(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Commons Chamber
Sam Carling (North West Cambridgeshire) (Lab)
In recent weeks we have seen a number of powerful men held to account for hideous abuse, particularly towards women, and I pay tribute to those victims who have fought for too long to be heard and taken seriously. However, I have initiated this debate to speak on behalf of another group of victims who often face significant barriers to being heard and believed, because society struggles to understand what has happened to them. I refer to victims of cults and high-control religious groups. These are organisations that go far beyond the acceptable boundaries of a mainstream religion and take over people’s lives, using fear, shame, isolation and authoritarian power to control and coerce their members. Most people are not aware of the extent to which groups like this can operate in the UK, because by their very nature they are often quite secretive or seem benign to the outside world. That is one of the primary reasons why the victims of such organisations so often struggle to be believed: people simply do not accept that this can be going on in modern society.
Let me take a moment to comment on the attendance in the Chamber tonight. It is rare for more than three or four Members to be present for an Adjournment debate, but the breadth of those who have come to show support demonstrates that people care about this issue, which affects our constituents. I am very grateful to them all.
I will focus on religious groups, but it is important to recognise that cults do not have to be religious in nature. There can be cults in all sorts of areas—any areas in which an “us versus them” narrative can be built. Victims from those backgrounds also deserve be heard.
I commend the hon. Gentleman for bringing this issue to the House, as he has in the past. It is important to mark the concerns of local parents for their children and the need to protect ordinary parenting for those who believe in religious freedoms. It is the high-control religious groups who use intimidation and manipulation to control individuals. Does the hon. Gentleman agree that such behaviour must be distinguished from ordinary religious teaching and genuine pastoral care, and that genuinely coercive harmful practices are more carefully targeted by legislation?
Sam Carling
I thank the hon. Gentleman for making that point. I entirely agree with him about the importance of making that distinction clear, as I will later in my speech. We all have many fantastic religious organisations in our communities, and they do brilliant work.
The types of abuse that I will discuss tonight, and the organisations that I will use to exemplify each one, are varied, but together they are often termed “spiritual and ritual abuse”, when spirituality or culture are weaponised to inflict harm.
Tessa Munt (Wells and Mendip Hills) (LD)
I entirely accept the hon. Gentleman’s point about religious groups, but having thought about it earlier today and with the help of some of the casework that I have received, I have established that also included are spiritual enlightenment groups, multi-level marketing, group awareness training, internet-based psychotherapy groups and personal growth organisations. What they have in common, of course, is coercive control. Does the hon. Gentleman agree that coercive control must cover all sorts of cults and belief systems, and that that needs to be included in the regulations that are currently going through Parliament?
Sam Carling
I am grateful to the hon. Lady, with whom I have worked on this issue for some time, for making those points. I will respond to some of them later in my speech.
I want to tell a victim’s story—that of Rachael Reign, who escaped from the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God and now runs a survivor advocacy group, Surviving Universal UK. Rachael joined the organisation when she was 13, and before long she was warned that the devil would use people close to her to tell her bad things about the Church and encourage her to leave. That was made out to be a test of faith, but in reality, it was the beginning of coercive control and psychological subjection to create a dependency in her mind on the Church, and to shut down her critical thinking. Each Friday, she had to attend an exorcism service, with intense prayers involving physical contact and telling her that she had demons within her. Later, she was made to perform exorcisms herself, including on traumatised people, and she was told that if she ever left, all the demons that she had cast out of herself and others would be waiting for her. A BBC “Panorama” documentary in 2023 secretly filmed the Church doing this to a 16-year-old, and reported how a gay ex-member said that he was subjected to similar “strong prayers” at 13 years old to try to change his sexuality.
Samantha Niblett (South Derbyshire) (Lab)
I thank my hon. Friend for securing this really important debate. The Government’s recent report tells the story of a gay man whose parents used emotional blackmail and manipulation, including making him attend group prayers in an attempt to “pray away the gay”. Does my hon. Friend agree that we must get the conversion practices draft Bill across the line and passed into an Act as soon as possible?
