Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Highways (Financing) Bill (Seventh sitting) Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateZöe Franklin
Main Page: Zöe Franklin (Liberal Democrat - Guildford)Department Debates - View all Zöe Franklin's debates with the Department for Transport
(2 days, 10 hours ago)
Public Bill CommitteesI agree. My hon. Friend makes a perfectly good argument. The proliferation of quangos, arm’s length bodies and stakeholder groups across the public sector and local government has led to a huge disparity in the remuneration paid to individuals sitting on different boards. It may be difficult to get a clear answer to that question, but we can take account of proportionality, time taken and actual outcomes. We talk a lot in politics in this country about what things should cost, but we too often forget outcomes. If we lock something around that into the stakeholder group, it will become more palatable to the travelling public, road haulage operators, coach operators, bus operators and others.
With that, I will sit down. Hopefully, the Minister will give us some assurances on that point. Has he reflected on whether the stakeholder group will operate in a good, functional manner, or whether it will become a talking shop, as we have seen all too often under Governments of all political persuasions?
Zöe Franklin (Guildford) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship again, Mr Dowd. Our amendment to clause 84 would ensure, as the hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire teaser-trailered, that local authority representatives have a guaranteed statutory seat on the ORR stakeholder group.
Currently, the clause leaves stakeholder group appointments entirely to ORR discretion. It uses vague generalities about user interest without guaranteeing council representation. It is incredibly important that local highways authorities and local planning authorities adjacent to tolled highways represent the communities most directly impacted by the traffic diversions, road wear and infrastructure pressures. The amendment seeks to make their involvement statutory.
The hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire also teaser-trailered the fact that clause 84 fails to mandate statutory representation for other groups, including disabled drivers, local residents groups and commercial road haulage associations. The Government should put the involvement of those groups on a statutory footing. In the evidence sessions, Declan Pang of the Road Haulage Association emphasised that the governance of the stakeholder group must be strengthened in primary law. The stakeholder groups are asking for representation. Similarly, the AA pointed out that if the ORR appoints its own advisory group without explicit statutory membership criteria, the group risks lacking true independence.
Does the Minister recognise our concerns, which led us to table the amendment? Does he recognise the concerns about the membership of the stakeholder group from the RHA and the AA, and the need for them to be on it? Will he commit to resolving that issue on the face of the Bill?
I am grateful to both Opposition spokespeople, the hon. Members for Mid Buckinghamshire and for Guildford, for their comments.
On amendment 38, which was tabled by the Liberal Democrats, clause 84 already requires the ORR to appoint those persons “it considers appropriate” and to ensure, so far as is practicable, that the group can provide informed advice on the interests of highway users and others with an interest in the provision and operation of licensed highways. The ORR will need to appoint members who are appropriate to the particular project and ensure that the stakeholder group properly reflects the interests of users and others affected by that project. That is precisely why we have deliberately not prescribed particular categories of members in the Bill; doing so could constrain the ORR’s ability to establish a balanced and effective group tailored to the circumstances.
That said, I accept the assertion that it is important to have certain groups on the body. I draw Opposition Members’ attention to paragraph 415 in the explanatory notes, which lists a number of different groups that it would be appropriate to include in the stakeholder group. As the hon. Member for Guildford would expect, local authorities are included, as well as freight representatives and other users of the highway. There is a clear steer there on what the Department expects in terms of representation.
I think both Opposition spokespeople were at times conflating the roles of the regulator and of licensees. It is important to remember that the ORR is the independent regulator here; it is its job to ensure that the licence is being operated in the interests of all road users. I think that addresses the point about how we can be confident that the ORR will listen to the voices of the stakeholder group: because its general duties under clause 1 require it to do so. The stakeholder group is the formal mechanism to ensure that the ORR is able to take those views into account.
In that exchange, I think there was a reference to the ORR summarily dismissing the chair of the stakeholder group if they got a little gobby—that is probably the colloquial term. I refer Members to clause 84(5)(c), which requires the approval of the Secretary of State before any such action is taken, so there is a safeguard to prevent that kind of thing.
Shivani Raja (Leicester East) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Dowd. I will speak specifically to my hon. Friend’s amendment 73. Parliament cannot be expected to wave through a major new road licensing system when the basic financial numbers have not even been published. Right now, we have no clear breakdown of how these licensed highways will actually be funded, or what will happen if the finances do not add up. As CMS warned in its written evidence to the Committee, unlike water or energy customers, drivers can choose whether to use a tolled road, and that creates a real demand risk if traffic falls short. That is alongside unanswered questions about how escalating construction costs will be dealt with.
Before a single provision of the Bill comes into force, the Secretary of State must publish the full financial model and set out exactly what liabilities could fall on the public purse. Taxpayers deserve to see the real cost up front and not discover the risks after the contracts are signed. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s thoughts.
Zöe Franklin
We are also concerned about clause 85, because it appears to grant sweeping powers to the Secretary of State to provide direct state financial assistance, including grants, loans, guarantees and indemnities, to private licence holders or special administrators. We are concerned that this creates a moral hazard whereby private operators enjoy commercial profits during good years while taxpayers shoulder the financial risks if traffic revenues fall short or construction costs overrun.
State financial assistance under clause 85 must be strictly restricted to external macroeconomic shocks, and only after private equity investors have absorbed the initial commercial losses. Taxpayers must not be forced to fund corporate bail-outs for private toll road companies while local councils’ road maintenance budgets face a severe squeeze. We all know the state of many local roads due to the ongoing local government finance issues, so do statutory limits exist under clause 85 to prevent taxpayers from bailing out failing private toll operators when commercial traffic projects prove overly optimistic? Does the Minister agree that that represents another example of privatising profit and nationalising debt?
I will turn to amendment 73 tabled by the Opposition. The regulated asset base model being introduced by the Bill is a standard financial model for large infrastructure and has been used in other sectors, such as water and nuclear. It gives private entities a regulated return on their investment, or specifically in the case of roads, allows the investor to charge tolls for the use of the infrastructure that they will build and maintain, with the level of those tolls checked by the regulator to make sure they are fair for road users.
I point hon. Members who have spoken to the funding statement issued by National Highways in February 2025, which gives a more detailed explanation of how those models would work in relation to projects that may be brought under the Bill. I am afraid the request for the full details of the funding settlement and agreement is not appropriate; it is commercially sensitive and publishing it now in a very specific way could damage our ability to get the best deal for the Government when we enter into the final transaction. Given there is already a report in the public domain and that specificities would damage the potential for us to get the best value for the taxpayer, I urge hon. Members not to push the amendment to a vote.