House of Commons (23) - Commons Chamber (10) / Written Statements (6) / General Committees (3) / Westminster Hall (2) / Petitions (2)
Westminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
Dr Roz Savage (South Cotswolds) (LD)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered e-petition 767687 relating to holding a UK-wide briefing on climate and nature risks.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I thank Chris Packham for starting this petition, the national emergency briefing team for their tireless work, the more than 138,000 people who signed the petition and the many colleagues who have joined us today.
I attended the original national emergency briefing in Westminster Central Hall last November and have been heartened by the number of screenings taking place across my constituency and every other constituency across the country. In the South Cotswolds, screenings took place in Cricklade, Tetbury, Malmesbury, Hullavington, Lechlade, Fairford, Sutton Benger and Cirencester. They have galvanised the public, but the country needs something more.
The petition calls for a national briefing introduced by the Prime Minister and delivered by independent scientists, broadcast on live TV, radio and online platforms. For the avoidance of any doubt, I emphasise that it would not be a showing of the existing film from last November, but a new briefing organised, orchestrated and owned by the Prime Minister and his Government.
Caroline Voaden (South Devon) (LD)
I thank my hon. Friend for introducing this important debate. We had that style of briefing during the covid pandemic. Does she agree that this is on a much bigger and more critical scale than that? Briefings like that give people agency to make decisions about their lives, which is why they are so important. Will she join me in commending my constituents Simon and Nick Oldridge for creating the national emergency briefing?
I congratulate the hon. Lady for bringing this debate before the House. Putting the facts before the public is plainly to be applauded, but does she agree that they need to be the full facts—for example, that it will cost £695 billion to achieve net zero in this country by 2050 and that, by the end of the century, that would result in a reduction in warming globally of 0.00376°C?
Dr Savage
With some reservations, I thank the right hon. Gentleman for his intervention. I would be delighted to have a meeting with him subsequently to debate those figures.
I commend the Prime Minister for attending COP31, especially as he was the only G7 leader to do so, and welcome his pledge that the UK is to begin a new era of British leadership.
Dr Ellie Chowns (North Herefordshire) (Green)
I pay tribute to all our constituents who signed the petition and have shown the national emergency briefing in in our constituencies. They highlight just how important this issue is to them, and they have shown leadership. The hon. Lady talked about the Prime Minister’s desire to show leadership. Does she agree that the very first thing he should do is therefore to rule out Rosebank, make clear that fossil fuels must stay in the ground and stop pouring fuel on the fire of the climate and nature crisis?
Dr Savage
I am not here to debate the pros and cons of Rosebank, so I will stick to the subject at hand.
This moment calls for moral courage: the courage to tell people the truth, however uncomfortable, and trust them to rise to the challenge. The natural systems on which our lives, prosperity and security depend are under threat. We must understand those risks and act while we still have the power to change course. For years we spoke of climate change as something that would happen in the future somewhere else—perhaps somewhere with polar bears or coral reefs.
Rachel Gilmour (Tiverton and Minehead) (LD)
I thank my constituents for the overwhelming interest that they have shown in this matter. The 2025 drought alone cut UK arable farm revenues by more than £800 million, and by August this year over 70% of England was in drought. Does my hon. Friend agree that when a major reservoir, such as Wimbleball in my constituency, falls to just 13% of its capacity, that ceases to be merely an environmental concern? Climate and nature risks now pose a direct economic and strategic threat to the UK’s food security and should be treated as such by the Government.
I remind hon. Members that interventions should be short. This is a very popular debate and I want to get everyone in who wishes to speak.
Dr Savage
My hon. Friend pre-empts my next line. That future has arrived—it is here. Last week’s BBC “Panorama” episode “Fire and Floods” reported more than 2,800 deaths from this summer’s heatwaves. On one particularly difficult day, ambulance services in the south-west dealt with 4,000 incidents, which equated to one new emergency call about every 15 or 16 seconds. Around 7 million properties across the UK are at risk of flooding in more extreme rainfall. “Panorama” visited Tenbury Wells, which used to flood about once every decade but has flooded eight times since 2020. Local businesses struggle to obtain insurance. Who would risk starting a business when every winter brings the possibility of losing everything?
A 2024 report led by the Green Finance Institute found that, under severe scenarios, nature’s deterioration could reduce UK GDP by as much as 12%. The right hon. Member for South West Wiltshire (Dr Murrison) might want to factor that into his calculations. Consider our farmers: one featured on “Panorama” lost 70% of his spring barley yield to drought. Food production depends on healthy soils, reliable rainfall and functioning ecosystems.
My hon. Friend talks about the plight of farmers. Having three poor harvests in a row has cost arable farmers an estimated £4.8 billion. We know there is no food security without nature security. Does my hon. Friend agree that the Government should back my good food Bill and put food security at the heart of Government?
Dr Savage
I wholeheartedly endorse my hon. Friend’s good food Bill, which is timely and important. What I have outlined are questions of food security, economic stability, public health and national resilience. The Government know that. In January they published a national security assessment, albeit in somewhat edited form, on the degradation, and even the collapse, of global ecosystems. Its conclusions should have commanded national attention. The report found with high confidence that every critical ecosystem that it examined is on a pathway to collapse. It warned that some could begin to collapse from 2030 and concluded that without significant improvements to our food systems and supply chains, Britain would be unlikely to maintain food security if those collapses trigger international competition for food.
Jess Brown-Fuller (Chichester) (LD)
This year, Chichester, where 1,200 people are employed in the horticultural industry, saw an aphid infestation that meant one business had to throw away 445 tonnes of produce. Warmer summers and milder winters caused that infestation. Does my hon. Friend agree that climate change impacts not just our environment but businesses up and down the country and leads them into volatile situations where they might not be able to survive, which impacts our food security?
Dr Savage
Absolutely. Those are the unforeseen consequences, in many ways. That is a heartbreaking waste of food, and it is just beginning.
Surely the British people deserve to know what the Government already know. Despite the warnings, Britain remains alarmingly under-prepared. The Government have confirmed that the UK holds no national strategic food stockpiles. Our food supply chains depend heavily on just-in-time deliveries, which are very efficient when everything works but extremely vulnerable when extreme weather disrupts harvests, transport and international supply chains simultaneously. The dominoes could fall with catastrophic consequences.
The Climate Change Committee has warned that 6.3 million properties in England are at risk of flooding, rising to about 8 million in 2050. In its latest assessment, not one of 46 adaptation outcomes was rated “good” for delivery. I serve on the Environmental Audit Committee, and our flood resilience inquiry has exposed serious weaknesses. This is an argument not for panic but for better preparedness, which begins with knowledge and understanding.
During the covid pandemic, the Government held regular briefings with scientific experts explaining what was happening, what remained uncertain and what people could do to protect themselves, their families and their communities.
Tessa Munt (Wells and Mendip Hills) (LD)
On my hon. Friend’s point about covid, there were 4,500 heat-related deaths in the summer. In such circumstances, surely, we should require the Government to give us a very clear idea of what they want to do. The best way to do that is exactly what my hon. Friend is proposing: covid-style briefings on the television.
Dr Savage
I agree, and I look forward to the Minister’s response to my hon. Friend’s point. Those briefings may not have been perfect, but the principle was correct. When a nation faces a serious threat, its Government must be honest with their people. The Government’s “Be Ready” campaign encourages households to prepare for emergencies, and I welcome that, but a few tins of food and a wind-up radio will not cut it when we look at the likely disruption ahead.
Vikki Slade (Mid Dorset and North Poole) (LD)
We have a proud history of public information films and briefings going right the way back to the ’70s and ’80s. But my constituent Amanda has suggested that a national day of action alongside these briefings would allow everyone to see the things they can actually do to make a difference. Does my hon. Friend support that idea?
Dr Savage
That sounds like an excellent idea from Amanda. The briefing would need to be just the start of the story. I know that campaigners already have ideas on how to follow up on that to make sure that people have support to get ready.
We rightly take terrorism and cyber-attacks seriously, but climate and nature breakdown demand no less attention. If a hostile power had caused the number of deaths attributed to this summer’s heatwaves, we would surely regard it as a national emergency. We must also consider misinformation. Research from the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero suggests that 53% of people find conflicting information about climate change so confusing that they struggle to know what to believe. A credible briefing by independent experts would give us a shared understanding grounded in truth.
There is encouraging evidence about how people would respond. An independent evaluation after screenings of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” gathered more than 13,000 audience responses. Of those responding, 89% felt better informed, 87% felt more motivated to act, 57% perhaps surprisingly felt more hopeful and, crucially, four in five of those who were less hopeful still felt more motivated to act.
Claire Hazelgrove (Filton and Bradley Stoke) (Lab)
Does the hon. Lady agree that it is so often the brilliant environmental campaigners and organisations, such as those in my constituency, that provide hyper-local examples of the actions we could take? Perhaps we would do well to look at those examples nationally. I also give thanks to the 287 local residents in my constituency who signed this petition and helped enable this debate today.
Dr Savage
Yes; there are definitely examples of best practice across this country that can be shared, adopted and adapted elsewhere.
The film’s audiences were self-selecting, but we should not underestimate people’s capacity to hear difficult truths and respond positively. That matters particularly for our young people. A whole generation is growing up knowing that the world they will inherit may be less stable and secure than the one their parents knew. Eco-anxiety contributes to stress and, for some, disengagement. When a problem feels overwhelming, it is easy to conclude that nothing we do really matters.
I can somewhat relate to that feeling; if I may, I will share a personal story. It was in 2003, when I was travelling in the Peruvian Andes, that I saw glaciers that local people told me had retreated dramatically during their lifetimes. Something that I had understood intellectually suddenly became visibly and viscerally real. I started reading everything that I could about the ecological crisis. For a while, I felt like I was in a real panic, just desperate about the degradation of our world, but not knowing what I could do about it.
Eventually, I hit on the slightly crazy idea of rowing across oceans to raise environmental awareness. I make no grand claims about how much my rowing reduced emissions—although a rowboat is very low-emission—but it gave me a purpose and a sense of agency. It turned anxiety into action. Instead of feeling helpless, I had found something constructive to do. Imagine what we could achieve if we gave our young people genuine agency and a sense of ownership and responsibility towards their own future.
Lee Pitcher (Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme) (Lab)
Research by IPSOS shows that 52% of young adults aged 16 to 34 believe that we should have strong climate action, while for the generation aged 55 and over, that figure has come down from 52% in 2024 to 39%. Would the hon. Lady agree that when we are looking at the petition, we need to ensure that we communicate to all generations?
Dr Savage
Yes, it definitely does need to span generations, because we need all hands on deck.
Going back to young people, we need not just to tell them to recycle more or fly less and shoulder the burden of problems that they did not create. Instead, we need to give them the knowledge, opportunities and power to shape the world that they inherit. That is the opportunity before us today. A national briefing must not simply frighten people into understanding the reality of climate change and ecosystem collapse; it must also equip them to respond.
Rowing solo across oceans taught me that you cannot just ignore the weather forecast if it is bad and hope it will go away. You need to get ready before the storm to make sure that you are ready when it hits; ignoring it will not make you safer. You study the conditions, get ready, decide what to do and do everything that you can to stay safe. Our country needs that same realism and determination. Unlike rowing solo, we must do it together. A national briefing should just be the start. It should begin a sustained conversation reaching beyond those who already care, and invite communities to consider what the risks mean to them locally.
During the second world war, Britain’s resilience depended not only on national leadership, but on millions of ordinary people growing food, manufacturing supplies, caring for neighbours and contributing however they could to the national effort. They were participants in a national endeavour, not just helpless spectators. Our circumstances today may be different, but that sense of shared purpose remains incredibly relevant.
In my constituency of the South Cotswolds, we are exploring this through a project called “Stronger South Cotswolds”, which I launched earlier this year to build a more connected, resilient and self-reliant constituency. Picture local food networks connecting farmers with schools and hospitals, strengthening livelihoods and food security; community hubs bringing neighbours together and keeping emergency supplies at the ready; locally generated energy reducing bills and vulnerability; and restored wetlands and healthier soils protecting homes and farms from flooding and drought.
Carla Denyer (Bristol Central) (Green)
I thank the hon. Member for giving a brilliant opening speech and all our constituents for signing the petition to enable this debate. She was part way through a brilliant list of examples of bottom-up action that her constituents are working on collaboratively to improve their resilience from the climate and nature crisis. Does she agree that the Government’s current, rather more top-down, and I would say weaker, approach to resilience is not cutting the mustard, and that supporting grassroots resilience and adaptation work is the way forward?
Dr Savage
In my experience, when we put a small amount of money into the hands of local people who know exactly what to do with it and what the key intervention points are, we get a brilliant return on investment. I totally agree with the hon. Lady that we need both: top-down and bottom-up.
Those are practical, achievable things, and they build something that the Government cannot manufacture from Whitehall: the relationships and trust that we saw during covid, on which resilient communities depend. Research led by Professor Tom Oliver at the University of Reading has explored how involving communities in understanding climate risks and developing responses can increase both awareness and preparedness.
However, community resilience is not an excuse for the Government to withdraw. We cannot expect volunteers to compensate for inadequate flood defences or failing infrastructure, nor can we expect struggling households to fund measures that they simply cannot afford. It is up to the Government to provide honest information, co-ordination, resources and essential infrastructure. They must reduce emissions, restore nature, protect the vulnerable and give communities the means to act. Do not devolve the problems; devolve power and resources. National leadership and local initiative are partners; neither can succeed without the other.
As I draw towards the end of my speech, I have three questions for the Minister. First, will the Government commit to a live, prime-time national briefing, presented by the Prime Minister and delivered by independent scientific experts? I recognise that broadcasters make their own editorial decisions, but that is no reason for the Government to decline to organise a briefing. Secondly, will they make that briefing the beginning of sustained public engagement, helping communities to understand the risks? Thirdly, will they back that engagement with the resources and powers that communities need to act?
I want to finish on a hopeful note—not the passive hope that everything will somehow turn out all right, but the active hope that comes from knowing that we still have choices and that the choices that we make now matter disproportionately. We already know that we are heading into choppy waters. Some changes are already unavoidable, but others can still be limited by what we do now. I have seen what ordinary people can achieve when they find purpose and come together. Our country has extraordinary reserves of courage, ingenuity, generosity and collective wisdom. What is missing is the national leadership to give those efforts a shared direction. The Prime Minister could stand before the British people and say, “These are the risks that we face, this is what the evidence tells us, this is what your Government will do and this is how, together, we can prepare for the future.” That would not be an admission of defeat; it would be an act of true leadership. It would show respect for the British people, confidence in their judgment and faith in their capacity to rise to the challenge.