Sam Carling
I absolutely agree with my hon. Friend. I am really pleased that she has raised that, because a significant amount of that abuse is going on, disguised as therapy or some other helpful practice, when it absolutely is not that. It is entirely relevant to the abuse I am discussing, and I appreciate her raising that.
In an article in The Guardian earlier this year, other victims spoke of the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God’s financial exploitation of its members through “prosperity gospel” teachings. A victim, referred to in the article as Jennifer, was coerced into handing over £15,000, despite the Fundraising Regulator later finding that the church breached the fundraising code. The church was aware of her previous mental health issues when it took a large donation from her, and did not have policies in place regarding vulnerable donors. Other victims named in the article, including Rachael, corroborate the constant, extreme pressure placed on people to give huge sums. Rachael was coerced into giving regular tithes from the age of 13, and she was taught that she would otherwise have a “devouring spirit” descend upon her life and that she would be “robbing from God”.
This group is a cult, and it is spreading through London at pace, particularly targeting black people. It is also legally classified as a charity, meaning that it receives tax exemptions and significant public money through gift aid. With a donation and legacy income of over £13 million in the year to March 2025, in theory up to £2.5 million of that could be direct public gift aid subsidy. I have called before in this House for fundamental changes to charity law that would stop that, and I hope the Government will take that on board. I also urge the Government to look at putting the Fundraising Regulator on a statutory footing, so that it can be empowered to hold organisations accountable for failures.
The clear threads in these stories are coercive control through financial exploitation, threatening horrific consequences for leaving, and shutting off critical thinking. Such coercive tactics are commonplace in high-control groups. Another is mandated shunning, whereby adherents are ordered to ostracise former believers who have left, even if they are close family. In my previous Adjournment debate in March, I spoke about how the Jehovah’s Witnesses, the group I was raised in, do that. It happens when people leave of their own accord, or when the religion forces them out for doing something it considers sinful—being gay, for example, as we have just discussed. There are also cases where someone has been sexually abused within the Witnesses. When they have reported it, their abuser has faced no consequences but they, as the victim, have faced shunning, which may lead to homelessness—for example, if someone’s parents shun them and force them out of the home.
Similar shunning occurs within Scientology, which retains a significant presence in the UK. Scientologists are required to adhere to a strict system of internal ethics. Reporting another Scientologist to the police is considered a “crime” and will result in expulsion and forced disconnection, so someone can lose everybody and everything they have ever known, even if they are a child—a clear sign, once again, that it a cult. Over the summer, The Times published the results of an undercover investigation into Scientology. Children as young as 13 are being taken out of school and made to work full time for a pittance, having signed so-called “staff contracts”. One 15-year-old girl was found to be administering massages to adult male staff.
I cannot see how that is not modern slavery, yet the church insists that these children are “religious volunteers”, and nothing has been done to put an end to the practice since the article came out. Indeed, as far as I and the survivors I work with are aware, pretty much every case where an ex-Scientologist has reported abuse, modern slavery, human trafficking or harassment to the police in recent years has been closed without investigation. Police forces up and down the country seem to consider such claims too unbelievable to be happening in 2026, yet they are happening. Will the Minister follow that up as a policy point with the police? The media are very reluctant to do so for fear of legal action, but will the Minister join me in very deliberately referring to the brave people who have escaped Scientology as victims and survivors, in recognition of their experience?
The children I have referred to will not receive a secular education, as many people growing up in high-control groups do not, and thus they will be trapped, with their entire networks in the organisation and without any qualifications. When people do not have exposure to the secular world, they do not know how it works and they cannot just leave.
