change” to our banking system.
“We will break them up and break them down.”
It continues:
“Until such a time, the taxpayer will have to continue underwriting the banks”—
well, we know that from this Budget.
“To recognise this, we are proposing a new levy on bank profits at a rate of 10%...This levy would be supplementary to corporation tax”.
Well, where did that happen? If we look at corporation tax outcomes—[Interruption.] The hon. Member for Cheadle (Mark Hunter) intervenes from a sedentary position. Would he like to repeat what he just said? I think he said that the Lib Dems did not win. Well, we all know that; that is why we are complaining about what they are doing.
If I look at what the banks are saying about corporation tax, I find that they are rewarded and compensated for the £2 billion levy that the Budget wants to raise. We have some more juicy quotes here; the Lib Dems might want to listen to them. Here is one:
“Bankers were relieved that the chancellor’s speech failed to repeat the coalition government’s threat to end ‘unacceptable bonuses’”.
Deutsche Bank analysts noted the significance of the corporation tax change:
“Taking 2% off the 2012 tax rate for the five banks listed in the UK would increase profit by £1.16bn, that is it should almost offset all of the banks’ tax. Overall a good outcome for the banks.”
A number of bank analysts calculated that some banks could benefit from the Chancellor’s measures. As I have said, Deutsche Bank concluded that it was a “good outcome” for banks, while an analyst at UBS expected Lloyds and HSBC to benefit by 2012 because the cut in their corporation tax bill was larger than the hit that they sustained through the bank levy. HSBC banking analysts concurred:
“We’d expect most domestically-orientated banks, for example Lloyds, to be better off after four years than they were pre-budget”.
How has it come about that a party that went through the general election giving all those quotes about how they were going to break the banks up and break them down, and make the bankers pay until the pips squeaked, has come to support a Budget that takes from the bankers with one hand, pays it back with the other and rewards the banks with a tax benefit at the end of it? And at the same time they will be marching through the Lobbies to the drumbeats of the Tories, voting for cuts in benefits and an increase in VAT, and making the poorest people in our communities pay, when the banks are not paying.
It was all puff and wind from the Liberal Democrats during the election. We have heard it all before, and we are hearing it again. This time, however, they have actually got to vote for something. They are actually in charge and responsible for what they are voting for, and they are going to pay a very heavy price indeed.