Several hon. Members rose—
Order. Two things: first, can I remind hon. Members to stand? We have to calculate how long everybody gets to speak, and if you have already spoken and do not intend to make a whole speech, can you liberate a space for people on the sides who do want to make a speech? We are also starting with an immediate time limit of four minutes—I am pretty sure that will go down.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I commend the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) for setting out incredibly well why the film matters. In the four minutes that I have, I want to move on to what will happen if the film is not shown, because it is important that this place looks at the counterfactual.
I am pleased to say that, on this side of the House, we are not engaged in what is called climate delayism, but sadly, those in this country who wish us to take the risk are growing increasingly louder. There is a clear, concerted effort to deny the climate crisis by saying that we can delay action.
Rachel Blake (Cities of London and Westminster) (Lab/Co-op)
Will my hon. Friend give way?
Apologies, I do not have time—I am so sorry.
Seventy-seven per cent of people surveyed by the Met Office believe that climate change is a concern, but 70% of the narratives that we now see on social media refer to the concept of climate delayism—the idea that the economic can trump the ecological, when the reality is that the two go hand in hand. The hon. Member for South Cotswolds articulated very well the cost of not taking action. On the question asked by the hon. Member for North Herefordshire (Dr Chowns), we see that in the debate on Rosebank. For many of us, the economic case is not there because we do not own the oil; but more importantly, the ecological case is clear. Watching the film and looking at the risks that we are taking drives it home to many of us why we cannot afford the time to delay.
The former Member for North East Somerset, Jacob Rees-Mogg, went on GB News and argued that we were living through a medieval warm period and that we have always been able to adapt. Well, I know exactly where the dinosaurs came from and what happened to them at the end of their tenure as well. We would do well to remember that the film points out to us that 2024 was the first year that the world’s temperature exceeded above 1.5°C, above pre-industrial levels. We know we do not have time to delay action on the climate. That is why we must reject Rosebank, but also recognise the work that this Government are doing, in particular the investment they are making in renewable energy. If we do not show the film, people will not recognise that the hon. Member for South Cotswolds is right that there needs to be clear, independent, factual information. If we do show this film and say that that is enough, that is also not the right answer. We owe our constituents action on these issues.
I want to flag the importance of climate resilience in urban communities. I defy anyone who wants to tell us we should either add to the emissions or somehow delay action on net zero to come and talk to my residents in Walthamstow, whose houses were burnt down during the heatwave this summer, when the fires burnt so quickly because the ground was so dry. I defy anybody who wants to say that we can delay action on climate change to come and talk to my constituents who cannot get insurance because they live on a floodplain. We owe it to everybody in this country not just to tell the truth, and recognise that sometimes the truth has not been told in this place, but to tell the truth that we can take action.
When I see my Government investing in renewable energy, I look at what I can do at a local community level. I am proud that in my community in Walthamstow we are inspired by the film. We are working together to get everybody solar panels and batteries, inspired by the community energy fund, to cut the cost of living crisis and energy bills, and also fossil fuel emissions.
The jacket that I wear today has come from a sustainable fashion project in Walthamstow, working with Age UK as well as the Re-Loved Club. The film tells us that if we are armed with information, we can be inspired to act. Let us make sure the British public get the information they need through that broadcast, and also recognise that when action is being taken, they too can be part of it. We are doing it in Walthamstow. I applaud what the Government are doing, and I hope we can all work together to do more of it.
The time limit is informal, so the extra minute does not apply—the clock is ticking forward.
Manuela Perteghella (Stratford-on-Avon) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I am grateful to the petitioners, who include 337 of my constituents in Stratford-on-Avon.
“One touch of nature makes the whole world kin”,
wrote Shakespeare. Those words from Stratford’s most famous son remind us that our wellbeing is inseparable from the natural world around us.
When our farmland suffers drought, habitats decline and communities face increasing climate risks, we are reminded that human and nature’s health are bound together. The science is clear, the impacts are visible, and communities across the country are already experiencing the consequences. That is why I support the petition and the call for a nationally televised emergency briefing on the climate and ecological crisis.
In Stratford-on-Avon, nature matters deeply to people. I have had the privilege of attending screenings of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” in Stratford, Alveston and Ettington, but many more were held in towns and villages across my constituency. Our communities understand what is at stake. We know the reality of flooding and wildfires. We treasure our countryside, our rivers, our farmland and our local environment. We know that protecting nature is fundamental to protecting our health, our livelihoods, our local economy and our way of life. An emergency briefing broadcast nationally would help to communicate not only the scale of the challenge but the practical solutions available to us. Until we treat the climate crisis as an emergency, in the same way that we treated the covid-19 pandemic, we are frankly sleepwalking towards our own extinction.
There is hope: we need a comprehensive UK adaptation strategy that embeds climate resilience across Government decision making. We need adequate support for communities facing flooding, drought and heatwaves. That means investing in nature-based flood management, sustainable drainage systems, water security, home upgrades and resilient infrastructure. Acting now is far less costly than paying the price later.
A televised emergency briefing would not solve the climate and nature crisis overnight, but it would ensure that the public have access to the facts, understand the choices before us and can play their part in a national resilience strategy, as well as in shaping a safer and more sustainable future. If we are serious about protecting our country, our national security, our people, nature and especially future generations, then informing the nation must surely be the first step. I urge the Government to heed this petition.
Alex Mayer (Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard) (Lab)
I was not expecting to be called so early in the debate, so I will make some limited points. We are in the midst of a climate and biodiversity emergency, and I absolutely want as many people as possible to hear the evidence, because it matters, but we need to address a couple of issues. First, I would not want to compel any broadcaster to have to show a briefing, as much as I want as many people as possible to see the information. We need to look to the future: imagine another Government declaring a national emergency on something else that we did not agree with. I want people to find out about climate and nature risks, but we need to be cognisant of that.
Pippa Heylings (South Cambridgeshire) (LD)
Given that the Communications Act 2003 says that all broadcasters have a responsibility to report on things of national and international import, does the hon. Lady not think it is up to the broadcasters to provide the facts?
Alex Mayer
Absolutely; the more facts that are out there, the better. I was delighted to hear those facts when I went to a screening in Leighton Buzzard in my constituency. My second concern, though, is that we might be preaching to the converted. I think everybody who went to the screening in Leighton Buzzard agreed with me, but I want to make sure that we talk to people who do not.
My constituents have similar concerns, because they feel that the people who come to briefings already agree with them. They are concerned about schoolchildren. Does my hon. Friend agree that the Government should put together a briefing that could be shown in schools, to reach schoolchildren who may not have the information that has been provided in local screenings?
Alex Mayer
It is important that young people get as much information as possible. When I go to schools, young people are particularly concerned about the climate emergency and really want to make a big difference.
We need to give a message of hope, not just fear. We have some fantastic things to talk about: the fact that greenhouse gas emissions have halved since the 1990s is a fantastic achievement by people across this country, and we have scientists working on future plans as well. To go back to my point that we need to reach people who do not agree with me, we need to make sure that the messages get through to people where they are at. That might mean adverts on petrol pumps showing the carbon cost, or maybe “Thank you” messages to all the bus passengers for the difference they make by travelling in a greener way.
Rachel Blake
My hon. Friend is making an interesting argument about how we get the point across. Was she as struck as I was by the amount of people who signed the petition, as well as by the number of Members of Parliament who are here for the debate? Does she think it is possible that the public are ahead of politicians who seek to deny the level of the climate crisis and, even worse, to divide communities on what was previously a consensus on the climate action we need to take? Does she agree that we need to move forward in consensus to make sure we have the strongest possible public and political will behind the urgent need to invest in our infrastructure and mitigations?
Alex Mayer
My hon. Friend makes a very good point. We have to remember that progress is not always linear. If we are to ensure that we get the solutions that the vast majority of people in this room want, it is vital that we bring people along with us.
Does the hon. Lady agree that although the Prime Minister and No. 10 at large will bring a great degree of gravity to any such briefing, it would have more impact across the whole of society and the whole political spectrum if it also involved other political leaders in Westminster and, much more importantly, the leaders of the devolved nations? A lot of the changes we are going to have to make relate to devolved matters.
I hope the hon. Lady is concluding, because she has gone over four minutes.
Alex Mayer
As I said, the more people we can get involved in the debate—whether that is the leaders of devolved nations or mayors—the better. It is also really important to hear the voices of independent experts.
No—we cannot accept another intervention during this speech. We have a whole list of speakers to get through.
Alex Mayer
Finally, I welcome some of the action the Government have been taking, particularly on tree planting, which is really hopeful. I am so amazed by how many Members are here. This is a fantastic opportunity to get more and more people involved.
Brian Mathew (Melksham and Devizes) (LD)
It is an honour to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) and the Petitions Committee.
I pay tribute to the 137,000 people across the United Kingdom, including 558 from my constituency, who signed the petition demanding a televised national emergency briefing. Over the past few months, I have sat in numerous community centres and church halls across my constituency to watch the “People’s Emergency Briefing” alongside hundreds of residents. Every time the reaction is the same: shock at the scale of the threat, followed by demands that the rest of the population be properly informed.
Last November, 10 of Britain’s leading experts, spanning national security, public, food systems and climate science, laid out the unvarnished trust. They warned that climate and nature breakdown is not a distant issue: it is a clear and present danger to our supply chains, our NHS and rising household bills. Even our own Joint Intelligence Committee has warned that global ecosystem collapse threatens UK national security. Yet there is a gap between that reality and current policy. The UK’s emissions fell by just 1.8% last year. We cannot ask the public to back transformative policies if they are kept in the dark about why they are necessary.
When the Minister responds to the debate, will she answer two direct questions? First, will the Government commit to broadcasting a prime-time, expert-led national emergency briefing, so that every household hears the facts straight? Secondly, what concrete policy shifts will follow to close the gap between our current trajectory and what is required to achieve genuine national climate resilience?
Brian Mathew
My constituents are ready to face the truth. It is time the Government matched their courage.
Chris Hinchliff (North East Hertfordshire) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Dr Huq. I declare an interest as the chair of the climate and nature crisis caucus.
One fact is at the forefront of my mind in this debate: the fossil fuel projects around the world that have already been given the go-ahead will emit nearly seven times the carbon pollution that our planet can cope with to stay within the safe limits of warming. We are on course to hit nearly twice that limit of 1.5° of warming. If that happens, it will damage our country beyond all recognition: our seasons will break down, and spring and summer as our parents and grandparents knew them will not return; many of the iconic wildlife species that make England England will vanish; and even our ancient oaks will fail and die. That will be England gone.
Even if we do not care about the future of our country, that level of warming will also destroy our living standards, with huge increases in insurance costs, more frequent flooding and wildfires, spiking food prices as supply chains break down and agricultural yields fall, and the temperature in our homes and workplaces becoming increasingly unbearable.
Chris Hinchliff
I am not going to give way, sorry.
That warming is also probably the fastest way to bankrupt our nation, as it will become impossible to keep up with the cost of crumbling infrastructure, with bridges and railways destroyed by storms, and the need to retrofit our schools, hospitals and care homes to cope with weather that they were never built to withstand. We cannot let that happen.
I have had reservations about the call for an emergency briefing, given my concerns about the backlash that it may trigger from those fundamentally opposed to tackling our pollution, and about how the precedent may be abused in future, but the threat we face now is too great and the need for co-ordinated national action too urgent for reservations and caution to win out. I therefore back the campaign for a national emergency briefing, led by the Government, to set out how we all need to pull together to prepare, and to prevent the worst consequences of climate breakdown from destroying our way of life.
James MacCleary (Lewes) (LD)
During my tour of my constituency this summer, a group of constituents attended several meetings to speak with me about the climate and nature emergency, and specifically the national emergency briefing. I attended a local screening of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” in East Dean, a village in my constituency. It made it clear how the warnings issued by scientists and security experts are directly relevant to the communities that I represent.
In Lewes, we know only too well the devastation that flooding can cause. In 2000, more than 600 homes were flooded when the River Ouse burst its bank, and just down the river in Newhaven, significant investment has been required to protect hundreds of homes and businesses from coastal flooding. The town’s fishing industry faces challenges from changes in sea temperature and currents bringing new, invasive species. In Seaford, further down the coast, as well as in neighbouring coastal villages, rising sea levels pose serious long-term challenges in respect of flooding and coastal erosion.
I want to draw attention to how local initiatives are making a big difference. One such initiative is the Ouse valley climate action programme, which has been helping communities to restore habitats and strengthen resilience against floods and droughts. My constituents have also organised a national petition on the national emergency briefing, which I shall look to present in this place in due course.
Local efforts must be matched by national action. As the Liberal Democrats’ defence spokesperson, I was particularly interested in the film’s national security implications. After watching the screening I invited Lieutenant General Richard Nugee, who made the national security assessment, to meet me. We talked about the threat posed to Britain by climate change and habitat loss. We often think of national security in terms of the threat of war, whether that is Russian aggression or the safety of our NATO allies, but climate change threatens to make an already unstable world even more dangerous. Food shortages, population displacement and increased competition for resources can all lead to conflict and instability. That makes climate resilience and nature loss a national security issue that should, as such, be integrated into our security strategy.
Monica Harding (Esher and Walton) (LD)
Does my hon. Friend agree that the Government’s own national security assessment tried to bury talk about the devastating impact of the climate crisis not only in the UK but around the world, where it is causing migration into this country—that is, the small boats?
James MacCleary
As ever, my hon. Friend’s intervention is exceptionally well timed. I was about to say that I have taken a particular interest in the Government’s assessment of the impact on our national security of biodiversity loss and ecosystem degradation. The abridged findings, published earlier this year, warn of potentially serious consequences for food security and resilience in the UK, with several key ecosystems at risk of collapse as early as 2030. The full report was due to be published more than a year ago, but still only a portion of it has been made public. I am mindful of the confidentiality concerns associated with national security matters, but given the scale of the concerns raised, I would like further clarification from the Minister on how the findings are shaping Government policy, and on what steps are being taken to share additional evidence.
My constituents want lawmakers to fully grasp the magnitude of this issue. It is not a challenge for Government alone; it affects all of us. So many people can see the threat but feel overwhelmed by it. We need to do better than just telling people how bad it is; we need to provide practical help and support. Too often, climate action ends up being seen as the preserve of the middle classes. When someone is using a food bank and looking after a family on their own, it can be hard to prioritise an issue as vast as the climate emergency. That is why we need to do more than just point at Ministers and MPs and say, “Fix it.”
We are fortunate to have two thriving climate hubs in my constituency, in Lewes and Seaford, where volunteers who understand the scale of the climate emergency give up their time to educate, inform and support our community to take action in their own lives. I invite the Minister to meet representatives from the Lewes and Seaford climate hubs to understand both the challenges they face and the opportunities that people-powered action can create to help us all to contribute, whatever our circumstances.