Sureena Brackenridge (Wolverhampton North East) (Lab)
I am very grateful to my hon. Friend for securing this important debate. A mother recently came to see me with concerns about her adult daughter’s involvement with a religious organisation locally. She described how her daughter was once very close to the family, but became increasingly isolated. Concerns were also raised about financial contributions she made while she was a student and struggling to pay everyday basic costs. Of course, freedom of religion is a fundamental right, but does my hon. Friend agree that there may be a gap in the support available to families when concerns arise about undue influence, social isolation or financial pressure in organisations that fall outside the scope of existing legislation on coercive and controlling behaviour?
Sam Carling
My hon. Friend’s intervention lets me make a really important point. Stopping psychological subjection in high-control religious groups is not anti-freedom of religion; it is pro-freedom of religion. People who are trapped do not have free choice, and creating true free choice means making sure that people are free to change their religion or leave a religion. I will shortly come to her point about support.
Luke Myer (Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland) (Lab)
Coercive control is wrong in any context, but does my hon. Friend agree that there is something particularly insidious about religious and faith-based abuse, because it preys on something as intensely personal as someone’s faith?
Sam Carling
I agree entirely, and it is a very deep perversion of what religion is meant to be. I speak as someone who is not religious but who recognises how much value religion and faith can add to people’s lives. To distort and twist that in such a way is deeply wrong.
When people in these cults and high-control groups take the extraordinarily brave step of leaving, despite the immense barriers to doing so both physically and psychologically, who is there to support them and what help can they find? The answer is very little. There is a deep lack of awareness among therapists and care professionals about this deep-reaching type of abuse and harm.
I thank my hon. Friend for securing what, as others have said, is a really important debate. For someone to leave their high-control religious group or cult can mean losing their family, friends and community all in one go. Would he join me in paying tribute to the volunteers and organisations who support people at what can be an extremely lonely and difficult time, including Faith to Faithless run by the Humanists UK?
Sam Carling
I am grateful to my hon. Friend, and I will shortly sing those volunteers praises, because it is very much right that we thank them.
People just cannot understand why victims in these groups do not leave early, or why they stayed. The themes of thought control, financial exploitation, isolation from family and friends, and threats against leaving should sound familiar, because they are exactly the things that characterise domestic abuse and coercive relationships. Indeed, the Government’s statutory guidance on what could constitute criminal coercive behaviour puts it as
“a range of acts designed to make a person subordinate and/or dependent by isolating them from sources of support, exploiting their resources and capacities for personal gain, depriving them of the means needed for independence, resistance and escape and regulating their everyday behaviour.”
That is a very good definition, but there is a catch. Under the current law, coercive control can take place only in a family or in a romantic relationship, so when religious leaders or cultic groups do exactly the same thing, it is not covered. The Family Survival Trust has been campaigning to change that. It is one of the few organisations that specifically aims to support cult survivors, and one to which I often refer cult survivors who write to me, alongside the excellent Faith to Faithless service operated by Humanists UK, which supports people leaving a range of different religions and the consequences that can bring.
May I ask the Minister and officials to look at the Family Survival Trust’s extensive report on coercive control and cultic groups in the UK, published in 2022, which sets out the scale of the problem far more than I can in the time I have available? Would she agree to meet me and the Family Survival Trust to explore options for legislative reform? That could mean a change to the existing coercive control law through the Serious Crime Act 2015 to remove the requirement for a family or romantic connection, or it could mean a new offence.
Governments around the world are waking up to the reality of what people are being subjected to. France has had legislation in place since 2001, focusing not on particular organisations but on the psychological subjection tactics they use. It strengthened that in 2024. Belgium passed an abuse-of-weakness law in 2011, and Luxembourg passed a similar law in 2013. Several proposals aimed at combating psychological manipulation, particularly in relation to high-control groups, are under consideration in the Italian Senate, and the Government of the Netherlands consulted earlier this year on a proposed Bill, too. In the Australian state of Victoria, a parliamentary committee published an extensive report in July this year, specifically on the recruitment methods and impacts of cults and organised fringe groups. It concluded that there was
“a clear case for legislative reform”
to capture
“group-based coercion as a distinct criminal offence”.