Becky Gittins (Clwyd East) (Lab)
It is a privilege to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I thank the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) for securing this debate on behalf of the Petitions Committee.
Like so many Members in this room, I was privileged to attend a viewing of the emergency briefing earlier this year. In my case, it was in Ruthin in my constituency. I thank Denbighshire county council and councillor Barry Mellor, as well as members of the Ruthin Friends of the Earth group, for putting on such a fantastic event. I have to say that I found it both frightening and utterly compelling.
I start by welcoming all the actions the Government have taken so far. As the Prime Minister said at the COP31 climate summit last week,
“The climate crisis is not a distant threat. It is upon us all now, devastating lives and livelihoods everywhere.”
Climate change is a national security issue, and I was very pleased to hear the Prime Minister reiterate the UK’s commitment to meeting our 2050 net zero target. With the UK taking on the presidency of the G20 next year, I was heartened to hear that we will put climate firmly back on the global agenda.
There are those who benefit from our lack of climate action and energy independence. As we have heard in the debate today, many of those voices can be very loud online. I have observed, as I think we all have, how certain actors have managed to amplify their voices online, often prompting and promoting inaction and sowing disinformation. It is therefore more important than ever that authoritative and trusted voices are heard on this topic.
Earlier this month, I held a climate summit in my constituency of Clwyd East. The purpose was to bring forward and together a number of climate groups working across my constituency, to learn lessons from each other and to work out how we can amplify and make more effective the work to tackle climate change. I take the opportunity of this debate to thank all the groups that attended and the many more in my constituency who are doing fantastic work to tackle the climate and nature crisis.
Sadik Al-Hassan (North Somerset) (Lab)
In my constituency, we have had various screenings of the climate emergency national briefing, and we found it to be a both frightening and enlightening experience. Some 11,000 of my constituents signed a petition to save an ancient forest called Big Wood. Does my hon. Friend agree that tackling the climate emergency needs to start with protecting our heritage and ancient forests?
Becky Gittins
I agree with my hon. Friend. A lot of the efforts on climate change need to begin at home. Some of the most valuable work I see in my constituency starts right on the doorstep.
I heard some of my constituents’ views at my climate summit. Having been to see the emergency briefing, they gave valuable feedback on what they saw. My constituents were clear that it is good economics to take climate action and to take it now. They agreed that the focus on national and food security is welcome, and despite the seriousness of the task ahead and the frustration that we need to go much further globally, there was still a lot of hope in the room. There was optimism that many solutions are already available and just need to be adopted and scaled, with local people keen to feel the benefits of clean energy in their communities.
I have been contacted by dozens of constituents who rightly want to see a national briefing. Ministers have said that decisions on national screenings are a matter for broadcasters, but I would like to see the Government working to ensure that the messages from these briefings are distributed as widely as possible, and I encourage them to use all the platforms available for that. It is clear that to change trajectory we need climate champions at every level. We know that the consequences of doing nothing will be catastrophic for our planet. As the MP for Clwyd East, I am steadfast in my commitment to tackling climate change and ensuring that people are given all the information they need as a crucial and foundational step.
Charlotte Cane (Ely and East Cambridgeshire) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I declare an interest as the chair of the all-party parliamentary group for sustainable flood and drought management.
If we do not tackle climate change, my constituency will be under water. That will not be fresh water; it will be salt water, and we will lose the breadbasket of England. It will kill existing nature and flood our precious chalk streams and aquifers with salt water. Hot, dry summers and wet winters will become the norm, with frequent droughts and floods. As we have heard, the UK’s green and pleasant land will be totally changed. People, animals and plants will die. Many countries will become uninhabitable, and people and animals will migrate to parts of the world where the climate is less hostile. The changes that we need to make are challenging, and we need to bring people with us to deliver them.
Claire Young (Thornbury and Yate) (LD)
At the screenings of the briefing that I saw in Thornbury and Pucklechurch, I was impressed by the local action already being taken. Does my hon. Friend agree that any national briefing should be accompanied by evidence-based toolkits of action that everyone, from voluntary groups to the farmers who grow our food, can take?
Charlotte Cane
I agree with my hon. Friend. At many of the screenings I have gone to, people have had exactly that discussion, asking, “What can we do, what should we do, and how do we stop this?” I have attended many of those screenings, like many other Members, but this is too important to leave entirely to volunteers. The Government need to step up and brief us all on the climate emergency, just as they did with covid. The Government can bring together experts and data and give advice that will be seen as impartial. That would help to create a shared understanding of the challenges that we face by ensuring that people received consistent information from independent experts rather than having to navigate conflicting claims online.
Good public information leads to better decisions. When people understand risks, they are better placed to make informed decisions about their homes, their businesses, their health and local communities. Greater awareness can help communities, businesses and public services to work together more effectively. The benefit is not simply knowledge, but better co-ordination and stronger local resilience.
With drought, extreme heat and wildfires, this summer has really brought home to the UK what climate change might look like for us here. Recent winters have brought drastic flooding. It is not too late to stop this getting worse, but we need to act urgently and we need to bring people together. At the moment, it is too much about environmentalists versus farmers, the fuel poor versus Just Stop Oil campaigners, and climate deniers versus net zero. We need to come together as people working to protect our planet. I ask the Minister to commit to providing a balanced Government briefing to give everyone the facts and to allow us to work together to implement solutions.
Dr Simon Opher (Stroud) (Lab)
I thank the 947 people in Stroud who signed the petition—the third highest number of signatories in the country, so well done Stroud.
After the last two summers that we have had, and that day in July 2022 when we absolutely smashed the highest temperature ever recorded in the UK, it seems quite incredible that a stubborn group of people still do not believe in climate change. The temperature that day was not just a fraction above that record; it was a whole 2°C above. In Olympic terms, that sort of performance would immediately have alerted officials to the use of anabolic steroids. Indeed, I believe the metaphor holds: we now have climate change on steroids. The science is incontrovertible: our carbon emissions are causing temperatures to rise.
This is not a problem for just our grandchildren; the part of the film that most struck me was about tipping points. An oceanographer from Exeter, Professor Tim Lenton, talked about the North Atlantic currents and the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation. I have a personal connection to this: my son did a PhD at the British Antarctic Survey on what was happening to that current and the effect of increased glacial melt. Essentially, cold, dense waters at the pole sink and provide a deep water current that flows deep towards the equator and powers our gulf stream. Increased glacial melt from Greenland glaciers releases less saline and less dense water, which means that the current is slowing down and may well stop. That will just turn off our gulf stream and our climate will change in about a decade. It will be very scary. I worry, though, that most people who have seen the film already believe the science, so we are just preaching to the converted.
Luke Murphy (Basingstoke) (Lab)
My hon. Friend is giving a powerful speech. Does he agree that some of the best-informed people are young people? The issue is often raised when I visit schools. A public communications strategy must therefore reach people of all backgrounds and all ages, and importantly have voices that everyone trusts.
Dr Opher
Young people get this issue much better than older people, in a way. If we have a national briefing, we will reach different parts of society. That is incredibly important.
Climate change already claims more lives than war in this world. In the UK alone last summer, we had 2,800 excess deaths. In the NHS, there is now a summer crisis, not a winter crisis. That is all a result of climate change. Really, we have two choices: we can sit back with a mad gleam in our eye and see what happens while our water becomes scarce and the excess deaths mount, or instead, we can act. That might mean acting unilaterally to start with, but the UK has always led the world in a moral sense. We are justly proud of that; sometimes, it is necessary to step up.
There are concerns currently about Rosebank. A young activist in Stroud, a man very passionate about the climate, said that we should leave the oil in the ground at Rosebank. His reason was that we might need it—at least as a last resort to blast off from the planet when we have finally wrecked it. He actually used rather stronger language than that. It is our duty not to let that happen. That starts by changing the public perception and making everyone realise that we have a choice—but not for much longer.
Andrew George (St Ives) (LD)
It is a pleasure to contribute to this debate and I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) on an excellent introduction. I too attended the briefing almost a year ago. It was very impressive. All the material presented then has been crystallised in a brilliant film, which I have viewed at a number of screenings across west Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, where there is increasing alarm at what it portrays.
It is revealing that this is perhaps the best-attended debate at Westminster Hall in which I have spoken; I counted earlier certainly 75 Members of Parliament. I submitted an early day motion in May this year on the national emergency briefing, calling for exactly what the petition does. Some 115 Members of Parliament across six—although not all—political parties signed it, and I am grateful for their support. If any MPs present in the Chamber have not yet signed, I encourage them to add their names. The EDM highlighted exactly what the petition and the debate have highlighted: the impact in terms of societal disruption, the heatwaves and wildfires caused by climate change that we had experienced thus far—more happened after the EDM was submitted—the biodiversity decline, and the food and national insecurity that will be a result of what has been described.
Alison Hume
Last year, a wildfire ripped through the North York moors, coming within a mile of RAF Fylingdales. Does the hon. Member agree that wildfire resilience and protecting and compensating affected communities is a vital part of the Government’s work?
Andrew George
Indeed; I welcome the fact that the Government are looking at their national resilience programme. A storm resilience summit is happening in my constituency on 27 November following the impact of Storm Goretti, which devastated large parts of my constituency on 6 January this year.
Jayne Kirkham (Truro and Falmouth) (Lab/Co-op)
Our constituents in Cornwall are at the pointy end of climate change. They care and they very much see it coming. Does the hon. Gentleman agree that, as the Government have committed to clean power by 2030 and no new oil and gas in the Energy Independence Bill, we should be investing in new technologies, such as floating offshore wind, critical minerals and geothermal, that would benefit Cornwall’s economy as well as the planet?
Andrew George
Yes, of course. The EDM notes the substantial economic costs of inaction compared with the benefits of rapid transition to a low-carbon economy. There are great opportunities, as well as consequences if we do not address this. To echo the hon. Member for North East Hertfordshire (Chris Hinchliff), there is a concern that by doing this, we would provoke the naysayers, the flat earth society and the climate change deniers. The right hon. Member for South West Wiltshire (Dr Murrison) said earlier that we need all the facts, including the misleading and selective ones that he mentioned.
Andrew George
I cannot. Going ahead with this would provide an opportunity for those ridiculous points to be rebutted properly in public.
Linsey Farnsworth (Amber Valley) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I congratulate the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) on her fantastic opening speech. I thank the 128 of my constituents who signed the petition. I know that many more are extremely worried about the impact of climate change. It is often said, and rightly so, that the safety of our country and our citizens is the first duty of Government. Climate change and its accompanying symptoms of biodiversity loss, extreme weather, flooding, food shortages and extinctions threaten our national security and that of our children and grandchildren.
Linsey Farnsworth
No, I will not take any interventions out of respect for the people below me on the Chair’s list.
When I think about the future that I want for my children and generations to come, clean air, water and beautiful countryside like that in Amber Valley are non-negotiables. However, I know only too well that there is a very real and imminent possibility that those things and the resources that we have been privileged enough to take for granted for many years will be replaced by a different picture: one of extreme weather, increased deaths during freezing winters and boiling summers, scorched fields and food and water scarcity. We had a glimpse of that in the summer just gone.
In May, I attended one of the screenings of the national emergency briefing hosted by Amber Valley borough council and Transition Belper at the Ritz cinema. Together with the Government’s national security assessment of global biodiversity loss and ecosystem collapse, that briefing sets out the need for action with brutal directness and clarity. As MPs, we have a moral and social responsibility to understand those issues and address them with the urgency that they demand. That is why I am pleased that our Prime Minister attended COP31 to co-ordinate action with world leaders and experts.
Climate change is an issue of critical national importance that requires global co-operation and solutions at all levels. We are doing our bit in Amber Valley. Locally, brilliant organisations are doing fantastic work to increase awareness of the risks of climate change, encourage sustainable practices and protect natural habitats. I will be hosting an event in March that brings together these brilliant local stakeholders with national organisations to co-ordinate action and ensure that nature in Amber Valley remains protected.
Although reports and assessments are vital to understanding the current situation and the action we can take, they are not always accessible or widely read by the general public, whereas misinformation can be found with a few clicks online. What steps are being taken to combat misinformation and climate change denial so that the public are equipped to understand the risks that we all face and make informed decisions?
Adrian Ramsay (Waveney Valley) (Green)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. Our era will be remembered as the era of a catastrophic climate and nature emergency, and the history books—if we still have them—will be written about whether we did enough. Having hosted a screening of the national emergency briefing in Diss and attended others in Stradbroke and Harleston, all of which are in my constituency, I can attest to its ability to inform and inspire action among people. A prime-time briefing would be incredibly powerful.
This summer’s extreme heat shows the stark reality of the situation. In just one period of the summer’s prolonged heat and drought conditions in May and June, over 2,800 people died from heat exposure, and the economic impact is estimated to be as much as £2.3 billion. We know that our resilience to such life-threatening heat is severely reduced by the destruction of nature’s ability to absorb carbon, regulate temperatures, store water and protect communities from extreme weather. These imminent risks are all well documented in the UK’s nature security assessment on global biodiversity loss, ecosystem collapse and national security, which was partly published in January. The intelligence community has confirmed that climate breakdown is accelerating the degradation of ecosystems, which is compounding irreversible threats to our national security. Nature is not a luxury we can strip away in the name of growth. It is intrinsic to our life support systems, our national resilience and our security.
We are not short of evidence, targets or solutions. What is missing is the urgency, investment and political leadership. Current UK carbon budgets are based on out-of-date targets and focus too little on the action needed in the next few years. Progress has stalled. Emissions were down by only 1.8% in 2025, the Government have removed support from key areas like the warm homes plan and electric vehicles, and we do not know what the Government are going to say on the critical issue of whether the Rosebank oilfield licences are to be granted.
Action on climate adaptation has been diabolically insufficient. The Climate Change Committee found that not one of its 46 categories for adaptation showed evidence of good progress, with 12 rated as insufficient. In other words, we are simply not prepared for the impacts of climate change. So what do we need? We can and should empower local communities. In particular, local resilience forums need to be properly funded in every corner of the country to ensure practical protection for communities on the ground. What progress is being made towards ensuring that is the case? In Waveney Valley, we are making strides to meet the challenge. In February, I will hold my second annual sustainable communities conference, bringing together parish councils, community groups, environmental champions and those inspired by the briefing to be part of the solution.
What we most need is much stronger leadership nationally, including cross-departmental, whole-government approaches, so naturally I welcome the appointment of Dame Madeleine Alessandri as the UK’s special representative for climate security. I very much hope that it is a promising sign that the Prime Minister is taking the threats seriously, but the real test is whether the Government adopt a credible strategy to avert the worst climate threats. It would be a good start to see an official Government response to the nature security assessment on global biodiversity loss, ecosystem collapse and national security that sets out how the Government will respond to these major risks.