So there are a range of options available to us. I urge the Government to work with me to consider them in detail, and to bring forward measures to combat the very real phenomenon of psychological subjection in high-control groups in the UK.
Let me turn briefly to what else we can do to support victims right now. In 2023, the Bloom review was published, an independent review of how Government engage with faith. There are some things in there that I do not agree with, but on the whole, I think it is a very valuable report that made important recommendations around countering extremism and supporting victims of high-control groups. True to form, the previous Conservative Government welcomed the report, said that they would consider the recommendations carefully, and then proceeded not to lift a finger on them. I want to cite recommendation 19:
“Government should fund a programme that supports vulnerable people to leave high-demand groups, high-control movements (often referred to as cults) or religious groups. In addition, this work should help people who face isolation as so-called ‘apostates’ and those facing threats of homelessness, shunning and honour-based abuse.”
It goes on to praise Humanists UK for its work in this space. Its Faith to Faithless helpline launched in February 2024, and within its first year, over 500 people received crucial support. But the support those incredible volunteers offer cannot match demand, and it cannot provide the deep-reaching therapy that many victims need to overcome years of abuse.
I had the privilege recently of hosting a parliamentary screening of the BBC documentary, “Inside the Cult of the Jesus Army”, at which I met several survivors from that organisation. I also met Gillie Jenkinson, a psychotherapist who specialises in helping cult survivors, having spent much of her 20s in a cult herself. She has called for the NHS to offer specialist counselling for those leaving cults. That is a deeply specialist type of support that just does not exist on any major scale right now. Gillie has spoken of trying to find that support herself and finding none; that is what motivated her to train and develop her own practice. Will the Minister work with Government colleagues to examine how we can develop much-needed expertise in this space, within NHS-funded counselling? What can the Government do to provide support for people to rebuild their life?
Connor Naismith (Crewe and Nantwich) (Lab)
My hon. Friend is giving a powerful speech and deserves immense credit for bringing forward this debate. Allegations against members of the Ahmadi Religion of Peace and Light, headquartered in my constituency, are a matter of public record. Local children’s services and Cheshire police are, unfortunately, shouldering the burden of carrying out due process in that case. Does my hon. Friend agree with me that in the aftermath of such cases, we really need cross-Government co-ordination and resourcing to ensure that local communities do not pay the price?
Sam Carling
I remember seeing that case earlier this year, and I was very sorry to hear what happened, when I learned more of the details. That is exactly why we need the Government to take high-control groups seriously at policy level. We need to create the powers and offences to deal with cases like the one in my hon. Friend’s constituency before they become catastrophic and create more victims who need more immediate support, so that this harm is prevented.
I am coming towards my conclusion. Perhaps the Minister could consider picking up once again the recommendations in chapters 6 to 8 of the Bloom review and providing a substantive response to it; the Conservative Government who commissioned it failed to do so. One of the major issues, in my view, is that supporting victims who are leaving high-control groups does not fit neatly into any Government Department. There are safeguarding and crime concerns for the Home Office; implications for faith, on which the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government leads; links to healthcare, as I have just outlined; and I highlighted earlier the problems that a lack of education can create for employment. There are also implications for charity law and regulation, which comes under the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport. This is truly cross-cutting.
What steps can the Government take to create ownership of this issue? Could they set up a dedicated unit of some sort against spiritual, ritual and cultic abuse, or give a named Minister responsibility for co-ordinating across Government in this space? Until Government and Parliament take this issue seriously, people will continue to suffer, and I know that all of us want to ensure that is not the case. So let us have the courage to do what Governments have shied away from for too long: call this out and put an end to it.