What we really need is for the Government to put climate and nature resilience at the heart of everything they do, stop the roll-back of commitments on the green transition, make clear they will not support the Rosebank oilfield and move nature restoration much higher up the political agenda. The question facing us is: with the warning lights clear to all, will the greatest failure in history be that we lacked the political courage and determination to act or, as we go beyond the 11th hour, will we rise to the challenge and do all we can to protect lives and livelihoods?
John Whitby (Derbyshire Dales) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. Last November, I attended the national emergency briefing at Central Hall, and I have been lucky enough to attend six screenings in my constituency, with more in the diary. During the discussion section after the film at one screening, a gentleman said that he was surprised that there was no attempt to give the other side of the argument. First, that shocked me because there is no other side of the argument—the film is based on scientific fact. Secondly, it made me realise that there is a wider narrative—that the climate crisis is not a thing or is an issue that the jury is still out on, rather than one where there is a cast-iron scientific consensus.
The leading environmental psychologist Professor Lorraine Whitmarsh from the University of Bath has found that 89% of people felt better informed after they watched the briefing. Is that not exactly what the Government need in order to get the public to back the urgent action that we need on climate change?
John Whitby
I agree with the hon. Member. That is why we must expand access to this information and the truth that it lays bare. The truth is that we know from temperature records that it has not been hotter than this in the last 150 years. We also know from scientists that it has not been hotter than this in 120,000 years—a reality that we are now all too aware of in this country.
The film’s release this year coincided with a punishing summer that brought us over 1,000 wildfires, five heat waves, drought and nearly 3,000 excess deaths. For many, the climate became the biggest issue affecting their daily lives for the first time. In Thorpe, I met people concerned that disposable barbecues would cause a wildfire at the tinder-dry Dovedale. Farmers were feeding their livestock using their winter stores as the fields were brown and barren. Appropriately, some of the viewings of the film that I attended were on swelteringly hot evenings.
The problem is not for tomorrow. People are expecting us to act now. So far, this Government have had an excellent record on climate action. It was great to see the Prime Minister demonstrating our global leadership at COP, but we have to do more.
Rosie Wrighting
My hon. Friend is being very generous in giving way. Does he share my feeling that particularly when it comes to young people, yes, it is important to communicate the concerns, but it is also important to communicate that action can be taken—that there is hope to save our climate?
John Whitby
I agree. Of course there is hope. We are nowhere near finished yet, but we have to do more. We have to ramp up our transition to clean energy, and we have to stay the course on electric vehicles. We have to put even greater urgency into building out the grid and we have to keep attention on hard-to-abate sectors. I remind the Minister that Peak Cluster is still waiting for a route to market. We need to get on with removals. We need to protect our food production. I urge the Government to reiterate their commitment to tackling the defining challenge of our time and to hold a UK-wide briefing so that the public can be in possession of all the facts, worrying though they often are.
I call Josh Dean. Sorry; we are going to the other side—everyone is mixed up. I call Tim Farron.
It is a pleasure to serve under your guidance, Dr Huq. I apologise to the hon. Member for Hertford and Stortford (Josh Dean). I am sure his time will come. I pay tribute to my hon. Friend the Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage), who led this debate with characteristically inspirational rhetoric and her own story, which is deeply moving.
There is no doubt behind the science that proves that climate change is real, increasingly catastrophic and caused by human activity since the industrial revolution, especially since the middle of the last century. Clearly, the answer is a transition to renewable energy and to stop the use of fossil fuels. Even someone who is not quite convinced by that must surely recognise the fact that Putin cannot turn off the sun, the wind or the waves. If energy security is the thing that might persuade someone, that is proof that we need to make that transition and we need to do so speedily.
I am deeply concerned about the impact of climate change on our planet. I am much more concerned about the impact of climate change on human beings—what it means when land is desecrated and deluged, as it is being right now, with the mass movement of human beings desperate to seek the resources denied to them because of changing weather. I am much more concerned about what that means for conflict and the lack of resources available to all of us.
The consequences for human beings are enormous. Too many people living comfortably in the west think that it does not affect them. My goodness me, it does, or soon it will. Like so many people today, I support a national briefing being televised and being a key moment of public service broadcasting that can bring people together. We need to stop sitting in silos. We need to work together to tackle this gravest earthly threat that we face.
I was pleased to attend the Grange showing of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” just a few months ago. Kendal has had several of them; we had them in Stainton, Ambleside and Crosthwaite, and constituents have attended in Penrith and Sedbergh as well. We are a community that cares desperately and deeply, and one that has the resources to help us tackle climate change. Cumbria has tons of wind and water—we even sometimes see the sun—and we have nuclear. We have the ability to contribute as part of the national, patriotic endeavour to tackle this great threat, and to boost our economy while we do so.
Hon. Members would be surprised if I did not talk about agriculture, and I am going to because it really matters. All of us individually can tackle climate change in the way we live our lives domestically, and in our businesses and communities. But the Government have levers they can pull that can make an even bigger difference. Seventy per cent of England’s land mass is agricultural, so if we want to shift the dial, we should start there, where we can do the most good.
I appeal to the Minister to talk to her colleagues, particularly about how we get farm payments right. That really matters. The Government’s failure, and the Conservatives’ failure, to roll out the sustainable farming incentive so that the majority of farmers, if not all of them, can be in it has not just hurt those farmers, their incomes and our ability to feed ourselves; it has put outside the tent thousands of farmers who could be contributing to the climate and nature endeavour. That is why the Government need to open the SFI again to make sure that everybody is in the tent. If they are outside, what will they do? They will either go out of business, which is miserable, or they will stay in business by doing the only thing they can to pay the rent: intensify and do harm to our environment. The single biggest thing the Government could do to tackle the climate and nature emergency is get every single farmer into the SFI tent, for the good of our country and our planet.
Josh Dean (Hertford and Stortford) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I want to recognise the many local people in Hertford and Stortford who have supported and engaged with this campaign, such as Janine, who told me:
“This matters to me because I have two sons who went to Richard Hale school in Hertford like yourself and I fear for their futures.”
Jason said that he and his partner want their child to
“grow up in a community, and a country, that took these risks seriously and acted on them in good time.”
They are real people thinking about their children and their communities and about the world we leave behind. We owe it to them and future generations to act, as a community and a country, on the dangers of the climate crisis, which we know are becoming a reality.
My generation has grown up in the shadow of an escalating climate crisis. These issues are not simply abstract concerns about our future; they are keenly felt by young people. They have shaped young people’s thoughts and anxieties about the world they will one day inherit, and it is people like us, in rooms like this, who they will one day look back on and judge for whether we did enough to secure their futures.
Does the hon. Member agree that one practical thing we could do is ban the construction of new waste incinerators, and dispose of our waste responsibly further up the waste hierarchy?
Josh Dean
The right hon. Gentleman makes an important point and it will be on the record.
Last year, I attended the national emergency briefing in Westminster. When I left, I felt pretty desolate. At first I thought, “What can we do?” and I felt the same anxiety I had felt as a young person when I first learned about the climate crisis. But on reflection, and over the coming days, the message I took from that screening was not one of hopelessness; it was that the future is still within our grasp. The technologies, the expertise and the solutions to the crisis exist, but a political and societal movement is required to deliver them at scale and pace. Seeing the briefing renewed my determination to make a difference. Imagine the impact of a credible, accessible and evidence-based briefing delivered on a national scale.
My hon. Friend has set out why the climate crisis is now a matter of life and death. Does he agree that when it comes to that evidence base, it is important that Government communications are based on evidence of what works, both for those who are already persuaded but also for those who are not—those who do not know a lot about this issue?
Josh Dean
I absolutely agree with my right hon. Friend’s point; it could not be more important. Just imagine millions of people having the opportunity to engage with those facts, hear from trusted experts and better understand the risks we face and the opportunities that come from addressing them.
People in Hertford and Stortford have a right to know the scale of the challenge, as well as what we can do to meet it. Otherwise, I fear that the climate crisis will continue to be viewed as a series of natural disasters happening on the screen of a smartphone, getting closer and closer, until it is outside the window and there is nothing we can do to stop it.
I therefore support the call for the Government to screen a live, expert-led briefing to the nation. I hope the Minister will listen carefully to the concerns that have driven so many people in my community and across the country to support the petition, and consider how we can better engage with the public on climate and nature risks. An informed public is a better prepared public, and if we are to meet this challenge together, we must do it by bringing people into the conversation and being part of the solution.
Shockat Adam (Leicester South) (Ind)
It is an absolute pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I refer Members to my entry in the Registrar of Members’ Financial Interests as the chair of the all-party parliamentary group for ethics and sustainability in fashion. What the petition is asking for was demonstrated last month, when the Government asked people to stockpile in their houses, possibly because of environmental factors such as the super El Niño. If the Government can tell people to stockpile, they can certainly tell them why.
I have just returned from COP31 in Antalya, where I spent time and chaired panels with Members of Parliaments from west Asia and north Africa, for whom this issue is not theoretical but a reality. In their countries, young ladies are having to walk further than their mothers did to get water, and young girls and boys are having to drop out of education because their harvest has failed again.
For those people, this issue is not a future concern; it is a present concern. The irony is that that is also the case for us in this country, but we seem to be ignoring it. We have just had the hottest summer recorded in Europe since records began. An estimated 50,000 people died from the heat on this continent. In 2022, nearly 3,000 people died in England because of the heat. That is more than died on our roads.
This issue is also not abstract for my constituents. New findings from the Ordnance Survey’s heat vulnerability index put Leicester among the 10 most heat-vulnerable cities in Britain, and it projects that we will climb the furthest, to fourth, by the end of the century. Ironically, Leicester is home to the National Centre for Earth Observation at Space Park Leicester, whose scientists map those heat islands from space. We have the data, but we do not have a plan.
I also want to speak about the state of our state. The National Audit Office found that 89% of our prison sites are at very high risk of flooding, and 75% of our court buildings are at risk of overheating. NHS England estimates that heat-related deaths already cost £6.8 billion a year. The NAO found that most Government bodies are still at an early stage of understanding their own climate risk.
I therefore have three asks of the Minister. First, we need to publish a resilience plan for the public estate. The NAO has done the diagnosis for our prisons, courts, hospitals and schools, but we need a plan with a timeline, funding and a named owner. Progress should be reported to this House every year.
Secondly, we need to put adaptation on a statutory footing. We have legally binding targets to cut emissions, but none to protect people from the climate change that is already here. The fourth national adaptation programme, due in 2028, must not merely explore stronger objectives but set measurable targets in law for flood protection, heat-safe homes and hospitals, and early-warning systems that reach everyone—and I do mean everyone. At COP31, I spoke about how disabled people are not usually part of the conversation; even though they are four times more likely to die in a disaster, 86% have never been asked to help plan for one. It is a similar situation with women across the globe. In a cyclone in Bangladesh in 1970, the ratio of male to female deaths was 1:14. However, as a result of women’s participation, a cyclone of the same strength in 2020 had a ratio of 1:1.
Thirdly, we need to hold a national briefing. The Government’s response said that broadcasters decide what they screen. Of course they do, but during the pandemic the Government held their own briefings and broadcasters chose to carry them because the public needed to hear them. Every figure I have used today is already in a Government document—the public deserve to hear them too.
It is a real pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Huq. I thank all the community groups in east Leeds that organised the screening of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” on the climate and nature crisis, including Eco Friendly Garforth, Climate Action Leeds and members of Halton in Bloom. It is a powerful documentary that conveys the true scale of the climate crisis and, crucially, offers a way forward. That hope is so important.
Climate devastation is the product of humanity’s actions, but limiting climate change’s impacts and protecting people from its consequences can also be the product of our actions. The screenings in Whitkirk, which I attended, and in Garforth made a big impact on people in our area, as did the many screenings up and down the country. As the petitioners are calling for, we need the Government to be doing the same: communicating with people the realities of the climate threat, showing the action we need to take to limit it, and showing how the Government will protect people from its impacts.
Climate change is not just some future problem; it is happening now. We saw that with the summer’s extreme heat, with tens of thousands of deaths across Europe alone, and with the droughts affecting food production and the horrific storms in Nepal. The truth is that it will get much worse if we do not take the action needed, and that means making the right choices, such as not going ahead with the climate vandalism of Rosebank—and that is what it would be.
It also means taking on the wider power of the fossil fuel industry, which has driven us to the climate cliff edge. The fossil fuel industry knew for decades about the dangers its endless pursuit of profits posed for humanity. Those powerful forces do not want us to take the climate action needed; they want us to delay. They want to distract and to keep their profits flowing. We see a dangerous web of fossil fuel interests, climate deniers, donors and so-called think-tanks seeking to shape our politics to stop the action we need, spreading misinformation and attacking the very policies needed to tackle climate change.
We must challenge that. We must expose the misinformation and make the case for urgent climate action. The Government can help to do that by ensuring a covid-style national broadcast on the climate and nature crisis. Like rejecting Rosebank, this could be part of the climate leadership that we so desperately need.
[Karl Turner in the Chair]
Gideon Amos (Taunton and Wellington) (LD)
It is a pleasure to see you both in the Chair, Dr Huq and Mr Turner. I thank the hundreds of people in my constituency who have signed the petition.
As the Liberal Democrat housing spokesperson, I am acutely aware of the impacts on people in their own homes. There have been 2,800 excess deaths in this country. We need to have not just warm homes but cool homes—indeed, better homes. We need to change the way we plan for homes and carry out development. I was proud to be at the original emergency briefing in Westminster Methodist Central Hall with colleagues here today and with my hon. Friend the Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage), who introduced this debate so compellingly.
I want to spend the few minutes I have thanking the community groups in Taunton and Wellington that have picked this issue up. It is not just an issue for the individual; it has been picked up by a whole range of community groups in my constituency, including Climate Action Taunton, led by the fantastic Karuna Tharmananthar, Taunton Quakers, Wellington Arts Centre, the chamber of commerce, Portt accountants and the villagers in North Curry and West Monkton, who are holding briefings, nearly all of which I have been to or will be going to soon. The messages I have received are more compelling still.
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to point out that nature recovery is not just for Westminster. Communities right across Somerset are rolling up their sleeves on this issue and building on Somerset’s local nature recovery strategy. Somerset council and Somerset Wildlife Trust are working with residents and community groups right across the county to turn ideas into action. Does he agree that a national screening of the emergency briefing would unlock understanding for more people, who will then know the risks and how to act to support nature recovery?
Gideon Amos
Absolutely. I completely agree with my hon. Friend and constituency neighbour. As well as supporting the briefing, this gives me a chance to point out that this is such a wide-ranging issue. Somerset council, for example, has changed its fleet of buses to electric and brought in new and more bus routes. There are so many things that we need to do.
I want to give the remaining time to some of those people who have written to me. One said:
“I’m sure you were as horrified as I was by the drought and heatwaves this summer...I’ve lived in Somerset for almost 40 years and this is the first time I’ve known”
such high temperatures. Another said:
“I speak as a flood victim, grandparent, and in trepidation about the future we will leave for those to come.”
Another one said:
“Living in Somerset, we are already seeing the devastating consequences of extreme weather. Flooding has caused enormous damage to homes, farmland, businesses and communities, leaving families facing financial hardship, uncertainty and emotional distress. We know only too well how vulnerable our county is, and it is frightening to consider how much worse these events could become as our climate continues to change.”
Another wrote:
“With our local landscapes, farmland, and community resilience facing clear pressures from volatile weather and biodiversity loss, having our representatives speak up on this could not be more vital for our area’s future and that of the next generation.”
Finally, one gentleman wrote to me:
“As a professional building surveyor I see more and more damage every year resulting from the extreme heat and lack of rain each Summer, and in Winter from extreme rainfall.”
I want to end with a message of hopefulness. As one or two other Members have highlighted, a national briefing needs to be about not just presenting the facts—which we must do; we surely have a duty to present those facts to people—but hopefulness and the opportunity for change. At these emergency briefings, I am inclined to bring out the National Grid: Live website, which shows that, in 2009, 75% of our electricity was generated from fossil fuels, but, today, that is only 23%. Change is possible. If we work together, we can have a better future and we can tackle climate change.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. There can truly be no more important inheritance than leaving the planet that we all rely on in a fit state for the future. But this summer, and going into winter, my community has seen at first hand the failure of successive generations of politicians to treat that inheritance, and its value, with the seriousness that it deserves.
Whether it is the way in which the extreme heat put farmers and firefighters at risk tackling wildfires and droughts right across my community, or the fact that, going into winter, already too many homes have been exposed to flood risk as a result of extreme weather, right across Hitchin, in my towns and villages, we have seen at first hand that climate change is not some distant future threat; we are starting to live with it right here and right now. The people who pulled together in my town are a credit to their community, and the way in which we have responded fills me with hope and pride.
But just as the best of us has been typified by my community’s reaction, the worst of our politics is too often at play when we talk about climate change. At the moment when the urgency of action could not be clearer, we see those on the right of politics all too often seeking to use this as a political dividing tool, either through outright climate denialism or through subtler, but no less pernicious, denial of the cost of delaying action—the suggestion that somehow we can simply avoid taking the necessary steps without any cost to us. While it is more cowardly, that form of denialism is no less dangerous, and it is one that our Government must continue to face down and reject.
Faced with that, though, there is a lot that gives me hope. One thing that has given me the most hope of anything over the past few months is how I have seen my community start to mobilise and demand better from all of us. With screenings of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” organised by Stotfold and Shefford town councils, and in churches such as St Mark’s in Hitchin, in Hitchin boys’ school and in village halls such as Kimpton’s, we have seen people right across my community come together, set out the case for action, ensure that everyone is well informed and start to organise collectively on how they can hold to account all of us with the power to act. Their ask, to begin with, is simple and compelling. In an age of disinformation and when the worst forces in politics and online seek to weaponise this cause, how can we ensure that everyone is apprised of the facts? Against that backdrop, the call for a briefing, to ensure that everyone has access to the information—yes, with some of the careful nuances and caveats that colleagues have set out—seems clear and compelling to me, and it is one that I hope the Government can find their way to advancing over the coming months.
In the meantime, we should not use the absence of such a briefing as an excuse to let ourselves off the hook. After last summer, the urgency of action could not be clearer. I am proud to be supporting a Government who have already taken several really important steps, from driving forward clean power deployment, to starting to show leadership on climate issues and attending, at the highest level, COP again. Although those who seek to delay action are right to highlight the fact that climate change is a global issue, it is wrongheaded to suggest that we will somehow get the rest of the world to go faster by going slower ourselves—I cannot think of a madder line of argument. We need to ensure that we are continuing to double down on this.
I am proud of some of the local wins that members of my community have been able to achieve together. They have been working to hold the Government to account, to strengthen future home standards, to ensure that solar panels will be mandatory on new builds in the future, and to secure investment in a new forest for central Bedfordshire—changes that are so simple and practical, and also profound. They will make a meaningful difference to the environment that all my communities rely on.
However, we have to go further. We need ambitious and pragmatic action to ensure that we build the consensus that we need and drive forward the dramatic change in energy use that we will rely on as a country. Measures to ensure that we do this in a lower-cost way are welcome. We should not be beholden to any ideologies here. Actions such as reforming the link between gas and electricity prices and ensuring that we break down some of the transmission costs that are pushing up our constituents’ bills far too significantly at times are welcome. But pragmatism cannot be a byword for inaction; it cannot be an excuse to delay. We can be in no doubt, after last summer, of the urgency of this cause. My constituents and future generations will rightly judge us harshly if we fail to act, and ensuring that everyone has access to the right information to make informed choices seems to me a sensible place to start.
Perran Moon (Camborne and Redruth) (Ind)
It is an honour to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner, and I thank the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) for initiating this debate. I have rarely attended a more important one.
Communities in Cornwall need no convincing that the climate and nature crisis is real. Jutting out into the Atlantic and with a vast coastline, we are on the frontline of climate change. We have been battered this year alone by storms including Goretti in January and Austen last month. Every time we are hit, thousands of homes go without power, villages are left isolated and the only train line in and out of the duchy closes. From the emergency briefing, it is clear that we will face more frequent violent storms in winter and more drought in summer. We have had months of drought across Cornwall, and much of Cornwall still has severe drought status.
My constituents want action. Since April, 18 emergency briefings have been held in village and town halls across my Camborne, Redruth and Hayle constituency, and I have attended several of them. As a result of those, I wrote in May to the Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport asking for a national broadcast on the climate and nature crisis.
Cornish infrastructure was built for a climate that no longer exists. A national briefing would give people trusted information about the risks to their homes, health, food and livelihoods. But I struggle with the Government giving climate change warnings on one hand while on the other considering Rosebank, as well as potentially weakening the ZEV—zero emission vehicle—mandate, which could lead to an increase in petrol demand higher than double the proposed annual output from Rosebank, with all the resultant carbon emissions.
I support this e-petition and thank the 460 constituents in Camborne, Redruth and Hayle who have signed it. Let us use this opportunity to act in accordance with the scale of the threat and provide practical support and infrastructure changes to mitigate the climate changes that will only get more pronounced.
It is always a great pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Turner. In south Manchester, we have seen the devastating impact of extreme weather. The River Mersey forms the southern border of my constituency, and we have a storage basin there for excess water when the Mersey is in danger of overflowing that is designed to protect local houses from flooding. Until recent years, we used the basin occasionally—maybe once every 10 years at most—but the Environment Agency has had to activate the basin three times in the last five years because of major flood events caused by extreme rainfall. In January last year, the water surge was so powerful that it broke through the additional flood defences and flooded areas in my constituency beyond where we thought houses might be at risk. The flooding damaged homes, disrupted businesses and placed pressure on local infrastructure.
Like a number of colleagues in the Chamber, I attended the briefing in Westminster Central Hall a year ago. The information in the presentation was scary and the warnings were stark. Since then, there has been a number of showings of the summary film of that event in my Manchester Withington constituency, in Chorlton, Didsbury and Withington, some of which I have attended. I thank the local residents who organise them. They are always full, and after each one I get a number of emails from constituents saying how shocked they are at the content and asking me to press Ministers to take action on the climate crisis. Many of those constituents and I have taken personal action, whether that is cutting down on meat eating or giving up a car to rely on public transport or active travel. Those are small changes, but at scale they can make a difference. I am pleased that the Government are acting on climate change too, whether that is record investment in renewable energy or the £15 billion warm homes programme to make our older buildings more carbon efficient. That is progress.
Still relatively small numbers are attending those local briefings. My fear, as we have heard, is that we are mostly preaching to the converted: the people who care enough to attend an event in the first place. I thank the 478 of my constituents who signed the petition. I am grateful to them all for taking action, but the scale of the climate crisis requires more. I have joined calls for a national televised briefing because the scale of the challenge needs more than just Government action; it needs a culture change across the country. Yes, it needs buy-in to progressive policies from Government, but it also needs the wider population to take action. We need everyone to be taking those small actions, which is why we need everyone to understand the scale of the challenge. Local briefings are important, but they are reaching a relatively limited number of people. The usual Government statements and updates on this issue do not receive the attention that they deserve, and they do not generally capture the public’s imagination.
To create a national understanding of the scale of this issue, a televised briefing is an interesting idea, and the time for it has come. I appreciate that this is an unusual ask. I also know that the Government are reluctant to intervene in the editorial choices of public service broadcasters, and I understand that. As chair of the all-party group for the BBC, I generally agree with that approach, but the scale of the crisis needs a radical, one-off action. A national briefing along the lines of the covid-style briefings would create the national conversation that would start to create the culture change we need. We cannot tackle the climate crisis without that kind of major national and international effort, and I encourage Ministers to consider that.
Olly Glover (Didcot and Wantage) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I thank and praise my hon. Friend the Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) for setting out the context for this e-petition with her customary eloquence and passion.
There are 487 petition signatories in my Oxfordshire constituency, and many communities have had local screenings of the national emergency briefing, including in Didcot, Harwell village, Harwell campus, Wantage, at least two in Cholsey and at least two in Wallingford—those are just the ones I am aware of; I suspect there have been more. That is in addition to lots of regular ongoing activity showing my constituents’ passion for climate and nature, such as the Wantage schools climate conference and a new working group led by Cholsey parish council about community resilience.
That interest reflects widespread concern about the risks resulting from changes to our climate and a loss of nature. That is based on what is happening today, in 2026—the many flooding issues across my constituency; this year’s heatwaves; the effect on people’s health and comfort; and concerns about loss of open space and nature—let alone what may happen tomorrow.
My big concern is that there seems to be a growing variance between what the Prime Minister says at events such as COP31 and the Government’s actions or potential actions on climate and nature. The Government’s carbon budget and growth delivery plan only just scrapes through the sixth carbon budget on paper, yet the Government’s actions put achieving it at great risk. They are cutting funding for the warm homes plan, and there is talk of a U-turn on Rosebank and diluting the zero emission vehicle mandate. This Government have also presided over the cancellation of the midland main line railway electrification, and there continues to be a total absence of a credible plan based on proven technology to end our reliance on diesel trains in the decades to come.
It is increasingly difficult to see how the Government intend to meet their legally binding climate commitments without relying on more costly and harder-to-deliver alternatives. I will read with interest what the Climate Change Committee concludes on the zero emission vehicle mandate later this week.
We cannot keep kicking the climate change mitigation can down the road. There are many ways that decarbonisation and economic growth can work together; they are not mutually exclusive. I visited the Westmill solar and wind farm in Oxfordshire on Friday, which is a community-owned and community benefit-focused scheme with small-scale investors. It shows how such schemes can benefit communities and small-scale investors as well as the wider economy and supply chain.
We need a more ambitious programme of domestic solar and battery, plus insulation improvements. Those together would create jobs and economic growth, as well as freeing up more of people’s money to be spent on things other than energy. We need far greater ambition on infrastructure for electric vehicle charging and for walking and cycling—things that would benefit consumers, the economy and the planet. We need to improve current technology and our efforts to discover future environment-compatible technologies so that we can strengthen the UK’s credentials in research, development and science, as well as decarbonising our country.
The savings that may result from not decarbonising are very likely to be dwarfed by the costs of adaptation in future, particularly with the impact of losing the warming currents that are talked about in the national emergency briefing, which could see us having Russian-style winters. The costs that would result from that alone, for changing our buildings and our approach to heating, would be enormous.
The petition asks a very clear question, and my concern is that the Government's response to it is a typical nice set of words but a very vague British state response. I hope that the Minister can give a clearer response to it.
I thank the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) for her excellent opening speech. I also thank Chris Packham for starting this petition and everybody who has signed it.
I put on record my thanks to my constituents who are organising screenings of the national emergency briefing across my constituency. I have already attended some screenings and I look forward to attending more, including one at Holy Trinity church tomorrow. The national emergency briefing sets out starkly the science of climate change, the impacts it is already having and the chaos and hardship yet to come, especially if we fail to limit global warming to 1.5° as we are currently on track to do. We see directly in the film how carbon emissions caused by humans are affecting every corner of our planet. There is a chilling moment in the film when we learn that the conditions we are experiencing—extreme heat, flooding and weather chaos across our country—are the best we can expect to see in our lifetime as things stand.
However, the film also sets out a powerful message of hope. Action to address climate change, both by reducing carbon emissions to allow nature to recover and by adapting our towns and cities to be resilient to a changing climate, benefits everyone. The film shows places such as Curitiba in Brazil, where, after several decades, strong local leadership has transformed the city by focusing on climate adaptation and delivering a better quality of life, sustainable jobs, efficient transport and hospitable neighbourhoods for everyone.
Climate action requires difficult decisions. I believe that it must mean that the Government refuse to agree to further fossil fuel drilling in the North sea, including at Rosebank. I believe that it must mean sticking with the zero emission vehicle mandate. Making those hard decisions will mean that we are able to seize the opportunities presented by the necessary transition to net zero: investing in the industries that help us to reduce emissions and the skills that our young people need to gain jobs in the new green industries; empowering local leaders to transform towns and cities at a neighbourhood level with planting for shade and flood mitigation; retrofitting homes to reduce bills and save lives during extreme weather events; developing the circular economy to reduce both waste and costs to consumers; and much more besides. But we will not fully grasp the opportunities available to us while there are still too many dissenting voices denying the necessity of such action and encouraging short-term expedient decision making that sustains our dependence on fossil fuels.
Difficult decisions are easier when there is a consensus that they are necessary. I have not heard any argument about the science shown in the national emergency briefing. But most people are not thinking about the climate most of the time. They are preoccupied with the pressures of everyday life. However many screenings are arranged by community groups across the country, it will mostly be those who already know and understand the science and urgency of the need for climate action who attend them.
A national emergency briefing introduced by the Prime Minister and screened on public service broadcast channels, as well as on social media, would help to build the consensus we need to take further, bolder action on the climate emergency. It would enable the Government to explain what is already being done, which is a lot; why bold decisions, which some regard as challenging, are necessary; and how investment in the net zero transition will ultimately benefit everyone.