(1 year ago)
Commons Chamber
Sam Carling (North West Cambridgeshire) (Lab)
I really welcome this Government’s move to restrict the access of abusers to their children, in order to protect them. All too often, however, victims who are members of tightly knit, small religious groups are pressured to interact with their abuser when they get out of prison. Some religious leaders and organisations that I am aware of commonly tell victims that God has forgiven their abusers and they therefore need to do so as well. In some cases, I have seen those victims be ostracised or shunned if they refuse to engage. Does the Minister agree that the Government need to think about how we can seek to resolve that cultural problem in small religious groups?
I thank my hon. Friend for that thoughtful intervention, and he is right. We need to get this right for all victims of all crimes—that includes intersectionality and vulnerable victims.
That point speaks to the heart of the amendments tabled by my hon. Friend the Member for Lowestoft (Jess Asato) in relation to by-and-for services and specialist support services. She mentioned Jewish support charities, and I am meeting Jewish Women’s Aid tomorrow to talk about how we can better support them. She is right that this has to be holistic and comprehensive, because one size does not fit all when it comes to victims of these crimes.
(1 year, 5 months ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
Sam Carling (North West Cambridgeshire) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dame Siobhain. I thank my hon. Friends the Members for Tamworth (Sarah Edwards) and for Morecambe and Lunesdale (Lizzi Collinge) and the hon. Member for Henley and Thame (Freddie van Mierlo), who secured this debate. It has been worth it for all the puns, if nothing else.
I will use my time to speak about what a positive impact making this change would have, particularly for LGBT couples. In the 2021 census, 37% of people in England and Wales identified as having no religion. Among lesbian, gay and bisexual people, that jumps up to 63%. The numbers for trans people, while a bit less clear due to some issues with the census, are similar. With that in mind, it stands to reason that those LGBT couples would generally prefer to have a non-religious ceremony when they get married.
Indeed, that is what is happening. Humanists UK, whose stats I will be quoting throughout—I also declare an interest as a member of the all-party parliamentary humanist group—has found that, following the legislation of same-sex marriage in 2013, humanist celebrants do more same-sex marriages without legal recognition every year than there are legally recognised religious same-sex marriages. That means that many people are opting for these meaningful, inclusive ceremonies even though they do not carry legal weight. That says something very powerful about the demand. Part of that is out of necessity. Humanists UK’s statistics have also shown that less than 1% of places of worship in England and Wales have registered to perform same-sex marriages, so, in practice, a lot of the time, LGBT couples who want to get married and have their union properly recognised are left with very few real options.
That is not to downplay the Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Act 2013, which was a big step forward in LGBT rights. To give credit where it is due, that Act was one of very few positives under the previous Conservative Governments, albeit something that got through only because Members from other parties, particularly my own, supported it. That Act, as others have said, included a provision for an order to be laid in future to recognise humanist marriages without the need for further primary legislation, so we could make this change very quickly.
In Labour’s 2024 election manifesto, we committed to strengthening the rights and protections of cohabiting couples. The Minister cited that in response to a recent written question on humanist marriages, which I was pleased to see. I know the Government are currently considering the recommendations from the Law Commission report on weddings and will hopefully confirm the position on that soon. I look forward to that development, as I know humanists have been waiting a long time for legal recognition. I hope we hear more about that today.
There is huge support among various religious groups for this change, as my hon. Friend the Member for Tamworth said. More recent polling has shown there are majorities in favour across all religious groups, as well as across voters of all major political parties. Last year, Sandi Toksvig and Stephen Fry were joined by Stonewall, the Terrence Higgins Trust, the LGBT+ Consortium and the LGBT+ groups affiliated to all three major political parties in writing to the Prime Minister about what recognition would do for LGBT couples. This seems to be one of those issues on which pretty much everyone agrees.
Given the overwhelming public support, the ease with which this could be introduced and the impact it would have on LGBT couples in particular, I hope we see recognition of humanist marriages in England and Wales, joining Scotland and Northern Ireland, so that everyone in the UK has the option to have a legally recognised humanist ceremony.