I understand the Government are reluctant to undertake such a briefing in the format suggested by the campaigners. If the Government will not move forward in that regard, I urge the Minister to set out what the public education programme for the climate emergency will look like, because the Government have agency in this debate, and it is vital that we build the consensus that is needed.
Dr Danny Chambers (Winchester) (LD)
It is a pleasure to see you chairing this important debate, Mr Turner, on the petition calling for an emergency briefing. I was delighted to host and organise a screening of the briefing at the Winchester Science Centre, which was absolutely packed and was organised with Winchester Action on Climate Change. In the lively discussion afterwards, one thing became clear: there is a big appetite for all policymakers to see the film.
There is something deeply troubling in our politics. Across many democracies, including our own, scientific facts are increasingly being weaponised or dismissed as part of political discourse. We have seen the rise of political figures, including Donald Trump internationally and Reform UK here at home, who are increasingly associated with climate science denial and vaccine misinformation. It is not confined to extreme politics, because the Conservative leader announced that anyone who believes in achieving net zero carbon emissions will be blocked from standing as a Conservative candidate at the next general election. Let us think about what that actually means.
Climate change is a scientific fact and yet it is being recast as a test of political loyalty. When politicians ignore scientists and experts, problems that could have been managed early become crises, and ordinary people pay the price. Whether we are talking about climate change or pandemics, they pay in economic damage, in national security and with their lives.
Members in this room are from different political parties, and the people here in the Gallery today will have different political views. That is entirely right. But in a world of pandemics, climate shocks and crop failures, people of all political colours can surely agree on one thing: electing leaders who disregard science, or weaponise it for short-term political gain, is a luxury we simply cannot afford.
In veterinary science there is a concept called “one health”: a recognition that animal health, human health and environmental health are inseparably linked. A good example is disease control, because diseases that were classified as tropical when I was studying at university are now spreading to other parts of the world. We all know about the bluetongue virus that is spreading through livestock. When I was at university, the bluetongue 3 strain was a disease of southern Europe and northern Africa. It spread up through Europe; it was in south-east England a couple of years ago. It caused devastation in the south-west this year, and in the last couple of months it was detected in Scotland for the first time. Those dead sheep and cattle are a direct result of climate change. It is terrible for animal welfare and family businesses but also directly affects our food security.
Climate change is not just about sustainability, food production or even the health of our planet. Its effects sit upstream of many of the crises that we are trying to deal with in politics. Extreme weather leads to crop failure, which leads to food insecurity, which drives instability, displacement and conflict. Those pressures do not remain constrained to one geographical area. They disrupt global supply chains, which affects prices in our supermarkets. They contribute to the migration and displacement of people, which causes pressures that are at the top of our political agenda, including the small boat crisis. We are creating the conditions for international instability, and that fuels economic insecurity and political extremism.
Dr Chambers
I will finish now, Mr Turner. When we talk about climate change, food security, water security and energy security we are not talking about distant, abstract environmental concerns—
Cat Eccles (Stourbridge) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I strongly support screenings of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” across the country. Over the past year I attended several community briefings. The first was in June at the General Office gallery in Stourbridge: the evidence was compelling and the warnings were clear, yet it was still possible to view much of it as a future challenge—something that may become more pressing. The second screening I attended was shortly after the fires that struck my Stourbridge constituency; it was a very different experience—the evidence was immediate. I had watched firefighters tackling the blazes and I was supporting the families who had lost their homes. The risks discussed were no longer something happening elsewhere; they were happening in my community.
The Fire Brigades Union has warned that climate change places increasing demands on fire and rescue services through more frequent wildfires, extreme weather and flooding, highlighting the need for greater resilience and preparedness. The National Fire Chiefs Council warns that the UK is not yet fully prepared for the threat of wildfires, floods and extreme weather, raising serious questions about whether our emergency services have the resources and resilience needed for the challenges ahead. I am pleased that the Government are co-ordinating across Departments for wildfires and extreme heat but I remain deeply concerned about the void between national and local government.
The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has issued guidance to local councils on assessing local preparedness, yet, three months on from the Stourbridge fires, my local council is yet to start any assessment of the public realm and green spaces. The local resilience forum held meetings with stakeholders after the fires but the meetings did not include any elected members and therefore excluded key community voices and information. The forums hold no statutory duties to implement findings, so lessons learned from Stourbridge run the risk of simply being forgotten.
We must use those experiences to inform future responses not just locally but nationally. As climate risk increases, we need to ask whether our emergency services have the resources that they need, whether local resilience forums are adequately equipped and effective, whether our infrastructure is resilient enough to cope with more extreme weather, whether new homes are being built and designed for the climate conditions that we know are coming, and whether the Government are planning for and keeping pace with the risks identified.
The Stourbridge fires brought those questions into sharp focus for my constituents, and demonstrated that climate-related risks are no longer confined to countries overseas or future years. Communities across the UK are experiencing them right now. The central message of the national emergency briefing is that human-caused climate change is already affecting our economy, infrastructure, food security, health and communities. We can see that with rising temperatures, increasingly severe flooding, pressures on food production and the fires in my constituency. The task before us is not simply to reduce emissions, but to ensure that our communities, public services and infrastructure are prepared for the changes already under way.
Connor Naismith (Crewe and Nantwich) (Lab)
I thank the more than 138,000 people who signed the petition, reflecting a growing public concern about the effects that climate change and environmental degradation are having on communities across the United Kingdom. The petition is built on a simple proposition: people deserve clear, reliable information about the risks posed by climate change and how those risks may affect their lives. Whether it is flooding and extreme heat, or impacts on public health and infrastructure, these challenges are no longer distant possibilities, but realities already being experienced by communities across our country.
Only this summer we saw the devastating impact of wildfires. Homes, businesses and natural habitats continue to be affected by extreme weather events, which are becoming increasingly common. These incidents serve as a powerful reminder that the effects of a changing climate are no longer distant and theoretical. A national briefing on the challenges facing our climate would help to improve public awareness and understanding of these risks, ensuring that individuals, communities and organisations are better prepared to respond to what may lie ahead.
Last month, I attended a local screening of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” film in Nantwich. I place on record my thanks for the local leadership of Sustainable Nantwich and, in particular, local campaigner Charlie Gobbett. The screening brought together campaigners, experts and members of the public to discuss how we communicate the risks associated with climate change and environmental decline. One of the points that struck me most was how we often talk about these issues as if there were an inherent conflict between the needs of the climate and of the economy. Indeed, politicians are often behind public opinion on the need to move faster towards clean energy.
In fact, it is our exposure to fossil fuel price volatility that poses a greater risk to our economy and living standards than any other, with almost half of all recessions since 1970 having been triggered by volatility in the global fossil fuel market. Inflation in the UK would have been substantially lower during recent crises if the country had had decarbonised power, heating and food systems earlier. Furthermore, there will simply be no economy on a planet that continues to get hotter and hotter every year.
Climate change and nature loss are some of the most defining challenges of our time. They demand seriousness, honesty and long-term thinking. I welcome the progress that this Labour Government have already made, and I hope that today’s debate helps to strengthen public understanding of both the risks that we face and the opportunities that come from acting decisively.
Amanda Martin (Portsmouth North) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I thank the more than 600 people across Portsmouth who signed this petition, particularly my constituent Viola Langley, who has worked so hard to promote the “People’s Emergency Briefing” film and stand up for our climate and nature. I thank the Church of the Resurrection, where I attended the viewing, after which I had some brilliant conversations.
Portsmouth is a low-lying island city. We know only too well that climate change is not some distant threat. We are already seeing its effect. We have experienced record-breaking heat, prolonged droughts, rising food prices and pressure on our public services, including through wildfires. This summer, Queen Alexandra hospital in my constituency declared a critical incident after extreme temperature caused several chiller units to fail.
I am proud that our Prime Minister attended COP and that we are taking cross-Government action. Through our clean power mission and our community energy fund, we are driving the transition to clean energy and reducing our resilience on volatile fossil fuel markets. Our £15 billion warm homes plan has already supported many families to cut emissions and energy bills in my city. We are also treating climate and nature breakdown as the national security threats that they are, but today’s debate is about something equally important: how we communicate the scale of the challenge and bring all people with us.
This morning, I visited Corpus Christi Catholic primary school in my constituency and held an assembly. I was struck by the questions that the pupils and school councillors raised with me. They wanted to know how they could turn their concerns and worries into law and real change. I thought that was an extraordinary question, and it is exactly the sort of question that we as MPs should be answering. Young people do not just want to hear that climate change matters; they want to know that their voice counts, that decisions are being made and that we are taking responsibility for their future, and we owe them a proper answer.
Of course, we need to reach beyond schools. People of all ages need to have clear, trusted information without being lectured or frightened and without scaremongering. They need to understand not just the risks but the solutions and opportunities. A national briefing hosted by the Prime Minister would be an important step in making sure people have access to the facts about the climate and nature risks we face, but I encourage the Government to think beyond the briefing itself. We need a longer-term approach to public engagement, using all the platforms available and bringing different generations together. The aim must not simply be to inform people but to give them the confidence and opportunity to be a real part of the change.
Surely any conversation about communicating the importance of nature on our planet must not just include scientists but the British national treasure we know as Sir David Attenborough. His ability to connect with people of every age, bring the natural world into our living rooms and make us care about what we stand to lose is quite extraordinary. We should learn from that.
The people’s emergency briefing shows that when people are given clear facts, they are not necessarily left feeling frightened or powerless; they can feel more hopeful and motivated to act. Yet more than half of people say that conflicting information makes it difficult to know what to believe, and more than half say that they are scared to speak up. We all have a responsibility to address that, and we also need to take the opportunities that it can bring. Clean energy, engineering, home retrofits and green technology can create thousands of skilled jobs. For Portsmouth, with our proud maritime engineering and defence heritage, that could mean real investment and an opportunity for young people: jobs for the future, while protecting their future.
The children I spoke to this morning at Corpus Christi Catholic primary school deserve to know that their concerns can lead to change, so we should do all we can for children growing up in Portsmouth. We owe them more than words, more than action; we owe them honesty and a future that they can look forward to.
Warinder Juss (Wolverhampton West) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner.
Climate change is happening now. We see it in the floods and the wildfires that have devastated communities, in the heat that puts older people, children and those with health conditions at risk, in the pressure on our food supply chains, our water, our homes and our economy, and in the loss of the natural world on which every single one of us relies. Yet there are still too many people in Britain who are not properly informed about the scale of the risk and what it means for their lives. The British public deserve a clear, honest, expert-led national briefing—not slogans, not scaremongering, not vague promises, but the facts about what is happening now, the risks we face, how we can plan and prepare for the future and adapt and respond.
I saw the people’s national emergency briefing film at the Wildside Activity Centre in my constituency of Wolverhampton West, and it shocked me. It was almost like a road to Damascus moment for me. The film shows us what happens when we treat the climate crisis as somebody else’s problem and a problem for a future generation. It highlighted the consequences of climate change on our health, food, security, economy and natural world. It reminds us that we are experiencing the consequences of climate change now, and that they will only get worse unless we act with real urgency. As has already been mentioned, the film did leave us with some hope, because it showed us that we still have choices. We can prepare, we can adapt, we can cut emissions, and we can do so in a way that creates stronger communities and a fairer country. The people’s national emergency briefing should definitely be broadcast across the country.
Members have spoken at length about our young people. In Wolverhampton West, we have some extraordinary young people who truly understand the challenge of climate change. One constituent is a passionate climate activist who travelled to COP30 in Brazil last year and saw at first hand how the world can come together to confront the crisis. She came back with a clear message: young people must not simply be invited into the spaces where we have our discussions; they must be equipped and empowered to help to lead the discussions. She is now working with an organisation called Young Voices to develop a youth climate negotiator programme, which will create a real pathway for young people between the ages of 18 and 30 to develop the knowledge, confidence, networks and practical skills needed to take part in formulating climate policy—from local communities to national Government, and in international negotiations.
Climate change will shape the lives of young people more than any other generation, but it is the young people in my constituency who are asking me the most questions about climate change. Young people are not just the future; they are also our present. I have two asks of the Government. First, will they commit to a UK-wide public briefing on climate and nature risks? Will they also ensure that young people are not merely consulted but genuinely empowered to shape the response?
My Wolverhampton West constituents, and people across the country, are not asking for panic; they are asking for honesty and leadership, and for the Government to treat the climate and nature crisis with the seriousness it deserves.
Joe Morris (Hexham) (Lab)
It is a pleasure, as always, to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I thank James and his mum Gillian, who came to my Allendale surgery on Friday and spoke to me about seeing the “People’s Emergency Briefing”. I also want to thank the hundreds of people in my constituency who signed the petition and the hundreds more who have attended one of the 26 showings taking place across my large, rural constituency.
I want to speak about what happens at those briefings. About 30, 40 or 50 people turn up—teachers, nurses, farmers—there is usually a nice flask, folding chairs and lovely biscuits, and people watch a 50-minute film about the climate and nature emergency. When the lights come up, there is a discussion. Nobody cheers and somebody asks the question that has brought us all here: why has nobody told us?
Those screenings have been in Haltwhistle, the Allen Valleys, Haydon Bridge, Humshaugh, Wylam, Ponteland, and Prudhoe, as well as at Hexham abbey, the Trinity Methodist church, my old school—Queen Elizabeth High School—and Kirkley Hall college. One has even taken place in the Throssel Hole Buddhist monastery in Carr Shield, where I am told it was shown privately to the monks. Ordinary people in villages across my constituency have looked at the evidence of what is happening to the climate and nature and decided that the rest of us should see it too.
Those people have gone ahead and booked the hall. They have looked at where they go for walks with their family—where the first dog they remember loved running off the lead—and they have decided that those landscapes and memories need to be protected. That tells us something. When a doctor has bad news, they do not hide the scan; they sit down, look the patient in the eye, explain it and say what will happen next. This is about respect for ourselves and each other. For too long, we have been treated as though we cannot handle that particular truth. We can, and we already have: we have sat in village halls, and we are waiting for many in this place to catch up.
My constituents have told me that they are worried about transparency from the Government, international bodies and the private sector, as well as security—their own, their country’s and the world’s—and survival, which is a word I did not expect to read so often in my inbox. They think about their grandchildren and the children they teach. They are asking what kind of constituency, what kind of Tyne valley, and what kind of country we are leaving behind. In a good number of cases they are angry about Jackdaw and Rosebank because it feels as though the country is being asked to take the emergency seriously while approving more of what causes it.
I represent a rural constituency and, to be blunt, we do not get to treat this issue as something that is happening somewhere else; the emergency is already with us. It is the fear of flooding, it is the 13,500 households off the gas grid whose winter bills shoot up every time there is a crisis halfway across the world, and it is the farms where people watch the weather for a living and are the first to know when it changes. Over the summer, I surveyed my constituents, and 89% of them told me that protecting the natural environment and fighting climate change was a key priority, while 90% want the Government to do more to back UK-produced food and 78% understand that growing more food here means fewer food miles and less damage to biodiversity abroad. Those are not people who have been won over by clever marketing; they are people who have looked at the evidence and can see what the next 10 years will bring if no one acts.
Who benefits from silence? At the last climate summit, 1,600 fossil fuel lobbyists went through the door and the words “fossil fuels” were struck from the final text. That was not an accident; that was by design. Here at home, people off-grid are paying double while Shell doubles its profits—the same war and the same winter, but two very different outputs. Working people in Hexham did not cause this problem, but they are being asked to pay for it twice, in their bills and in the world their children stand to inherit. Thirty summits on, we are yet to properly reduce the rate at which we pour fossil fuel emissions into the atmosphere. At the last one, those who profit from those problems were in the room, and the problem’s name was left out of the text.
I ask the Minister to judge the new fossil fuel decisions against the scale of the emergency. The public can see the contradiction between declaring a crisis and approving drilling—my constituents certainly can. We ought to think about their children and grandchildren in classrooms and village halls today. They will be alive in 2070. One day, they will ask what we did when we were told. Our generation has been given a crisis to face; the least we can do is face it with the information we need.
Martin Rhodes (Glasgow North) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner, and I thank the petitioners for securing the debate.
We face the twin climate and nature crises, and the petition raises an important question: how do we communicate those risks? I welcome any effort to improve public understanding of these issues, including a national briefing. People deserve access to clear, trustworthy and evidence-based information about what is happening and why actions matter.
However, we must be wary of thinking a televised briefing alone would be the most effective way to reach the largest number of people. If our aim is to engage the widest possible audience, we must meet people where they are, rather than rely on a traditional single briefing or event. If our objective is to reach as many people as possible, we need something broader than a one-off event; we need a comprehensive public engagement strategy that uses every available channel, platform and engagement method, and we must use them repeatedly and continually. That means schools, colleges, universities, libraries and workplaces, but it also means social media campaigns, online content, local journalism, community organisations and local public events.
My constituency provides some excellent examples of how that can be done. I place on record my appreciation for constituents and local organisations that have supported screening and discussion events on climate and nature issues. These have taken place at the University of Glasgow, the Mitchell library, the Pyramid at Anderston community centre and Maryhill Burgh Halls. Businesses and public bodies, including Arup and the Strathclyde Partnership for Transport, have also engaged with these discussions.
Those events create opportunities for conversation, challenge and debate, allowing people to consider what climate change and nature loss mean for their own communities. Wider engagement also matters because if credible voices do not communicate clearly about climate and nature risks, that space will be filled by misinformation and false narratives. Public trust requires an ongoing conversation, grounded in evidence and honesty, about the scale of the challenge and the opportunities that come from action.
Although I welcome the petition, my view is that success should not be measured by whether we hold a single, nationally broadcast briefing; it should be measured by whether we create a sustained national conversation that reaches all sections of society and enables people to engage with these issues in ways that are meaningful to them. The climate crisis and the nature crisis are the defining challenges of our time. We must use every tool available to ensure people understand both the risks we face and the opportunities that come from acting together.
Jon Pearce (High Peak) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner, and I thank the Petitions Committee for securing this vital debate. I also thank the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) and of course everyone who signed the petition, including the hundreds of people in High Peak.
I have listened to the debate, and it is not a theoretical one; it is about what is happening to our climate now. Our climate is already changing, and we are already living with the consequences. The year 2025 was the warmest on record in the UK, and the summer of 2026 broke that record once again. This summer, nearly three quarters of England was officially in drought. These are not predictions; these are facts.
In my constituency we have seen the consequences at first hand. It is among the most vulnerable to wildfires. This summer, the fire on Tintwistle moor burned more than 600 acres of precious moorland, destroying wildlife and habitats. Wildfires have burned across the UK, with devastating impacts on our communities. I was proud to lead the campaign in the summer to ban disposable barbecues and to help reduce the risk of wildfires. I attended the first wildfire summit and welcome the Government’s action to reduce the risks of wildfires. But as we have heard in this debate, wildfires are just one of the issues and just one of impacts of climate change. The costs of adaptation will far outweigh any of the short-term savings that those who want us to ignore climate change would have us believe in.
That is why the national emergency briefing is so important. I attended a screening in Edale, and I am proud of the communities across High Peak that have organised their own showings, bringing together experts to explain the threats we face, but also providing hope that we can rise to this challenge. However, we need to go further. That is why I back the call for a national briefing. I agree that it should be wherever people are and that it needs to be more than one briefing; it needs to be in every channel across the country.
We need to start a national debate about the challenges we face and the misinformation that is everywhere. So what do we need? We need the political courage to confront the reality, to challenge the misinformation and to act—before the costs of inaction become impossible to bear.
Pippa Heylings (South Cambridgeshire) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. As everybody else has, I thank my hon. Friend the Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) for opening the debate so powerfully on behalf of the Petitions Committee. I also thank the more than 138,000 people, including many in my constituency, who signed the petition. I welcome the fact that it is the Climate Transition Minister who is in her place to respond to this debate. That is important.
We have heard from many MPs today who, like me, attended the original national emergency briefing in Westminster last November. Like others, I pay tribute to the incredible perseverance and resilience of the national emergency briefing team and to the leading scientists, doctors, farmers, economists and military experts who set out the sobering consequences of what it really means to have climate and nature emergencies. That was highlighted by our Liberal Democrat spokesperson for defence, my hon. Friend the Member for Lewes (James MacCleary), who said that this is an issue of national security. It was also highlighted by my hon. Friend the Member for Winchester (Dr Chambers), who championed the importance of science and tackling disinformation and misinformation in our politics and policymaking.
MPs across the Chamber have described the impacts of this summer, which was the hottest on record, and our newly changed climate. As my hon. Friends the Members for South Cotswolds, for Westmorland and Lonsdale (Tim Farron), for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) and for Glastonbury and Somerton (Sarah Dyke) said, we must remember and consider our farmers, who have faced the worst harvest in years due to extreme flooding and now sustained drought conditions. As they said, there is no food security without nature security. Will the Government therefore please adopt our good food Bill? As my hon. Friends said, we must use SFI payments to make sure that every single farmer is inside the tent to help us tackle this issue.
Tragically, the climate crisis is no longer counted just in tonnes of carbon emissions; it is also counted in human lives. We heard today about the estimated 4,350 heat-related deaths in the UK this summer. Those are heat-related excess deaths. What does that actually mean? It means avoidable deaths. Over 4,000 avoidable deaths. As my hon. Friend the Member for South Devon (Caroline Voaden) said, if those were covid-related deaths, we would of course want and expect the Government to hold a briefing to say what they were going to do about it. Why is it different for the nature and climate emergencies?
From the Opposition, we heard, “Are we considering whether it is too expensive? Are we considering that the UK cannot make a meaningful difference?” As we have heard, what is too expensive is the cost of inaction—the cost of not doing anything or enough. Not acting cost the UK £30 billion in 2025 alone. The heatwave in June caused an estimated £1.1 billion hit to the economy. Where was that in the Budget? Estimates of the cost of inaction are more than £100 billion in just 20 years.
The key question being debated is whether the public should hear those facts. Some Ministers have said that it is just “too doom and gloom” and that a briefing would leave people in despair, which is not what we need. However, the evidence says otherwise. An independent evaluation of more than 13,000 viewers of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” found that 87% felt more motivated to act and 57% felt more hopeful.
I have seen that with my own eyes. There have been close to 50 public showings of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” across Cambridgeshire. In my constituency, the South Cambridgeshire Climate and Nature Group has helped people to organise screenings in Gamlingay, Trumpington, Haslingfield, Barrington, Comberton, Hauxton, Thriplow, Hardwick and Linton—twice—with more to come in Shelford, Duxford, Fulbourn and Harston. Concern and hope are contagious, and when the Government do not act, people do.
At those local screenings, I saw that people do not panic when they hear the truth. They want to be better prepared. They want to know how they can protect the people and places they love. The screenings inspired people to act, because the facts also include the solutions, as we have heard, and the things we need to do. It is not just about renewable energy. The Committee on Climate Change and the UK’s carbon budget are clear that this is also about our homes, transport, agriculture and businesses.
As our Liberal Democrat spokespeople for housing and for transport, my hon. Friends the Members for Taunton and Wellington (Gideon Amos) and for Didcot and Wantage (Olly Glover), have said, we cannot address the problem or meet our net zero targets if we hollow out the warm homes plan, weaken the zero emission vehicle mandate, follow a “Drill, baby, drill” approach or approve Rosebank in the face of the climate evidence.
James Naish (Rushcliffe) (Lab)
The hon. Lady talked about homes. The Labour Rural Research Group has pushed the idea of a dedicated retrofit programme for listed and rural buildings, because of the type of housing stock we have in rural areas. Does she agree that it would be a good thing for the Minister to look again at whether a dedicated workstream within the Warm Homes Agency could help with this issue?
Pippa Heylings
The hon. Gentleman has touched on a passion of mine. This is absolutely critical. I was at a presentation by Historic England entitled “Retrofit or Ruin”. People want to be part of this. As that meeting showed, we need in our planning to look at how we can balance conservation with the fact that heritage is living, and we need to show in our buildings that we recognise there is a climate emergency. I thank him for that question.
I worry about how inequality is being entrenched by our failure to act on the climate and nature emergency. Young people cannot thrive and make the most of the opportunities they are about to be presented with if their classrooms are overheating at the time of exams, if cold homes make them and their families ill, and when there is no level playing field—when, just like that, they lose everything in a flood.
I will ask the Minister three things. First, will she and the Government truly listen to the petitioners and empower citizens with a televised briefing of the facts, introduced by the Prime Minister and delivered by Government-commissioned and independent experts? Secondly, given her much-respected record in consensus building, will she urge the Prime Minister to heed our Liberal Democrat call for cross-party, whole-of-Government talks on how to get our country better prepared? That is where I believe we can all come together. Thirdly, given that the UK has just committed to the electrification target at COP31, will the Government go further than the road map that has just been produced and adopt a national electrification strategy? That will enable people to be part of the solution, getting off fossil fuels in homes, transport and the management of land.
The petitioners are asking for people to be trusted with the truth, for the Government to provide a hopeful space and for a call to action to us all to be part of the change we need, because there is still time.
Aphra Brandreth (Chester South and Eddisbury) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I thank the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) for opening the debate and the many, many Members who have taken part. There have been too many contributions to mention them all, but Members have raised concerns about the impacts of a changing climate on food security, on wildlife, on health and on the need for emergency preparedness. The hon. Member for Lewes (James MacCleary) shared the devastating impact of local flooding, the hon. Member for Camborne and Redruth (Perran Moon) shared the impact of droughts and the hon. Member for Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard (Alex Mayer) raised the need for a message of hope, not just fear. Many Members shared examples of local action in their constituencies.
I was pleased to attend a recent screening of the “People’s Emergency Briefing” at the Storyhouse in Chester. We are already feeling the effects of climate change. This hot, dry summer strained water supplies, put pressure on farmers and disrupted infrastructure. We need to prepare for those impacts, and restoring nature has a big part to play.
Martin Wrigley (Newton Abbot) (LD)
Given that the hon. Lady has been to the briefings and that she is acknowledging climate change, will she work with the rest of her party to restore the cross-party agreement that this is an existential threat that we face?
Aphra Brandreth
I will get on to that point immediately. It is important to say that the Conservative party believes that climate change is happening. We understand, however, that alongside mitigation, we must adapt to a changing climate and restore nature.
Markus Campbell-Savours (Penrith and Solway) (Lab)
Will the shadow Minister give way?
Aphra Brandreth
I will make some progress, and then I will happily give way again.
I want to be up front about why we have moved away from the 2050 net zero target. The way we cut emissions has to be affordable for families and workable for British businesses. Our manufacturers already face some of the world’s highest industrial electricity prices. If a British factory closes and we import the same goods, the emissions from making them overseas are excluded from our carbon budgets. British emissions figures may improve even if global emissions rise. Offshoring solves nothing. It lets the Government claim progress while pushing the problem elsewhere. We want action that brings global emissions down and keeps British firms investing, growing and creating jobs.
The petition calls for a UK-wide briefing. We welcome opportunities for people to discuss, challenge and learn about these issues. Alongside the in-person film screenings, the organisers have put the individual expert talks online—although I was surprised that they have not made the full film available online too. Platforms such as YouTube are already one of the main ways that many of us watch programmes. If the aim is to reach a national audience, putting the film online seems the obvious next step.
Markus Campbell-Savours
On that point—this is a mistake that a lot of people make—the aim of the campaign is not to get the film shown; getting the film shown is easy. The campaigners want covid-style emergency briefings where people at the highest level of Government and the civil service explain what we are doing about the challenges that we are facing now. The point the hon. Lady is making is moot.
Aphra Brandreth
I understand the hon. Member’s point. I was talking about access to the film specifically, but I will get on to my point that we need to share this message in a variety of ways and that a single briefing probably will not be sufficient.
At the screening I attended, following the film we were invited to share one word to describe how we felt. The audience responses ranged from “sceptical” to “frightened”, but the majority were words such as “anxious”, “scared” and “depressed”. I found some of those responses genuinely troubling. When people come away feeling frightened and helpless, I worry that we are feeding climate anxiety rather than addressing it. If we want to take people with us, we should also leave them with a clear sense of what they and their communities can do, and with confidence that the choices that we make in this place will be practical and affordable enough for them to support.
Cat Eccles
On the shadow Minister’s point about the one word people shared about how the film made them feel, does she recognise that film is being shown in community settings so that people are cushioned by the people around them and feel safe and able to discuss the matter, rather than watching it alone at home and having those feelings when they have no one to talk to?
Aphra Brandreth
The hon. Member makes an important point about the need to discuss these things. At the viewing that I went to, the discussion was very valuable, which actually raises the concern that, if a national briefing were put on television, there would not necessarily be that opportunity for discussion in people’s own homes.
Aphra Brandreth
I will make some progress, but I will take more interventions later if I have time.
Successive Governments have taken action to protect our environment. Under the Conservatives, Britain became the first major economy to halve its greenhouse gas emissions from 1990 levels. We introduced the Environment Act 2021, the most ambitious environmental legislation in a generation. For the first time, we put nature’s recovery into law, with legally binding targets to halt the decline in species abundance by 2030, increase it by 2042 and restore or create more than half a million hectares of wildlife-rich habitat. Our local nature recovery strategies gave every part of England a map of where nature matters most and how to bring it back, and we delivered.
At sea, marine protected areas covered 40% of English waters. We restricted damaging bottom trawling in protected areas and designated England’s first highly protected marine areas. On land, our £25 million species survival fund backed 20 projects, from Atlantic rainforest in Cumbria to the chalk rivers of Hertfordshire. The fund exceeded its habitat target, and more than 13,000 volunteers helped make that happen. That is what bringing people with us looks like.
Nobody knows our land better than farmers. That is why the previous Conservative Government created the sustainable farming incentive to reward farmers for protecting nature. Yet this Government have made a total mess of it. In March last year, they closed the scheme overnight; when it reopened in September, the money ran out in under six hours. Many farmers missed out. Local farmers in Chester South and Eddisbury tell me that with that kind of uncertainty, they cannot plan their finances or how they manage their land.
The hon. Member is being very generous in giving way. I hope she will forgive me for pointing out that the scheme she rightly criticises was designed by her Government. It was designed to be first come, first served, so we were obviously going to end up with a situation where big landowners, including water companies, charities and so on, soaked up Government money while the massive majority of farmers were locked out. Does she now regret creating a system that this Government ballsed up so badly?
Aphra Brandreth
The Conservatives did introduce SFI, but there was not a situation under the Conservatives where it ran out in the way that it has under the Labour Government. They need to take responsibility for the debacle that has been the current SFI.
Aphra Brandreth
I will make some progress. I will take more interventions later if I have time.
Farmland covers about 70% of the UK. If we are serious about restoring nature, we need to work with the people who look after it, yet the family farm tax, which the Government still have not fully reversed, is pushing farms to the brink. If this Government want to protect nature, they must back our farmers.
Nature has been in decline for decades. Natural England and the Environment Agency are charged with protecting it, yet the system is failing. In January, the National Audit Office highlighted that only nine of the Government’s 43 environmental targets and commitments were likely to be met. A system falling that far short needs fundamental reform. The Public Accounts Committee highlighted the bodies’ overlapping responsibilities. Farmers can find themselves dealing with both agencies, as well as with other regulators, when what they need is clear advice. Too often, we get a top-down, one-size-fits-all approach that drives up costs, delivers too little for nature and treats the people who know the land as the problem. That is why the Conservatives would restructure the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, abolish Natural England and the Environment Agency and bring their functions back into the Department. Ministers would regain full control of strategy and policy and, crucially, they would answer directly to this House for the results.
We will also back nature-based solutions properly. The Government say they support them, but when the Environment Agency withdrew support for catchment nutrient balancing in April last year, it shut down exactly the kind of practical, nature-based approaches that Ministers claim to want. This is regulatory caution winning out over common sense.
Britain accounts for less than 1% of global greenhouse gas emissions. We need to work with other countries to bring down those emissions and make practical, affordable decisions about the energy we still need here at home. Even the Climate Change Committee’s pathway to net zero sees Britain still using oil and gas in 2050. That is why we believe the North sea should stay open for investment. In itself, cutting British oil and gas production does nothing to cut demand. Producing less here risks greater reliance on imports, alongside the loss of British jobs, investment and tax revenue.
Aphra Brandreth
There is an emissions cost of replacing UK gas with shipped imports. Producing and delivering imported liquefied natural gas has been found to be more than three times as emissions-intensive as supplying UK gas.
Aphra Brandreth
I will be fair and make some progress.
I welcome the conversations that the briefing has started. We have a duty to be frank about the risks and give people practical ways to care for nature. That takes more than a single briefing. People should come away with the confidence to make a difference where they live. The Government have a part to play, too. They cannot defend a status quo that is failing to deliver for nature. I urge the Minister to back practical, nature-based solutions, stand by our farmers and take responsibility for the decisions that shape our countryside.
The Minister for Climate Transition (Katie White)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I thank the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) for opening this important debate, and for the passion and determination that she continues to bring to the issue that probably drove her—or rowed her—into this place. I value working with her across party lines. Climate change and nature loss are far too important for us to be confined by party politics. I know we share a determination to make progress.
I think that the shadow Minister, the hon. Member for Chester South and Eddisbury (Aphra Brandreth), personally believes in a lot of that work. I do not think it would be worthy of the debate to go through each of her accusations, but I would like to champion the things the Conservatives did in Government. I hope that she begins to build on and celebrate the successes they had. We will all share in those successes and go further together.
James Naish
The shadow Minister said that we should stand by our farmers. Does the Minister agree that, by underspending the DEFRA budget by £358 million, the Tories failed farmers and that what is most important is getting money out the door into farmers’ pockets so that our farms are profitable?
Katie White
I do not think this is the right frame for points-scoring. I am sure my hon. Friend is correct, but we are here to have a wider conversation and I want to respect that.
Katie White
I am going to make progress. I thank all hon. Members who participated in this debate. I have never seen a Westminster Hall debate as full as this. I have not managed to clock up how many MPs were in this Chamber, but there were strong contributions from my hon. Friends the Members for Walthamstow (Ms Creasy), for Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard (Alex Mayer), for North East Hertfordshire (Chris Hinchliff), for Clwyd East (Becky Gittins), for Stroud (Dr Opher) and for Amber Valley (Linsey Farnsworth); and from the hon. Members for Stratford-on-Avon (Manuela Perteghella), for Melksham and Devizes (Brian Mathew), for Lewes (James MacCleary), for Ely and East Cambridgeshire (Charlotte Cane), for St Ives (Andrew George) and for Waveney Valley (Adrian Ramsay).
My hon. Friend the Member for Derbyshire Dales (John Whitby) has been committed to these issues for a huge amount of time, and regularly contacts me about them. There were strong contributions from the hon. Members for Westmorland and Lonsdale (Tim Farron), for Leicester South (Shockat Adam), for Taunton and Wellington (Gideon Amos); from my hon. Friend the Member for Hertford and Stortford (Josh Dean), who talked passionately about the need to engage the youth; from my hon. Friend the Member for Leeds East (Richard Burgon), who is my friend from across the city; and from my hon. Friend the Member for Hitchin (Alistair Strathern), who is constantly asking about and campaigning on this agenda, which he was brought to this place to drive.
There were also strong contributions from the hon. Member for Camborne and Redruth (Perran Moon), who is the electric vehicle champion; from my hon. Friends the Members for Manchester Withington (Jeff Smith) and for Dulwich and West Norwood (Helen Hayes); and from the hon. Members for Didcot and Wantage (Olly Glover) and for Winchester (Dr Chambers)—the list goes on. My hon. Friend the Member for Stourbridge (Cat Eccles) passionately and eloquently talked about the impact on her constituency with such emotional intelligence and kindness. I was proud to sit alongside her and my hon. Friend the Member for Scarborough and Whitby (Alison Hume) at the wildfire summit.
We heard contributions from my hon. Friends the Members for Crewe and Nantwich (Connor Naismith) and for Portsmouth North (Amanda Martin), who is a champion not just for the ships in her constituency, but for the impact that climate change is having on them. We also heard from my hon. Friends the Members for Wolverhampton West (Warinder Juss), for Hexham (Joe Morris), for Glasgow North (Martin Rhodes), and for High Peak (Jon Pearce), also known as “Mr BBQ”. Last but not least, we heard from my friend and colleague the hon. Member for South Cambridgeshire (Pippa Heylings), whom I very much enjoy working alongside.
There is something wonderfully British about what has happened with the national emergency briefing. A film has become a movement. Ordinary people have booked village halls, borrowed projectors, put out chairs, made cups of tea and invited their neighbours to watch, listen and talk about the defining issue of our time—a grassroots campaign at its best. I thank the more than 138,000 people who signed the petition that has brought us all here today.
As a constituency MP, I am particularly proud to see this happening on my own doorstep. From Otley Courthouse and Horsforth Brewery to Guiseley theatre, Bramhope village hall, the Old Stables in Adel and the Bridge church in Otley, local people have been opening their doors and bringing their neighbours together, with more screenings to come at the Grove in Horsforth.
Listening to the debate, I have been thinking about what first drew me into climate campaigning and why, more than 20 years later, I feel just as passionately. In my early 20s, I joined Friends of the Earth and spent my evenings travelling across the country, organising town halls and persuading MPs to back legislation on climate change. We needed binding targets, accountability for politicians and a framework that would outlast any Government or political party. Some friends—even my future husband—told me that it would not happen, but in 2008 Parliament passed the Climate Change Act. Championed by David Cameron, it established legally binding climate action that has since been copied around the world.
What has kept me working on this issue for 20 years is that climate change touches everything: our economy, health, security and the communities we love. It does not fit neatly into one departmental box. As a Minister, I can assure hon. Members that that is both a blessing and a curse, but tackling climate change is also an extraordinary opportunity to improve people’s lives, renew our communities, build a stronger economy and leave things better than we found them. That is what drives me today as the Minister for Climate Transition. It is the same determination I felt in my 20s, now with the responsibility to help deliver change in Government.
I appreciate the consensual approach that the Minister took at the outset of her remarks. I came to this debate not to speak, but to listen and learn, given the amount of interest it had raised among my constituents. I wonder if she agrees with this summary, as I see it. I think the debate has shown a strong case for alerting people to the dangers, and for formulating measures to cope with the effect of the changes that are happening. Where I feel the case has not been made is for the idea that achieving net zero by ourselves will make any difference other than beggaring our economy. Would she say that that is a fair summary?
Katie White
If it is okay, I am not going to get into that, because I think everybody in the Chamber would disagree with the right hon. Gentleman, and I will talk later about Antalya.
I have always believed that these issues must make sense beyond Westminster. If we are not communicating clearly, we are not doing our jobs. That is why I have such respect for the national emergency briefing and for Chris Packham, Nick and Simon Oldridge, and the extraordinary people who have contributed, including Nathalie Seddon, Hayley Fowler, Angela Francis and Lieutenant General Richard Nugee, with whom I am working on a climate and security nature taskforce. [Interruption.] I will just try to make a little bit of progress; I am scared of the time. What those campaigners have achieved is remarkable, and I want to pay enormous tribute to everyone involved. I met the national emergency briefing leadership in June, and I can confirm that next week, my counterparts from DEFRA and I will meet them again to discuss the issues raised today and explore opportunities to work together.
Luke Myer (Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland) (Lab)
An under-discussed part of the film that really struck me was the section by Lieutenant General Nugee about the risk to national security. As the Government carry forward their national conversation on defence, will they ensure that that strand is part of the conversation too?
Order. If the Minister is going to take interventions, I ask people to make sure that they are short interventions and not speeches.
Katie White
I will come to my hon. Friend’s point in my speech, because it is covered.
As well as outlining the risks, it is important to highlight the progress that we have made. I have just returned from COP31 in Antalya. It is crucial that we work together internationally, which is why we had the strongest possible team out in Antalya. The Government are also acting to preserve nature and accelerate clean energy at home. We have committed more than £7 billion to our natural world and created three new national forests, the first ones for 30 years. We have published the nature security assessment, the first of its kind globally, examining how ecosystem degradation and collapse could threaten Britain’s resilience, security and prosperity. We are acting on that evidence, including through our planned investment of up to £400 million in the Tropical Forest Forever Facility.
Through the climate and nature security taskforce, which I co-chair with the Cabinet Office, independent experts including Richard Nugee, we are examining how these interconnected risks could affect Britain and where we must strengthen preparedness.
I am grateful to the Minister for her generosity this afternoon. I welcome the fact that she, along with her counterpart in DEFRA, will be meeting with the national emergency briefing leadership. When doing so, may I impress upon her the fact that that could contribute to our general efforts to improve resilience?
Katie White
I thank the hon. Member. At COP31, the Prime Minister made clear that climate change is national security. I was particularly pleased to see him appoint our first UK climate security envoy. I am delighted to confirm to hon. Members today that she will be joining our climate and nature security taskforce.
That is one side of the coin; the other is the transition to clean energy. Since July 2024, we have secured enough clean energy to power 20 million homes. We have restarted new nuclear development, phased out coal and met every carbon budget to date. We have set carbon budget 7— among the world’s most ambitious climate targets—and attracted £110 billion of private investment into that growing industry. That means jobs, growth and opportunities for industrial communities.
At COP31, what struck me was the international focus on electrification. It is not the most accessible word, but essentially it means replacing fossil fuels with electricity across transport, heating, cooling and industry. It is how we reduce emissions, but it also brings practical benefits: electric vehicles can be cheaper to run than petrol and diesel cars, and electric technologies are often more efficient. We have published our own electrification road map to capture those benefits in Britain and support international pledges to accelerate the transition. As COP31 continues, we are determined to build momentum towards COP32 in Ethiopia and through our G20 presidency.
I want to recognise the value of the conversations that have taken place as a result of this campaign and the opportunities available now to build on them. Success is not simply about how many people hear the message but about whether they feel informed, involved and able to make a difference. I know from experience that grassroots engagement can change the national conversation, and today is a testament to that. This Government want to listen, work together and turn that energy created into lasting action on climate and nature.
I agree with the national emergency briefing team that we must be honest with people about the risks posed by the climate and nature crisis. Building on our work over the past two years to engage the public on climate and nature, I am working tirelessly, alongside some of our country’s very best scientists, communicators and engagement experts, to ensure that public understanding of climate change remains high. People deserve to understand what is happening to our climate and nature and to feel part of the solution, so I will work with the climate and nature taskforce to explore further opportunities for public engagement.
I thank Chris, Nick, Simon and everyone involved for bringing people together, making the science accessible and helping our country confront these challenges with urgency and hope. I will keep all Members who have spoken today updated on progress.
Dr Savage
I thank the many people who spoke in this debate. I had lost track of how many people had spoken even by the end of the interventions on my own speech, let alone all the speeches that happened thereafter. It would be unfair of me to single out anybody. However, I will single out my hon. Friend the Member for South Cambridgeshire (Pippa Heylings), who spoke with such passion and energy that, if we could only plug her into the national grid, I think we would have an amazing source of renewables right here.
I am enormously encouraged to hear the Minister say that she will be meeting with the national emergency briefing team next week to discuss the issues raised today and to explore the opportunities, because those opportunities are many. I spent much of my 20 years as an environmental campaigner before coming to this place asking myself whether change happens from the top down or the bottom up, or even the middle out, and the answer is that we need all of the above. The first step on that journey is for people to not just have the information available but know with absolute clarity that that information is dependable and accurate. Understanding and engagement—yes. Empowerment and unleashing that untapped potential in the Great British public to address these existential issues that confront us right now—absolutely, yes.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House has considered e-petition 767687 relating to holding a UK-wide briefing on climate and nature risks.